The first thing that Tamsin learned about the plumb-chain was that it was not alone.
She had thought it a chain. A single dark rope of green-black links going down through a hole in the foundations of the world, with a brass pear hanging from it and a ramshackle cradle clinging underneath: that was a thing she could hold in her head. Then Edda Fenn, who had been staring over the rail for an hour with her notebook shut on her knee, said in a thin careful voice, “Keeper. Look to the left of the lantern.”
Tamsin looked.
There was a second chain. It hung on the far side of the shaft, a yard from the wall, and so close to the first that she had taken it for a trick of the lamplight. It was as long in the link as her arm and as thick as her thigh. It was black. It was not the green-black of the plumb, with its gloss of age, but a dead flat black that drank the light, and it did not swing.
The plumb swayed on its slack with every tick of the winch. This one hung straight, the way a plumb-line hangs, with a weight on the bottom of it that she could not even begin to guess.
“That’s not the Houses’,” said Pru.
*It is taut,* Tamsin wrote on the slate, in a hand that shook a little. She turned the slate so they could read it. *Look at the links. Nothing holds still like that unless something is pulling.*
“I have been looking at them for ten minutes,” said Pru. “Do you know what they’ve got on them?”
She had her ledger open on her knee and her pencil behind her ear. She held up the lantern. In the swinging yellow light, on the flat of the nearest link, Tamsin saw a mark, stamped deep and neat as a coin: a pair of small sewn lips with a single stitch across them.
It was on every link. It went on down the black rope as far as the lantern would carry, one stamp to a link, a long procession of closed mouths, and every one a little blurred at the edge, as if it had been made with a very small, very careful hand.
---
“It’s the school,” said Pru.
Her voice had gone high and flat, a clerk’s voice, the one she used for reading figures that she did not like. “The Straight Mouth. It’s in the Tenterhook ledgers. They put it on everything they buy off the children, so that the bill’s honest. Mister Sterne had a page of it in the Bench papers. It’s a hallmark. It says *this was paid for fair.*” She swallowed. “I thought it was a stamp for paper.”
“It is a chain,” said Edda Fenn, “of some kind of lie.”
She had written it down. She wrote everything down; it was one of the things that Tamsin had always found hardest to forgive in her, and now found she could not do without. The pencil went scratch, scratch, scratch in the half-dark. “I do not say that it is made of them.
I say that it is hallmarked as a purchase from that source, and that it is lengthy, and that it has been under the Hall of the Houses for a considerable time without anyone in the Hall knowing.” She paused. “I also observe that it is not hanging from anything.”
“What?” said Cassian.
He had not spoken for a long while. He knelt in the far corner of the cradle with his back to the rail and his pale eyes shut, and the slow, careful, interior look of a man listening for a note in an orchestra. He had said, on the way down, that he would be quite all right. He had said it eleven times.
“There is a hook at the top of the plumb,” said Edda. “I looked as we came away from the dais. The Houses’ chain is hooked to the winch. The other has no hook. It goes up into the roof of the shaft and does not stop. It has been run through the foundations of Lanthorne from some other point altogether, and let down. I think that it comes from the Ground.”
*Then it’s going to the bottom,* wrote Tamsin, *too.*
“Yes,” said Edda. “I have been wondering what is at the bottom.”
---
They went down for a long time after that without speaking.
It was a queer, pale, dreamlike descent. The black masonry of the shaft had stopped at about the depth of the cloud-sea, and what came after was veined and shining, a smooth fleshy wall that gave back the lanterns in long wet ripples. There was no echo in it. Their voices fell and were swallowed. A drop of water on the end of the rail was a drop of warm water, and it tasted, when Pru licked it off her finger with an apologetic face, of salt and of rain.
Tamsin watched the black chain.
It kept pace with them exactly. The plumb went down, and the chain went down with it, a yard off, in the same slow measure, and she began to have the unpleasant impression that it was not hanging at all, but descending.
Every now and then it gave a small tremor, as a rope does when a great weight is trying to move on the end of it, and each time it did, the whole wet wall shivered with it, and a long way down below there was a sound like a very large door.
She put her bandaged hand flat to the nearest wall. It was warm. It was beating.
*Do you feel it?* she wrote.
“Aye,” said Hob’s voice, from a hundred feet above, thin and queer down the shaft. He was talking down the speaking-tube that Odo had rigged on the chain, a length of hollow cane with a tin horn at each end, and his voice came to them like a man talking in his sleep. “I feel it on the handle. She’s pulling like a mule. Is that you pulling, Keeper, or is it her?”
*It’s him,* Tamsin wrote, and held the slate over the horn. *He’s glad we’re coming.*
“Right,” said Hob. There was a long pause. “Only I’d like it known that I’m not.”
---
The knock came at what Pru’s pocket-watch said was a quarter to one.
