Lucan reached the Mooring forty minutes too late to be useful and exactly in time to be afraid.
He had been at the Bench, in a borrowed chair at the back of Judge Fenn’s chambers, arguing with her about the form of a writ that he was no longer permitted to draft, when Edda’s boy came through the door without knocking. The boy had run all the way from the Slings. He had no breath. He said “Miss Orsolay” and “fell” and “the whale looked at her,” in that order, and Lucan was on the stair before the sentence had finished.
Now he stood at the door of the round room under the tower, with his hat in his one hand and his coat buttoned crooked over his dead arm, and could not make himself go in.
She was lying on the narrow iron bed under a quilt. Somebody had taken off her boots. Somebody had put a hot brick at her feet, and another at her side, and a third on her breastbone, over the new white lace, with a folded towel under it.
Isabeau sat beside her in the straight chair, with Tamsin’s hand in both her own, and her lips were moving. She was not singing. She had been forbidden to sing. She was speaking, quite softly, as one speaks to a child who is half asleep.
“She’s all right,” said Pippa Lowe-Daunt.
She was sitting on the floor with her back against the stove and the green hat in her lap, and she looked, for the first time since Lucan had met her, like a woman of forty.
“She came round once. She asked whether the bailiff was gone. I said yes. She said, *Good,* and went out again like a lamp. Doctor Quill says it’s the heart-line. He says it’s wider by two fingers. He says that if she does it again she will not wake up, and he says it as if he’d like very much to be contradicted.”
“Did he say how long?”
“He said *rest.*”
“He says that to everyone.”
“I know. It’s why I don’t believe him.” Pippa looked up. Her kohl was gone altogether, and without it her eyes were round and young and appalled. “Go in, darling. She’s not going to bite.”
“I am aware.”
“Then why are you standing in the door like a bailiff?”
He went in.
---
He had not planned to sit. He had planned to look, in the clinical and temperate way he looked at everything, and then to go downstairs and be of some use. But the chair by the bed was empty, and Isabeau, without a word, rose and gave it to him, and touched his shoulder as she passed, the dead one, very lightly.
“I shall be on the stair,” she said. “If anything changes, I shall hear it.”
“Madam.”
“Lucan.” It was the first time she had used his given name. Her voice, in its rust and its whisper, was kind. “You are not household, and I am not a tenant, and no paper in the world may say otherwise. Sit.”
She went out. He sat.
The room was quiet. The stove ticked. Somewhere below, a long way down, the Underdecks were still on the terraces, he could hear them, a low murmur like a tide going out, and under that, so deep that he felt it in the chair’s iron legs, the slow vast note of the whale.
He took her hand in his good one.
It was cold. It was always cold, now; the cold had come to live there, and it was no use pretending it hadn’t. He folded his fingers round hers and did not try to warm them, for he had learned the hard way what the giving did, and he would not take her one inch nearer the edge. He only held.
“You are a very stupid woman,” he said.
She did not stir.
“You were told. You were told by every physician in Lanthorne, by your mother, by me, by the *whale,* I should think, in his own manner. One working more and you are gone. And you did it for the sake of a syringe.”
The brick on her breastbone shifted a little as she breathed.
“I said, a week ago, that I should not ask you to marry me until I had got you out of this. I believe I said *until the sky was safe.* It is a ridiculous condition. It was always going to be ridiculous. The sky is never going to be safe, Tamsin. It is a *sky.*”
He heard himself say it and he was appalled.
“I am not asking,” he said, quickly. “I should like that understood. It is not a proposal. I am a recused counsel in a borrowed coat and I have a dead arm and a letter of resignation in my pocket. It is a, ah, an observation.”
“Is it,” said Tamsin, with her eyes shut, “a *good* observation?”
He nearly dropped her hand.
“I have been awake,” said Tamsin, “for about three minutes. It’s very rude of you not to have noticed.”
“I did not notice.”
“You were making a speech. I didn’t like to interrupt. I’ve never heard you say *ah* before.” She opened one eye. It was greenish, and bloodshot, and perfectly clear. “Is it still a good observation if I’d like to hear the rest?”
