Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 25

What the Photograph Can’t Say

Jessa’s oven was spotless. I knew because she opened it to show me.

“Look,” she said. “You could eat off it.”

“I’d rather eat off a plate.”

“I’m making a point about my state of mind.”

It was Monday evening, and I stood in the kitchen of her apartment above the hardware store in Ridgetop Reach, where I had stood a hundred times before the world got complicated. The radiator knocked. A pot of soup sat on the stove, smelling of onions and thyme. Her good right hand stirred, and her left, with its stiff little finger and the ring finger that would never fully bend, hung at her side holding a wooden spoon with a grip she had spent two years teaching it.

We had not said anything about the statement. We had said hello, and I’d put my duffel by the door, and she’d said, “You look terrible,” and I’d said, “Thank you,” and she’d said, “Sit,” and I’d sat. The soup had come first because soup was how she said things she was afraid to say.

“Eat,” she said.

I ate. It was very good. I told her so. She nodded without turning around.

“You can be angry,” she said.

“I’m not sure I am.”

“You should be. I’d be.” She switched off the burner. “I went behind your back.”

“You did.”

“I’m not sorry I did it. I’m sorry how it landed.” She turned at last. Her face was thinner than I remembered, her mouth set, her eyes dry and enormous. “If I’d told you first, you’d have talked me out of it.”

“I would have tried.”

“You’d have made a very good case. You always do. You’d have said it was my career, my life, my sound board, my hands. You’d have said I didn’t have to burn it all down.” She pulled out the other chair and sat. “And I’d have listened, because you’re my sister and I’m always listening to you. And I’d have gone another six years with a story that has a hole in it the exact shape of you.”

I put down my spoon.

For six years I had told myself that I’d made a choice. A sixty-second choice in a rigging loft, with a knife in my hand and a sister swinging from a failing line, a choice made so fast that it felt like weather. Cut the secondary.

Drop her to the safety net before the primary pulled the whole frame down. It had worked. It had also cost her the use of one hand, and cost me my name, and then I had spent six years refusing to let her pay any of the bill.

“I thought I was protecting you,” I said.

“You were. You were also deciding what I was allowed to carry.”

“That’s the same thing.”

“No.” She said it gently. “It really isn’t.”

We sat with that. The radiator knocked. Down in the hardware store someone dropped a box of screws, and a long, cheerful bad word floated up through the floor.

“I didn’t write a joint story,” Jessa said. “That’s the other thing. I didn’t write that we were victims together. I wrote what I did and what I saw. That I shouldn’t have been up there. That I’d been asked to go home and didn’t.

“That the anchor failed and that you cut a line, and that if you hadn’t, I’d be dead.” She wiped her cheek with the back of her good hand. “I wrote that I was angry for years at the wrong person. And that it was never fair that you carried it.”

“That’s very generous.”

“It’s accurate. It’s the only thing I wanted from you. Accurate.” She laughed, wetly. “It’s also a terrible thing to do to a person. I know. I’m sorry.”

“Don’t be.”

“I mean it.”

“So do I.” I reached across the table, and she took my left hand in her right. We held on like two people on a sinking raft. “I’d like to write mine. By myself. Without reading yours.”

“You can read mine.”

“I’d like not to. If we match, I want it to be because they match.”

She nodded slowly. “That’s what I wanted to say. I was afraid to ask.”

“You’ve been asking for a week. You cleaned an oven.”

“It was a stress response.”

“It was a very clean oven.”

She laughed again, truly this time, and I laughed with her, and for a while neither of us could stop.

---

Maris came by at nine with a box of leftover pastries from a customer fitting and a bolt of terrible green fabric she wanted our opinion on.

“It’s called Pond Scum,” she said, unrolling it across Jessa’s couch. “It’s the color my mother has forbidden in any home she owns.”

“It’s honest,” Jessa said.

“It’s repulsive. I love it.”

She looked well. She had cut her hair to her chin and wore a canvas apron over her sweater with pins stuck in the collar like a tiny armory. Her new studio was three blocks from the Reach’s main street, in a tailor’s old shop, and she had already, she reported, been called “Miss Keene’s girl” twice by the same old man, and had corrected him both times. It was a small satisfaction and she was treasuring it.

“Ames’s office called me,” she said, sitting on the arm of the sofa. “They’re going to notify the other thirty-nine. They asked me whether I wanted to be there when they notify the first batch.”

“Do you?”

