The Honorable Tamsin Ridley of the Third District Court sits for an emergency telephone hearing at ten o’clock on Wednesday, and she begins it by announcing that she has had four hours of sleep and does not intend to be charmed.
I am in the Keeper’s sewing room with the speakerphone in the middle of the table, a legal pad in front of me, and a pot of Cyrus’s tea going cold at my elbow. Priya sits on my left with the laptop.
Livia sits on my right in a borrowed gray sweater with the cuffs turned back twice, her hair pinned up, her hands folded. She looks about fifteen and about fifty. She is the only lawyer in the room admitted to practice in Utah, and she has not eaten since yesterday.
“This is In re the Estate of Ansel J. Varnell,” says the judge’s clerk, a dry flat Salt Lake voice. “On the record. Appearances.”
“Livia Varnell, Your Honor. Petitioner, and the decedent’s granddaughter.”
“Andrew Pellam, Pellam and Rowe, for the respondent estate and the custodian pro tem.” An old man’s voice, reedy and careful.
“And Colin Strand, Your Honor, same firm.”
“And,” says Judge Ridley, “I’m told there is a third person on the line who is not a party and has not entered an appearance. Who is it?”
Livia leans toward the microphone. “Maren Holt, Your Honor. Of Pike and Aldana in Denver, currently on leave. She holds the item in dispute.”
“Ms. Holt, are you counsel to anyone?”
I tap the pad. Priya reads it out. “She isn’t, Your Honor. She is a witness. She has laryngitis.”
“Does she?” A pause. “I’ll hear her in whatever way she’s able. I’d like to hear her voice at least once, Ms. Holt, so the record knows who I’m speaking to.”
I lean over the microphone. It is a very odd sensation, like pushing a boat off a beach. What comes out is a dry whisper with nothing under it.
“I’ll keep it short, Your Honor.”
There is a brief silence on the line, and then, unmistakably, a snort from the bench.
“Then we’ll get along,” says Judge Ridley. “Ms. Varnell, proceed.”
---
Livia is very good.
I have watched a great many lawyers in a great many courtrooms, and I know the difference between one who is performing and one who is simply telling the truth in the right order. She does not raise her voice.
She sets out the facts in four sentences: the death on Sunday, the petition filed that night, the order signed before midnight, the lock changed on Monday on the strength of an ex parte paper that she was not served with and had no chance to oppose.
“The respondent says it is protecting the decedent’s papers,” she says. “I am the decedent’s granddaughter and, if my father is not found, his sole heir. Mr. Pellam is protecting them from me. I would like to know on whose instruction, and I would like to open the study.”
“Mr. Pellam?”
“Your Honor.” The old man’s breath whistles. “The petition was filed by this office on the instruction of the executor named in the decedent’s will.”
“Who is?”
“Mr. Royce Varnell.”
“Who is missing.”
“He is, Your Honor, since Sunday evening, in circumstances of which I have only heard.”
“Then who, since Sunday evening, has been instructing you?”
The silence is long enough that I can hear Colin Strand’s chair creak. I look at Priya. She is writing furiously and does not look up.
“The office,” says Mr. Pellam, “has a standing authority.”
“From whom?”
“From the holder of the Rowe interest.”
“I’m sorry. The what?”
---
It takes him eleven minutes, and the judge lets him have all of them, and by the end of it I have a page of notes in a handwriting even I can’t read.
Pellam and Rowe was founded in 1971 by two men, Andrew Pellam and a lawyer named Elias Rowe, as a two-man firm in Salt Lake City, and for twenty years it did contracts and estates for what Mr. Pellam describes, with a certain delicacy, as *a family of clients with property in the south of the state.* Elias Rowe died of a heart attack in October of nineteen ninety-three. He had no children. His widow sold his third of the firm in the spring of nineteen ninety-four.
“To whom?” says the judge.
“By assignment, Your Honor. To a bearer.”
“I don’t know what that means.”
“I did not either.” The old man’s voice has begun to shake.
“The instrument was a deed of assignment, prepared by counsel for the Varnell family. It transferred Mr. Rowe’s interest in the partnership, and certain rights attached to it under the family’s governing papers, to *the holder of this instrument.* The holder has never appeared. The distributions, which are generous, are paid by bank draft to a post office box in Moab, Utah. I have never met him. I believe in thirty-two years I have spoken to him on the telephone twice.”
“And the *rights attached.*”
“A seat. On the Council.” A cough. “The family has a governing body of seven. There were always seven. Mr. Rowe held one of the seven in trust, and when his interest was assigned, the seat went with the paper. It has voted by written proxy, every year, as the holder directs.”
I don’t write. I’ve stopped writing. I’m looking at Livia, who has gone absolutely still, with her eyes on the speaker.
“My grandfather never told me,” she says quietly. “There are seven chairs. I thought there were six, and a vacancy.”
