Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 65

Counted

It is a very strange thing to hear yourself speak when you cannot.

Tamsin stood at the rail of the pearl ledge with her mouth shut and her hand clamped over the ring of light on her finger, and listened to her own voice come up the black chain from the dark. It was a good voice. She had forgotten that.

She had spent her whole life being told it was too loud, and she had spent a day without it, and now it rose out of the floor of the Keeping as warm and clear and certain as a woman calling her family in to supper.

“I am so sorry that I am late,” said her voice. “I did try to come sooner. There was a great deal of stone in the way.”

Nobody moved. Edda Fenn had stopped breathing, as far as Tamsin could tell. Pru had put both hands over her ledger as though it might be taken.

*I did not know it could do that,* said Fathom, very low. The great chamber had gone still around the sound. *It has never spoken to me in a borrowed voice. It has only ever counted.*

“It did not borrow,” said Lucan.

He had gone grey about the mouth. He stood close at her shoulder, not touching her, with the ring on his left hand burning so brightly that she could see the bones of his fingers through the skin. His voice was quite level. It was the voice of a man at the very end of his procedure.

“It was paid. The fifth fan closes on the nearest listening throat. That was Quill’s phrase, was it not? He did not know what it meant. Neither did I. The nearest throat that was listening to her, at that moment, was not in the Hall at all.”

*Tap,* went Tamsin’s knuckle on the rail. Then, because it was not nearly enough, she pulled the slate round on its string and wrote, with the chalk clenched in her fist, *It has my voice.*

“It has your voice,” said Edda. Her own had gone thin. “As a toll. Paid in good faith, at the price of a public hearing, into the first ear that was open. I should say that it would hold up. I should say that it is the most disagreeable thing I have ever read.”

---

“I would be very glad,” said the voice from the floor, “if somebody would answer me. It is a long way, and I have not been much practised in talking.”

It was the same voice, but it was no longer saying the right things. She felt that before she could name it, as one knows a stranger in a friend’s coat. It spoke with her cadence and her breath. It had her habit of dropping the last word of a sentence a little, as if she were leaning on it.

But the thoughts behind it were old and wide and slow, and every phrase had a faint round hollow in it, like a word said down a very deep well.

*Do not answer,* said Fathom sharply. *It does not know the shape of a promise. It will hold you to a thing you said by accident.*

“I do not think,” said Edda Fenn, in her driest voice, “that the Keeper has any intention of answering. Counsel will answer.” She stepped forward to the lip of the ledge, notebook in one hand, and looked down at the water where the black chain went in. “Who is speaking?”

“The creditor,” said Tamsin’s voice. “Or the nearest I have to a clerk. It is a figure of speech. I do not like it. I have been given a great many in the last day, and it is very hard to tell which is the true one.”

“On what instrument do you claim?”

“On the one you have just seen. I have seen it too. It was a very pretty Bill, and a good lie, and I have been paid on it for eleven years, in the one currency that a lie can be paid in.” The voice paused, courteously. “In time. I have had eleven years of the household’s time. I should like to say that I am grateful.”

---

She did not feel it begin. That was the worst of it. She was watching the black chain where it ran into the shallows, a dead flat rope that drank the light, and the first she knew of the change was Pru’s gasp, and the small cold touch at the edge of her own vision, like a hair laid across an eye.

*Tamsin,* said Lucan, urgently. *Your hand.*

She looked down at her bandaged wrist. Under the grey linen, where the wrapping had slipped, there was a line. It was no thicker than a thread. It was the colour of frost, a thin cold white that gave back no light, and it went round her wrist in a single neat turn and ended in a knot.

She touched it. It did not hurt. It was quite cold, and it was quite tight, and it was exactly the shape of a hand that has been raised.

“I have one too,” said Pru, in a faint voice. She held up her left arm. “I had it up when you started to speak. I had it up for an hour. I did not know.”

Edda Fenn had pulled back her own sleeve. She looked at her wrist for a long time. She did not say anything at all, and then, with extreme precision, she wrote it down.

*It counted,* wrote Tamsin. She could hardly read her own hand. *It said, interest, from the Call. One voice a day on the principal.*

“The principal is the household,” said Lucan. His voice cracked. “But the Call was the city’s. The Gallery was full. Every hand that went up for you--”

“Nine thousand and some,” said her voice, from the floor, in the gentlest of tones. “I do not think it is as many as it will want. But it is a start. You will understand that it has been a long wait, and one has to be careful with one’s accounts.”

---

It was a quarter of an hour before anyone could stand to think. Tamsin spent it sitting on the ledge with her back against a shelf of warm honeycomb and a small wet hand holding hers.

It was the child. She had woken without a sound, as children do, and sat up in her heap of shawls with her coat round her knees and stared at the people around her with those large grey unblinking eyes. She had been told, evidently, that she was not to ask. So she had come across the pearl on her hands and knees and taken hold of the nearest hand that was bleeding, and held it, quite tightly, without a word.

