Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 59

Calder

Claims Manual, 33.2: A public record is a promise by the government that it will be late.

The state capital is called Calder, and it is the sort of city that has a very good dome and nothing under it you would want to live in. We came into it on the eight-ten bus on Monday the eighth of January, Ines and I, in our good coats, with a single banker’s box between us and a folded card in her pocket, and it was snowing in the slow, indifferent way that snow falls on government.

The State Insurance Guaranty Association occupied the fourth floor of a granite building across from the legislature. It did not have a sign. It had a brass plate by the elevator, the size of a playing card, which read, in tasteful letters, S.I.G.A., as though the people who worked there had been asked to keep their voices down.

The reception area was carpeted in the color of oatmeal, and the receptionist had the glazed courteous look of someone who answers a telephone for people who are not going to call back. We told her what we wanted. She said that the Association’s records were handled by the board secretary. She picked up a phone. She said, “Connie? There are two women,” and listened, and said, to us, “She says to come back.”

“Through there?” said Ines.

“Through there,” said the receptionist, with a small flicker of what I thought was sympathy.

The board secretary’s office was at the end of a corridor of closed doors. It was a small, square, perfectly tidy room, with a single window onto an airshaft, and I thought, with a peculiar tightness in my chest, of Ines at twenty-nine. The woman behind the desk was sixty-one, short and square, with gray hair cut like a helmet, half-glasses on a beaded chain, and a cardigan the color of putty. She had a nameplate that read CONSTANCE VAIL, and a rubber stamp in her right hand, and she was in the middle of stamping something. She finished. She looked up.

“Ms. Ferreira,” she said. “Ms. Quigley. I have been expecting you since the second of January.”

Ines, who had never in my sight been surprised by anything, said: “Have you?”

“There is a form for a records request. Nobody fills it out. They come in and say, I would like to see the minutes, as though minutes were a kind of soup. I stamp the form in three places, I give them a copy, and they leave.” She picked up a blank form and slid it across the desk. “You will notice that the form says, in the box marked Purpose, Please be brief.”

“What would you like us to put?” I said.

“Whatever is true. Hardly anyone does.”

Ines took the pen. She wrote, in her fine slanting hand, a single line. I read it upside down. Purpose: To examine the record of the Association’s executive sessions concerning the Tern Reinsurance Pool and any cooperative named in Note 13.

She slid it back.

Connie Vail read it. She read it twice, with her lips moving very slightly, and then she took a stamp from a drawer, the old black kind with a wooden handle, and brought it down on the form with a sound like a small door shutting. RECEIVED. Then another. DATE. Then a third, which I had not seen before, a red one, with a single word.

“What does that one say?” I said.

“It says, Noted,” said Connie Vail. “It is the one I use when I wish to be able to prove, afterward, that I saw it.”

“I have been the board secretary for twenty-two years,” she said. “I take the minutes. I keep the minute books. I attend every meeting, public and executive, and I write down what is said in a style that the board has asked me to make as bland as possible, and I do. I am extremely good at it.”

“Mrs. Vail,” said Ines.

“Miss. I never married. I was waiting for a man with a more interesting job than mine.” She almost smiled. “The Association’s open minutes are public. They are in the binder behind me. You may photocopy them at ten cents a page, and I advise you to bring a lunch. The executive session minutes are sealed by a resolution of the board. I cannot show them to you. That is not a courtesy I can extend. It is a statute.”

“We understand,” said Ines, kindly. “We will ask for the refusal in writing.”

“You will not need to.” Connie Vail took off her glasses. “I did not say you could not see anything. I said you could not see the minutes. There is a thing the statute requires of me, section nine-forty-one, subsection three, that nobody has asked about in twelve years. It requires the secretary to maintain a public index of every action taken in executive session. Not the discussion. Not the vote count. Not who said what. Only the date, the item number, and a description of the action in not more than twenty-five words.” She put her glasses back on. “It is two hundred and twelve pages. I type it myself. It is the only part of my job that is not bland. It is quite the most honest document in the building, because no one has ever read it.”

Ines was quite still. I think she was doing the thing she does when she has found, in a statute, the one word she needs, and does not wish to frighten it.

“Where is the index?” she said.

“In the minutes room. Down the hall, second door. It has one chair. The window does not open.” Connie Vail rose. “You may read it for ninety minutes. No copying. No photographs. You may take notes, in pencil, on paper that I will give you. At the end of ninety minutes the room is needed for a meeting of the investment committee.”

“Is it?” I said.

“It is not,” said Connie Vail, “but they will have called by then.”

She led us down the corridor with a small, brisk step, like a woman who had spent her career being very busy so that nobody would ask what she thought. At the second door she paused, with a key on a ring in her hand, and spoke without looking at either of us.

“Mr. Strand asked for the index in November. And again on the twelfth of December. Both times I was out.” She turned the key. “I am out rather a lot, on days when Mr. Strand calls. It is a defect in my constitution.”

“Has anyone else asked?”

“Commissioner Doyle,” said Connie Vail, “asked me on Friday morning, in the hall, with great kindness, whether anyone had requested it. I told him that I had received a records request from a firm of no importance, on the second of January, for the minutes of the investment committee, which was true, and that I had no other.” She opened the door. “It is the only lie I have told in twenty-two years, and I find it has made me thirsty. I shall be getting tea. Do not leave the room.”

It was a closet. A table, a chair, a lamp, a shelf. On the table, squared up with the care of a woman who squares things, lay a single gray three-ring binder, two inches thick, with a label on the spine in typewriter capitals: EXECUTIVE SESSION INDEX, 2011 TO PRESENT.

“It is arranged by date,” said Connie Vail, from the door. “Nineteen to twenty-three is at the back. I should begin there.” She closed the door.

Ines pulled out the chair, and then, with a small, wry noise, gave it to me. She stood behind me with a pencil. I opened the binder at the back. The pages were crisp, and the type was a little uneven, as if hammered on a very old machine by a person who disliked her machine and loved her job.

I began at July.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!