St. Anselm Memorial Hospital had been remodeled twice in six years, and the only part nobody touches is the fire stair.
I learned that from Santo, in the parking structure, in the particular flat voice he uses when he is reciting facts in order not to feel them.
East tower. Back of the building. Behind the loading dock and a door that says STAFF ONLY in three languages and has not locked properly since the Carter administration. Eight flights, concrete, with a steel rail painted green. Nine days before Christmas, six years ago, it had been the only place in Chicago where a man could stand in the dark and not be seen.
“He’d come here,” said Santo. “If it was me, I’d come here.”
“You’d go to the place where you did the worst thing?”
“I’d go where I last had company.” He stood by the car, with his hand on the roof. He had not put on his coat. “Dom sat on the fourth landing with me, at dawn. He gave me coffee in a paper cup. He said: ‘You don’t have to go back in. They can wait.’ I didn’t. I sat with him until it was light.” His mouth moved. “I’ve been trying to remember that cup for two days. It’s the only part of the night I’m not ashamed of.”
I took his hand. It was cold as a doorknob.
“Rule six,” I said. “I’m going to ask you something, and you can say no.”
“All right.”
“I’d like to go up first. Alone. I’d like you to wait where he can’t see you, and hear, if you’d like to hear, and not come up until I say your name. And I’d like you to stay on the landing below.”
He looked at me for a long moment. I thought he would refuse. I knew exactly how it would sound, because I had practiced it in the car: a woman telling a man to stand in the worst place of his life and listen to a friend lie.
“Why below?”
“Because that’s where Enzo stood,” I said. “And he heard everything. And it was the only thing that kept him honest.”
Santo shut his eyes. When he opened them he said, in a perfectly calm voice, “Yes.”
---
We left Teddy and Carlo at the loading dock, and Gia and Priya in the car with the radio on. I carried my phone in my left hand with the light off and my right hand on the rail.
The stair was exactly as he’d said. A tall bare shaft, painted the green of old hospitals. A strip of yellow tape across the floor of the second landing, where someone had spilled something. A faint smell of floor wax and radiators, and under it a wintry, wet-concrete smell that pressed on the back of my teeth. The bulbs were on, in cages, at every other floor, so that between them were long stretches of gray.
Santo came up behind me, on the first flight, one step at a time. I did not look round. I could hear him counting under his breath. At the third landing he said, “Four,” a flight early, and then, “Sorry,” and then, “Five,” and I heard his hand take the rail.
On the fourth landing, I stopped. He stopped a flight below me, and I felt him do it: the sound of a man’s weight going quiet.
There was a bulb at the top of the fifth flight, burned out. Beneath it, in the gray, someone sat on the top step with his back to the wall and his knees up, in a dark overcoat, with a paper cup between his feet.
“Dom,” I said.
“Hi, Margo.” He did not turn his head. His voice was dry and light, and he sounded like himself, that was the awful part, as if I’d caught him on a coffee break. “You found the book. Walter’s guest book. I wondered if you would. I wrote ‘passing through’ on purpose. It was a joke.”
“It wasn’t funny.”
“No.”
I climbed the last flight and sat on the step below his, so that our heads were level, and I put my phone face down on the concrete between us. Below me, a long way down, in the dark, I knew my husband was standing with his hand on a rail.
“I’m going to ask you some questions,” I said. “I’d like you to answer. I’d like you to understand that I’m not here as a judge. I plan weddings. I’ve seen men lie about their mothers’ maiden names. I know a lie from a secret. You can tell me which this is.”
“That’s generous.”
“It’s not. It’s a long way to climb.”
He laughed, once, a breath. Then he put his head back against the wall. He looked, in that light, ten years older than he had on Friday, when he’d stood beside my husband holding a ring box with a slip in it and a dimple he turned on like a lamp. The dimple was gone. There was only a gaunt, kind, ruined face, and a mouth that wanted to be funny and wasn’t going to get to.
“November nineteenth,” I said.
“It was a Friday.” He shut his eyes. “He wrote me first. Before that. In the spring, after my mother. A card. A funeral card, with a heron on it, in pencil. It said, ‘I’m sorry about the line. Ask me before you ask anyone else.’ So I did.”
He turned the paper cup a quarter turn with his foot. “I rang the number. It was Mom’s shop in Berwyn, the old one. It rang through to a prepaid phone, and a man answered, and I knew it was him because he said, ‘Dominic,’ and nobody has called me that since my mother.”
“You said you hadn’t heard his voice since you were eleven.”
