They left Pinecrest at noon on Thursday in Tessa’s car, with a thermos, a bag of oranges from Oyelaran, and Imogen Hallett’s cassette recorder wedged between the front seats with its little red light on.
Imogen had insisted. She had said that if one of the hollows was going to ask whether anyone was there, it ought to be answered in the voice that had taught the question, and that she could not go herself because her heart was fine and her knees were not.
She had said it in the lobby, in a blanket, to a deputy who had been trying to explain medical transport. Then she had pressed the machine into Nell’s hands and told her not to drop it.
“It has forty minutes of me counting and about six of me not counting,” she said. “Use whichever is called for.”
Hana stayed to run the phones. Joan stayed because Alan said the stairs would kill her and she said the stairs could try. Vance stayed, at a table by a window, with a pen he could not use and a list he was dictating to a young deputy in a flat, steady voice, name after name, as a man reads out a roll of the dead.
---
Port Marren, Ohio, was a long gray town on a long gray lake, and it took the better part of ten hours to reach, with a stop for gas and another for Priya, who was carsick.
Tessa drove. Nell’s hands could not be trusted on a wheel; they had started, the night before, to give a faint electrical buzz, as if the nerves were being tested one at a time. Priya sat in back with her knees drawn up and a road atlas from the glove box, not looking at it, and for the first two hours nobody said anything that was not about gas.
“Brake,” said Tessa, at the tail of a truck. “And. Ease.”
“You don’t have to say it anymore. You got the stairs back at breakfast.”
“I got the stairs back because I said it every single time.” Tessa kept her eyes on the road. “If I stop saying it, I’ll stop being able to do it. I’m not taking the chance on the interstate.”
Somewhere past Wheeling the afternoon went to rain, and Priya, who had been silent for forty minutes, said without turning from the window, “It said it didn’t stop. On the card. Do you think that’s true?”
“Which?”
“That Theo didn’t stop. That somebody stopped him.”
Nell looked at the wipers. “I think everything in this story that stopped was stopped by a person,” she said. “Imogen cut a tape. Pike cut nine minutes. Pryce read a line. I tapped a rail. I don’t think there’s a single unit in the water that chose its own end. I think they all had it chosen for them, by people who thought they were being kind.”
“That’s a lot of kind people.”
“It’s the most dangerous thing there is,” said Nell.
---
The Lakeshore Inn & Suites stood at the end of a long road by the water, a four-story brick box with a green awning and a sign that offered AQUATICS PACKAGE, FREE WIFI, FAMILY SUITES. It was a quarter to eleven when they pulled in. Every one of the lot’s two hundred spaces was full.
Inside, the lobby had been turned into a dormitory.
Parents slept in armchairs, in sleeping bags along the carpet, under the brochure rack, with their shoes off and their coats on. Children in team parkas lay head to foot on the sofas. A girl of about ten, in a swim cap, was doing her homework on the registration desk, and a woman with a clipboard and a lanyard that said MEET DIRECTOR was walking up and down between the sleepers, speaking in a low hoarse murmur to someone on the phone.
The night manager was waiting for them at the desk. He was a stout man of fifty in a hotel blazer, with a name tag that said GIL and eyes like boiled eggs.
“You’re the people from the call,” he said.
“Nell Voss.”
“Gil Navarro. I’m very sorry about the mess.” He looked at the lobby as if it were a personal failing. “I’ve had seventy kids and ninety parents in here since yesterday afternoon, and every one of them wants to know why the pool’s been closed. I told them a chemical issue. Nobody believes it. Come on. I’ll show you. I’d like somebody to look at it who isn’t me.”
---
The pool was in a glass annex off the back of the lobby.
It was a plain L-shaped hotel pool, eight lanes’ worth of water in a space made for four, with a cracked ceiling, a row of plastic chairs, and a laminated sign about running. The lights were on. The water was black.
It was the same black. It lay flat to the tile, as still as a poured sheet of glass, and gave back nothing. A faint odor came off it, of cold stone and iron.
And in the shallow end, at the foot of the steps, stood the thing.
It was gray. It had a gray canvas vest, an orange float, a felt face with a pale oval where the eyes would be. It stood with its arms at its sides, and at the end of the right arm a card was held out, flat, in a gray felt hand, as one holds out a ticket.
“I told them it was a display,” said Gil, in a small flat voice. “It’s in our brochure. They put it in five years ago, when we got the aquatics package, and nobody ever turned it on. I thought it was a decoy. I mean, a prop. I’m sorry. I don’t know what I mean.”
“Does it move?”
“Not when I’m looking.” He swallowed. “It knocks.”
