I call his name forty-one times, and I feel like a fool for every one of them.
“Pickle!”
The cottonwoods take it and give back nothing. It is twenty past midnight and nineteen degrees, and I am standing at the edge of the pond in a navy funeral dress with a work coat over it and a flashlight in my fist, shouting at a dog who has been deaf in one ear for six years and cannot hear me in the other if the wind is wrong.
I do not know why I keep doing it. Some part of me thinks that if I do it correctly, the sound will find him. That is not science. It is something older, and I have no other tool.
“Pickle! Buddy! Come on!”
The ice on the pond throws my light back at me. The dead cattails click. A coyote starts up somewhere to the north, a thin, silly, rising laugh, and another answers it, and I stand there with the hairs standing on my arms and think of the man in the beige suit saying old animals wander off.
Behind me, up the lawn, the house has every light on. Sheriff Pruitt’s cruiser is in the drive with its bar lights turning slow and silent, red and blue on the bare trees. Two deputies are working the outbuildings with flashlights. Someone is knocking on the bunkhouse door, and I turn and walk fast the other way, toward the creamery, because it is the one place that dog knows how to go.
The brass padlock lies in the grass where Cole dropped it two nights ago, cut in half. The steel door stands shut. I put my hand on it. It is as cold as a gravestone, and nobody has touched it.
I sit down on the frozen ground, in front of the door, where he sat.
“Okay,” I say. “Okay. Okay.”
I count. Forty-one pounds. A thirteen-year-old heeler with a failing liver, two days off a seizure, in nineteen degrees, with no coat. I know the number for how long he can last in this air with his body fat and his coat. It is a very specific number. I put it away where I keep numbers I cannot look at.
Pruitt finds me at one.
He comes through the windbreak with a big handheld lamp and his hat pulled low, and he does not say anything for a time. He just stands there with the light pointed politely at the ground.
“Doc.”
“I know.”
“I need to ask you some questions.”
“I know, Dale.”
“Where’s Ines Abara?”
I look up.
“Her room’s made up,” he says. “Her purse is gone, and her good coat, and her car’s in the garage. Her phone’s off. I’ve got a woman of sixty-one who’s been in this house for thirty years, and the dog, both gone since about nine tonight. That’s the second note.” He holds up a plastic bag. “HE ATE FIRST. What does that mean to you?”
“It’s what the old man said.”
“Gus.”
“It’s what he made them say. Feed the dog first. The dog eats, then everybody else.” I swallow. “It’s a rule. It’s a thing from this house.”
“So somebody’s telling you the dog ate.”
“Yes.”
“As in, he’s done.”
I do not answer that. I cannot make my mouth do it.
Pruitt lowers himself onto his haunches in the frost with a grunt, a big soft sad man in a duty coat, and he rests the lamp on his knee. “I’ve known you fifteen years,” he says. “I held your hand when your daddy’s truck came back on a flatbed. I’m going to say something I don’t want to say, and you’re going to let me say it.”
“Say it.”
“In about eight hours, you’re going to stand in front of Florence Hatch in a courtroom with a clock that’s been stuck at ten after four since 1987, and a lawyer for the Brandt Family Foundation is going to tell her that the guardian of a thirteen-year-old animal lost him. That she falsified an inventory. That there was a break-in at her clinic and a note on her kitchen table. And that there’s not a dog.” He rubs his jaw.
“I’m going to be sitting there, and I’m going to have to answer what I saw. I don’t want to be the man who tells her the truth about that.”
“I didn’t hurt him.”
“I know that.”
“I didn’t.”
“I know.” His voice cracks, very slightly, and he looks away. “I know you didn’t. But a judge doesn’t know it, and the other side’s going to make her not know it. Find that dog, Josie. I’ll have every man I’ve got on the roads till sunup, and then I have to be in court.”
I search for the rest of the night.
I do the pond and the windbreak again. I do the irrigation ditch on my hands and knees. I do the road, the long dark county road, walking it with a flashlight and a mouthful of his name, for three miles one way and three miles back, until the soles of my feet are two hot coins.
I look in the ice house. I look in the root cellar, with its slanted doors and its smell of potatoes, and find nothing but shelves, and the door standing a little ajar, which I do not stop to think about. I look in the bunkhouse, in the barn, in the tack room. Under a feed trough. Behind the stacks of sweet hay.
I am no good at any of it. I am an animal doctor. I know what to do with a body. I do not know what to do with an absence.
At five o’clock Tori finds me on the barn steps.
