Pettibone Weather Station, log, January ninth, in a schoolteacher’s hand: “9 p.m. 41 F. Light rain. Wet road, no ice. Executed as scheduled. I am sorry. I am sorry. I am sorry.”
Six hours to the Giveback of Wend Mill.
He would not sit at first.
He stood in the kitchen doorway with his cap in one hand and the log book in the other, a tall, stooped, courteous man of eighty or so, with a tweed jacket worn to a shine and a pair of glasses mended at one hinge with fishing line. He looked like a retired geography teacher. He looked, in fact, exactly like what he was, and that was what made the rest of it hard.
“I would like to say it standing,” said Carl Ostrander. “If it’s all the same. I’ve had five years of practice sitting.”
“As you like,” said Nell.
She had taken the head of the table without meaning to. Teo sat at her right, very still. Hal was by the stove, arms folded, with a look Nell had seen on a man at a funeral who had come to throw a punch and had forgotten why. Margit had a pencil. Odie had been told to go upstairs and had said no, in a small voice, and been allowed to stay on the stairs.
“My name is Carl Ostrander,” he said. “I taught earth science at Pettibone Consolidated for thirty-eight years. I keep a weather log. And since the spring of 1971 I have been the Clerk of Works to a body that I understand no longer exists in law, and has not for a hundred years.” He swallowed. “I was twenty-seven. The previous Clerk was a woman named Harriet Voss. She handed me an envelope and a key and said, ‘Carl, the schedule comes by post. You run it as written. You do not alter. If you try, you will find that you cannot.’”
“And did you try?” said Nell.
“Every month for fifty-four years.”
It was said with such flat tired humor that Priya, in the corner, made a small helpless sound.
“I will give you the mechanism,” said Ostrander. “It is not interesting. A brown envelope arrives on the first Monday. Inside is a typed sheet. A date, an hour, a gate. I go to the gate and turn the wheel. Sometimes I do not remember doing it. Sometimes I do. If I try to leave a gate closed that is meant to be open, I find my hand moves on its own. If I try to write a different figure in the log, the pen stops. The only thing I have ever been permitted to alter is the weather.” He opened the book to a marked page and held it out. “I may write down what actually happened. The Commission never asked me to falsify the log. It only asked me to open the gate.”
“So you recorded it,” said Margit. “Every time.”
“Every time. To the decimal. I thought, someday somebody will ask for the figure. It is the only act of defiance I was ever allowed.” His mouth trembled. “On the ninth of January, five years ago, the sheet said: ‘Open the Route 9 feeder at 8:40 p.m. To clear the road for the Answerer’s brother.’ I did not know what it meant. I assumed a figure of speech. A pipe, a culvert, a thing to be flushed. I turned the wheel. At nine, I wrote forty-one degrees, light rain. At eleven, the radio said there had been an accident on Route 9.”
He stopped.
“I knew,” he said. “I knew in my stomach. I did not know the name. I did not know it was a boy until Miss Sondergaard telephoned.”
No one spoke. The kitchen clock ticked. The wheel went round.
“I have not slept a night through since,” said Carl Ostrander. “That is not a plea for sympathy. It is a statistic. I wanted to tell the truth to someone who would be able to hold it. I could not tell it to the police. They would have written it down, and the pen would have stopped in their hands. I could not tell it to a priest. He would have given me absolution, and I do not want it.” He lifted his eyes. “I have come to tell it to the sister.”
Nell had not moved. She sat with both hands flat on the oilcloth, in the light from the window, looking at this very old man who had killed her brother with a wheel.
Her breath was quite even. She noticed that. It was as if she watched herself from a short distance away, and approved.
“I’m not going to tell you it’s all right,” she said.
“I would think less of you.”
“I’m not going to say I forgive you either. I don’t know if I do. I’d like to be honest about that.” She counted to four. It was a held door. “Mr. Ostrander. Can I ask you something?”
“Of course.”
“Say more about the log.”
His face moved. For a second the old teacher’s composure slipped, and underneath it she saw something so raw that she had to hold her own expression still.
“You want to hear the log.”
“I want to hear what it was like to write it down.”
“It was,” said Ostrander, and his voice cracked, “the worst thing I have ever done. And the only thing I have ever been proud of. I wrote, ‘Wet road, no ice.’ The pen allowed me. And I thought, this is what I can do. I can leave it where a person will find it.” He looked at the book in his hands. “For five years I have kept the real figures of every drawdown. I have a box in my basement. Seventeen schedules. Seventeen true entries. Somebody, someday, was going to ask.”
“Someone did,” said Teo, quietly.
“Yes. Miss Sondergaard.” He gave her a small, stiff bow. “It was the best telephone call I have had in a decade.”
“I would like it noted,” said Margit, a little thickly, “that I was very polite.”
“You were extremely polite.”
“I intended to be.”
A silence. Nell let it stand for the length of a breath. Then she said, “There’s a sheet for today, isn’t there?”
He closed his eyes.
“Yes.”
“It came by post.”
“It came this morning.” He reached inside his tweed jacket, and drew out a brown envelope, not sealed, folded once, and set it on the oilcloth between the sugar bowl and the salt. “I opened it in the car. I did not intend to give it to you. I find I cannot do anything but.”
Teo unfolded it. A single typed line, in the same faded face as the folder.
Close Upper Wend Gate at 5:50 p.m. so the Giveback arrives together.
“Together,” said Teo.
“All at once,” said Ostrander. “Four thousand sacks, a hundred and fifty years, in a single wave. Without the sluice to sink it an inch per telling.” He was ashen. “I cannot refuse. If I go near the wheel at five-fifty, my hand will turn it. I came to give you a chance to stand in front of me.”
“We will stand in front of you,” said Hal, from the stove, in a voice like gravel in a bucket. “Me and the boy and the schoolteacher. Anybody who’s got a back.”
“It will not be enough,” said Ostrander, miserably. “It is the Hand’s will. I cannot—”
“It’s not the Hand’s gate,” said Nell.
They looked at her.
She held up a small cold key on a loop of green wool. “I opened it. It says N. B. on the bow. Ruth Brinkerhoff kept it for me. If I’m the Answerer, it’s mine.” She turned it in her fingers. “I don’t think a schedule written by a hand nobody can see can close a gate that belongs to the one who answered. I think there’s a rule about that. I think it’s the whole reason the office exists.”
“Is there?” said Margit.
“I’m going to find out,” said Nell. She stood. “Mr. Ostrander. Sit down.”
He sat.
She stood over him, small, plain, in a borrowed cardigan, with her brother’s handwriting folded in her pocket, and put her hand, once, lightly, on the old man’s shoulder. It weighed nothing.
“You’re going to tell all of it again at the counter tonight,” she said. “Out loud. In front of everyone. Not for me. For the seventeen.”
“Yes,” said Carl Ostrander. “Yes. I’d like that.”
“And I’ll be listening.”
He bent his head. His shoulders, in the tweed, began to shake. In the corner, Hal turned and looked out of the window at the wheel. Outside, in the warm, bright, deceiving noon, a hundred and eighty people were walking up the lane with candles.

