Priya answered on the first ring.
"Sadie?" Her voice cracked straight down the middle. "Oh my God. Oh my God, you're okay. Are you okay? Say something."
"I'm okay." I was standing on the back porch in my socks, shaking. "Priya, I don't remember anything. I went live at 11:58, I read the ad, and I woke up in my bed. That's it. That's all I have."
There was a long silence on the line.
"Then I need you to sit down," Priya said. "Because I remember all of it."
I sat down on the cold porch steps.
"At midnight, the feed glitched," she said. "Every camera froze for about one second. Then it came back, and you were just sitting there at the table. And then you said, 'Oh.' Just like that. Like someone had tapped you on the shoulder. And you started to smile." Her voice wobbled. "You looked straight into the camera and you said, 'Priya, I remember. I remember everything.' And then you muted the mic."
"I remember what?"
"You didn't say. You just sat there writing in a notebook for hours. Pages and pages. Sometimes you cried. Sometimes you laughed." She took a shaky breath. "At 6:40 in the morning, the trail cam on the dock picked up movement."
I closed my eyes. "Tell me."
"People, Sadie. Walking up out of the lake. Dozens of them. They just came up out of the water, like they were climbing stairs, and they walked up the beach toward the houses. They were soaked, but they weren't in a hurry. They looked calm. Happy, even." Her voice dropped to a whisper. "And all the doors in town opened. People came running out in their bathrobes, down to the beach. They were hugging them. Crying. An old man carried a little girl up the beach on his shoulders like it was the Fourth of July."
My hands were so cold I could barely feel the phone.
"At 7:30," she went on, "the back door of your kitchen opened. And a guy walked in. Young. Tall. Wet hair. Varsity jacket."
I couldn't breathe.
"Your mom dropped a frying pan. And you just launched yourself at him. You hung on him like you were drowning." Priya's voice broke completely. "Sadie, I've seen the photos on your wall. It was Danny. And behind him there was another man. Older. Gray at the temples. Same eyes as you."
I pressed my fist against my mouth.
My father died when I was nine. A summer squall came up out of nowhere while he was fishing alone. They found his boat upside down two miles out. They never found him.
The lake, everyone said, never gives back what it takes.
"At 7:41," Priya said, "a hand reached into the frame of the kitchen camera. An older woman's hand, with a silver ring. And the feeds started going dark. One at a time. All eleven. Like someone was walking through the house collecting them."
"The server," I said. "You recorded everything. It's on the server."
"That's the thing." She made a sound that was almost a laugh, almost a sob. "Every file is there. Seven hours and forty-one minutes, all eleven feeds. But when I play them, every single one is just the lake. At night. Black water. No sound. Nothing else."
The wind moved through the pines. Down the street, someone's screen door banged.
"Then at 11:51 last night, you called me," Priya said. "From your cell. You were laughing and crying at the same time. You said, 'Priya, I'm with Danny, and I'm okay, and I need you to promise you won't let me forget.' I could hear water. Waves. You said, 'Danny's holding my hand. We're walking down to the water now.' And then the call dropped."
I looked down at my left wrist.
There was a faint bruise there. Four slender marks on one side, one on the other. The shape of fingers. When I touched it, it was cold. Not cool. Cold, like the skin had been under ice.
By the back door, my hiking boots sat on the mat. They were soaked to the laces. A small puddle of lake water had spread out underneath them, and in it, a few grains of dark sand.
"Sadie?" Priya said. "Are you still there?"
"I have to go," I whispered. "I have to check something."
Hide one where we used to hide stuff.
When Danny was ten and I was seven, he discovered that the third step of our front porch was loose. If you pried up the board with a butter knife, there was a hollow space underneath, dry and dark, about the size of a shoebox. We called it the Vault. We hid candy there, and comic books, and once, a garter snake, which my mother found and did not appreciate.
I hadn't thought about the Vault in fifteen years.
Inside, my mother was still humming at the stove. I took a butter knife from the drawer, walked out the front door and knelt down on the porch.
The third board came up easily. Like it had been lifted recently.
Inside the hollow was a plastic sandwich bag. And inside the bag was a single black memory card and a folded piece of notebook paper.
I knew the handwriting before I unfolded it. I'd know it anywhere. It was mine.
WATCH ALONE. DON'T SHOW MOM. IF YOU FIND A SECOND CARD, DON'T WATCH IT UNTIL YOU'VE WATCHED THIS ONE ALL THE WAY THROUGH. —S. (YOU.)
I drove to the end of Larch Street, where the road runs out at a gravel turnaround above the lake. I parked facing the water. I locked the doors. I put the card in my laptop with hands that wouldn't stop shaking.
There was one video file. It was nine hours long.
I pressed play.
The screen was dark at first. Then a phone flashlight clicked on, and there was a face, lit from below, crammed into what I slowly recognized as the closet of my childhood bedroom. Coats behind her. My old softball bag.
It was me.
Not me now. Me on the 19th. My face was blotchy from crying, and my eyes were huge and bright and wild, and I had never in my life seen myself look so happy and so terrified at the same time.
"Hi," she whispered. "It's me. You. It's 3:12 a.m. on the nineteenth. Mom's asleep. Everybody's asleep, waiting for morning." A shaky laugh. "You're not going to remember this. That's okay. That's why I'm recording it."
She wiped her nose on her sleeve.
"At midnight, I remembered. Not just today. All of them. Every nineteenth I ever lived in this town. It all came back at once, like a dam breaking." She pressed her hand flat against her chest. "Dad comes home on the nineteenth, Sadie. Every year since we were kids. He walks up out of the lake at dawn and comes in the back door and makes pancakes, and he burns them, every single time. I sat on his lap at breakfast. I remember. I remember all of it."
I was crying so hard I could barely see the screen.
"And I remember twelve years ago," she whispered. "The last nineteenth I was ever here. I remember the beach. I remember following him. I remember how cold it was."
On the screen, my own face crumpled.
"There's something everybody in this town knows today, and nobody will know tomorrow. And you need to hear it from me, because nobody else is ever going to tell you."
She leaned toward the camera until her face filled the whole frame.
"Danny didn't drown twelve years ago, Sadie," she said. "I did."

