Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 26

The Board

Claims Manual, 14.1: An adjuster whose independence is in doubt shall disclose the doubt before the doubt is discovered.

The State Board of Insurance Licensure meets in a paneled hearing room on the ninth floor of the capitol annex, under a ceiling painted with sheaves of wheat. Five members sit on a raised dais. Nobody has ever explained the wheat.

I wore the gray suit. Boone wore the green one. Between us, on the table, I had my pencil, one folder, and a small blue-cased phone in an evidence bag, with a tag in Priya Lindqvist’s handwriting and a chain-of-custody form signed in four places. Renata had handed it over herself on Tuesday morning, in Lindqvist’s windowless room, and said, “Don’t lose it,” and been given a receipt.

The room was full. Noor sat in the second row in her best cardigan with her hands clenched. Renata and Odette sat beside her, in their funeral clothes, upright and silent. In the back, a few journalists. And on the other side of the aisle, on a leather chair with a footrest, in a very good coat, sat Desmond Wray.

He had been released on his own recognizance. He had a new tweed jacket. He looked rested.

He did not look at me. He turned a page in a folder, with a fond, tired smile, as though he had come to a retirement party for someone he was very sorry to see go.

Everett Strand rose for the complainant. He had been Wray’s lawyer for nine days. He was, I think, the best I had ever watched, and I spent the first twenty minutes watching him the way you watch a fine surgeon open you.

“The respondent,” he began, “is not a villain. I want to be clear. She is a talented adjuster who made a mistake in good faith five years ago, and then, under pressure, compounded it. This board has the authority to say, quietly, that an adjuster who has twice failed to meet the standard of independence ought not to hold a license.”

Boone touched my wrist.

He took the board through it in order. The Carver payment. The nine days. The report I had signed, the annex I had not seen. Then he turned to Brannock.

“In October, Ms. Quigley traveled to Brannock Island to adjust a claim. Within five days, she had entered into what can only be called a personal relationship with the principal of the claimant. She kissed him, Madam Chair. On or about October ninth. Three days before she served a denial she knew would bring the claimant’s family a public humiliation, and one day before she presented to a deputy a report that exonerated an island full of his associates.”

“Objection,” murmured Boone. “Characterization.”

“Overruled, for the moment,” said the chair, a gaunt woman named Augustina Reyes, in a voice like a dry stick. “Mr. Strand, make your point.”

“Ms. Boone?” said Chair Reyes.

Boone did not rise. “My client would like to make a statement,” she said. “I have told her not to. She has declined.”

“I see.” The chair looked at me over her half-moon glasses. “Ms. Quigley.”

I stood. My knees held.

“I would like to begin,” I said, “with the conflict.”

Strand’s head came up.

“I did kiss Mr. Amaral. October ninth, in the boathouse, during a storm, before I had served the denial. I should not have. I put that fact in the file on October twelfth, in my own hand, in the ninth page of my report, and I disclosed it again to Ms. Lindqvist. It is not hidden.” I looked at the board. “I do not offer it as an excuse. I offer it as a fact. I was an adjuster of record with a personal interest in a claimant. I should have withdrawn from the file on October ninth. I did not. I served the denial anyway, and I wrote that it was true, because it was, and I would do it again. But I had a conflict, and I did not step aside, and that is a violation of section fourteen point one of the manual that I have cited, all my life, to other people.”

A sound went around the room, not a murmur, something lower.

“Second, the silence.” My voice was steady. I was surprised by that. “Mr. Strand is correct. I stood forty feet from a fraud five years ago and told no one. I would like to put it in the record now, fully, with a witness who can corroborate it.”

I nodded to Boone, who stood and handed the board’s clerk an evidence bag.

“Exhibit Fourteen. A mobile phone belonging to the late Marcus Tillman, custodian, returned to his family by the county. It contains three photographs, timestamped five fifty-seven p.m. on the date I describe. They show two unmarked box trucks, a man carrying out stock, and Desmond Wray.” I did not look at him. “They also show my car.”

The clerk carried the bag up to the dais. At last, on a monitor beside the chair, a photograph came up. A loading door. A tall man in tweed.

Wray had not moved. His smile was very still. For the first time since I had known him, I saw it fail, a small stiffening at the edges, like a coat that doesn’t fit.

“Madam Chair,” said Strand, rising, “this phone is five years old. The chain of custody—”

“Is attested by the State’s investigator,” said Lindqvist, from the back of the room, in her dry cardigan voice. “I’ll provide the log.”

I made my statement. It took twenty minutes. I did not use the words victim or override or fault. I said what I had seen, and what I had done, and what I had not. At the end I said, “I paid a claim in nine days because a man I trusted told me to, and I did not look because I did not want to. Two hundred people on an island have since asked me to look. I would like to keep looking. I understand if this board decides that I should not.”

The board deliberated for forty minutes. We waited in the corridor beside Renata, who said nothing and stood beside me anyway. When we filed back in, Chair Reyes did not look at Wray.

“The board finds,” she said, “that Ms. Quigley’s conduct on Brannock Island constituted a failure to disclose a conflict of interest under section fourteen. The board finds, further, that her five-year silence regarding the events at Carver Furniture was a serious lapse of professional duty. The board also finds that her disclosures in this matter were voluntary, complete, and, in the experience of this board, unprecedented.” She laid down her pen. “Her license is suspended for ninety days, pending the conclusion of the state’s investigation. She may not act as adjuster of record on any file. She may act as a witness, and the board encourages her to do so.”

It could have been worse. It was bad enough. I stood very still and felt the ground go out from under me and then, somehow, hold.

“Thank you,” I said.

“Do not thank us,” said Chair Reyes. “Adjourned.”

The room broke into noise. Journalists rose. Wray stood with a slow, judicious movement, buttoned his tweed, and turned, at last, to look at me across the aisle. The old kindness was there, but it was very thin now, like paint on a boat.

“Hollis,” he said, gently, “my friend. I did try to keep it clean.”

A man in a navy suit was walking up the aisle behind him with a manila envelope. It was Leland Pruitt, the soft pink general counsel, with his silver glasses and an expression of ritual regret. He did not look at Wray. He held the envelope toward me with both hands, like a man at a funeral offering condolences.

“Ms. Quigley. I am instructed to deliver this in person. Northfield Casualty has concluded its internal inquiry.”

“It’s a seating chart,” I said.

“It is a termination of employment, effective immediately. I’m sorry.”

I took it. It was a very light envelope. I was fired in a room full of wheat, by a man who had watched me for eleven years, in front of the people I had hurt and the one I had been loyal to, and the strangest thing was how little I felt.

“Hollis,” said a voice, close behind me.

Priya Lindqvist had come down the aisle. She stood very straight in her gray cardigan with a tired, unreadable face.

“You are not finished,” she said, low. “The board suspended you. It did not silence you. And Northfield did you a favor. A state witness cannot be accused of being under the thumb of her employer.” She looked at the envelope. “Come outside. We have a great deal to do.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!