“Erg scores,” said Georgiana Svoboda, and slid a printout across Hamish Lanphier’s workbench as if she were laying down a winning hand. “Every rower in both clubs, ranked by a two-thousand-meter test. It is objective. It is fair. It takes one afternoon.”
“It takes a machine that doesn’t move,” said Hamish.
“That is its virtue.”
“A boat moves.”
It was Thursday night, and the garage had shrunk. Twelve people stood in a space meant for two cars and a ladder, shoulder to shoulder among the life jackets, and the single hanging bulb made everyone look a little embalmed. On one side of the workbench stood Hamish with Dimi and Ferd Caskey. On the other stood Georgiana, with Mireille Joubert and Casper Wojtowicz. Lachlan Yarbrough leaned against the filing cabinet with his arms folded.
Ox sat on the bucket in the corner, where she had been told to sit and not to speak.
“I’m not saying scores don’t matter,” said Hamish. “I’m saying a score is what a person does alone in a basement. We’re not racing alone in a basement.”
“So what is your method?” said Georgiana. “Who has shown up the most?”
“I’d like to see who shows up. Yes.”
“Mr. Lanphier, I have a woman on my crew who has not missed a morning in eleven years.”
“Then she’ll make it.”
“She is sixty-one.”
“Then she’ll probably make it.”
The room made a sound that was almost a laugh and was immediately regretted. Georgiana did not move. Ox watched her, and watched Hamish, and watched the two of them stand in the glare of a bare bulb like two old wrestlers who each knew the other’s weight.
“Excuse me,” said Ox.
Nobody turned.
“Excuse me,” she said, a little louder.
“You’re cox,” Georgiana said. “You will be told.”
“I’ll be steering the result,” said Ox. “So I’d like to have an opinion first.”
Hamish looked at her, and then, to her surprise, so did Lachlan. His arms stayed folded, but his head tilted a fraction.
“Go on,” said Hamish.
“We have twenty-six rowers and eight seats,” Ox said. “Erg scores tell you who’s strong. They don’t tell you who makes a boat go. A very strong person can slow a boat down by pulling a half-second early. A weaker person who’s perfectly in time can make the boat faster than the sum of the parts. The only way to find out is to put them in a boat and race.”
“Seat racing,” said Lachlan.
“Yes.”
“That’s what Denholm did.”
The name hit the garage like a dropped wrench. Nobody moved. Ox kept her eyes on the workbench and her hands flat on her knees.
“It’s a good method,” she said carefully. “It’s the only fair one I know of.”
“It is also,” said Georgiana, “exhausting, imprecise and subject to wind.”
“I can control wind. A little.”
“You are not a god.”
“No, ma’am. I’m a gauge tech. I can measure it.” She took a breath. “Here’s what I’m proposing. Saturday, after the dock opens to both clubs. Two eights, side by side, same stretch of river, a thousand meters. Race one, we row the lineup that we’ve got. Then we swap one person from each boat, a pair of people who row the same side. Race again.
The boats are different speeds, so the first number doesn’t matter. What matters is the change. If swapping you into the slower boat makes it gain two seconds, you’re worth two seconds.”
“Two seconds on a thousand meters is huge,” said Bram Rahimi quietly, from the doorway.
“Two seconds is a long way. Under a second is a tie.” She turned a page of the notebook on her knee. “We repeat it for every pair. We swap back, to check. We switch lanes, so neither boat gets the good water.
I’ll write down the stage on the gauge before every piece, so we know the current isn’t shifting under us, and I’ll note the wind from the weather station at the water plant. If the margin changes by less than a second, it’s a tie and we say so.”
“And then?” said Georgiana.
“And then somebody decides what a tie means,” said Ox.
The silence lasted several seconds. Then Georgiana said, in a tone of faint surprise, “You’ve thought about this.”
“I’ve thought about it for three years.”
She regretted the sentence instantly. Mireille Joubert, who had spent fifteen minutes staring at her phone, looked up. Casper Wojtowicz stopped scratching his beard.
“Fine,” said Lachlan. He pushed off the filing cabinet. “I’ll do it. I’ll sit wherever she says. I’ll swap if she wants me to swap.”
“You’re stroke,” Georgiana said. “You’re not going to be swapped.”
“Then I’ll sit in the Pig Iron,” he said, “and row the whole thing for someone else’s seat.”
“Why?”
“Because it’s the same number whoever does it.” He glanced at Ox. “And because if the stroke is above the process, it isn’t one.”
Georgiana opened her mouth. She closed it. Hamish, in the corner, picked up his coffee and stared into it with great seriousness, so that nobody would see his face.
“Saturday,” said Georgiana at last. “Six o’clock. I will be watching.”
“You’ll be the only one who’s dressed for it,” Hamish said.
On Saturday the river had dropped another foot, and the whole bank had grown a skirt of gray silt that squelched under shoes. The sun came up thin and cold behind the Water Street bridge. Ox stood on the dock with a clipboard she had borrowed from the county and a sheet of lanes in her notebook, and she found she was gripping both so tightly that her knuckles ached.