“Where?”
“In the wall.” He pointed at the pipe along the base of the glass, a copper line with a valve. “It knocks once. And then it waits. I’ve been sitting with it since midnight last night, with a chair. It knocks and I say, I’m here. And it knocks.”
Nell looked at the card. It was white, laminated, curled at one corner. It had a name on it in a child’s printing, in pencil.
*THEO.*
And under that, with the same shaky care: *COME IN.*
---
“There are three,” said Gil. “I told Ms. Hana on the phone. Three Theos, if you count the one who goes by Theodore, which he does. Theo Marsh is eight, on the Dolphins. Theo Banerjee is eleven, with the Tidewater club. And Theo Lacroix is fourteen. He’s here with his sister.”
“Have any of them been near the pool?”
“Theo Marsh was at the door at two last night.” The manager’s voice dropped. “In his socks. He’s a sleepwalker. His mother said he’s never done it before. I found him standing with his hand on the glass. He said his name was being called. She took him upstairs and put a chair against the door.”
“And the others?”
“Nothing yet. Tonight?” He spread his hands. “I’ve doubled the staff at the lobby. I’ve told the parents to keep the kids in their rooms. But I’ve got ninety parents and a lot of rooms, and I can’t watch every door.”
“No,” said Nell. “Nobody can.”
She looked at the water. She took the card out of her swimsuit strap, the warm one that had gone cold, and turned it so that the child’s printing was toward her. *I DID NOT STOP. I WAS STOPPED.* She held it a moment against the light, and put it back.
“What do we do?” said Gil.
“We sit with it,” said Priya.
---
They sat with it for more than two hours.
It was Priya’s idea, and it was the right one, though none of them could have said why. They set up four plastic chairs at the rail, with the glass at their backs and the black water in front, and sat in them. Nell. Priya. Tessa. And Gil, who had refused to go back to the desk, and who took the end chair with his hands on his knees.
Every ten minutes the pipe knocked. Every ten minutes somebody said, “I’m here.” They said it by turns, in order, in an ordinary voice, as people say it to a child who has called from the next room.
“I’m here,” said Nell, at eleven forty.
Knock.
“I’m here,” said Priya, at eleven fifty.
Knock. It was always one. The second beat never came. After each one the pipe waited, and the silence was so exact it had edges, and no one in the chair row could stand it.
At half past midnight Nell took out Imogen’s recorder and pressed the button, and the old woman’s thin voice filled the annex, counting. *Forty. Forty-one. Forty-two.* It rang off the tile. The figure in the shallow end did not turn its head.
“It can’t hear it,” said Tessa.
“It can’t count.”
“No.” Nell switched it off. “Imogen said it. A pair is company. It’s not that it can’t hear a number. It doesn’t know what one is for. It was never taught to be answered.”
She stood up, and with her flat hand, softly, as Tessa had at Pinecrest, she knocked twice on the tile at the rail.
Pair. Pause.
The pipe in the wall did not knock back. But the figure in the water, for the first time in an hour, turned.
---
It turned from the waist, slowly. The felt face came round. It looked at Nell, and at the knuckle that had knocked, and at Priya, and then, very slowly, at the pipe.
“Again,” whispered Priya. “Do it again.”
She did. Pair, pause, pair. And from the wall, in a clumsy, uncertain, staggering beat, as a child tries to clap in time with a song it has never heard, the pipe answered. One. And, a long moment after, a second.
A pair.
The hotel went dead quiet. In the lobby the sleepers stirred, and someone coughed, and someone said, in a thin voice, “What was that?” The figure stood with its hand held out, and it did not move, but something went through the whole body of it, a kind of slackening, as when a tight shoulder is allowed to drop.
“It heard,” said Gil. “Did it hear?”
“It heard.”
“Is that all?”
“I don’t know.”
It was at that moment, at two minutes past one, that doors began to open on three floors at once.
---
They came down the stairs in their socks and pajamas, three of them, from three different floors, at three different paces, with their eyes open and not seeing.
Theo Marsh was first, eight years old, in dinosaur pajamas, with a small gray stuffed seal under one arm. Theo Banerjee came next, from the east stairs, with his goggles round his neck. The oldest, Theo Lacroix, with a team parka over a T-shirt, came down the main staircase with his hand sliding along the rail, and behind him on the stairs, two steps behind, in a long nightshirt, his sister, shouting his name.
“Theo! Theo, wake up! Theo!”
He did not wake. He walked, with his eyes half-lidded and his face quite peaceful, across the lobby carpet between the sleeping bodies, and not one parent stirred. The three of them converged on the annex door with the unhurried, sleepwalking stride of boys following a bell.
