On cribbage nights, the lobby of the Larkspur belonged to the Liars.
Nobody called them that to their faces. The Ferris Gap Evening Cribbage and Fellowship Society had met at the card table by the fire since 1974, three men and sometimes a fourth, and the official purpose was cribbage. The actual purpose was lying. Politely, inventively, for hours, over bad coffee and a bowl of Marnie's oyster crackers, they told one another stories that began with "Back when I was running the plow" and ended somewhere in the neighborhood of fiction.
I'd grown up on those stories. I could still tell the lies from the truth by the cribbage pegs. A man who really remembered something moved his peg while he told it. A man who was inventing kept his hands still.
"And that," Iggy Sobel finished, "is how I came to conduct the regional symphony in my pajamas."
"You never," said Wick.
"I did, Wickham. Fog. Missed bus. I gave them the downbeat and they never knew."
"Your peg didn't move."
"I'll have you know my peg has dignity."
I laughed. I hadn't meant to. It came out sudden and rusty, like a gate, and three heads turned toward the sound as if a deer had walked into the lobby.
"There," Iggy said, pleased. "Thawing."
I was sitting on the arm of a leather chair with a folder of payoff letters in my lap and a cup of coffee I'd been given without asking. It was almost nine. The radiators ticked. Outside, rain had come back on, soft and steady, and the front windows were fogged to the sills.
"I've been told," I said, "that I'm not forgiven."
"You're not," Wick agreed.
"Wick," said Iggy.
"I'm only agreeing with her. She's a sensible woman. Never insult the sensible." He laid a card. "Fifteen two, fifteen four, and a pair is six."
"There's a procedure," Iggy told me. "I've been mayor for eleven years and I've learned a thing about forgiveness. It's like an old furnace. You can't hurry it. You stand there with a wrench and a nice attitude, and eventually it catches."
"Like Gerald," I said.
"Exactly like Gerald."
Ray Novak didn't say anything.
He sat across from Wick with his cards fanned in a big, scarred hand, a man built like a mailbox, square and gray and dented. I hadn't seen him up close in ten years. He'd been fire chief for twenty-six of them. He'd taught me to ride his son's old bicycle once, running behind it in his big black boots shouting "Pedal, Hartigan!" so many times that the phrase still sounded like affection. I'd called him Mr. Novak, then Ray, and then, for a few long engaged months, Dad, in a joke we both pretended wasn't a promise.
He laid a six of hearts on the table.
"I'll say this once," he said, to the cards. "I'm not mad at you."
"Okay."
"I'm mad at a lot of things. The world. The weather. My knee. You're the nearest piece."
"That's fair."
"It's not fair. It's just where I'm aiming." He looked up. His eyes were Gabe's eyes, gray-green, the color of lake ice, and I had not known how much I'd missed them until they were turned on me and I couldn't hold them. "You hurt my son."
"I know."
"He's a grown man. He doesn't need me defending him."
"I know that too."
"Then we understand each other." He gathered his cards. "Fifteen two, and I'm out."
"You're out of what?" Iggy said, baffled.
"Everything," said Ray. "Peg me, Wick."
I realized I was smiling in a way that hurt. Beyond the cribbage table, past the big stone hearth with its ashes and its iron andirons, a clock ticked on the mantel, and the lamplight fell yellow on the old brass key board, on the empty hooks, on one hook in particular, the ninth, from which hung a single brass key with a round tag. A numeral, 9, stamped into it. Polished bright. The only key on the board that had been touched in the last year.
"Wick," I said. "How long has the Room Nine key hung there?"
The little postmaster's hands paused over his cards, just for a breath.
"Longer than I've had a heartbeat that worked right," he said. "Why?"
"Because it's the cleanest thing in the building."
"Dot polished it every morning."
"That's a lot of devotion for a guest who never comes."
"She was a devoted woman." He laid his next card very carefully. "Thirty-one. Go."
Iggy said, "Wick, that's twenty-nine."
"Then I'm confused, and you're welcome to the point." Wick gathered his hand. "I'm going to bed."
"It's nine o'clock."
"I'm eighty-one. I've been going to bed since 1998."
He stood, ninety pounds of starch and stubbornness in an oatmeal cardigan, and crossed the lobby with the careful dignity of a man who doesn't intend to be asked another question. At the door he paused, and without turning around he said, "It's good you're home, Nell. It's about time somebody was."
Then he was gone, out into the rain with a folded newspaper over his head.
"What was that?" I said.
"A good man," said Iggy, "being very bad at lying. Take it as a compliment. Your move, Ray."