It was all there on the page. Twenty-six rowers, six pairs of candidates, twelve pieces of a thousand meters each. She had planned it in the gauge truck at lunch for two days, drawing arrows in the margins, and she had given each piece a number and a purpose.
She had not planned for the weather, which was cold, or for the audience, which was forty people on the bank.
Gideon Havlicek found her at the end of the dock before the first boat went out. He was a lean, sandy man in a surveyor’s fleece, with sunburn in the creases of his eyes and the quiet manner of someone who spent his days looking through a small lens at a faraway pole.
“I hear it might be me and Mika,” he said.
“It might.”
“I’d like to ask you one thing.”
“Go ahead.”
“Whatever the number is, I want it to be the number.” He scuffed a boot on the concrete. “I don’t want to be picked because of how long I’ve rowed. I don’t want to be picked because I look like a person who ought to be in the boat. If she’s faster, put her in.”
“And if you’re faster?”
“Then I’m faster. I can live with that.” He looked at the river. “I’ve had a bad month. I’d like one clean answer.”
“I can’t promise it’ll be clean.”
“I know,” said Gideon. “I measure things for a living. Nothing’s clean. I just like to see the error bars.”
She wrote that on the back of her hand with a pen, because it was the best thing anyone had said to her all week, and she did not know yet that she would need it.
“Why are there so many?” she whispered to Hamish.
“Family,” he said. “Friends. A man from the newspaper.”
“There is a man from the newspaper?”
“A very small one,” said Hamish. “He has a notebook. He looks happy.”
She had never wanted to be seen less. She tucked the clipboard under her arm and walked down the dock to where the two boats waited in the water, side by side, bumping very gently.
The first race was the plain one, the baseline. She sat in the Constance and Wynn, Halewood’s nineteen-year-old cox, a tall boy with a sunburned neck and a sullen look, sat in the Pig Iron. The two crews were mixed, four and four in each boat, and Ox had drawn the lineups by lottery from a coffee can. Nobody could say she had stacked it.
“Ready all,” she said. “Row.”
It was a ragged start. Both boats jerked forward, and the Constance, which was lighter and had better riggers, pulled ahead by a half length in twenty strokes. Ox did what she had always done in a race, and shut out everything but the boat: eight backs, eight blades, the pulse of the slide, the faint drag of the current at the stern.
She heard herself talking in a low, level voice, a stream of small instructions. Ten at base, bow pair, watch the finish. Settle. Settle. Long, long, long.
They crossed the line half a length ahead. She had the stopwatch in her hand before the boat stopped.
“Three minutes, fifty-one,” she said. “Pig Iron, three minutes, fifty-four. Margin, three seconds. Swap.”
The swaps were the slow part. Each took ninety seconds, in which two rowers climbed out and two climbed in, and everyone sat in the cold wind talking too loudly. Ox recorded the stage on the gauge, the wind speed and the time. Hamish had set up a folding table with a thermos. Georgiana stood at the end of the dock in a long navy coat with her hands in her pockets and did not take her eyes off anyone.
By the sixth piece it had become a rhythm. Ox rowed, timed, wrote, swapped. The numbers piled up in a column on the page.
Mika Kimura against Gideon Havlicek, the quiet, powerful surveyor who had been rowing for nine years, came up as pieces seven and eight.
Ox knew it before the first stroke. It was the one she had been dreading. Both of them rowed starboard. Both of them wanted the two seat. Mika had been on a boat for five months. Gideon had been on a boat for nine years. On paper there was no contest.
Piece seven: Mika in the Constance, Gideon in the Pig Iron. The margin was two seconds in favor of the Constance. The crew sat in the cold and nobody said anything. Mika’s hands trembled on the oar handle, and Ox, sitting behind her, saw her lean forward and press her forehead against the oar for a moment, like someone testing a hot stove.
“Swap,” she said.
Piece eight: Mika in the Pig Iron, Gideon in the Constance.
She expected the margin to widen. She had been sure of it. A nine-year rower in the faster boat against a five-month rower in the slower one: it ought to have gone the Constance’s way by four seconds, five.
She watched the Pig Iron through the whole piece. On the outside, it was a rough boat, heavy and slow. But with Mika in the two seat something had changed. Mika wasn’t pulling harder, she was pulling at exactly the same instant as everyone around her, and the Pig Iron’s oars had begun to enter the water like a single hand. At the three-quarter mark the old boat closed a half length.
At the line, the stopwatch read three minutes, fifty-three seconds for the Constance, and three minutes, fifty-six for the Pig Iron.
“Three seconds,” she said aloud, to nobody. “Margin three.”
“Two last time,” said Bram Rahimi, from five seat. “So it’s a one-second swing.”
“Against her,” said Gideon quietly, from the Constance, “or for her?”
“For you,” said Ox. “Plus a second.”
A pause. A boat slapped a wave, and the wake rocked them gently side to side.
“A second is a tie?” said Casper, in the doubtful tone of a man who suspected he had done the arithmetic wrong. “I thought a tie was half of that.”
