SHAKE WELL BEFORE USING. DO NOT SHAKE THE PRESCRIBER.
Winnie fed him. I want that on the record, because there was a good deal of argument that morning about what he was, and nobody in the galley of the Hazel Dawn at seven o'clock was in any state to settle it, but Winnie Plunkett looked at a thin man in a long coat standing dripless in her doorway and said, "Sit, pet, you look peaked," and put a bowl of oatmeal in front of him with a lump of butter in the middle.
He thanked her. He held the spoon for a long moment, the way people hold a pen they have not used in years. Then he put it down and did not eat.
"I cannot taste it, I'm afraid," he said. "But I should like it to be warm. Is that foolish?"
"No, pet," said Winnie.
Hank sat at the head of the table in her cardigan with her arms crossed. Pez sat at the far end and threw salt over his left shoulder, then his right, then, after some thought, in the general direction of Ansel Marek's boots. Kenji hung in the doorway counting under his breath. Dunmore had come up from the pier with her shoes on and her notebook out and the expression of a barefoot woman who has been handed a fourth client she did not choose.
"State your authority," she said.
"I have none," said Ansel. "I am the instrument. I was drafted to be a rule and have only lately been permitted to be a man. I can tell you what I know, and I should like you to correct me where the Court's records disagree, because I have not seen them in a hundred and seventy years and I am certain they are a good deal tidier than I was."
"Noted," said Hank.
"Thank you, madam."
"I wasn't thanking you."
"No. I understood that."
He folded his hands. I had my notebook on my knee and Tav on my left, and I wrote what he said, and I will give it here in order, because it was the only time in the whole business that anyone explained a rule to me in plain English without charging by the hour.
The third chair is not a seat. It is a shift. When the Court was founded, there were two chairs, one for the sea and one for the shore, and every matter that came before it was a matter of one or the other. Then came a matter that was neither, and the Court had no chair for it. The person who brought it was not drowned and not ashore. He was kept. The Court founded a third chair to hold the matter, and the matter needed someone to hold, and someone sat down.
"And the sitter," said Dunmore, "is the person whom the matter concerns."
"Not always. For the first of them, it was a man who wished the matter to be heard and had no other means." He looked at the oatmeal. "While a sitter sits, the matter is open. When the matter is heard, the sitter stands up. That was the whole design. It was a very short sentence. 'The chair shall hold the petitioner until he is heard.'"
"Until he is heard," I said.
"By the Court."
"And the Court heard you."
"The Court," said Ansel, "has never heard me. It has heard everyone else. It heard Tobias and the kegs and a hundred and forty-one petitions about the weather. It put me to Tuesday. It put me to Tuesday on the first of January and on every Tuesday since, and nobody could hear me because the clause said 'the Court' and the Court was only ever the two reeves, who were in a hurry. I sat, and sat, and wrote in the margin." His hands tightened, very slightly. "Eleven days ago a younger sitter was filed for. The chair, which can count, let me go. I walked up your stairs. It is the most remarkable thing I have ever done."
"You walked up 612 steps," said Pez, "in the dark."
"I should say I was carried, rather, by a quite spectacular sense of grievance."
Winnie put her hand over her mouth. It was Tav who laughed first, a short startled sound, and then Kenji, and I saw even Hank's mouth give a quarter-inch before she took it back.
"So the order," said Dunmore, sitting very straight. "The petitioner is to attend in person at the next spring low and sit in the middle chair. You say that is the trap."
"I say it is a promise I made two hundred years ago, in good faith, and worded very badly. The Court is bound by it. It cannot seat your brother any other way. And once he is seated, 'until heard' applies, and the Court has the same two reeves, with the same hurry, and the same Tuesday."
"The Reeve of the Shore seemed to me rather attentive," said Dunmore.
"She is. So was I. It makes no difference. The Court cannot hear a sitter under a sentence that does not say who hears him. I know. I tried. I wrote the question in pencil for a hundred and seventy years." He turned his head to me. "Your brother wrote to the Clerk that he would like to be asked what he wants. That is a very simple request, Miss Marek, and the chair is the one place in the Roads where it cannot be answered."
I wrote it down. I had been writing it down for twenty minutes, and under the page my hand had gone cold in a way that had nothing to do with the galley. I looked at my left wrist. It was only cold. It was not writing.
"What about relief?" said Tav. "You said you got up because somebody else was filed for. If Danny sits, does that let you go? Properly? For good?"
It was a good question. It was the question I had been trying to ask for twenty minutes and had not been able to get past my teeth. Ansel looked at him, and then at me, and for the first time I thought I saw the man behind the man under the coat.
"Yes," he said.
Nobody spoke.
"It would let me go. It would send me out of the room like a coat that was never fitted, and I should be, I think, nothing, or something very quiet, and I will be honest with you, I have wanted that for a long time." He swallowed. "I want it still. I want it very much. And I tell you plainly that I will not have it at your brother's price. I did not walk up your stairs to ask you to sell a young man into my chair."
"Then what do you want?" said Hank. It was the longest sentence she had said to him.
"I want to amend," said Ansel Marek.
"Amend what?"
"The sentence. A sentence can be amended by its author, if the author can produce the original. That is the law, Ms. Dunmore will tell you, the oldest we have. But I cannot produce it. I am the original." A dry little smile. "I mean that I am what is left of the original. The page I wrote it on is gone, and the Court, which kept the instrument, has never had the pages. It has only the sentence, copied, and the copy is wrong, and you cannot correct a copy from a copy. You need the book it was torn from."
"What book?" said Dunmore.
"The Day Book. My apothecary's register. I wrote the chair in the back of it on a Tuesday in a state I cannot recommend, and tore out the page and gave it to the first reeve, who was a decent man and did not look at it. He bound it into the rolls. The rest, the register, stayed in the shop, and the shop became a dispensary and the dispensary became something else." He closed his eyes. "I wrote it wrong, Miss Marek. I know exactly how. It is in the next three lines and I can't remember them. I can remember that I was weeping. I cannot remember the grammar."
"Where's the book?" I said.
He opened his eyes.
"On Cask Island," said Ansel. "In Kettle Harbor, in the cellar of the Union. And the people who keep it do not, I believe, know what it is."