“I am Wick,” she said, at last, to the ring. “I do not like it. It is not lying. But it has not said a single thing that is not so, and I find that I cannot bear it.”

*Yes,* wrote Tamsin. *Neither can I.*

“It has your voice,” said Wick, “and it is the voice of the chain.” She said it as a plain fact, a sum worked to the end. She looked toward the water, where the black rope ran in, and her small face did not move at all. “It is the thing at the bottom.

I have never been told to look. But I have been oiling it every hundredth link for six days, and it has never once said a thing to me that was not true. I did not understand that was the horror of it.”

Tamsin put her arm round the grey coat, and for the first time since the Hall, found that she had something in her to say. She could not say it. She wrote it. She wrote it in the biggest hand that her fist could manage, and held the slate up in the light of Cassian’s lamp.

*Then we are going to tell it something that isn’t.*

---

It was Cassian who stopped her.

He had been standing so long at the far end of the shallows with the lamp in his hands that she had stopped seeing him. Now he came across the water slowly, with the golden glass held in front of him like a candle in a draught, and stopped at the foot of the ledge, and looked at the slate. He did not smile. It would have been cruel if he had.

“Miss Rook,” he said gently. “Keeper. I beg your pardon. You are going to lie to the creature, and it is a very natural thing to want, and I think that it would be the end of you.”

*Why?* wrote Tamsin.

“Because it has your voice.” He said it patiently, as a clerk explains a clause. “A voice is a witness. It is the one thing that you cannot swear to a falsehood in. Doctor Quill told me, at the Hall rail, what the fans were: they are not paid out of you, they are paid *through* you, to the nearest ear. If you speak a lie in that mouth, you will not be lying, I fear.

It will be the creature that says it. It will say it in your voice, and it will be believed, and it will go up the chain to the Ground in your name.” His pale eyes were very steady. “I have been a Registry officer for twenty years. I know what happens to a seal that someone else holds.”

“He is right,” said Edda Fenn, very quietly.

*Then what do we do,* wrote Tamsin, with a hand that would not stay still. *It will take every voice in the city. It will take them one a day.*

“We pay it,” said Cassian Varnholt, “in the one coin that a thing that cannot lie will accept.” He turned, and for a moment looked not at her but at the child, in her great grey coat, with her bucket, and the lamp on its pole. “We give it a hearer.”

---

She did not understand at first. She thought that it was a figure.

“It listens,” said Cassian. “That is all that it does. It has been listening to the whales for a thousand years, through a chain that was made of the voices of children. It asks, and it counts, and it holds. But it cannot be *answered.* Not once, not by anyone, not ever. It has never in its life had a conversation.”

He drew breath. “Every person who has ever spoken to it has been a purchase, or a lie, or a debt. If there were a hearer who sat with it, and listened, and told it what was so, quite plainly, without paying anything at all...”

“It would have a reason not to call,” said Fathom, slowly.

*I have been the only hearer, for eleven years. It is a poor thing to be alone with.* The vast voice shook. *I have kept the shaft shut with my breath, and I am tired. I should be very glad of a second.*

“The lamp is a ledger of mornings,” said Cassian. “It will go on writing them. I should like to be the one to read it.” He glanced down at the little golden window in his hands. “I am not a brave man. I have never been. But I have been a coward for eleven years, in the dark, and I find that I am rather good at the dark.

I should like to sit at the foot of the chain, and take the bucket from this child, and listen to it. Until the Thursday callers have found their way down, and the Under has learned to talk.”

*Cassian,* wrote Tamsin, and her hand was shaking so badly that the chalk broke.

“Oh, my dear,” said the Procurator tenderly. “Do not look like that. I am quite aware that I have the best of the bargain.”

---

They did the sums, because that was what they did.

It took Edda Fenn twenty minutes. She sat on the pearl with her notebook and Pru’s ledger and a stub of pencil, and she turned the thing round and round in her hands like a woman looking for the loose thread.

There was no loose thread. A household under a lien could not be freed by anything but a hearer; a hearer must come of his own will, be named in the Keeping’s own books, and be willing to be kept; and the swap that Lucan had thought was open could not be touched, because the only one who could have taken his place was a woman with five white fans round her heart.

“His term stands,” said Edda, at last, flatly. “Eighty-five days. I cannot buy him out. I cannot put myself in. There is no clause that allows a hearer who is not the Keeper’s household, and the Keeper’s household has one hand that can hear.” She laid the pencil down. “I am sorry. I would give a great deal to say otherwise. I have read it nine times.”

“Then I stay,” said Lucan.

He did not say it grandly. He said it as he said everything, with the faint dry ironic care of a man declining a second helping. His eyes were on the ring, on the long bright line that it made along his hand. “It is a proper arrangement. Someone must be Cassian’s counsel. He has not signed anything since he was thirty-one, and I should not like him to begin without one.”

He lifted his head, and his eyes were not dry at all. “And the term runs from the day of the Call, in any case. It will not be shortened by my going up. I should rather be down here, with the whale, and a man with his mornings, than up there in a gown watching it fall in.”