“I thought about it.” She pulled a pin from her collar and slid it back in. “It was my certificate that started it. But I’d feel like I was taking credit for a thing I only happened to find. I said no. I said I’d write a letter instead, saying I’m available if anyone wants to ask me what it felt like to learn.”

“That’s a good letter.”

“I’m good at letters. They never talk back.” She glanced at me. “How’s the shoulder?”

“Bad.”

“How are you?”

“Worse than the shoulder.” I smiled. “Better than I was.”

“I’ll take it.” She slid off the arm of the couch and sat beside me. “Jessa told me about the statement.”

“Did she?”

“She told me because I asked her whether she wanted me there at the dinner, and she said no.” Maris looked at her hands. “She said it was between sisters. I’ve decided to find that very moving and not hurt.”

“It’s a good policy.”

“I’ve been practicing.”

---

On Tuesday morning, I did the one thing I had been avoiding. I drove across town to my own apartment, which I had barely seen in two weeks, opened my mailbox and found the panel’s letter.

It was a cream-colored envelope with a return address in the state capital. It had a formal seal, a signature block and a paragraph that said the Towerfall Accident Review Panel was reopened under a standing provision for incidents with unresolved physical evidence and that I was invited, but not compelled, to submit a written account by the end of the month. An interview would follow. Counsel was permitted. I could submit separately from any other party. I could decline.

At the bottom, in a slightly different font, someone had added a paragraph.

The panel has received a physical evidence file, including photographs of the primary anchor assembly from the date of the incident, a retained fragment of the severed secondary line and a copy of the original inquiry report. The panel is aware that some materials were in private custody for a period. Requests for further documents will be handled by the Panel’s secretary.

“Private custody,” I said aloud, to my empty kitchen.

That was Ellis. That was his copy of the report, the one he’d bought and never read to the end. And now it was in a state file, which meant he’d sent it, which meant he had already, quietly, started.

I put the letter on the table. I did not call him.

At ten, I drove to the Reach’s old equipment yard, where Oren was waiting in front of a locked shed. He stood with his clipboard, a thermos and a cardboard box.

“Good morning,” he said.

“What’s in the box?”

“Photographs.” He opened the shed. “I took them. Six years ago, three days after Towerfall. I was called in by a friend at the venue, not by the inquiry. I wasn’t allowed near the anchor. I stood at the edge of the cordon and took pictures with a long lens.”

“You never told me.”

“You never asked.” He set the box on a workbench. “I didn’t think they’d help. They don’t prove anything. I want that clear. A photograph can show you a rusted plate. It can’t say who knew about the rust.”

He took out a stack of prints. They were glossy and slightly curled, the corners soft. He laid them out in a row, left to right, like cards in a game for which I did not know the rules.

The first showed the arena rigging loft from a distance, a dark steel lattice, a gap where the anchor assembly had hung. The second was a close-up. A big, plain, ugly plate, twelve inches square, bolted into a beam, with one corner torn clean away.

“Rust bloom,” Oren said, pointing. “Here. And here. It’s a long, slow stain that starts at the bolt shoulders. Paint over it, you’d never see it from the ground. From a ladder, with a flashlight, you’d see it in ten seconds.”

“Someone didn’t look.”

“Or someone looked and wrote something else.” He moved his finger. “It’s what the photographs can’t tell me. I’m not going to guess.”

I looked for a long time. I had spent six years not looking at pictures of that plate. It was strange, in the end, how small it was. A square of dull iron the size of a dinner tray. It had held up a woman, a hoop and a roomful of money, and then, one night, it had stopped.

In the third photograph, a small tag dangled from a wire near the bolt. A paper tag, laminated, tied on with orange twine. The kind that rig inspectors hang on equipment to say it has been checked.

“Oren.”

“Mm.”

“There’s a tag.”

“There is.” He leaned in. “It’s in every picture. I’ve looked at it for years.”

“What does it say?”

“I can read the date. September twelfth. Three weeks before the accident.” He tapped the lower corner. “And the initials of the inspector. Two letters. L.R.”

“Do you know who L.R. is?”

“I know exactly who L.R. is.”

I felt it before I understood it, a cold finger down the back of the neck.

“The inquiry report,” I said slowly. “The letter says the panel has a copy of the inquiry report. Ellis’s copy. Does it say anything about an inspection three weeks before?”

“It says there was no inspection.” Oren put the print down very carefully, as if it might wake. “It says, and I remember because I read it the way you read a diagnosis, that the anchor assembly ‘had not been examined in the preceding calendar quarter.’ Everything the inquiry decided rested on that sentence.”

“And the tag says it was.”

“The tag says someone with the initials L.R. hung a card on that plate on September twelfth.” He rubbed his jaw. “It doesn’t say what he found. It doesn’t say what he wrote. It doesn’t say whether the card was a lie. I’m not going to tell you what I believe, because I might be wrong, and you’ve spent six years living with a story that someone told you with confidence.”

“Who is he?”

“Lyle Rowe. Sixty-seven now. He was an engineer for the state’s rigging board for thirty years. He sat on the original inquiry as a technical reviewer.” Oren looked at me. “Which means, if the tag is real, the man who inspected the anchor and the man who signed the report that said nobody had inspected it are the same man.”

“That doesn’t make sense.”

“No.”

“Unless he didn’t write the sentence.”

“Unless.” He nodded. “That’s a very careful unless. I’d carry it around for a day before you say it to anybody. Including a panel.”

I stared at the little paper tag, laminated and faded, a hair’s width of orange twine in the grain of a six-year-old print. I thought of all the things I had assumed. That the failure was cheap negligence. That no one had checked. That it was the arena’s fault, or Beck’s, or mine.

“It could be nothing,” I said.

“It could.”

“It could be exactly what it looks like.”

“It could be that, too.” Oren folded his hands. “That’s the thing about photographs, Cleo. They give you questions with very good edges.”

---

Ellis called at eleven forty that night.

I had spent the evening at Jessa’s table, writing, in longhand, in a lined notebook, with a pen that did not bleed. I had written four pages and torn up two. I had written one sentence, I cut the secondary line, and then looked at it for an hour before writing the next.

Jessa came through twice. The first time she set a mug of tea at my left hand, the side I could still lift, and went to the sink without glancing at the page. The second time, near ten, she stopped behind my chair with a dish towel over her shoulder, and I felt her not look.

“I’m not reading it,” she said.

“I know.”

“I’m reading your neck. You’re holding that pen like it owes you money.”

“It’s a first draft.”

“Mine had seven.” She rested her good hand on the back of my chair, lightly, the way you touch a rail you don’t plan to lean on. “Write the ugly sentence first. Then go back and make it polite, and see whether you can stand the polite one.”

After she went to bed, I wrote the ugly sentence. I did not tell the inquiry the truth because I was twenty-two and frightened, and because it was easier to be the reckless one than to say my sister had been standing where she was never supposed to be.

It looked smaller on the paper than it had felt in my chest for six years. It also looked exactly like me, which I had not expected, and I sat with that until the radiator knocked twice and the tea went cold.

I picked up on the first ring.

“Hi,” I said.

“Hi.” His voice sounded scraped. “It’s done.”

“How did it go?”

“I stood up in the closed session and said it. All of it. The purchase, the report, the fact that I never read the appendices. I said I didn’t challenge the conclusion because it was convenient.” A breath. “I said I had already forwarded my copy to the state panel on Saturday.”

“I saw. In the letter.”

“Did you?” A tired laugh. “Good. Then I did one thing right.”

“What did they do?”

“There was a lot of noise. Yvette said it was a staggering breach. Two delegates asked whether I should step aside. Delegate Tran said I’d shown more honesty than the last three alphas combined, which wasn’t a compliment to the last three.” He exhaled.

“Finch had promised to keep it in closed session and hold the vote if I came forward on my own, and he kept the promise by about a hair. The vote was seven to six. They’re postponing the renewal by one month, pending a full review of my records. I keep my seat for now.”

“Seven to six.”

“Six who wanted me out. That’s a lot of people.” His voice softened. “I don’t know if I’ll be here in a month, Cleo.”

“Okay.”

“Is that all right? That I might not be?”

“I’d rather have a man who isn’t sure than one who is.” I looked at the notebook. “I found something today. I’m not allowed to say it yet. Not until Oren says. I’m telling you so you know I’m not hiding it. I’m waiting.”

“Waiting is good.”

“Is it?”

“It’s the opposite of what I’d have done.” He paused. “Cleo?”

“Yes.”

“Whatever you found, I’d like to be told in your time, not mine.”

I smiled into the dark kitchen. “Chair?”

“Chair,” he said. “Always.”

We hung up. I sat there for a long time with the notebook open to the single line, listening to the radiator knock, and thought about a laminated tag and two initials and a man in a state office who had written one thing and might have been made to sign another.

At midnight, a text arrived from Oren, short as a nail.

He’ll see us Thursday. He said yes. He said, and I’m quoting, “I’ve been waiting six years for someone to ask me the right question.” Bring the photograph. Bring nothing else.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!