“I hadn’t. He was a boy of eleven and I was eight. A boy’s voice, I meant.” Dom tapped his knuckles on the concrete. “That’s a lie, Margo. I told it on Hanna’s step and I watched you catch it and I told myself you’d let it go. You didn’t. You’re good.”
“Go on.”
“He said, ‘Dom, I didn’t do it.’ That was the first thing. ‘I didn’t do it, and I can’t tell you who did, because if I tell you he’ll do it again.’”
“Did what?”
“Anything. The hospital. The stair. The notes. The man who walked into Enzo’s room with a syringe.” His voice thinned. “Everything. He said someone else had the pencil, and he was only the hand.”
---
I made myself breathe. Behind me, from below, came a very small sound, which was Santo letting go of a rail and taking hold of it again.
“And you believed him.”
“I wanted to.” He opened his eyes. They were red, and perfectly dry. “I wanted it so badly, Margo. He taught me to ride a bicycle. He taught me to hold a pencil.”
His mouth tightened. “He sat on my front step the day Dad died and didn’t say anything, just sat there, for four hours, and left a plate of Mrs. Dabrowska’s cookies on the rail when he went. I was eight. You don’t, at eight, think of a boy like that as a murderer. I thought of him as the one good thing about the church.”
“When did you start telling him things?”
“At first it was nothing.” He turned the cup round with his foot. “Whether Santo ate. Whether Nonna slept. Whether Gia was happy at school. He’d say, ‘I just need to know they’re all right.’ And I’d tell him. A card here, a phone call there. It felt like a kindness. A man in a dark house looking out of a window at the people he loves.”
“A kindness.”
“For the first year.” He wet his lips. “Then he asked about Enzo’s room. And I said I didn’t know. And he said, ‘That’s all right,’ and sent a letter to my mother, who couldn’t pay for her shop, and the shop was paid. And then it was an obligation. I’d be holding the bill in my hand. I’d think: if I stop, she loses the shop.”
“And then your mother died.”
“And I thought it’d stop. And it didn’t. By then it was a habit. It was my job. I fed him a small true thing every month, and he fed me a small true thing, and the one thing I told myself was: this is Luca. It’s Luca. He loves them. He’d never.”
He stopped. His chest was going in and out. “He called me in March of this year and told me my mother had been his friend, too. That they’d talked on Sundays for fifteen years. That she was the only person who ever said his name out loud. And that he was sorry about the lights.”
“And November?”
“I flew in on the nineteenth, for a dealership meeting in Rosemont, and I went to Elston. I had the address. I’d had it for years and I’d never used it. I went in and I stood in his shop.”
He lifted both hands, and let them fall. “He looked like death. He was just a man, Margo. He was just sick and clever and very tired. And he said, ‘Friday the thirty-first, you mustn’t be at the table. Santo mustn’t know until it’s done. If he finds out, Nonna pays.’”
“Pays what?”
“He wouldn’t say. ‘It’s not me. It’s the one who holds the pencil.’ And I said, can I help? He said, ‘Yes. Come to the wedding. Stand beside him. Don’t tell him you came. Don’t look at him.’ And I said I would, because I’d been looking at the back of that man’s head for twenty-four years and what was another day.”
---
I knew what was coming. It is a thing about my trade: one learns where a story is going before it gets there, the way a stage manager can feel an audience cough.
“The Lemon,” I said.
He went very still.
“Larkspur ballroom at ten. Cake at the dock at nine. Sabbatini’s men at the van at 9:04.” I kept my voice level, with some effort. “I let six people know it was bait. Priya, Santo, Gia, Nonna, Hanna, and me. You weren’t one of them. Dom, when did you read it?”
“I didn’t read it.” He pressed his knuckles to his mouth. “Priya’s binder. She left it on the flour-room table at a quarter past eleven, open. I was typing the toast. I looked at it for a minute. A minute. And then, God help me, I stepped into the hall with my phone and I rang the number.”
“What did you say?”
“I said, ‘Luca, they’re all at the Larkspur at ten.’ He said, ‘Thank you. Nobody dies.’ And I said, ‘Nobody dies?’ And he said, ‘Nobody. I promise.’ And I stood there with my back against the wall and I thought, this isn’t a spy, this is just a man telling me that no one will be hurt.”
“A van was parked in the Larkspur dock at 9:04. A man in that van was texting Ricci to ask whether my lemon cake was still on.”
“I know.” Dom’s voice cracked clean in half. “I know. I found out in the car on Friday, at ten past nine, when Teddy said the word ‘van’ out loud. And I thought: he lied. And then I thought: it wasn’t him. It was the other one. The one who holds the pencil. Luca gave him the answer I gave Luca. I carried it, Margo. I carried it into the room with my own mouth.”
