I lost the suppression hearing at 9:40 on Thursday morning, after forty minutes, by a margin the judge called "closer than the Commonwealth deserves."
Dante Willis took it better than I did. He sat at the defense table in a borrowed shirt with the collar buttoned too tight and said, "Okay," in the voice he'd used in the jail. In the holding cell afterward, over a paper cup of water, I explained what the loss meant: the gun stayed in, the stop was lawful, and the case now rested on a boy's reasonable belief that a phone was a pistol. The Commonwealth had offered eight to sixteen years. I told him what that meant, minute by minute, year by year, and what a jury might do, and then I stood up and left the room.
I was gone eleven minutes. When the deputy let me back in, he had turned his chair to the wall and was looking at the cinderblock.