“Under a second is a tie. A second on the nose is the edge of one.” Ox looked at her page. “One second swing. If you squint, Gideon’s faster.”
“By a second?”
“By a second over a thousand meters. It’s small.” She heard herself. “It’s not nothing.”
Nobody spoke. Mika sat in the Pig Iron with her hands clenched on the oar. Ox could not see her face. She could see her shoulders, which were rigid, and the long braid hanging between them.
“Run it again,” said Lachlan from the stroke seat of the Pig Iron.
“It’s not necessary.”
“Run it again. Please.”
She wanted to say no. Every instinct said it was a bad idea. She looked at Hamish on the dock, who made no signal at all, and at Georgiana beside him. She looked at the stopwatch in her hand.
“We’ll run it again,” she said.
It was the twelfth piece, with a river that had begun to rise a quarter inch, which she knew because she had watched the surface of the water against a piling for an hour. They swapped Mika and Gideon one more time, in reverse order.
This time the swing was eight-tenths of a second, the same way.
She sat in the stern of the Constance holding the stopwatch and let the numbers settle. Swing of one second. Swing of eight-tenths. Corrected for the river, which had crept up while they raced, it came out at nine-tenths of one second.
Nine-tenths. A rounding error. A coin.
“It’s a tie,” Ox said.
Georgiana had walked down to the end of the dock. She stood over the boat with her hands in her coat pockets and looked down at Ox, and her face was exactly as unreadable as before.
“It is not a tie,” she said. “It is nine-tenths of a second in favor of Mr. Havlicek.”
“It’s inside the error.”
“It is a number. Numbers are what we have.”
“Yes,” said Ox. “And the error on a number like this is about a second. Whoever sits in two seat is going to be exactly as good as the other, plus or minus.”
“Then who sits there?”
“I don’t know yet.”
“That is not an answer.”
“It’s the true answer.” She heard her own voice, level and low. “I’ll decide tonight.”
Georgiana looked at her a moment longer. “You will decide,” she said. “Not Lanphier. Not the crew.”
“I’m the cox.”
“It is a very large amount of authority,” said Georgiana, “for someone who left.”
She walked away. The clipboard dug a groove in Ox’s palm.
It was past eleven when the last boat was racked and the last cold doughnut gone. Ox sat alone at the end of the dock with her feet over the water, the notebook on her knee, and eleven pages of numbers staring back at her.
Behind her someone sat down. She did not turn.
“Nine-tenths,” said Hamish.
“I know.”
“What are you going to do?”
“I don’t know.”
“You do.”
She said nothing. Out on the water the heron she had seen on the first morning was back, standing on the same half-sunk desk, one leg tucked up, watching nothing.
“If I put Gideon in, I’m following the number,” she said slowly. “He’s faster. He’s more experienced. Halewood’s happy. If I put Mika in, I’m following my gut. She makes the boat sit down. The crew feels it. I can hear it in the oars. But I can’t prove it. It’s nine-tenths of a second against the number.”
“A tie is yours to break,” said Hamish. “And you’ll be wrong to somebody.”
“Somebody’s going to lose a seat.”
“Somebody was always going to lose a seat.” He leaned on the piling. “That’s the whole job, Radovich. It’s not the rowing. It’s knowing that you’ve got eight chairs and twenty-six people and every one of them lost something in that flood.”
“Mika lost her car.”
“Gideon lost his house.” He said it flatly. “His mother’s house. He hasn’t told anyone. He got a call at the water plant, and he came to row anyway.”
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
“Because you’d have picked him.”
She looked at him.
“And I wanted,” said Hamish, “to see what you’d do without knowing.”
He got up and went back up the dock with his coffee. Ox sat for a long time with the notebook open on her knee.
In the end she wrote the lineup on a clean page, in pencil, at ten past midnight on the kitchen table of her apartment, with the radio low and the heating off. Stroke, Lachlan Yarbrough. Seven, Mireille Joubert. Six, Casper Wojtowicz. Five, Bram Rahimi. Four, Ferd Caskey. Three, Soledad Zabala. Two, Mika Kimura. Bow, Dimi Demetriou. Spare, Gideon Havlicek, with a circle drawn around the name, and under it, in smaller letters, first call.
She wrote the reason underneath it, and then she crossed the reason out.
The reason was not that she had followed the number. The reason was that when Mika sat in the boat, the whole boat sat down, and the thing she had been listening for her entire career, that soft synchronized bite of eight blades in water, had happened under her hands. She could not prove it. She had written “tie” on the page. She had known, as she wrote it, what she would do.
She fixed the paper to the dock board with four thumbtacks at six the next morning and went to work.
By eight o’clock she had read two gauges, cleaned a clogged orifice line at Culvert Four, and eaten a gas-station sandwich in the truck. At ten past eight, her phone buzzed on the dashboard.
It was a message from Bernadette Hyland.
Received a complaint from Halewood regarding the selection process. Please call me. Today.
She looked at it for a long time. Then she turned the phone face down on the seat, and started the truck, and drove to the next gauge.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!