*I’ll come every Thursday,* wrote Tamsin.

“I know. I have it in the ring.” He had begun to laugh, very softly, a small, silent, helpless shaking. “I cannot say the word, and I cannot laugh. It is the most ridiculous situation in which I have ever found myself. I am going to be a very quiet man for eighty-five days.”

She went into his arms. It was not a decision. There was nothing in her that could have stopped it. She held on to the back of his coat with both ruined hands, and he laid his chin on her hair and held her up off the floor, and neither of them made the smallest sound.

---

Ottoline Varnholt heard the news through a length of hollow cane.

It was Hob who had thought of it. He had been calling down the speaking-tube since the cradle had left the Hall, in a steady stream of reports on the state of the winch, and when Edda put the horn to Cassian’s mouth, the Lady’s voice came down it as dry and quiet as a sheet of paper. She had been standing at the rim of the hatch for four hours. She had not once left it.

Tamsin did not hear what he said to her. She had walked a little way off, with Wick’s hand in hers, to give them the Keeping. She heard only the low steady murmur of his voice, and once, quite clearly, his tender and foolish laugh. And then she heard the Lady answer, in a voice that she had never in her life heard her use.

It was a very simple sentence. It was only: “I shall come on Thursdays, then. I shall bring the cup with the chip.”

“You will find the stairs very long,” said Cassian.

“I have been climbing them for eleven years,” said Ottoline Varnholt. “I believe I can manage one more flight.”

He put down the horn. He stood a moment with his head bowed. Then he went and sat down at the foot of the black chain, on the pearl step where the water ran in, with the golden lamp on his knee, and took from the child’s small stiff hands the little brass bucket of oil. Wick let it go one finger at a time. She stared at him. She did not say that nobody was coming. It was no longer so.

“Count them for me,” said Cassian, gravely. “I am very bad at it. I have only recently got my mornings back.”

“There are one hundred and eleven links in the first fathom,” said Wick.

“Thank you. Then I shall start at one hundred and twelve.”

---

The ascent was a long and mostly silent business. Four of them went up: the Keeper with her slate, and her counsel, and the clerk, and a very small girl in a grey coat who had never before been taken anywhere. They swung up the wet pale shaft in the cradle with the lanterns burning low, and the black chain hung beside them, dead and taut. It had stopped saying anything. Tamsin did not trust that for a moment.

She did not look down. She had been told not to. But at the last, when the pale walls had given way to black masonry and the cold clean air of Lanthorne was coming down to meet them, she put her hand on the rail and let the ring on her finger do what it had been wanting to do for six hours.

It was very quiet. It was only a small bright warmth, and a single dry voice, as plain as a man clearing his throat, from a long way below.

*Eat something,* said Lucan. *You will not be able to think on an empty stomach, and I shall know.*

She pressed her forehead against the cold rope, and laughed without a sound, and wept, and let the winch take her up into the light.

---

It was nearly dawn when the cradle came out of the hatch under the Speaker’s dais.

The Hall was empty. The great horseshoe of benches stood in rows in the grey light, and the black and white tiles ran down the middle of it with a long white scar across them that seemed to breathe. A few Underdeckers sat about in the aisles, asleep on their coats.

Hob stood at the winch with his cap in his hand and his face the colour of putty. He had been there all night. He took one look at her and did not say a word, but only put out an arm and helped her over the rim.

“Your mother’s up on the Tallow stair,” he said. “She’s singing. She hasn’t stopped. She says Tallow’s calmer.” His eyes went to the empty place behind her. He cleared his throat. “He isn’t coming, then.”

*Not yet,* wrote Tamsin. *Thursdays.*

“Right,” said Hob gruffly. “Right you are. I’ll tell Odo. He’ll have it on a card.” And he wiped his nose on his sleeve, with great deliberation, and began to coil the line.

She walked to the doors of the Hall alone, with Pru behind her, and the child on Edda’s hip, and the first light of the ninth day coming gold across the colonnade. It was very still. There were hundreds of people on the plaza, asleep, in long untidy rows, in families, with their children across their knees and their lamps burned out beside them.

It was the whole city, or the part of it that had not been able to go home. She stood on the top step and looked at them, and for a moment she thought, quite simply, *that is a lot of people to have been right.*

Then the first of them woke up, and sat up, and rubbed his eyes, and lifted a hand to shield them from the sun.

There was a thread round his wrist. A thin, cold, white one, as neat as a ring.

She saw the next, and the next. A woman holding a baby. A boy in a baker’s apron. A very old man with a pipe.

She saw the whole long field of waking faces turn, one after another, to look down at their own raised hands, and stop, and begin to be afraid. Every wrist that had gone up for her in the Hall of the Houses had been marked, and every one of them was counted, and she stood on the steps in the dawn with her slate in her fist and no voice, and understood that the Under had not been waiting for the Keeper at all.

It had been waiting for the city.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!