“There is no vacancy, Miss Varnell. There never was. The seventh chair is the Rowe chair, and it has been filled by a proxy for thirty-two years.”
“And Sunday’s petition?” says Judge Ridley. “The ex parte order? Who authorized it?”
“The holder of the Rowe interest.” Pellam’s whisper drops. “By written direction, Your Honor, delivered to our office by courier on Sunday evening. At ten past eight.”
I’m writing again. Ten past eight. Forty-four minutes after the old man died on the gravel with my hand on his sleeve. No courier drives from the Alder to Salt Lake in forty-four minutes. Either that paper was written and signed before Ansel Varnell was dead, or someone was already in Salt Lake and was told by telephone. I write both down and draw a box around them.
“What did the direction say?” says the judge.
“It instructed this office to petition for custody of the decedent’s papers, to hold the study sealed, to demand the return of any photographic material, and to move to void any declaration taken on the riverbank.” A very long pause.
“I want to say that I did not like it, Your Honor. I have been this man’s lawyer for thirty-two years, by mail, and I did not like what I was asked to type. But the instrument is valid. He has the authority. I have never in my life refused it.”
“How is the direction signed?”
“It is not signed.” A strangled laugh. “It is drawn. There is a small drawing, in blue ink. A wolf.” He stops, and I hear him gather himself, a tiny wet breath. “It has been the same drawing every time since nineteen ninety-four. I should say that I have been afraid of that drawing for most of my working life.”
---
The judge is a wise woman. I know this because she does not remark on the wolf. She makes a small noise in her throat, as one does at a thing one is going to think about later in the bath, and then says, in her brisk dry voice:
“I’m going to make some orders. Mr. Strand, don’t object, you’ll have your chance to be heard on the first Monday I have free. I’m going to treat the ex parte order as a stopgap that has now run its course. I’m appointing Ms. Varnell special administrator of the decedent’s estate for fourteen days, limited to the preservation and inventory of his papers. Mr. Pellam, you’ll give her access to the study, and you will not be there when she opens it.”
“Your Honor”
“You’ll be there, Mr. Pellam, at the *door.* You will be in the hall. A bailiff from my court will attend with a camera and inventory every sheet that comes out of that room. I want it done before the Council sits.”
“The Council meets Friday, Your Honor,” says Livia, very low. “The Falls. At noon.”
“Then Friday at eight, in the morning, which gives the bailiff a good deal of time.” A rustle. “Now. The photographic negative.”
I sit up. Priya’s pen stops.
“Ms. Holt, I’m told you hold an item that the respondents claim is the property of the estate and that you claim is evidence. I’m not in a position to decide, today, what it is. I’m going to order that it be preserved. The original goes to the registry of this court, in a sealed envelope, by bonded courier, by five o’clock tomorrow, and it stays there until I’ve heard from everyone. It is not to pass through anyone’s pocket on the way. You may keep copies.”
I write. *TOMORROW 5 PM. SEALED.* I hold it up for Priya, who nods.
“Does the witness understand?”
I lean to the microphone. “Yes.”
“And is she going to be a nuisance?”
I think about it, and I give the only honest answer a lawyer can give.
“Probably.”
“Good,” says Judge Ridley. “We’re adjourned.”
---
I let myself shake for exactly four minutes. I do it in the pantry, standing at the cold window with the heels of both hands pressed against my eyes. When I take them down Livia is in the doorway with two cups.
“I should have known,” she says. “About the chair. A Varnell would. I’m a lawyer who read the family papers in her grandfather’s study at fourteen, and I never once asked what the seventh was for.”
I take the cup. *HE KEPT IT FROM YOU.*
“He kept everything from everyone, and he did it with such courtesy that you walked out thanking him.” Her smile is crooked. “I called nobody on Sunday, you know. I want to say that, as long as I’m saying things. My phone was in the barn. Okafor has it now, with a form. She says she’ll have the records tomorrow.” She sips. “I wanted you to hear it from me, instead of from the form.”
I put my good hand over hers. It is a small enough gesture. She looks at it.
*I NEVER THOUGHT IT,* I write. It’s a lie. Then, because I am trying to be a better one, *I THOUGHT IT FOR TEN MINUTES. I’M SORRY.*
“Ten minutes is generous. I’d have thought it for an hour.” She turns her hand over under mine and grips, hard, once. “Thank you for saying so.”
---
I have promised the court an envelope, and I take it as seriously as I have taken anything.
Priya does the scanning in the Keeper’s sewing room with the door locked and a Warden outside it. She has borrowed the Hall’s flatbed scanner, an ancient gray thing that groans like a donkey, and a lens from Teo’s brother’s camera, and she has been told by a friend at the Denver library that three exposures at different angles will give her a file she can enlarge to the size of a door.
