Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 12

Renata

Claims Manual, 5.2: Communications with the family of a deceased person shall be routed through counsel.

I took the coffee, because refusing it would have been another way of managing her.

We stood on the Port Harlow dock with fish trucks idling behind us and Noor pretending to study a bollard. Renata Tillman drank hers black. She watched me not know where to begin.

“Start with the nine days,” she said.

“I can’t. Counsel would say—”

“Counsel isn’t here. I am.”

So I told her. I told her the way I had told three hundred people on a harbor lawn, only now there was no crowd to hold me up, and every sentence landed on one pair of steady brown eyes. A claim in a furniture warehouse. A charming man who knew the names of my staff. A second walkthrough I skipped on the ninth day because the first had been clean and I was tired of being the person who made kind people wait. A check. A second fire, in the annex, nineteen days later.

“He was working a night shift,” Renata said. “Fifty-eight years old. He liked the annex because it was warm.”

“I know.”

“You don’t know that. You know what the file says, which is ‘one fatality, custodial.’” She turned the cup in her hands. “He had a name, you know. It’s on a stone in Saint Brendan’s. You could have put it in the file.”

“I know the name. Marcus Tillman.” My voice cracked on the second word and I let it. “I’ve known it for five years. I’ve said it to nobody until yesterday.”

She was silent for a while. The ferry horn went, behind us.

“I thought you’d say you were sorry,” she said finally.

“I am. But that’s not worth anything to you, and I’m not going to hand it over as if it were.”

“What would be worth something?”

“I don’t know. I thought you’d tell me.”

Something moved across her face, a flicker that might have been the beginning of anger or the end of it. She finished the coffee and dropped the cup in a bin.

“Come on,” she said. “I’m not doing this on a dock.”

Her truck was a white pickup with a ladder rack and a magnet on the door that read TILLMAN ELECTRIC, LICENSED, BONDED. She drove with one hand and didn’t speak. Noor sat in the back and held the thermos like a rosary. I looked out at Port Harlow, the nice neighborhoods and then the less nice ones, and the road that led to the old industrial strip by the river, where the Carver buildings had stood.

“You didn’t take the highway,” I said.

“No.”

“Where are we going?”

“You said you’d say it to me. I want to say something back, and I don’t do that at red lights.”

She parked in front of a low brick building on Millrace Street, with a hand-painted sign that said TILLMAN ELECTRIC and, below it in smaller letters, since 1989. It was a two-bay shop, with coils of wire on pegboard and a space heater going. A woman of sixty-six or so sat at a desk by the window, doing something with a calculator and a mug of tea. She looked up when we came in, took in me and Noor, and went back to her calculator.

“Ma,” said Renata. “This is the adjuster.”

“I know who it is. It was in the paper.” The woman did not turn around. “Sit. There’s bread.”

I sat. Noor sat. There was bread, and butter, and nobody explained why. I understood that I had been admitted to something, and that admission might be revoked at any time.

“My mother is Odette,” said Renata. “She doesn’t like to talk about the fire.”

“I like to talk about it,” said Odette Tillman, still at her calculator. “I like to talk about it with someone who is going to do something besides cry.”

“I’m not going to cry,” I said, which was a lie, and a tear dropped onto the bread. I took the bread and ate it, because it was the only thing available.

Odette laughed, one dry bark, and turned around in her chair.

“Well,” she said. “She eats. Marcus would have liked that.”

Renata took a canvas bag from beneath the desk and set it on the table between us. She didn’t open it.

“I am going to tell you what I want,” she said. “I’m not going to tell you in a nice voice.”

“Please.”

“I do not want an apology. I want the file. The real one, every page, not what Northfield wrote to the county. I want to know what the man you worked for knew, and when.”

“I don’t have the file. My copy was purged. Noor?”

“Boss, I might have a copy,” said Noor. Her voice had a tremor in it. “I was going to tell you on Monday. I didn’t want to do it on a dock.”

Odette made a small sound of approval.

“I want that,” said Renata. “And I want the second walkthrough.”

“The second walkthrough doesn’t exist. I never did it.”

“Then do it now.” She pushed the bag across the table. “Not the building. The building’s a parking lot. I mean do it on paper. Go through every page of that file, line by line, the way you should have, and tell me what was in it that you should have seen. And then tell it to someone who can put it in the right record. Not in a newspaper. A real one.”

I looked at the bag. It was an ordinary canvas tote, stained at the corners.

“What’s in it?”

“My father’s things. The state gave them back after the inquest. His keys, his lunch box, his notebook.” She unzipped it. “I never opened the notebook. I couldn’t. And then last night I read your name in the paper and thought, well, this is the person who’s supposed to read it.”

“Renata,” said Odette, gently.

“I know, Ma. I know.” She took out a small spiral pad with a green cover, soft with handling, and set it on the table. The cover had a coffee ring. The first line, in blue ballpoint, in square tidy capitals, read: M. TILLMAN, NIGHTS, SITE LOG.

“He wrote everything down,” said Renata. “Every building he cleaned. Who left the lights on, who took the good paper towels. He said a custodian was the only person who really knew a building.” She pushed it toward me. “Read it. Out loud, if you can.”

I opened it. My hands were not steady, and I put them flat on the table to make them so. I turned the pages carefully, slowly, as if the paper might forgive me for being clumsy. Months of entries, in the careful hand of a man who liked things in order. Mr. C gone by 7. Boiler loud. Rats again, call exterminator.

I came to the last page with writing on it. The entry was dated nine days before the annex burned. It was five lines long. I read it aloud, and the room went very quiet.

“Insurance man came by again after close. Brought a cake. Third time this month. Mr. C laughed too loud. Nobody brings cake to a claim that’s already paid.”

I looked up. Noor was white.

“He wrote that,” I said, “nine days before he died?”

Renata nodded. She hadn’t read it. I could see she hadn’t. She watched my face as if it were a window onto something she had been afraid to look at for five years.

“Which insurance man?” Odette said.

I closed the notebook, and I put my hand on it, flat, the way you put your hand on a table in an earthquake.

“I paid that claim on day nine,” I said. “Nobody from Northfield should have been at that warehouse after the check cleared. Nobody. Not anyone.”

“Except,” said Renata.

I thought of a gentle, tired face over a plate of eggs, a courtesy I had once mistaken for kindness. A man who brings a cake to a building he has already robbed.

“Except one,” I said.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!