She has come in a rush, still in her pajama pants, with her teal hair standing up and a thermos in each fist, and she sits down beside me without a word and pours coffee into the lid and holds it under my nose. I drink it. It is bitter and hot. She watches me do it with the tragic, faithful eyes of a very young person who has been told to be strong.
“Respectfully,” she says, “I want to tell you something. And I want you not to be mad.”
“I’m not mad.”
“I saw the truck again.”
I put the cup down.
“Tuesday. Behind the clinic, around six. I told you it was a dark crew cab, and I couldn’t remember anything else. I couldn’t, I swear. But I lay in bed tonight and it kept coming up, like a bad penny, and I finally got it.” She grips the thermos. “It had a decal on the driver’s door. White. A little snowflake. With an H in the middle.”
“A snowflake.”
“I thought of Christmas.” She makes a face. “It looked like a snowflake made out of a letter. And I was thinking about my mom, and whether she’d put up lights this year, and that’s why I didn’t remember. But I remember now.” She swallows. “It’s on the trucks that haul for the plant in Laurel. Halvorsen.”
For some time I do not say anything.
I think of a term sheet, and a block of gray type. A parent entity in a font that nobody was supposed to read to the end. I think of a man in a beige overcoat setting a bag of kibble on a counter and straightening it, gently, to face the room.
“Tori,” I say. “I need you to do something for me. It might be dangerous.”
“Respectfully, no,” she says at once. “But I’ll do it.”
I carry the cooler out of the truck myself. It has been in the cab since Wednesday, a plain blue Igloo with a lid taped down in three places, and I have written on the tape every hour since.
Inside, in layers of paper towel and ice packs, are all the things I have that matter. Three jars of coffee beans. Two tubes of Cole’s blood. Three of Pickle’s, in labeled sleeves. A tube marked G.B., in block capitals, in a hand that is not mine. The retriever bag, sealed in plastic and signed twice.
I put a manila envelope on top of them, and in it a form, and I sign it, and I sign across the flap.
“Rimrock Diagnostic,” I say. “The lab on Zimmerman Street, in Billings. It’s a university lab. It’s independent. It has a director named Dr. Anselm, and he does not answer to anyone, and he has no cloud, and no vendor. You hand it to him. In his hand. Not his assistant. Him.”
“Boss.”
“You tell him it’s a chain of custody and he is to sign every line.”
“Boss, what’s in here?”
“Everything,” I say. “Don’t open it. Don’t stop for gas. Don’t take a phone call unless it’s me.” I put both of my hands on her shoulders. “If anybody tries to take it, you give it to the sheriff.”
“What about the hearing?”
“I’ll be there.”
“What if you’re not—”
“Tori.”
She looks at me. She is twenty-four. Her eyes are very wet.
“Go,” I say.
She goes.
The bank calls at ten after six.
I know the number. I let it ring, and then I answer it, because when you are in a hole you do not pretend there is no sky. It is Mr. Treadwell of Pronghorn Valley Savings, the loan officer, a soft-voiced, apologetic man whom I have known since the sixth grade, and who has never in his life enjoyed a sentence.
“Josie. I wanted you to hear this from me.”
“All right.”
“We’ve received a letter. From a law firm in Billings, regarding a pending petition. It alleges material misconduct by the borrower. Diversion of controlled substances.” A paper rustles. “Under the terms of the note, I’m afraid this is an event of default.”
“The sale isn’t until January second.”
“It was January second. I’m very sorry. The bank has accelerated.” A pause. “It will be advertised in the Courier on Monday. The sale is December fifth.”
I stand in the gray yard with the phone against my ear and the wind in my face, and I look at the cottonwoods. I do not say anything. I do not count.
“Josie? Are you there?”
“I’m here.”
“I wanted to tell you,” says Mr. Treadwell, in a very small voice, “that I think it’s a terrible thing.”
“Thank you.”
“I wanted you to know I said so.”
“Thank you, Mr. Treadwell.”
I hang up. I put the phone in my coat. It is the one hour of the day when the sky is the color of a pearl, and I stand in it, and I do not cry, because it is a thing I have not done since I was sixteen and I am afraid that if I start I will be unable to stop.
The Pronghorn County courthouse was built in 1911 of yellow brick, with a copper dome and a clock tower that has said ten after four since before I was born. It has a single courtroom, on the second floor, with a long oak bench, a flag, a scarred table for each side, and a smell of floor wax and wet wool.
I sit at the left-hand table, alone, in my funeral dress.
I have no lawyer. I tried. I called three, from the truck, between the ranch and town, and each of them was kind and busy and had a conflict with the Brandts. I can see Dub in the front row, with his folio in his lap and a fixed, terrible expression. He cannot speak for me. He is the trustee.