It takes two hours. She works with white cotton gloves and a loupe, breathing through her nose, and when she is done she has seventeen files and a headache.
Frame thirty-six comes up on the screen like a window opening. The bluff. The seated figure. The whistle on his chest, and the cap, and the raised arm.
“Look at the arm,” says Priya.
I do. It’s the left. It is lifted, bent at the elbow, with the hand open at the level of the ear, and I have been looking at that gesture for three days and calling it a wave.
“It’s not a wave,” she says. “It’s the sign. Wardens use a signal on the bluff to the men at the bank. Teo showed me. The open left hand at the ear means *now.*”
I feel my stomach turn over, slowly.
“He’s not watching,” says Priya, very low. “He’s calling it. He’s giving the order that starts the drowning, with his hand, in front of a camera, because he thinks the only camera is a clerk’s. And Rosalind’s, a few yards off, takes it anyway.”
*THIRTY-SIX YEARS AGO.*
“Thirty-six years ago.” She zooms. “And it’s his left. I checked it against the sprocket holes. A negative reverses everything, so I flipped it twice. It really is his left hand.”
I think of my father. Left-handed, quiet, a man who did the crossword in pen and drew his *J* like a fishing hook. I think of a hymn whistled in a yard. I do not let myself think anything further. It is a long way across a river from a thought to a fact, and I have been burned at the crossing before.
Priya sees my face and does the kind thing, which is to hand me a job. She asks me to write the cover note for the registry envelope, three lines, in a lawyer’s cold hand, and I do it. *Sealed original, one negative strip, thirty-six frames, received from the Witness of Corwin Ridge. Chain of custody attached.* It is a relief to write a sentence that asks nothing of anyone.
When I have finished I find that I have pressed so hard the pen has gone through to the blotter, and that my hand, my wretched right hand, has cramped around it so tightly that Livia has to open my fingers one at a time, as Reyes did on the riverbank, and neither of us mentions it.
I put the cover note under the flap with the others and do not look at the table again.
At four o’clock I seal the original negative into a manila envelope with Priya and Hobart and Agnes watching, and sign across the flap in the little rough hand I have left. Agnes lays the Keeper’s wax on it. She presses her thumb into the wax and her ring after, and I realize that I have just been given the Ridge’s oldest courtesy, a seal nobody in Utah will understand and nobody in Colorado will forget.
---
The courier is a pleasant young man from a bonded Salt Lake service who has no idea what is in the envelope. He signs for it at half past four, and Hobart escorts him to the county line. Hobart is back by seven with the courier’s receipt and a gray face.
“He was followed,” says Hobart. “A white sedan. Utah plate. It sat behind us for forty miles and turned off at the Silver Fork light. I took the number.” He hands the slip to Knox. “Okafor’s running it.”
“Anyone you know?” says Knox.
“No.” Hobart’s jaw works. “But that’s the third car this week with a Salt Lake sticker on the bumper, and it never comes within a mile of the gate. It sits on the county road. It goes away. I’d like it said, in front of people, that I’m uneasy.”
“It’s said,” says Knox.
---
The call comes at eight. I take it on Priya’s phone, in the pantry, because the number says *Salt Lake City* and Priya says, “Don’t,” and then, “Okay, put it on speaker, and I’ll type what you can’t say.”
“Ms. Raman?” The voice is thin and old and very frightened. “I’m sorry. This is Andrew Pellam. I got your number from the clerk. I wasn’t sure you would.”
“I’m her paralegal. Ms. Holt can hear you.”
“Ms. Holt.” A breath. “I won’t be long. Strand is down the hall. I told him I was going to the men’s room, and I’ve been standing in it for four minutes.”
I tap the pad. Priya reads. “She says go ahead.”
“I should have said it in court. I couldn’t, with Strand on the line, and with the order the way it was.” His whisper cracks. “I told the judge the Rowe seat votes by proxy. That is true. It has. For thirty-two years.”
“Yes.”
“On Friday it won’t.”
I stop breathing.
“I had a telegram today. From Moab. Nobody sends a telegram, Ms. Raman, it’s a service I thought was dead. It says, in one line, that the holder of the Rowe interest *will attend the Council in person on Friday at noon to cast the seventh chair for the Chair of Ashgrove Falls.* It says he’s already in Utah.”
The old man swallows. “In thirty-two years, he has never come. He has never so much as sent a photograph. He sent a drawing and a bank draft and a telegram, and on Friday at noon, at the Falls, he’s going to walk in the door.”
I put my pencil down very carefully. The tip is broken. I don’t remember breaking it.
“And Ms. Holt.” Pellam’s voice drops until I have to lean in. “There is one more line. I’d like you to hear it before I hang up, because I think it was written for you and not for the Council. It says, *The Witness is welcome to sit at my left hand. I haven’t had company in a very long time.*”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!