Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 100

Terms

On the first Wednesday in May, at 4:15 in the afternoon, the District Attorney told Levon Kasparian that his uncle wished to plead guilty to killing his brother, and that she was inclined to let him.

I wasn't there. I was a witness, and a woman in my position doesn't sit in on conversations about what the Commonwealth will accept. I sat in the Defender's library, on the ninth floor, with a plea binder open to a page I wasn't reading, and at 5:40 Levon texted me the words *Before dinner. My place. Silva is coming.* Then, a minute later: *I'm making soup. Do not offer to help.*

His apartment in Fishtown has two rooms and a kitchen with a window onto an alley where a cat has been waiting since 2019 for someone to apologize. The copper pot was on the stove. He had tied on the apron that says KISS THE COOK, which his landlady Mrs. Tavitian had given him in January as a threat, and he was stirring yogurt and egg and barley into a pale, fragrant soup he called *spas* and told me was a wedding dish. There were three bowls on the table and a fourth on the counter, beside a small laptop propped against the wall.

"My grandmother made this the night before anyone signed anything," said Levon. "She said you should not decide on an empty stomach, and you should never decide on a full one. It's a very precise recipe." He tasted it. "Tell me the DA's offer before it burns."

"You tell me," I said. "I wasn't there."

He gave me the terms in order, standing, wooden spoon in hand, the way he'd once told me the facts of a murder he was charged with: without adjectives. The DA had received a letter at noon from Nolan Adair, on behalf of his client, withdrawing every prior position. Hrant Kasparian would plead guilty to third-degree murder in the death of Aram Vahan Kasparian, to arson, to risking a catastrophe, to insurance fraud, to conspiracy in the death of Leonard Fisk. A negotiated sentence: twenty to forty years, which for a man of sixty-two is a polite way of saying the rest of his life. No trial. No testimony beyond a short colloquy before Judge Pell, to establish a factual basis. No cooperation against anyone else.

"The last line is a sentence," I said.

"It is." Levon turned off the burner. "The DA says it's the best case she's ever seen for a plea. She said it makes the Commonwealth whole in three weeks instead of four months. She said, and this is a quote, that a trial is a gamble the victim's family never asked to place." He set the spoon on a saucer, squared it, looked at it, and left it crooked. "She also said the grand jury on Mr. Whitlow would not need Hrant's trial to proceed. It would go on. It would have the evidence it has now."

"It would have a card in a box and a pencil rubbing."

"Yes."

"And no witnesses under oath. And no subpoena power of a trial, and no jury, and no record."

"Yes." He took off the apron. "I wanted you to say it before I did."

"Also, before," he added. "Cole told me about the pad. *Not the boy.* The morning of the fire Aram made me promise I'd stay home that night. I was twenty-three. I thought he meant Papa's temper." He rinsed his hands. "I've been wondering since Monday whether I was the boy."

The doorbell rang. It was Silva Kasparian, in a navy raincoat with her silver braid pinned up, carrying a covered dish and an umbrella, and behind her on the stair Sade Adeyemi, with the huge travel mug and a rolling bag that contained, I learned, a tablet, a charger and an emergency eye-gaze keyboard the size of a pizza box. She set it up on the counter beside the fourth bowl. At 6:30 sharp the laptop lit, and in the frame, in his gray cardigan, in a room at St. Brigid's with a window behind him, was Vahan.

"Papa," said Levon, standing a little too fast. "I'm at the apartment. I'm making your soup. You'd say there's too much barley."

The old man's left hand lay on the armrest. It lifted, an inch, and pressed once.

Silva ate nothing. She sat with her hands folded on her raincoat, which she had not taken off. She is sixty, small and straight, a woman who had sat in the first row of a courtroom for six months watching her husband be looked at. "Levon," she said, "I will tell you what I think, and then I will stop, because it isn't mine to decide."

"Please."

"He will take it." She said it quietly. "He has decided to take the card to prison with him. I have been married to him thirty-six years and I know what his face does when he has put something down. He will plead, and he'll go to Laurel Gap or Pine Hollow, and he'll teach the men to read, and he will be very kind. And nobody will ever ask him what it was for." She looked at the laptop screen. "I think that is what he wants. I think it is the last thing he knows how to give."

Nobody answered. On the small screen, Vahan's eyes had moved to the tablet. For twelve minutes we ate a soup too thick with barley and watched the cursor jump among the letters. Sade did not touch the screen. When the line was complete, she read it aloud, once, in the careful voice of a woman who has promised never to lead.

"A-S-K," she said. "Ask. H-I-M."

"Ask him what?" said Levon, very softly. "Papa, ask who what?"

The cursor moved. Four minutes. Then: *ARAM SAID.*

I put my spoon down. The kitchen was very warm and the window had steamed. Levon had gone perfectly still beside the stove with his hand on the back of a chair.

"He wrote it on a card," I said. "In pencil. In capitals. *Ask him what it is in advance for.* It's in the evidence room." I looked at the little screen. "Mr. Kasparian, did he say it to you?"

One press. Yes.

"When?"

Sade held her hand over the board. The cursor wandered, stopped, found a letter, lost it. *AFTER THE BOOKS. TO THE DOOR. I DID NOT HEAR. I HIT THE TABLE.*

I felt Silva's hand close over mine on the table. It was not a gesture of comfort. It was the grip of a woman holding onto the edge of a boat.

"He said it to the door," said Levon, "and you didn't hear him." He knelt beside the laptop so that his face was level with the camera. "Papa. Listen. You were a man who'd just been told his son had stolen a ledger." He drew a breath. "I have promised to stop deciding alone. I've been asked to decide whether to let Hrant plead, and I'm going to ask you, and I want you to answer however you want, with a press or a tap or nothing. Do you want him to plead?"

Two taps. No.

"Do you want a trial?"

A long silence. Then one press, and, after it, a second line, slow as a candle burning down. *I WANT HIM ASKED.*

"By whom?" said Levon.

*YOU.*

He stayed on his knees for a very long time. I watched his back. In all the months I had known him he had asked for nothing from anyone: not a favor, not a doctor, not a loan, not a verdict. He had told me, once, in the first week, that a Kasparian does not ask because to ask is to owe, and it was the thing I'd have bet my record he would never do. His shoulders came down. His hand opened on his knee.

"All right," he said, hoarsely. He got up, and he squared nothing. "Silva, will you come to court? Mrs. Kasparian, I'd like you in the front row. Sade, I'd like you to stay for dessert." He looked at me over the small kitchen, over the soup and the copper pot, and I saw something in his face I had last seen at the Justice Center steps in November: a man standing on the far side of a decision he had made before anyone told him he could.

"I'm going to ask him," said Levon. "At the plea hearing, in front of Judge Pell, in front of everyone. Victims have the right to be heard. I'm going to use it. I'm going to ask my uncle one question, out loud, and I'm going to wait for the answer."

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!