NO SUBSTITUTIONS. NO REFILLS. NO EXCEPTIONS. EXCEPT THE ONE YOU ARE ABOUT TO MAKE.
Judge Hallam of the Marlow District Court had not smiled since his appointment, and on Monday morning he looked at Imogen Rusk's lunch pail as if it might go off.
"What is that?"
"An exhibit, Your Honor," said Mercy Dunmore. "Respondents' Exhibit Four. It contains six hundred and eleven tin tags."
"I can see that it contains tags. Why is it on my bench?"
"Because it's the only item in the case that tells the truth, Your Honor, and I thought it would be nice to have one in the room."
There was a ripple in the gallery. Hallam did not look up. He was a gaunt, bald, stooped man in a black robe a size too large, and he sat very high above the room, with a pencil behind each ear in a pattern I had begun to find alarming. He wrote nothing down. He had a reputation, Dunmore had told me, for deciding cases in the first ten minutes and spending the rest of the time finding out whether he had been right.
It was ten o'clock on Monday, Day 210. The courtroom was a high old paneled room with a flag, a clock, and three tall windows, and I have never seen so many hard hats in one place. Gus Brannigan had brought the whole of Local 9. They stood along the back wall in their canvas coats with their white hats in their hands, one hundred and forty of them, and not one made a sound. Hale sat in the second row beside Venn. Quarles sat beside him with a clipboard and a file box marked TRIPLICATE.
Across the aisle Strake sat with his hands folded and a look of serene regret.
"Mr. Strake," said Hallam. "It's your application."
"It is, Your Honor." Strake rose. "Halvard's position is simple. A refinery is a place of lawful business. Certain materials are held under a security. The respondents, a union local, a trespasser, a tidal tribunal and a barefoot lawyer, seek to interfere with that business. Halvard asks only that the status quo be preserved until the question of title is heard."
"The status quo," said Hallam.
"Yes, Your Honor."
"What is the status quo, Mr. Strake?"
"Your Honor?"
"I should like it in a sentence. I am an old man. I find it clarifies things."
Strake paused. It was only a half second, but I saw it. "The lots remain in the pipe room under tank four, in the custody of the plant, pending further order."
"The pipe room that was found with a rectangle of cold above it by a woman with four thermometers."
"The same."
"Which you told a visiting medical officer on Wednesday was empty."
"That was a tank, Your Honor. The pipe room is a separate—"
"Sit down, Mr. Strake," said Hallam, mildly. "I'll come back to you."
Dunmore did not get to argue. That is the first astonishing thing. She stood, and opened her mouth, and the judge raised one finger, and she shut it. Instead Hallam turned in his chair and looked down the length of the courtroom to the back wall.
"Is the foreman present?"
"Yes, Your Honor," said Rusk.
She stood. She had put on a clean shirt, a pressed one, with a collar. She had left the hard hat in the corridor and her hair had been flattened by a wet comb. She looked like a woman in her own funeral suit.
"Come up here, please."
She walked the length of the room. A hundred and forty hard hats turned with her. At the bench she stopped, with her hands at her sides, and Hallam looked at her for a long time.
"Ms. Rusk. You are the author of this exhibit?"
"I wrote the names, Your Honor. I didn't author them."
"Why?"
"Why what, sir?"
"Why did you write them? It wasn't your job. Mr. Strake, I'm certain, can show me a job description."
"I can, Your Honor," said Strake.
"Don't," said Hallam. He did not take his eyes from Rusk. "Ms. Rusk."
Rusk stood in the middle of the Marlow District Court and looked at the judge, and I saw her think about it. I had thought she would say something about her sister. I had thought she would say something about the Memorial or the Court or the sea.
"Somebody had to," she said.
Hallam waited.
"It was a pencil, Your Honor. It didn't cost anything. I just thought if nobody writes it down, then it's only a number, and it's the number the company says it is. And if somebody writes it down, even once, even in pencil, then it's a name, and somebody's got to say it back." She cleared her throat. "That's all it was. I never meant it to be a case."
"I see," said Hallam.
He picked up the pencil from behind his left ear. For the first time, he wrote something. He wrote a good deal, and then he put it down, and the courtroom heard the small dry noise of his chair as he sat back.
"I have read the visitor's report," he said. "I have read Miss Quarles's triplicate, which was very thorough and I would like to thank her for the index. I have not read a transcript of the Tide Court, because I am told it does not keep one. I have looked at Exhibit Four." He looked at Strake over his half-moon glasses. "I am not going to decide who owns anyone this morning, Mr. Strake. I haven't the jurisdiction, and God knows I haven't the appetite. I am going to decide what is the least I can do and still be sure that on Friday I have a case."
"Your Honor—"
"Here is the status quo. Nothing in the pipe room is to be moved, opened, or processed by anyone. Not Halvard, not the Local, not the Court. The room is to be jointly sealed, by lock, by two keys. Halvard holds one. The visitor, Dr. Venn, holds the other. Neither may open it without the other." He turned a page. "Mr. Strake, you will tell Halvard that this includes batch fifteen. It includes batch sixteen. It includes any batch, by any number, in any manner, until I have heard all parties on the question of title. That hearing will take place on Monday the seventeenth."
Hale, in the second row, had gone very pale.
"There is one more matter." Hallam took off his glasses. "I am told by Ms. Dunmore's brief that this tribunal on the Point sits on Friday morning at four. I am told the matters in re the kept are heard only in the presence of the kept. And I am told, though I find it hard to credit, that six hundred and eleven of them are in my jurisdiction."
"Your Honor," said Dunmore, quietly.
"I will not order them moved. I will not order them anywhere." The old man's eyes went to Rusk, still standing before the bench. "But I will say this. If the parties should agree, jointly, on conditions, to convey the sealed room, or the contents of it, under the joint seal and the joint key, to a place where the tribunal may see them, and return them on Saturday, I will not call it contempt. I would call it a courtesy."
Strake had gone as still as a man listening for a sound at the other end of a long corridor.
"Halvard will consider it," he said.
"Consider it quickly. Court is adjourned."
Dunmore turned and put her whole weight against my shoulder for half a second and then stood up very straight. Behind us Gus Brannigan said, quietly, "Boys," and a hundred and forty hard hats went on in one movement, and the sound they made was like the lid of a very large box closing on a good thing.
It was in the corridor that Strake caught up with us. He did not have his umbrella. He had his hat in his hand. His face held a civil, patient smile that went all the way to the eyes.
"Miss Marek, Miss Dunmore. A word."
"You've had your words," said Dunmore.
"I have one more." He turned the hat over. "The judge suggested a courtesy. Halvard accepts. We will convey the sealed room's contents to Greer Point on Tuesday, under joint seal, by water. It is a distance of forty miles." He gave a small, dry, regretful bow. "We shall, of course, provide the tow."