I took my coffee to bed.
The Gap Diner opened at five-thirty, which in Ferris Gap meant that by six the counter was a parliament of men in canvas jackets pretending not to wait for the day's gossip. I slid onto the last stool at the end, beside the pie case, and a plate of eggs and hash browns arrived in front of me with a clatter I felt in my fillings.
"Eat," said Tam. "I'll yell at you after."
"You can yell now."
"I'm not doing it with a customer base." She nodded at the counter. Eight faces turned very quickly back to eight cups of coffee. "I'm a professional."
She was in an apron the color of a school bus, belly leading her around the counter like a figurehead on a ship, hair in a topknot held with a pencil. Her diner was her whole life. Her parents had run it for thirty years, and when her mother Anjali retired she had been twenty-six with a fresh culinary degree and an ambition to open a restaurant in Montreal. Instead she'd stayed. She'd grown the diner into the best thing on Main Street. I had never once heard her say she'd given anything up.
She sat down across from me in the booth behind the counter. Then she put her head in her hands.
"Tam?"
"I'm fine. I'm fine. It's the hormones."
"You're crying."
"It's also very emotional, you jerk." She wiped her eyes with the heel of her hand. "I'm furious at you and I missed you. Do you know how hard it is to do both? I was going to say something cutting and practiced. I wrote it in the shower. And you walked in with your wheelie bag and your dumb blazer and you look like you haven't slept since June, and I just want to feed you."
"I'm sorry."
"For the funeral."
"For everything."
"Oh, honey." She took my hand across the table. Her fingers were warm and floury and shaking a little. "Dot was so proud of you. She had your newspaper articles on the lobby corkboard. She had a picture of you from some hotel award, from the regional one. She told every guest. 'My niece fixes inns, you know.' And then she'd look at the dust and say, 'Not this one, she's too busy.' And she meant it kindly. That's what killed me. She meant it kindly."
I couldn't say anything. I ate hash browns. Tam let me.
When I could talk again, I told her about the will, the bank and Lowell's offer. About the numbers, the buy-out, the Historical Society. She listened with her chin on her fist and her eyes narrowing.
"Three-ten," she said. "For the building."
"That's what he said."
"He's going to demolish it."
"I haven't proved that."
"Honey, I've lived here my whole life. A Prentiss has never done a nice thing for the town that didn't get him a parking lot." She stirred her coffee. "His father was the same. Aldous. Ran the bank for thirty years with a smile like an open drawer. The pension thing, you know."
"The mill pension."
"Nobody talks about it. Everybody's grandparents lost something. My mother's mother. Marnie's husband. Half the Liars." She lowered her voice. "My mom says the whole town got quiet that winter and has never quite come back. Like we all agreed on a story, and then forgot why."
"That a Ferris Gap thing?"
"That's every town."
I pushed my plate away. Out the front window, rain had thinned to drizzle, and the green rooftops of Main Street were steaming gently in a break of sun. A man across the street was unloading folding chairs into the church hall. Somebody's dog was barking at nothing.
"Tam," I said. "Have you been past the depot lately?"
Her face changed. It was a small change, the lift of an eyebrow, a quick flick of her eyes toward the counter as if she were checking who was listening.
"Funny you'd ask."
"I walked by yesterday. One of the boards is off the front door."
"Is it." She got up. She wiped her hands on her apron and began, with great concentration, to stack mugs that were already stacked. "Gabe boarded it up himself, you know. After the roof. Fifteen years ago, when the town couldn't afford to tear it down and couldn't stand to look at it. He's the only one with a key."
"I know."
"So I asked him. Last weekend. I said, somebody's pried your boards, and he said it wasn't him."
"Maybe a kid."
"Maybe." She set a mug on the shelf with a click. "But Gabe went down there the night before last and found a fire ring. A little one. Dug into the platform. And the ashes were still warm."
"Somebody's camping in there."
"That's what I said."
"What did he say?"
"He said," Tam said, "that whoever it was had swept up after themselves. And then he went home and didn't talk to anybody for two days. You know how he gets."
I did know how he got.
I thought about the river-stone color of his eyes in the basement, the cold flat voice. You haven't asked how anybody's been. And I thought about the thing I had been told in a hundred training seminars, that when a building starts to tell you things, you stand very still and let it.
"Tam," I said. "Is there anyone in this town who has a reason to be sleeping in a ruin?"
She turned, finally, and looked me square in the face. And what she said, in a voice so low that the counter couldn't have heard it, was the thing that ended breakfast.
"Not anyone who lives here," she said. "Which is what's scaring him."

