Pellam Bridge Grange Hall, notice on the corkboard, in Adaeze Pruitt’s block capitals: “TONIGHT 7 PM. TOWN MEETING. SUBJECT: JO. BRING A CHAIR. NO SHOUTING UNLESS IT IS ABOUT THE PARKING.”
Two nights to the crest.
The Grange hall held ninety chairs and a hundred and twelve people, and the extra twenty-two stood along the walls like jurors.
It was a plain high room with a pressed-tin ceiling and a stage at one end, hung with a velvet curtain that had once been red. A flag stood in the corner. Folding tables along the back held eleven casseroles, a coffee urn, and a plate of lemon bars that Nell had been told, in confidence, were a political statement. The room smelled of wet wool and burnt coffee and a faint scent of old varnish. Everyone had come. The woman who ran the diner was there, with her arms folded. Mr. Haskins in his tweed cap sat in the second row, scowling at the floor. Adaeze Pruitt had put on a hat.
Nell sat in the front row between Teo and Priya, with Tilly on the end, swinging her feet. Deputy Carraway stood against the wall with her hands behind her. Margit had brought a gavel from somewhere and was holding it in her lap like a captured weapon.
On the stage, in a folding chair, alone, sat the Tenant, in the plaid flannel, with her hands in her lap.
“Order,” said Lorne Fitch, from the lectern. He was in his good coat. He had shaved. His voice, which was not made for rooms, filled it anyway. “I will keep this short. We are here because Josephine Tull has come home. Some of you have visited. Some of you have written letters. Most of you have brought food, and I thank you.”
A murmur, like a wind in dry grass.
“The matter before the Grange is not whether she is Josephine,” said Lorne. “She says she is not. She says it plainly, and she cannot say what is not so, and I have heard her swear it at the counter. The matter is whether she is a neighbor.”
“She’s a spook,” said somebody at the back.
“She’s a miracle,” said Adaeze, loudly.
“She’s a lawsuit,” said somebody else, and several people laughed, and Carraway, against the wall, said under her breath, “Thank you, Gary,” in the voice of a woman who had been listening to Gary all her life.
“Order,” said Margit, and struck the gavel once on her knee, which made no sound at all. She did it again, on the chair arm, and it cracked like a shot. The hall went quiet.
“I would like to note,” she said, “for the record, that I am not a member of this Grange. I am a visitor. But I have been asked to keep time, and I shall. Each speaker will have two minutes. No one will interrupt. Mr. Haskins, you may go first, as you look as though you will burst.”
Haskins stood. He was a thin, tight, stubborn man of seventy, and he held his cap in both hands.
“I’ll say it plain,” he said. “She’s not Jo. She’s a thing the Vault made. And I’m not saying that to be cruel. I’m saying it because I loved Jo Tull. She was the best Keeper this town ever had, and she went up that ladder for us, and I can’t sit in a room and let her face be worn by somebody else.” His voice shook. “It’s not right. It’s not fair to her. That’s all.”
He sat. Nobody said anything. On the stage, the Tenant’s face had gone very still, and then, quietly, not defensive at all, she said, “That is a good reason, Mr. Haskins. I’d like to say thank you for it.”
He stared at her. “What for?”
“For loving her,” said the Tenant. “Most of what I’m made of is that.”
There was a sound in the room, like a breath held and let go.
One by one they stood. The woman from the diner said she had never cared for Jo, but would not put a thing out in the cold. Adaeze said a great many things and had to be gaveled. A very old man in a wheelchair said, “I buried my wife in October, and I would give a great deal for something with her face, and I am telling you it is not the same,” and sat, and the hall went silent, and the Tenant said gently, “I know, sir. I’m sorry.”
“I have a question,” said Gary, from the back.
“Gary,” said Carraway.
“It’s a real question. Who gets the casserole?”
“What?”
“The casseroles. There’s eleven. They’re for Jo. But she’s not Jo. So who do they go to? Is it a gift? Is it a, a residual? I don’t want to put a pan in the wrong house.”
The room looked at him. Then, from the stage, the Tenant began to laugh, helplessly, with her hand over her mouth, and after a moment Lorne put his hand over his own eyes, and Tilly, on the end of the front row, snorted out loud, and it ran through the hall like a flame through straw, until a hundred and twelve people sat there wiping their faces.
“They’re mine,” the Tenant managed. “I accept. I’d like to say, for the record, I don’t like the one with the olives.”
“It’s Mrs. Pruitt’s!”
“Then I will apologize to Mrs. Pruitt,” said the Tenant, “and eat around them. I only know about me.”
That was the moment. Nell felt it. It passed across the hall like a change in air pressure. In the third row, the woman from the diner uncrossed her arms.
“Then what do we call you?” she said.
The Tenant stopped laughing. She sat very still on the folding chair. She looked at her hands. And then, slowly, she looked down at the end of the front row, at an eleven-year-old in a cardigan with two perfectly parted braids.
“I don’t know,” she said. “I’ve been waiting to be asked.”
“What did you want to be called?” said Tilly.
“I didn’t think I had the right to want.”
“It’s a ledger,” said Tilly. “Everybody gets a line.”
The Tenant drew a long breath.
“Josie,” she said.
“That’s too close,” said Haskins, without heat.
“It is. But it’s the one name nobody has called me. They’ve all said Jo, or Josephine, or Mrs. Tull. But when I woke on the bottom stair, there was a word in the air, and it wasn’t any of those.” She looked at Tilly. “I think a very small girl said it, years ago, when she was two and couldn’t get her mouth round the rest. Josie. Josie. I think it was the first name she ever said. I think it’s in the Vault because it’s the last thing she gave away.”
Tilly had gone quite pale.
“I did say that,” she said, in a very small voice. “I forgot. I said it when I was two. She told me.”
“Then it’s yours,” said Josie. “It’s the one thing in here that’s only yours. I’d like to borrow it, if I may. Not take. Borrow.”
“Okay,” whispered Tilly.
“Do I hear a motion?” said Margit.
“I move,” said Adaeze, standing, hat askew, “that Josie Tull, whoever she is, is a neighbor of Pellam Bridge and shall be given the supper she is owed.”
“Second,” said the woman from the diner.
“All in favor?”
It was not unanimous. Haskins kept his hand in his lap. So did the old man in the wheelchair, who did not look away from her. But it was most of them. A hundred hands rose in the high plain room, with the casseroles steaming at the back, and Nell, in the front row, found that she was holding Teo’s wrist very hard.
“Carried,” said Margit, and cracked the gavel on the chair arm, and Josie put her face in her hands.
It was perhaps ten seconds later, as the room began to rise, as the chairs began to scrape, that the double doors at the back swung open.
Nobody saw who opened them. A cold wind came in, smelling of the river, and the lights flickered. In the doorway, in the dark, stood a man in a wet canvas coat, with a gray beard cropped close, and mud to the knee. He was big and slow. He looked at the hall and the hundred and twelve faces, and then at the lectern, and at the man behind it.
“Lorne,” he said, in a voice that carried to the back of the room. “Why did you ring for me?”
On the stage, Lorne Fitch’s hand slipped off the lectern, and he sat down, quite suddenly, on the floor.