“Block the door!” said Nell.
Gil got there first. He was heavy, but he was quick, and he planted himself in the doorway with both arms out. Theo Marsh walked into his stomach and stopped, and put up a small hand, and pressed on the manager’s blazer, as if it were a wall that would open.
“Come in,” said the boy, quite clearly. “I’m coming in.”
“Not tonight, buddy.”
“It’s calling me.”
“I know it is,” said Gil, and his voice broke. “I know. I’m right here. Stay with me.”
---
It took seven adults to hold three boys in a doorway.
Priya had Theo Banerjee round the chest, her cheek against his hair, talking steadily. Tessa had Theo Marsh by the shoulders. Nell, who could not trust her hands to hold a child, had taken the sister, who was sobbing, and had put the girl’s hand into Tessa’s pocket and said, *Hold on there, hold on.* Parents came in a stream, in their coats, with their phones lit, and the meet director with her clipboard, and a man with a camera who had to be sat down.
And all through it the pipe in the wall knocked, in a pair, in a pair, in a desperate, hammering, clumsy beat, as the figure in the water leaned toward the door with its hand held out.
It had found its answer, and it did not know what to do with it.
“It wants one of them,” said Priya, through her teeth.
“It wants somebody called Theo.”
“There are three!”
“It doesn’t know which.” Nell was backed against the glass, with the sister clinging to her sleeve, and she felt the cold of the annex come through it into her shoulders. “It’s not choosing. It can’t. It was made to the pattern of a boy waiting, and it has been waiting at a pool for five years, and nobody has ever once come when it called. Now somebody has. It doesn’t know which one is the right one to be sure of.”
“So what do we tell it?”
“We tell it who they are.”
---
It was the one thing nobody had thought of.
Nell crossed the lobby at a run and went into the pool annex alone, with every adult in the building shouting behind her, and walked down the rail to the shallow end and the black water and stopped a yard from the figure. She did not go in. She held up the recorder, and then she put it down on the tile, and took out of her strap the cold card, and held that.
“Listen,” she said, to the felt face. “I know you can’t count. I know you don’t know what it’s for. I’m going to tell you who they are.”
The felt face lifted.
“That one is Theo Marsh. He’s eight. He has a stuffed seal. He is on a team called the Dolphins, and his mother has put a chair against his door every night for two nights. That one is Theo Banerjee. He’s eleven, and his goggles are round his neck because he didn’t know whether he would be needed. The big one is Theo Lacroix.
He is fourteen and his sister is shouting his name, because she wants him back.” She breathed. “Not one of them is the boy you’re calling. Theodore Hallett is thirty-one years gone, and his mother counted him out on Wednesday night, and it was not you who did it. You were never meant to wait for him.”
Nothing moved. The water lay still.
“You were made by a man who was hiding a different thing,” said Nell. “You were made so that nobody would look at what was real. That wasn’t your fault. It wasn’t a thing you did.”
The gray figure looked at her for a long time.
Then, very slowly, it lowered its card. It laid it on the lip of the pool, face up, beside Imogen’s recorder. It stepped back out of the water, one pace and then another, and the black ran off its legs like ink off glass, and at the top of the steps it turned to face the lobby.
Behind her, three small boys woke up and began, in three separate voices, to cry.
---
The manager sat down on the lobby floor and could not get up.
He said, afterwards, to Priya, with a kind of dazed apology, that it was the door numbers. He could not read them. He had gone to take a key to the third floor and had looked at the brass 312 and it was only three marks. He had stood in the corridor for five minutes counting doors from the stairwell with his finger.
“I’ve worked this desk eleven years,” said Gil Navarro. “I can’t see what the room is.”
“It’ll come back. It comes back with practice.”
“What practice? How do you practice room numbers?”
“The same way you practice anything.” She sat down on the floor beside him. “You count them. Out loud. And somebody counts with you.”
On the tile of the pool annex, in a faint damp light, the card lay face up beside Imogen’s recorder. Nell had not touched it. She read it again, a third time, at one-thirty in the morning, with Tessa standing over her shoulder.
It had changed. The word *THEO* had been struck through, with one clean pencil line. Under it, in the same child’s capitals, a new line had appeared.
*NOT ME. NOT YOU. WHO.*
And under that, small, in a dull square print that was not a child’s at all, as if copied from a tag, one more:
*BRIGHTWATER 43. NOT SOLD.*
“Forty-three,” said Tessa. “Vance said forty-two.”
“He did.”
“Then somebody built a forty-third.”
Beside the rail, the wall behind the pipe knocked once, very quietly, in a pair.