On the right, at the second table, in a perfect charcoal suit, sits Margit Voss with a silver pen in her hand. Beside her is a man with a beautiful haircut named Preston Hale, who has not stopped smiling since he sat down. Behind them, in the first row, is Dennis Pell, in beige. And at the end of the row, on the aisle, with his hands flat on his knees and his face as blank as a wall, is Cole.
“All rise,” says the bailiff.
Judge Florence Hatch is seventy-one, and about the size of a hymnal. She has white hair cut like a helmet, and half-glasses on a chain, and a face with a good deal of weather in it. She sits, and arranges her papers, and says, “Be seated,” and looks at me over the glasses for a long, long moment.
“Dr. Marrow. You are unrepresented.”
“Yes, Your Honor.”
“Do you wish a continuance to obtain counsel?”
“I’d like to proceed, Your Honor. I can’t afford the time.”
“No,” says Judge Hatch dryly, “I don’t imagine you can. Mr. Hale.”
Preston Hale stands. He is very good. I want to hate him, and I cannot, because he is exactly as good as the best large-animal vet I ever worked under, and has the same trick of making a horror sound like a procedure. He lays out, in six minutes, the whole of the case. The dog, the will, the penalty clause. The inventory, signed by the guardian on the thirty-first, stating four vials, and the sheriff’s count of three. The break-in. The note.
“And, Your Honor,” he says, softly, “the animal is missing.”
There is a ripple in the room.
“Missing.”
“Since approximately nine o’clock last night. From the guardian’s residence, in her sole care. A thirteen-year-old animal with a serious medical condition, who was, according to the clinic’s own records, treated for a life-threatening collapse as recently as Wednesday.” He turns, courteously, to me. “The Foundation does not suggest the guardian intended harm. It suggests only that she is a young woman under tremendous strain, who has lost control of the single most valuable living creature in the state of Montana. The trust requires better.”
“Dr. Marrow,” says the judge. “Where is the animal?”
I stand.
I have rehearsed an answer. I have rehearsed it all night on the road, in the cattails, in the dark. It is a good answer, with clauses, and a tone.
“I don’t know, Your Honor,” I say.
The silence in that courtroom is a thing I will remember. It is the silence of a roomful of people, all of whom have met a dog.
“I see,” says Judge Hatch.
“I’m looking for him. The sheriff is looking. I believe he is alive.”
“On what basis?”
I think of a note, in block capitals, under a clementine.
“I believe he was taken by someone who wanted him alive,” I say. “For the moment.”
“That is not a basis, Dr. Marrow. That is a hope.”
“Yes, Your Honor.”
Hale lifts a hand. “The Foundation calls Mr. Colton Brandt.”
I turn my head.
It takes me a moment to understand what I have heard. Cole stands. He walks down the aisle, past me, with that long even stride, and he does not look at me. He takes the oath with his right hand raised and the left hanging at his side, and I see the white band on his wrist where the watch used to be.
“Mr. Brandt,” says Hale, “you are the son of the decedent.”
“Yes.”
“You live at Cold Spring Ranch.”
“I do.”
“And Dr. Marrow resides there under the terms of the will.”
“She does.”
“Mr. Brandt. In your opinion, as a member of the household, is Dr. Marrow fit to be the guardian of your father’s dog?”
I look at the table. I look at the grain of the oak, and I see a knot like an eye.
“No,” says Cole.
His voice is level, ironed flat, with nothing left in it that I can use.
“She has lost the dog,” he says. “She has signed a false inventory. She was not, as I told the sheriff, in the library with me on Tuesday evening. I was mistaken.” He pauses. “I lied, to protect her. I should not have.”
A sound goes through the room, a wave.
“She has been under great pressure, and she is, I believe, a good veterinarian,” he says. “But I think the dog is safer in another home. I think it is time the Foundation took the animal. I think my father’s estate would be better served.”
I do not hear the rest.
I hear, from a very great distance, Hale thanking him. I hear the judge asking me if I have any questions for the witness. I stand, because the body does what it has been taught. I hear myself say, “No, Your Honor,” in a voice like a cracked plate.
He does not look at me. He walks back up the aisle with his hands at his sides, and sits. He puts his palms on his knees. Margit, in the front row, turns her head a quarter inch, and gives him, with perfect elegance, a smile.
“I will not remove the guardian today,” says Judge Hatch.
I look up.
“The record is thin and the Foundation’s own counsel has not pressed for interim relief.” She peers over her glasses at Hale. “Have you, Mr. Hale?”
Hale has gone slightly pale. A very small, careful exchange passes between him and Pell.