“It is not a thing to be heard on a sickbed.”
“There’s nowhere else. Everywhere else is a tower.” She turned her head on the pillow and looked at him, quite gravely, with the lamplight in the lines round her mouth. “Lucan. Listen. I’ve been lying here and I’ve been thinking about my heart. It’s a funny thing. I can feel it, but it’s very far off, like a bell in another city. And I thought: *if it stops, I should like somebody to have said the thing.* I’ve never been good at it. I steal. I don’t *say.*”
“You do not have to.”
“I know. That’s why I’m going to.” She took a breath. “I’m not going to marry you when the sky is safe, either. It’s too long to wait. I thought I might do it when we’ve got the *key* to it. Which is Thursday, I think. Or about.”
He found that he could not speak.
“You may take that as an observation,” said Tamsin.
“I shall minute it.”
“Do.”
He bent his head. He kissed her forehead, quite lightly, over the faint white lace at her hairline, and her free hand, the warm-ish one, came up and caught his lapel, and held on to it with a grip that was not at all the grip of a dying woman. They stayed like that for some time, with his dead arm hanging uselessly by his side and her heart ticking, in its far-off city, and neither of them said anything intelligent whatever.
It was, he thought afterward, the best argument he had ever lost.
When at last she slept again, properly this time, with her breath slow and her fingers loosened in his, he stayed where he was. He told himself it was prudence. He told himself that a counsel ought to be within reach of his client. Neither statement would have survived a minute of cross-examination, and he was, for once in his life, entirely content to let them stand.
---
The Captain of the Watch was waiting on the landing when he came out, and he looked as though he had been waiting for an hour and a half.
“Sterne.”
“Captain.”
Anselm Wren had taken off his cap. He had been twisting it in his hands, and it had been twisted into something resembling a cabbage. He was a spare, upright, sandy man of forty-one, with a Ground accent that came up under his Lanthorne vowels when he was moved, and he was moved now. He kept glancing at the black ship.
“I have not slept,” said Wren.
“No.”
“I thought I should tell somebody what I saw. I would rather it were you than the Bench.” He swallowed. “I was on the lower landing, with my men, during the distress. When the whale turned, there was a flash of light up on the Widow’s stay, and I looked up, and I saw a man on the *yacht’s* rail. Not a deckhand. A gentleman.”
“Lady Varnholt’s guest.”
“I know the face. I’ve pulled it off every wanted-poster in the Crown for a month.” Wren lowered his voice. “It was Skell, Magistrate. The Houses’ *clerk.* He’s on her ship. He’s been on it since the dawn. He had a spyglass and a notebook. He was writing things down.”
Lucan felt a cold, quite different from the rime, creep across the back of his neck.
“Writing what?”
“I couldn’t see. But he was timing it. I watched him. Every time Tallow turned, he looked at a watch and wrote. When Miss Orsolay used the ring, he wrote for about a minute. Then he put the book away and he *smiled.*”
*”I wanted to see what he would do for you.”*
He had heard it, from the stair, in the Lady’s perfect carrying voice. He had thought it a taunt. It had not occurred to him that it might be a *method.*
“They’re not trying to win the distress,” said Lucan slowly. “They never were. A bailiff’s tag, a syringe. The syringe was a bait. They wanted her to use the ring in front of witnesses, on a schedule, with a whale who answers. They wanted to *measure* it. They wanted to know what it costs her.”
“Then they know.”
“They know exactly.” He pressed his hand over his eyes. “How much of that did you tell the Factor?”
“None. She’s my cousin by marriage. She’d have asked me to repeat it.” The Captain flushed a dull red. “I have not decided where my loyalty lies, Sterne. I’ll tell you that, since it’s the night for it.”
“I was born in the Ground. I was reared on a quiet house that a cloud-sea took, and the Factor has been better to my people than the Crown ever was. But I’ve been twenty-two years in this coat, and I find I rather like what it’s for. I’d like it to be worth wearing.”
“It is.”
“Then I shall go on wearing it.” Wren put his cap on, with an effort. “I’ll tell you what else. The Reckoning House. I’ve been there. Once, as a boy, with my mother, to register a death.”
