Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 49

Examination

Claims Manual, 23.5: The examiner arrives unannounced. This is not rudeness. It is the method.

The examiner arrived with four days' notice, a thing he described as an unannounced visit, on a Monday, by chartered launch, in a gray raincoat with a briefcase on a strap and a face like an unsigned form.

“Lowell Pratt,” he said, on the pier, to the assembled board, who had come down in their good clothes because there was no other way to be on a pier. “Senior Examiner, Division of Mutual Carriers. This is a routine financial and market conduct examination of a newly licensed entity under section forty-four of the Act.”

“How routine?” said Ines.

“The standard first-year examination.” He glanced at a clipboard. “Usually conducted at the one-hundred-eighty-day mark.”

“It has been twenty-eight days.”

“The Commissioner’s office has discretion to advance the schedule.” His eyes moved over us without stopping, like a lighthouse over rocks. “I have been asked to be thorough.”

“Asked,” said Ines, “by whom?”

“By the Department,” said Mr. Pratt, and began to walk up the pier.

I stood at the back, as I had been told to. I was, under the terms of my suspension and Boone’s sternest advice, forbidden to advise the Brannock Cover Mutual in any capacity during its examination. I could stand near. I could not speak. Graça had solved the problem in her usual manner. She had put into my hands, at the foot of the pier, a ball of gray wool and two needles.

“You will knit,” she said. “A woman who is knitting is not advising. She is furniture.”

“I do not know how.”

“You will learn. It is a good time for it.”

I learned, that Monday, in the Amaral dining room, in the most expensive tutorial of my life, between the hours of nine and four. The board met around the long table with Mr. Pratt at its head, flanked by two young assistants with laptops, and I sat in the corner by the stove with a ball of wool in my lap and a half-formed scarf on my needles, and said nothing for seven hours, and watched my friends be examined.

I will say it for the record. They were magnificent.

Pratt began with the books. He asked for the general ledger, and Noor, who had been awake since four, handed him a binder with tabs in four colors and a forty-page index. He asked for reconciliations, and Park, sneezing, gave him sixty-one pages of them, signed. He asked for the claims register, and Cleo Marsh, in a nurse’s cardigan with a pen in her hair, laid on the table a stack of nineteen composition notebooks.

“These are the register?” said Pratt.

“They are my notes,” said Cleo. “Every loss on the island since two thousand seven. Date, address, what burned or fell or broke, what I saw, what I paid. You may read them. I will tell you where the handwriting is bad.”

“There is no system of numbering.”

“There is a system. It is the date.”

“It is not a standardized claim number.”

“It is,” said Cleo, “a number that is only used once.”

He stared at her. She stared back. It was a very short exchange and I think he lost.

Hour by hour, the examination went on. The young assistants typed. Pratt asked about segregation of duties, and Billie, who held the Mutual’s tea-tin of dues in her capacity as treasurer, described the system by which three keys were required for the strongbox, kept by three different people, one of whom was Mrs. Pettibone, who had never forgotten hers. He asked about underwriting guidelines, and Haskell produced a hand-drawn chart of every roof on the island, with its age, slope, and shingle, and a formula, in pencil, that predicted wind damage within four percent. Pratt asked how it had been validated. Haskell said, “By forty years of being right.”

At noon, Pip, who had been standing in the doorway with a clipboard she had made herself, announced, “Quality control,” and inspected the examiner’s sandwich.

“Is there a problem?” said Pratt.

“There is a crumb,” said Pip. “On your file.”

He brushed it off. He wrote something. I think it was a note about the crumb.

I knitted. I dropped four stitches. I picked them up. At one o’clock I looked up from my scarf, which had by now achieved the shape of a small sad triangle, and saw, in the doorway to the front hall, with a cup of tea in his hand and a gray electronic cuff on his ankle, Teo.

He was thinner. His hair was cut. He wore a clean canvas jacket and he had the stillness of a man who has spent a month learning that stillness is a courtesy. He did not come in. He had been told, by order of the court, that he could be in my presence only with a third party, and the third party, in the person of his mother, was at that moment seated at the table, with her own knitting, glaring at Mr. Pratt.

He looked at me. I looked at him.

He glanced down at my lap, at the sad triangle, at my hands, which were shaking very slightly with the effort of holding two needles at once.

One corner of his mouth went up.

“It is a good scarf,” he said, softly, across the whole length of the room.

“It is a disaster.”

“It has a good beginning.” His eyes were warm and tired and amused. “Eleven thousand two hundred stitches, I am told, are required for the middle. I have every confidence.”

Nobody in the room moved. Graça, without looking up, said, “Mateus. You may stand in the door. You may not stand any closer.”

“I am standing in the door, Mother.”

“I am aware.”

It was the best moment of the day. I will state that plainly. It was three sentences in a doorway, with a state examiner at the head of the table and an ankle monitor between us, and I went on knitting for an hour with my face burning and my needles clicking and the dim, absurd, almost unbearable happiness of a person who has been spoken to in her own language.

At four, Mr. Pratt closed his binder.

“I have a preliminary finding,” he said. “The Mutual’s financial controls are in order. Its books are among the cleanest I have examined. There is a small deficiency in the filing of its market conduct manual, which should be corrected within sixty days. I will say that, on the whole, I am surprised.”

“Thank you,” said Ines.

“I am not complimenting you.” He did not smile. “I am stating a fact. I was prepared for a different result.” He glanced at the nearest assistant, who handed him a single sheet of cream paper. “There is, however, one matter on which I am instructed to give notice.”

I stopped knitting.

“The Mutual Assurance Act requires that every licensed mutual carry reinsurance, placed through an approved pool, on not less than forty percent of its premium income. The Mutual’s plan of operations, as submitted on the thirteenth of November, did not specify a reinsurer. The Commissioner’s office has, accordingly, designated one.” He cleared his throat. “Under section fifty-one, the Mutual is to cede forty percent of its premiums, retroactive to the date of license, to the designated pool, within thirty days. Failure to do so shall be grounds for the suspension of the license.”

“Designated by whom?” said Ines. She had gone very pale.

“By the Department.” Pratt read from the paper. “The only pool currently approved under the Act to reinsure a mutual of this class. The Tern Reinsurance Pool.”

In the corner, a ball of gray wool rolled slowly off my lap and across the floor, unspooling, and came to rest against the toe of Teo’s shoe.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!