“The Foundation will defer interim relief,” says Hale, “pending the animal’s production.”
“So noted.” She taps her gavel, a small dry tick. “Monday morning, nine o’clock. Dr. Marrow, you will produce Pickle to a veterinarian of this court’s choosing, in this room, alive and well. If you do not, I will grant the petition without further argument. Do I make myself clear?”
“Yes, Your Honor.”
“Good. We are adjourned.”
I do not remember leaving the room. I remember a door and a stairwell, a back one, a concrete shaft that smells of cold and old paint, and my hand on a metal rail. I remember that I am walking down, step after step, and my legs are working, and I do not know where I am going. I stop on the landing between the first and second floors. I lean against the wall and put my forehead on the concrete.
Footsteps.
I know them. They come down from above, not hurrying, and stop on the stair behind me.
“Josie.”
“Don’t.”
“I need to explain.”
“No.” I do not turn. “You stood in front of a judge and said I lied. You said it in front of the Foundation, in front of Dennis Pell, in front of the county. You said I was unfit.”
“I needed Pell to think I had given up.”
“Well, it worked.”
“He wants the sale done by Saturday noon.” His voice is very low and very rapid. “I told him last night I would sign. I told him I was finished fighting. I told him I would give testimony if the Foundation held off asking for the interim order until Monday, so that nobody could say a girl with a missing dog had been railroaded.
“Dennis wanted my testimony on the record more than he wanted a fast order. He thinks a removal that looks gentle is a removal that sticks. He agreed. That’s all of it. I got you until Monday. I got us a window.”
“A window.”
“I couldn’t tell you. You’d have had to act it. And you’re the worst liar I’ve ever met.”
I turn around.
He is two steps above me, with one hand on the rail. He is gray. His hand is shaking, I can see it, a fine hard shiver, like a leaf in a draft. His eyes are on my face, and the thing in them is so open, so unprotected, so entirely a plea for me to understand, that I want, I want so much, to do it.
I can’t.
It is a failure of something in me, some small broken part. I am thirty years old and I have been alone with every disaster of my life, and I have only just begun to let a man hold my hand at a pond, and he has taken it, and put it in a courtroom, and let it be broken.
“You sold a watch for the dog,” I say, “and a woman for the company. For the same price.”
He does not flinch. That is the worst of it. He stands there on the stair with his hand on the rail, and he takes it, entirely, the way he took the foreman in the barn at twenty-four, and the old man at Christmas for ten years, with his face perfectly still and perfectly polite.
“Noted,” he says.
I walk down the rest of the stairs.
I sit on the courthouse steps. It is the middle of the morning and the street is empty. It is a broad dusty street in a town of eleven hundred people, with a feed store at one end and a diner at the other, and a stoplight that blinks yellow, and not one car. A pigeon walks along the curb. High over my head, in the copper tower, the clock says ten past four.
I do not know how long I stay there.
I go to the clinic, because I do not know where else.
It is quiet and cold. The plywood is still on the back door. The stuffed raccoon watches me from the monitor in his tiny stethoscope. I go into the lab and sit on the stool in front of the dead machine and put my hands in my lap.
The capsule is in my pocket. It has been there for thirty-six days.
I take it out. I do not know why. I sit there in the cold light and turn it over in my hand, the little steel tube, no longer than my thumb, with the cap at one end and the ring at the other. I rub my thumb across the ring like a worry stone. Over and over, the way you do. Round and round.
It turns.
I stop.
I do it again, slowly. The ring, the small steel loop where the collar goes through, is not a ring at all. It is a cap. It has a thread so fine that it is invisible, and a quarter turn of play, and I am holding in my hand an object I have carried for a month without understanding that it has two ends.
My heart is going. I do not count it.
I unscrew the ring, and a second, smaller compartment opens, no wider than a pencil. Inside, tightly folded, is a sheet of onionskin paper.
I spread it on the counter with fingers that have gone stupid.
It is a map. It is drawn in black ink in a shaky, careful, beloved hand, and I know the shapes at once, the long line of cottonwoods, the pond, the horseshoe of the house and outbuildings. It is Cold Spring Ranch, from above. And all over it, on the pasture and the creek and the roads, in the corners of the old fields, are small neat X marks.
I count them. It takes a minute.
Fifty-two.
One for every Sunday of a year. A year of walks, set down on paper by a man who knew he would not finish them.
And on one of them, a little north of the main house, near a small square marked in the old man’s block capitals as BUNKHSE, a single X has been circled twice in red. Beside it, in the neat, wavering hand, one word.
HOME.

