Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 99

Motion Hearing

The Co-op conference room had eleven chairs, a flag, a water pitcher nobody trusted, and on the wall a framed photograph of the Bin in 1938, looking brand new and slightly embarrassed.

Voss took the head of the table. She had her hard case open at her elbow and her reading glasses on a chain, and she had pressed her suit. Marsh sat at her right with the minute book squared to the table edge and a fountain pen uncapped. Across from Dess, behind a neat stack of folders, sat Tamsin Ley, who had not slept either and had done a better job of hiding it.

Quill sat at the far end by the window, alone, in his gray overcoat, with his gloves folded on his knee. He had asked to attend. Voss had granted it on the condition that he speak only when answering.

"We are on the record," said Marsh. "Ten-oh-four on Saturday, the first of February. Present, the Board's county auditor in the chair, the secretary, the movant by counsel, the respondent, the Receiver, and, in the corridor, I believe, a number of the public."

"There are forty," said Teo, from the door. "I counted."

"Forty," said Marsh, and wrote it.

"Ms. Ley," said Voss. "Your motion."

Tamsin stood. She had a way of standing that was a little too straight, as if she had been told as a child that slouching was a lapse of character. She read the motion in a clear low voice and did not decorate it. The party of the first pan had an interest in the witness's answer. The public's guesses were unauthorized. The dog was in discomfort, as a matter of fact, thirty-four pounds and falling. A guardian should be appointed.

"Ms. Ley," said Voss. "Who is the party of the first pan?"

"I don't know, ma'am."

"You represent them."

"I represent the firm, which represents them. I have not met them. I've never seen a signature." She turned a page. "I want to say, for the record, that this is the least satisfactory representation I have undertaken, and I intend to do it carefully."

"Noted," said Voss, and Dess felt the room relax a half inch.

"Objection," said Bernie from the back.

"You are not a party, Mrs. Szymanski."

"I'm a citizen, hon. I'm entitled to a general objection." She stood up, in a hat. "I object on the grounds that it's a dog! Hoo-boy, who'll give me a guardian, a guardian, a guardian, who's got a guardian for a collie, I'm not hearing—"

"Bernadette."

"Sorry. It gets in me."

"Sit down," said Voss. "Dr. Lindqvist. Respond."

Dess stood. She had no notes. She had a warm right hand in her coat pocket, curled around the old brass tag, and she held on to it.

"He isn't a witness the firm sent," she said. "Walt Stroud sat in that chair in 1985 with the first Biscuit. Counsel's file says the firm paid for a dog that year. I believe it. I think somebody put that puppy in Walt's way. I think that's how the Creditor makes sure there's a witness beside the one who sits."

Tamsin Ley's head came up.

"But the one in the chair isn't that dog. He's the fourth. The first died in 1999. I've read Walt's vet records. This one came to Walt in 2010." She looked at the room. "Priya?"

Priya, in the second row, stood so fast she knocked a folder off her knee. She had a manila envelope and she held it like a hymnbook.

"Adoption record," she said. "Sorrel County pound. Intake, a stray, found on Route 30 in a ditch, approximately two months old. No microchip. Surrender fee waived by the pound's director because, and I'm reading, *nobody wanted to bill the puppy.* Adoptee, Walter Stroud. Fee paid, zero." She breathed. "It's signed in pen. There's a coffee ring."

"Admit the coffee ring," said Marsh, and wrote.

"A dog nobody sold," said Dess. "A dog nobody ordered. He was given. He isn't the party's property. If a witness is a creature who sits of his own accord and isn't let off by the asking, then he's the only one in the room who qualifies."

"Mr. Quill," said Voss. "The Board would be obliged for your reading. Not advice. Reading."

Quill raised his gray head.

"A witness," he said, "is the one who sits."

It was said as a child recites. Then he stopped, and the room waited, and he said, more quietly, "I should say that I have not sat in forty-one years. I have stood. It is not the same."

"I note that," said Voss.

"It is why I do not know the answer. A man who stands by a chair does not learn what it asks."

"And the firm's file?" said Tamsin Ley.

She had spoken to nobody. She was standing with a page in her hand, and the page was shaking.

"Ms. Ley," said Voss.

"I'd like to read from the 1986 file." She cleared her throat. "It's a receipt. For one border collie, male, red and white, crooked left ear, nine weeks, delivered to Walter Stroud in September 1985. Paid in full by the firm, on behalf of the party of the first pan, in grain. There's a note clipped to it, in a hand I don't recognize. It says: *He will not understand the gift. He will understand the dog.*"

"Read the date again," said Voss.

"September 1985."

"Two months before Walt's hour."

"Yes, ma'am. I've been up all night with it. The party gave Mr. Stroud a witness two months before he sat. I don't think they meant harm." She put the page down. "I think they meant to help him, in a way that cost him nothing. I think the party of the first pan wanted someone beside him."

"That," said Voss slowly, "is not in your motion."

"No, ma'am. I withdraw the motion."

The room made a sound like a held breath leaving.

"On what ground?" said Voss.

"On the ground that I can't tell my client what my client is. I don't know that a guardian is in the dog's interest. I know a dog is in the chair. I know the one before him sat an hour more than he had to. I don't know why. Neither does the firm." Her chin lifted. "I withdraw, with the Board's leave. And I'd like it noted that I have not been instructed to."

"Noted," said Marsh, writing, with relish.

Voss took off her glasses.

"The Board finds," she said, "that a witness seated by his own act is a witness and not property. The Board will not appoint a guardian. The Board will not remove him. The Board will not forbid the public from offering what they believe. But the Board notes, at the risk of repeating the Charter, that every wrong answer is weighed." She folded the glasses. "The public is advised."

"Advised," said Marsh, writing. "Ten fifty-one."

They went out into a noon that had gone brisk and bright, with a hundred small birds working the gutters. Tamsin Ley walked beside Dess with her folders held tight to her chest, saying nothing, and at the loading dock they both stopped.

A grain truck was idling on the deck.

It was an old Peterbilt with a twenty-ton hopper, painted the faded green of a corn leaf in October. It had pulled up to the scale and stopped dead square on the platform as if it had been parked by a ruler. Its engine ran. Its wipers were going, on a dry day, back and forth. In the cab there was no driver.

"That's the quarterly," Tamsin said, in a small voice. "It's early."

On the dash, the radio was playing. It was not music. It was a single high clear voice, a child's, on three falling notes and a fourth, again and again, with nobody singing it.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!