Miss Dorothea Pike asked for the floor at Thursday’s noon muster, and Ambrose Tull told me afterward that in a hundred and seven years nobody had ever asked for it, so there was no rule against giving it to her.
We had slept at Ines’s, Dee and I, with the dog across both our feet. Dee was in the upstairs hall again with a bagel and my phone, and I was back in the weave shed beside a woman whose thermometer had read fifteen at breakfast.
The muster floor was the open end of the shed, where the shifts changed. Benches had been carried in. Every one was full. The off shift had come, and a good part of the on shift, with their headsets pushed down around their necks, and there were faces at the glass of the records room and all up the iron stair.
Ines would not sit in the chair for it. She had dragged a stool out of Dispatch and perched on that, in her three layers, with the baton across her knees.
“From the top,” she said. “This is a meeting. I’ve run about four hundred of these, mostly for parents. Same rules. One at a time, nobody’s stupid, and if you go long I’ll cut you off. Mr. Tull has a motion.”
Tull rose. He had no notes.
“I move that the form of words lately adopted at the Quarry be not put in this house, nor in any house of this region.” His voice carried without effort. “I shall be brief. We are three hundred and nine houses. Each is lit. Each resident is posted. We have had fourteen years without a Disposition, which is longer than any region on the trunk. That peace has a cost, and one person bears it, and she is sitting on a stool.”
“The Quarry asked its dead what they would like,” said Tull. “It has since been obliged to ask two hundred other houses, at a cost of eighteen hundred and forty that it cannot meet. I submit that a question which bankrupts the asker is not a kindness. I submit that we are content. And I submit, with respect to our visitor, that content people ought to be left alone.”
He sat. It was a good speech, and I had to stand up after it.
“Miss Park,” said Ines. “You get the same three minutes.”
“He’s right about the bill,” I said. “I’ll start there. I can’t pay it. I added it up myself last week and I’ve had a stomachache since. If anybody tells you asking is free, they’re selling something. It isn’t free. Somebody keeps the lights on, and in your house I’ve now seen who.”
“But those are two questions, and he’s stapled them together. One is who pays. That’s real, and I don’t have it solved. The other is whether you get asked. And I don’t think you settle the second by pointing at the first. I work in a pharmacy. If a drug’s expensive, we fight about the price. We don’t solve it by never telling the patient what’s wrong with them.”
“You might be fine. Mr. Tull says you’re content, and he’s known you a lot longer than I have. I’m only saying he’s guessing. A very good guess, from a man who cares. It’s still a guess till somebody asks.” I looked at the stool. “That’s all I’ve got. It’s your house.”
I sat down. My knees were going.
“Miss Pike,” said Ines. “You asked for the floor. It’s yours.”
She stood up in the third row, in her buttoned cardigan, with her hands clasped at her waist like a child reciting.
“I only wish to say one thing,” said Miss Pike. “I have filed L through M since the autumn of nineteen forty. I have never misfiled a card. I have been commended.” She swallowed. “I hate it. I have hated it since about nineteen forty-one. I am not unhappy in general. I like my house and I like the girls in it. But I hate that drawer, and nobody has ever asked me, and yesterday a living person with a foreign telephone asked me whether I liked it and I went home and could not sit down.”
The shed was absolutely silent.
“I do not want to go anywhere,” she said. “I want that understood. I may very well choose to keep the drawer. I should just like to have said it once out loud, in front of people. That I hate filing.”
Somebody laughed.
It was one of the Dispatch juniors, a boy of about seventeen, and he clapped a hand over his mouth at once. But it had got out, and it went along the bench, and then the next bench, and in a few seconds three hundred of the orderly dead of Harrow were laughing, helplessly, the way a class laughs when the quiet girl finally says the thing. Miss Pike went scarlet. Then she laughed too.
“I hate Relay,” said a man near the back. “I’ve got no ear. I’ve been getting names wrong since nineteen sixty.”
“We know, Frank.”
Ines let it run a full minute. She was grinning, and it took ten years off her. Then she tapped the baton twice on the leg of the stool, and they stopped, the way seventh graders stop.
“Ruling,” she said. “The motion is that we don’t ask. I’m not carrying it and I’m not killing it. This house, the head office, gets asked. Today. One house, and then we look at what happened and we talk again.” She turned on the stool. “And Mr. Tull asks it.”
“Chief.”
“You know every one of them. You’ll want to help them answer. Don’t.”
He did it. I will say that for him. He stood at a table by the time clock with the form of words copied out in his own hand, and they came up one by one, and he asked. He was terrible for the first twenty. “You would wish to stay, I take it,” he said to a girl from Sorting, and Miss Pike, who had appointed herself to the end of the table, said, “Don’t lead her, Mr. Tull,” and he closed his eyes briefly and began again.
By four it was done. Two hundred and twelve in the head office. A hundred and ninety to stay. Nine to go, when they were ready. Thirteen who did not know. Of the hundred and ninety, sixty-three had added, unprompted, that they would like a different desk.
“They didn’t know they could switch,” said Ines. She was looking at the tally with a strange face. “Fourteen years. I never told them. I didn’t know they didn’t know.”
Miss Pike went to Dispatch. She had always wanted the telephones. Frank took her drawer and was, I am told, superb at it.
Ines asked Tull last. In front of everyone. He stood very straight.
“What would you like, Ambrose?”
“I should like my Chief to see forty,” he said. “I am aware it is not among the three answers. I am aware it is not in my gift, nor in yours.” His composure held, barely. “Put me down for stay.”
She put her hand on his sleeve. It went through, a little. Neither of them moved.
It was after that, when the benches were being carried back, that he found me by the stair. Ines had gone to the office. It was a quarter to nine.
“Miss Park. I owe you a candor. You conceded my best point in front of my own house, and I do not care to be outdone in fairness.” He took off the pince-nez and held them. “At two o’clock I filed an objection with the Toll. Rule Eleven of the tariff. No Chief shall be seated for a second region whose Reserve stands below fifteen.”
I felt the floor go a little.
“She read fifteen at breakfast,” Tull said. “At nine she will pay. She has no children at her door this week. The reading is taken at the hour of seating, and on Monday at eleven fifty-two she will not have fifteen, and she will not be seated, and she will not be permitted to tender anything at all.” He put the glasses back on. “I have saved her life. I have not asked her. You may tell me what you think of that when you have decided.”
“And my houses? If she isn’t Receiver, who is?”
“The next chair on the list. A Mr. Rusk, of Sennet Bend. He has never missed a payment.” His narrow face was wretched and quite steady. “He will close what he must, oldest arrears first. I am sorry for your houses, Miss Park. I find I am sorrier for mine.”