It was a soft, tidy rap, three times, on the wall of the shaft. It was no louder than a servant at a bedroom door. The cradle had just passed a place where the flesh-pale wall gave way to a long vertical seam, like a stitched cut, and the knock came from behind the seam, a yard from Tamsin’s elbow.
They all went still. The lanterns hissed.
*Tap, tap, tap,* said the wall again, politely.
“I shall answer it,” said Edda Fenn.
She did, in the manner of a woman about to deliver a ruling. She got to her knees on the patched sail, took off her spectacles, and cleared her throat. “This is counsel for the Keeper of Orsolay,” she said, “in transit. Who is there?”
There was a silence. It had the quality of a silence that is thinking about it.
“I am a link-keeper,” said a small clear voice, from the other side of the stone.
It was a child’s voice. It was not a frightened child’s, or a naughty child’s, or a shy one’s; it was the voice of a small person reading the first line of a prepared text, in a flat, careful monotone that was almost worse than tears. “I am a link-keeper of the Ground. My name is Wick. I am nine years old. I was told to ask the Keeper’s party their business. I was told to tell them the truth about the chain.”
“Wick,” said Cassian Varnholt. He had opened his eyes.
“Yes, sir.”
“How long have you been in the wall?”
“Since the sun went down, sir.” A short pause. “Not the sun. The lamp. I do not know what time it is. I was told that it would be dark. I did not know that it would be so *long.*”
---
The seam parted, with a faint damp sound.
It was no wider than a man’s hand. A light came out of it, thin and cold and the colour of skimmed milk, and in the light there was a small round pale face, quite still, with large grey eyes and a mouth like a ruled line. Tamsin had seen it already from a long way off, a small pale oval in the dark. She had not known, then, that it would have freckles.
She was a very small girl in a very large grey coat. She had a lamp on a long pole, the milky one, and in her other hand a little brass bucket on a cord. She had been crying. She had stopped. It was plain that she had been told that she was not to do it in front of strangers, and she held her face quite rigid, with her chin up, like a child holding a full cup.
“I am to say,” said Wick, “that the chain is full.”
“Full of what?” said Edda.
“Of *links.* I do not know what else. I was told that it was full and that I was to say so.” She frowned, with great effort, at a card that she had in her hand. “I was to say that the Keeper is welcome to go down, and that the Ground has no objection, and that it asks only that the Keeper count what she takes with her.
I think that is what it says. It is in a very small writing.” She turned the card over. “It says, *and bring a witness.*”
“Who sent you?” said Pru, in a very low voice.
“The Assessor’s office. Not Mister Dray. The other one.” The grey eyes went to Pru, and held. “I was not allowed to say who. I think that is because I do not know. I only got a card. I have been walking down the chain for six days, with the bucket, and putting a drop of oil on every hundredth link. They told me that if I stopped, it would run.”
“If it stopped,” said Tamsin. She had not meant to write it. The chalk had done it of its own accord. “What would run?”
She held up the slate. The child read it with her lips, slowly, as a person does who has learned her letters very recently.
“I do not know,” said Wick. “I only know that it is *heavy.* It is all that I know. I was told never to look down.”
---
Nobody said anything. In the cradle, in the hush, the lanterns burned very steady.
“How old did you say you were,” said Cassian, gently.
“Nine.”
“It is a very good age.” He had put out a hand into the dark, quite slowly, as a man feels for a banister; it found the edge of the seam and rested there, a foot from the small pale face, without touching. “I knew a boy that age, once.
He used to tell people that he could not sleep because the stairs were too long.” He swallowed. “Will you tell me something, Wick? I do not ask because I think that you will lie. I ask because I should like to hear one.”
“I cannot tell you a thing that is not so, sir.”
“Quite. Then tell me what you are afraid of.”
The child stood with her lamp in her small stiff hand and her mouth like a ruled line. It occurred to Tamsin that it was the cruellest question that anyone could have asked her, and that he had asked it in the kindest voice in the world, and that the poor little creature could no more help answering than she could help breathing.
“I am afraid,” said Wick, in her flat voice, “that nobody is coming to take the bucket.”
There was a long, shocked quiet. Pru made a small sound. It was not a word.
“Oh, my dear,” said Cassian Varnholt.
“I am sorry,” said Wick. “I did not mean to say that. It is only so.”
---
It was Tamsin who moved.
It was an odd, quick, stupid thing, with nothing in it of strategy, and she did it before she thought. She got up on her knees on the patched sail, with her slate swinging by its string, and put her ragged hand through the seam. The edge was warm and sticky. The little girl flinched, and did not pull back.
Tamsin did not have a voice. She could not say *I’m here.* She could not say *I’ll take it.* She had only two bandaged hands, that could not grip, and a ring of gold light on one finger, and a face that was all that she had left to speak with.