“What is it like?”
“It’s very quiet,” said Anselm Wren, and for the first time something shy came into his face. “It’s built round a Well. It’s the deepest thing in the Ground. They say it goes down to the bottom of the cloud-sea, to where the whales’ memory is kept, and the House is only a lid. The registrar’s a woman called Mistress Oriel. She’s three hundred years old, or very close. She doesn’t answer questions. She *takes* them down. She writes them on slips and drops them in.”
“And the Well answers?”
“I don’t know. I was seven.” He hesitated. “My mother told me that if you ever had a real question for the deep, you were to stand at the Well’s edge at the turn of the tide and say it out loud. And you were to say it *in your own voice.* No messenger. No clerk. No advocate. It had to be the person it was about.”
“The Keeper.”
“I’d say so.”
Lucan stood quite still. Outside the windows, over the long dark line of the cloud-sea, a thin silver light was beginning to show where the moon would rise, and somewhere under it, he thought, in the dark, something waited that had been asking one question for three hundred years.
---
He went down to the cells at midnight, because he could not sleep and because he owed a man an apology.
The Bench’s lock-up had a new inmate in the cell beside Pell’s, a thin young gentleman in a crumpled coat who sat on the cot with his knees drawn up to his chin and a stub of pencil in his fist. A tray of bread and cold meat stood untouched at his feet. Behind him, on the wall, he had drawn, in charcoal from the stove, a map of nineteen points on a whale.
“I’m perfectly well,” said Fennick Dill, without turning round. “I’m very comfortable. The cot is only a little damp. I have been marking the stays I think the bailiff will go for first. It’s a *very* interesting problem. If Miss Pym comes down, will you tell her I’m sorry about the seal?”
“She is aware.”
“I thought she might be.” His voice cracked on the last word, and he cleared his throat very hard. “Is Tamsin--”
“Awake. Furious. Betrothed.”
“I’m sorry?”
“I am told it is a Thursday matter.” Lucan leaned against the bars. “Fennick. I have been charged to tell you that the Bench is considering your case. Judge Fenn says there is a precedent for a lenient construction where the forger is moved by loyalty. She says she will see you in the morning. I believe she means to fine you, rather than to hang you.”
“That’s *very* kind.”
“She is not kind. She is fair. It’s rarer.” He paused. “I came down for another reason. The bailiff, Master Sedge. Did he speak to you? At the end?”
Fennick’s head came round. In the light of the single lantern, his round face had a certain slow, careful stillness that Lucan had not seen on it before, the stillness of a forger when somebody has put a clean sheet in front of him.
“He did,” he said. “Just as they took me past him. He leaned in as though to straighten my collar. He said, *Mr. Dill, you have a good hand. It is a pity. Tell the Keeper not to bring an advocate to the Well. It will not be heard.*”
“He said that?”
“And then he said, *And tell her to bring somebody who can hear it.*” Fennick blinked. “I assumed he meant a, a priest. Or a lawyer. I’d like very much to know what he meant.”
“So should I.”
“Do you think he’s on our side?”
“I think,” said Lucan, “that Master Quillon Sedge is a man who has done an unpleasant job for thirty years, and who has just watched a whale refuse to be tagged because a girl asked it nicely.” He looked down the long dim row of cells to the little barred window, where the moon was beginning to climb. “I think that even a bailiff has a limit.”
In the cell beyond, Pell had woken. He sat up in the rug with his hair on end and a look of vague alarm.
“I say,” he said, “has something been decided?”
“Yes,” said Lucan. “We are going down.”
“Down.”
“To the Ground. To the Reckoning House. We have five days by the sea, and one by the court’s reckoning, and no hold on the matter at all, apart from a clause on page nineteen and a bronze key and a woman who may not survive another working.” He straightened. “Mr. Pell, Mr. Dill, I am going to ask you both a great favour. I would like you to behave yourselves, and to remain exactly where you are, and to think very hard about a wall.”
“A wall.”
“With names on it. And a blank space.” He turned to go. “I find that when a lie has been three hundred years in the keeping, it is generally the thing that is *missing* that matters.”

