There is a particular sound that a courtroom makes when a very old lawyer says something that is true, and I heard it at twenty minutes to eleven on the morning of March 12, in the Superior Court at the county seat, when Philippa Stroud rose from her chair with both hands on the table and said, "Your Honor, may I ask the petitioner one question about arithmetic?"
It was a small sound. It was the sound of forty people shifting their weight. I had been in a number of rooms where money was fought over, and never one where the fighters were so evenly matched in age and so unevenly matched in everything else. On one side of the aisle sat Aunt Patrice Prentiss, seventy-one, in black wool and a hat with a small stiff feather, with her handbag on her lap and Warren Tisdale at her side in a charcoal suit. On the other, at the long table for the respondents, sat Stroud, Dana Whitcomb in her gray raincoat, Wren Lane with a legal pad, Ruth in her chair with a plaid blanket, and me.
Judge Amato had the bench. She was a short, square woman with iron-colored hair and half-moon glasses, and she looked at the petition, and at Tisdale, and at the packed gallery, with the same weary patience that one sees in a woman who has been asked to settle a family quarrel at a wedding.