She took hold of the bucket.
It weighed almost nothing. It was a little brass pail with a long cord, half full of thin dark oil, and it was wet on the outside with six days of small cold fingers. The child let go of it, one finger at a time. It was clear that nobody had ever told her that she could.
“I am not to go back up,” said Wick, in a small voice. “I was told. It is not allowed.”
*Then come down with us,* wrote Tamsin. She held it up, in her scarred, shaking, bloody hands. *Come with the cradle. I’m not allowed to say anything but that. I’m sorry.*
“It is not a lie, miss,” said the little link-keeper, wonderingly, to the slate. “You wrote it, and it is true.” She looked up. For the first time, something went across the rigid small face that was not an answer. It was an astonishment, so large and so bare that it was almost indecent. “Nobody has ever said a thing to me that I could believe all the way through.”
*That’s the only way I say them,* wrote Tamsin, and could not see the slate for a moment.
---
They took her in at the next landing of the shaft, where the wall made a shelf. She was the weight of a wet cat. She sat in the corner of the cradle with her coat round her knees and the milk-white lamp on the floor beside her, and Pru, without a word, took off her own shawl and put it round the grey one, and the child, after a long hard moment, laid her head against the ledger and fell asleep.
“Three hundred and five pounds,” said Hob’s voice, tinny and distant, in the horn. “I make that five over, Keeper. I’ll hold her.”
Nobody asked how he knew.
They went on, down, with the black chain at their elbow. The pale face of the shaft closed around them. It was warmer now, and the lanterns burned with a thicker light, and every now and again a deep slow rolling note went up through the plumb and the cradle and the soles of Tamsin’s feet. It was the voice that she had heard in the Hall, softened, almost expectant. It was waiting.
Cassian had begun to talk.
It was low, quick, and quite without sense. He was saying a list of things. He said *a cup with a chip,* and *the brown door,* and *a woman laughing on a stair.* He said the names of the days of the week, in order, quite slowly, and then once again, as a man says a prayer he has only just remembered.
His pale eyes were open. They were fixed on nothing. Edda put out a hand and touched his arm, and he turned his head and said, in a clear and tender voice, “Ottoline said that I should write it on my sleeve.”
“Cassian,” said Edda.
“It is coming up, Miss Fenn. It is the lamp.” He said it quite simply. “It is a long way off, and it is *near.* I can feel every morning that I forgot. They are all trying to come in at once. It is like a very great number of people running to a door.”
He pressed his hands flat against his eyes. His breath came short.
*Stop,* wrote Tamsin. *We can stop.*
“No,” said Cassian Varnholt. “No. I think it must be the lamp, and not you, that hurts. And I rather think it should.” He drew a long shaking breath, and took his hands from his face, and he was smiling, though it was the oddest, most terrible smile she had ever seen on a man. “It is not at all a bad thing, to be given one’s mornings back. I only wish that they had not all been the same one.”
---
They saw the floor at ten past two.
It was a pale circle at first, no larger than a coin, far below at the end of the shaft: a spot of dim rose light, as of a very large lamp seen through a very thick curtain. It grew. The walls fell away on either hand. The cradle swung out of the mouth of the crack into open air, into a great hollow vault of living pearl, and below them, enormous, rose-wet, humming, tier upon tier of honeycomb went up the walls into the dark.
And the floor was running with a thin shining sheet of water.
“Oh,” said Pru, in a very small voice. “Oh, it’s *lovely.*”
It was. It was the most beautiful place that Tamsin had ever been, and it had a great vast black pupil in the far wall as big as a lighthouse, and a thin old woman with a shawl sitting in the water with a lamp in her lap.
And between the two of them, a little apart, with the ring on his hand burning like a candle and his coat torn and his head thrown back to look at her, there was a tall man standing quite still in the shallow wet with his hands open at his sides.
He did not say anything. She did not say anything. They looked at each other across thirty feet of falling air and six days of Lanthorne and a great many lost words, and she found that she had put out her hand, as if to take hold of a rail that was not there.
Her whole face had begun to shake. He saw it. He smiled, in the lopsided way that he had, crooked and tired and helplessly glad, and put one hand to his own mouth and shook his head.
The cradle touched the water.
And behind them, in the long narrow seam of the crack, where the black chain went up into the dark, something that was not Hob and not the plumb and not the winch began, quite softly, to count.
*Nine,* said a small flat voice from the wall. *Ten. Eleven.*
It was a child’s voice, as flat and careful as Wick’s, and it was not Wick’s: Wick lay asleep against Pru’s ledger with her mouth a little open. It came out of the wax of the third tier, out of the hollows that had been stopped with the sewn lips, and it spoke with the most perfect courtesy.
*Keeper’s party. The Ground has come to collect the interest.*

