Priya pulled into my mother's driveway at nine that night in a rusted hatchback with a cracked windshield and every piece of audio equipment we owned piled in the back seat.
She'd quit her job at the call center somewhere around Eau Claire. She told me this while hugging me so hard my ribs creaked.
"I heard you walk into a lake," she said into my shoulder. "On the phone. I'm not doing this from three hundred miles away anymore."
My mother was asleep. Moose lay across the back door like a furry sandbag. Priya and I sat at the kitchen table under the lamp, with a laptop between us and my brother's envelope on top of the laptop.
THE LAST HOUR. For Sades.
"You don't have to watch it tonight," Priya said.
"Yes, I do."
I put in the card and pressed play.
The timestamp in the corner read 11:00 p.m., October 19th.
The camera was pinned to my jacket. It looked out over the public beach at night. Behind it, every window in Merrow glowed with a lamp. In front of it, the black lake stretched away under a sky full of stars.
And the whole town was on the beach.
Hundreds of people, carrying lanterns. The living and the drowned, walking together toward the water. Nobody was rushing. Some were laughing softly. Most were crying. Families held hands in long chains. An old man walked his wife to the waterline and kissed her and stood back, and she walked into the water without looking back.
At the edge of the shore, under a lantern, sat a small folding card table. Augusta Pell sat behind it with the green leather ledger open in front of her and a fountain pen in her hand. Her son Michael stood beside her with his hand on her shoulder.
"The Observance," Priya whispered.
On the screen, my father turned to my mother at the waterline. He held her face in both hands.
"Next year, Jo," he said.
"Next year," my mother whispered. "Burn the pancakes."
He laughed and kissed her forehead and walked into Merrow Lake. The water rose around him, up to his knees, his waist, his shoulders. Then he was gone, and the surface closed over him without a single ripple.
My mother stood on the beach with her arms wrapped around herself. Then a neighbor took her elbow and led her gently away.
And then it was just me and Danny.
He held my hand. I could see our hands in the bottom of the frame, his fingers pale and wet, mine gripping hard. We walked toward the water.
At 11:51, I heard my own voice, high and breathless, on the phone. Priya, I'm with Danny, and I'm okay, and I need you to promise you won't let me forget.
Beside me, at the kitchen table, Priya put her hand over her mouth.
11:52. The camera dipped as my boots hit the water. I heard my own sharp gasp at the cold.
"You don't have to do this, Sades," Danny said quietly.
"You gave me twelve years," past-me said. Her voice was steady. "It's my turn to give them back. You should get to come home. You should get to have a life."
"That's not how it works."
"Then how does it work?"
The water was at my knees. My thighs. On the screen, the lake looked like black oil.
Then, faint and far away, a dog barking. Frantic. Furious.
And footsteps, pounding down the sand behind us.
"Sadie! Sadie, stop!"
The camera whipped around. Theo Lindgren came charging down the beach in his flannel jacket, no lantern, his face wild. He crashed into the water, grabbed me around the waist and hauled me backward into the shallows so hard we both nearly went down.
"Not her," he gasped. He was looking past me, at the lake, at Danny. "Not her. Take me."
"Theo," Danny said. "No."
"Twelve years, man." Theo's voice broke. "Every nineteenth, I remember. I remember you walking in there for her. I remember standing on this beach doing nothing. And every twentieth, I forget, and I wake up hating myself, and I don't even know why." He turned to the card table. "Mrs. Pell. It can be anyone, right? Anyone who goes willing?"
Augusta's face was white. "Only if the debtor writes the name," she said. "Only the debtor's own hand."
Theo turned to me. He put his big, rough hands on either side of my face.
"Write it," he said.
"No." Past-me was sobbing. "No, Theo, no, no—"
"You have a show, Sadie. You have two hundred families waiting for you to find their people. I've got a bait shop and a dog." He smiled. It was the gentlest smile I'd ever seen. "Write it."
He let go of me and walked backward into the lake.
"Theo!" I screamed on the recording. I lunged after him and Danny caught my arm. I knew those fingers now. I could feel the cold bruise they'd left on my wrist, throbbing at the kitchen table.
"Sades. Listen to me." Danny's voice was low and fast. "If no name is written by midnight, the lake chooses. It'll take him and you both. And it'll still be hungry."
11:56. Theo was up to his chest. The black water lapped at his beard.
"Tell Moose he's a good boy," he called.
Then he went under.
On the kitchen floor, Moose lifted his head and whined, a long, low, broken sound.
11:57. The camera showed the card table. Past-me's hands, shaking violently, snatching the fountain pen from Augusta. Writing. Pressing so hard the nib tore the paper.
11:57 p.m. Kept: Theodore Lindgren, in place of Sadie Kerrigan.
Danny pressed something into my hand. A white envelope.
"The card," he said. "Put it in here. Leave it in Theo's truck. It's the only place you'll come looking tomorrow."
11:58. He kissed my forehead.
"Love you, Sades," he said. "Don't come back next year."
And my brother walked into Merrow Lake, and the lake closed over him like a door.
For a few seconds, the camera just showed the water. Black. Flat. Silent. Augusta's lantern flickering at the edge of the frame.
Then a voice came out of the lake.
It was close. Impossibly close. As if someone were floating just under the surface, right in front of the camera, whispering up through the water.
"Sadie," Theo's voice said. "It's so cold. