Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 56

Maplewick

The post office in Maplewick had a flag, a bench, a bulletin board with a lost cat on it, and eleven hundred and some brass boxes with little windows, and it was the least sinister building I had been in for a week.

We got there at ten to two. The panel had recessed until four, because Thorne’s resignation had to be read to the Hall’s executive committee in a room on the second floor of the Annex, and Tolliver had said, drily, that the county could not hold two crises at once and would take them in order.

Ames had stood in the corridor with a phone against one ear and a hand over the other and had then said four sentences to Nita and two to Ellis and one to me.

The one to me was: “You go as a witness who touches nothing, or you do not go.”

It was a lawful errand. It was also a small one, which was what made it safe. A man is entitled to ask about his own post office box. The district could not walk into the Maplewick post office and ask who rented Box 1147, because that was a federal building and a federal question, and a postal inspector would have to be summoned, and the earliest he could come was tomorrow. But the holder of Box 1146 could ask what was in his own file.

So we drove there in Ellis’s truck, the three of us on the bench seat, Nita in the middle with a ledger on the knees, Ellis at the wheel with his hands at ten and two and his jaw very tight, and me by the window, watching the county go by, brown and flat and gray with the end of a long season.

Nobody talked for the first ten miles.

---

“I could resign the title,” said Ellis.

We were on the long straight past the grain elevator. He said it to the windshield, quietly, the way a man says a thing he has been carrying under his tongue since breakfast.

“The title,” I said.

“Delegate. I’ve got thirty days left of it. They’ve taken the bench seat, which is a courtesy to the part of me that likes sitting down. The title is the other thing. It’s what Finch can wave. If I gave it up this afternoon, before anybody asks me to, it would be one less thing that’s mine to lose in public.”

Nita’s eyes moved, once, to me, and returned to the ledger.

I knew what I wanted to say. I wanted to say, don’t. I wanted to say, you’ve earned it, you’ve done nothing wrong, you’re the only honest man in the Hall and I won’t have them take a thing from you. It was a good speech and it was all true and I had it ready in my mouth like a boot in a doorway.

I held it for the length of a mile marker.

“What would you be giving it up for?” I said.

“I don’t follow.”

“If you resign it, is it because you want to? Or because you want to hand them the thing before they take it?”

He took his time. A tractor came the other way and we both watched it pass.

“The second,” said Ellis.

“Then I don’t know that it’s mine to say. I’d like you to keep it. I’d like it very much. But I’ve been very careful for a month not to decide things for you.” My voice did something I had not planned. “And if I start now because I’m scared, I think I’ll never be able to stop.”

“You’re not deciding it for me.”

“No. I’m telling you what it costs me to leave it with you.” I turned to look at him. “It costs me quite a lot. I’d like you to know that. And then I’d like you to do whatever you’d do if I weren’t in the truck.”

He drove another half mile. Then, without turning his head, he reached across Nita’s ledger and found my good hand and held it, hard, once, and let it go and put his own back on the wheel.

“Thank you,” he said. “I’m going to think about it.”

“Good.”

“Not today.”

“Not today,” I agreed, and Nita, between us, turned a page with great delicacy, and I decided that we were going to be all right, or at least that we were going to be wrong together.

---

The clerk at the window was a stout, round, silver-haired woman in a cardigan with a name tag that read MRS. OYELARAN, and she looked at Ellis the way you look at a long-lost nephew who has come to borrow money.

“Mr. Voss,” she said. “Well, I never. It’s been years.”

“Three, Mrs. Oyelaran. I’m sorry.”

“I wrote you a note. I wrote you two. They were stuffed in the box.” She leaned on her elbows. “That box is a disgrace, Mr. Voss. I couldn’t get the door shut. I had to take things out. I put them in a bundle.”

“I’m afraid I haven’t been a very good customer.”

“I’ve had people with bad habits. I’ve never had one who left forty statements in a tray and said he’d be back.” She laughed, which made her chins move. “What can I do for you?”

Ellis put both hands on the counter. He told her, clearly, as a man who has learned that the quickest way through a thing is to state it, that he was the holder of Box 1146, that he had reason to think someone had been using the box without his knowledge, and that he wished to see his own file, including any record of duplicate keys.

I watched her face change. It did not change to suspicion. It changed to something worse, a kind of tender, professional dismay.

“Duplicate keys,” said Mrs. Oyelaran. “Oh, dear. Hold on, hon.”

She went into the back. We waited under the lost cat. It had a name, Biscuit, and an address, and a reward of twenty dollars, and somebody had added at the bottom in felt pen, he is very friendly and will not hurt you. I looked at that for a long time.

When she came back she was carrying a gray cardboard file folder with a rubber band around it, and she did not open the little half door. She talked to us through the window.

“I’ve got your rental card,” she said, “opened three years ago, in your name, and the key issue slip, one key issued. That’s the one you had. And I’ve got this.”

She slid a single sheet of pale green paper under the glass. It was a form, half printed and half typed, with boxes to check and a place for the postmaster’s initials and a stamp at the bottom, an inked circle, a tiny bit smudged.

DUPLICATE KEY REQUEST - SAME HOLDER.

Date: September 9.

“That’s this year,” said Nita, very softly. “Five weeks before the refund.”

“Five weeks and a day,” said Ellis, in a voice that had no breath in it. “Before I did anything. Before I’d heard of Sutter.”

I read the form over his shoulder. The holder’s name was typed: E. VOSS. The holder’s signature was a slashing, confident, rather beautiful E followed by a V that had been written without lifting the pen. It was nothing like Ellis. Ellis signs his name like a carpenter signing a work order, upright and square and with the last letter dropped.

It said that the holder had lost one of two keys and requested a second. It said identification had been presented and a copy retained. It said the request had been made in person.

And below that, in the small box that said SUPPORTING DOCUMENT, someone had stamped, in violet ink, a round seal I knew: a tree and a hammer and a ring of tiny letters. DELEGATES’ HALL - RECORDS COMMITTEE. And in the middle of the seal, in a neat upright little pen, the words PER E. THORNE.

---

I looked at the stamp for a long time.

It was a good stamp. It was clear. A man in a hurry would not have been able to do it so well, and a man who owned the Hall’s seal would not have needed to. It was the Hall’s violet and the Hall’s tree. The hand beneath it was the hand that had initialed a page of Rider 9 in pencil on the margin, small and upright and slightly worn.

“It looks like Mr. Thorne,” said Mrs. Oyelaran, unhappily. “I’d have said so. I remember a note from the Hall, now that I see it. It said Mr. Voss was ill and a colleague was authorized to pick up the key. I took it in good faith. I’d no reason not to.”

“Who picked it up?” said Nita.

“I did the form myself, dear. It was Christopher’s day off. A gentleman came in.” She frowned, a deep, cheerful, honest frown. “A very nice-looking gentleman in a pale coat. I want to say tan. He had lovely manners. He’d got the ID copy in a clean envelope with the Hall’s crest on it, and he said Mr. Voss had been called away and would I be so kind. I made him sign the slip.”

“Left-handed?”

Mrs. Oyelaran looked at Nita as though Nita had pulled a rabbit out of the air.

“Why, yes. How did you know? He had to turn the slip around.”

I did not breathe. Beside me, I felt Ellis go through the whole sequence, I think, in a single second: the lost key, the unopened post, the letter that he had never read, the stranger who had walked into a post office with his name and his driver’s license and a Hall stamp, and had put out a left hand to sign for a copy of the way into his private life.

“How long did the second key work?” said Nita.

“Until two weeks ago. Then he came back and said it had stopped. I gave him a third.”

“Two weeks ago,” I said.

“He was ever so gracious. He said the lock must be sticky. I told him Mr. Voss ought to have it oiled.” She drew the cardigan together at the neck. “Is it a crime? Did he do something to your box?”

“He read my mail,” said Ellis, quite quietly. “For about three months. I think. I think he read it as it arrived.”

It was an odd little silence. In it, the clerk of Maplewick looked from the form to Ellis’s face and back again, and a tear, quite suddenly, ran down her round powdered cheek and dropped on the green paper, and she said, “I’m so sorry, Mr. Voss. I should have known better,” and I was reminded that I had forgotten, in a month of important people, how many small kind ones had been quietly used.

---

Nita did the rest. I stood by the lost-cat board while Nita photographed the form, the slip, the stamp, the rental card, and wrote out a receipt for Mrs. Oyelaran to sign. I heard the words chain of custody, and federal, and inspector, and tomorrow. I did not listen. I was thinking about something else, and I wanted to think about it before I forgot where I had put it.

The pieces fell into a pattern, and the pattern gave me a quiet cold sick sense of elegance.

If the man with the left hand had been reading Ellis’s mail since the ninth of September, then on or about the seventh of October, he had read the notice that a payment of eleven thousand dollars had cleared to a broker named Sutter. That was how Devon had known on the eleventh.

It was not magic and it was not a leak. It was an unopened envelope, three days in a brass box, carried out of the post office by a pleasant man in a pale coat.

It explained a thing that had troubled Yvette’s kitchen for a week, and troubled me, and was a relief, in the way that the answer to a puzzle is a relief even when the puzzle was about you.

But it explained something else too. It explained why the seal read PER E. THORNE.

“Nita,” I said, in a low voice. “Can I say something that’s only a guess?”

“You may say it to me.”

“This is the third time. The Hall seal on the key request. The initials in the Rider margin. The Chair, with a capital. The note in the carton, the master key. Everything points at that building and everything points up the stairs at him.” I looked at the green slip. “And every single time it points, it points in a way that’s easy to read.”

“Easy.”

“A man who wants a Hall chair to wear it would have to be able to get the seal, the key, the stationery, the mailroom. Someone who’d been around a long time and had the run of the place.” I rubbed my wrist. “And Thorne gave himself up to us this morning. In public. He said he’d had the yellow form in a drawer for three years. He volunteered a sin. He’s the first person in this who’s taken the blame without being asked.”

“And that troubles you.”

“It troubles me that it fits.” I said it as quietly as I could. “Somebody told me last night that a man like that has read your file and doesn’t need to know what you’ll say, only what you’ll be proud of. I’d like to be careful about being proud of finding the obvious answer. I’d like to know what it’s for.”

Nita did not say anything for a few seconds. When the answer came, it was very dry.

“That’s a better sentence than I’d have liked to say first,” said Nita. “I’ll put it in the note. Not that it’s evidence. That it’s the right kind of doubt.” A pause. “Don’t say it to Ellis yet.”

“Why not?”

“Because he’s just discovered that a stranger read his letters,” said Nita, “and it’s a day for one thing at a time.”

---

I found my phone in the truck.

It had been in the glove box since noon, switched to silent, because a ringing phone in a hearing is an act of war. I picked it up while Ellis was still on the steps, signing a paper, and the screen was full.

Two missed calls from Jessa at 1:12. One at 1:31. A text, at 1:33, which said: PICK UP.

And another, at 1:40: I’m not angry. I just want to be told.

I read that one three times with my thumb over the screen. It was a short sentence. It was in no way dangerous. I felt it as I would have felt a hand on the back of my neck.

I called her. She picked up on the first ring.

“You went to Maplewick,” said Jessa.

“How do you—”

“Ames’s clerk told me. She thought I knew.” A short, level breath. “I didn’t mind that you went, Cleo. I’d have gone, if I’d been asked. What I minded was learning it from a clerk in a corridor, in front of Odette, who was kind enough not to look.”

“I should have called before.”

“Yes.”

“I put the phone in the glove box. It was a hearing.”

“It was a recess,” said Jessa, “and you know the difference.” It was a flat, kind, unhurried voice, the voice of a woman who spent her days in the roofs of small venues telling men twice her size why a shackle was wrong. “I’m not doing this to hurt you.

I’m doing it because last month I stood in a kitchen and told you I wanted to be asked. I don’t want to have to say it again every time we have a hearing. I want it to be a thing you do.”

“It’s a thing I’ll do.”

“All right.” I heard her let out a breath, and I realized that she had been holding it for an hour. “Then I’ll tell you what I wanted. I was going to say it at one, and then I thought, I’ll say it when she picks up, and now it’s two.”

“Go on.”

“I remembered something. It’s probably nothing. Do you remember what I said yesterday, about the man in the shed? The promoter with the clipboard?”

“The pink-cornered envelope.”

“It’s not the envelope.” She was speaking slowly, as she did when she was building a rig, setting each piece before she reached for the next. “He had an orange. He was peeling it. He put the peel on Lyle’s bench, beside the drawer, in a neat little coil, and Lyle was furious, because Lyle hates mess and hates fruit, and he swept it into the bin.

I’ve not thought about it in six years, Cleo. And this morning in the corridor, you walked past me, and I smelled oranges on somebody’s hand.”

I stood very still with the phone against my face.

“It was Ms. Quint,” she said. “I think. A cream. And it came back. The whole shed, and that morning. I’d never have thought of it.”

I closed my eyes. I felt the cold truck seat against my back and the sun on my eyelids. I heard Ellis’s boots on the steps.

A man who smelled of nothing. A man who had bathed in unscented soap and put on a washed coat, who had decided, years ago, what to be near. But a man who ate an orange in a rigging shed six years ago, because somebody has to eat.

And a man who peeled one in a dark room on a Monday night while a machine hummed, because the smell of the thing is in the fruit and not on the person, and a man cannot wash the peel out of the air.

“Jessa,” I said. “Say that again. The part about the coil.”

“He peeled it in one piece. A long spiral. He left it on the bench like a spring.”

I had seen that. I had seen it that morning, in the corridor, at the foot of the Annex steps. Not an orange. A little curled paring of rind on the rail, dried at the edge, tucked into a corner of the stone where somebody had sat, an hour before the cartons came.

I had not understood what I had seen. I had noticed it and let it go, the way you let go of a pin on a floor.

“He was here,” I said. “At the Annex. This morning. Before the hearing.”

“Cleo?”

“I’ll call you back in ten minutes. Don’t go anywhere. I’m going to tell you everything, I promise, and this time I’ll do it first.”

I hung up. Ellis was at the truck door. He looked at my face, and I saw him decide not to ask, and then decide to ask anyway.

“What?”

“Drive,” I said. “Please. The Annex. Fast.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!