He put his face in his hands.
I did not touch him. I wanted to. Instead I sat on a cold concrete stair with the knowledge that this man had held my husband up for a night, and a morning, and six years, and had in a single phone call handed my cake and my family to a van.
It is difficult to hold both. I have planned a funeral where the bride’s mother and the bride’s father were both in the front pew and not speaking, and I remember thinking that the secret to a day like that is not to ask anyone to feel one thing.
“Rule four,” I said at last. “No lies. And no deciding what the other person can bear.”
“I know the rule.”
“You decided, for six years, that Santo couldn’t bear a name.”
“Yes.”
“You decided, on the thirtieth, that I couldn’t bear a phone call.”
“Yes.”
“Then it’s the end of deciding.” I picked up my phone and turned it over. “I’m going to say one name. And you’re going to answer me honestly. Is Santo on this stair?”
He lifted his head. I saw the realization cross his face, and the fear, and something else, a vast, boyish, terrible relief. He didn’t ask me how I knew. He looked down the shaft, into the gray.
“Tino?” said Dom.
For a moment, nothing. Then, from the landing below, in the dim, in a very steady voice that I had heard a hundred times asking me whether I’d eaten, Santo said:
“I’m here. I’ve been here since you said ‘Margo.’”
---
He climbed up. I want to say that plainly, because it’s the part that will stay.
I heard every step. A man who had not used a stair in six years, if he could help it, who had counted them like beads, came up one flight, steadily, with his hand on the rail and his breath whistling, and stopped on the landing below ours. And then, because it was not enough, he came up the last flight too.
He stood in front of Dom Ferrante and looked at him.
It was the look he’d given him at the font. It lasted a good deal longer. The gray light from the window fell on his face, and on a friend’s, and I held my breath and watched twenty-four years of ledger being weighed.
“You told him the Lemon,” said Santo.
“Yes.”
“You let him think I’d forgive it.”
“No.” Dom’s eyes were streaming. “I thought you wouldn’t. That’s why I kept going. If I’d stopped, I’d have had to be the man you’d have to forgive.”
“That’s the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard.”
“I know.”
“It’s also,” said Santo slowly, “the most like you.” He put out his right hand, not for a handshake, but palm up, the way he does at the beginning of every day with a question in it. “Give me your phone.”
Dom took it from his coat. It was a cheap black thing, the kind sold in drugstores. He held it out. Santo took it, and weighed it in his palm.
“And your keys. And your passport. Margo says it’s in a jacket at River Forest. I’ll have Teddy collect it.” His voice did not change. “You’ll stay at Taylor Street, above the shop, in the room you slept in when you were twelve. Hanna will give you your meals. Carlo will sit on the stair. You’ll leave only when I say, and with someone.”
“Am I a prisoner?”
“You’re my best man.” Santo’s voice cracked on it, the first crack I’d heard. “That’s the worst part. I haven’t found a way for you not to be.”
Dom put his head down on his knees, and he cried, silently, and my husband stood over him with a stolen phone in his hand and did not touch him, and did not leave. The bulb two flights down buzzed. A long way off a gurney rattled through a corridor. And on the stair in the dark we stayed, the three of us, for a long minute, in the oddest ceremony I have ever staged.
Then the phone in Santo’s hand lit up and began to ring.
---
It was a plain screen. A single line of numbers, no name. A Berwyn exchange.
“Don’t,” said Dom, lifting his head. “It’s him. It’s the line. He’ll know it’s you.”
“Good,” said Santo.
He pressed the speaker, and held it between us, in the dark of the fire stair, in the place he had said yes six years ago.
For three seconds there was nothing, only a faint far-off sound like an organ pedal held and let go, a long, low, patient note. Then a man’s voice spoke, dry and careful, a little hoarse, with something very tired in it and something very precise, the voice of a man who counts the steps.
“Tino,” it said.
“Luca.” My husband’s hand did not shake. “I’m on the stair.”
“I know. I’m sorry about the lights.” The cough came, small and civilized, and was folded away. “Is the bride there?”
“I’m here,” I said.
“Mrs. Corvino. Margo. Thank you for asking first.” A pause. “Tomorrow. Mount Hedwig. Eleven thirty-six. You’ll bring your husband and your pencil and nobody else, or I won’t be able to stop him.”
“Stop who?”
“Ask me tomorrow.” The line breathed. “Dom, you did well. It was a very small lie. I’d have told it too.”
The line went dead.

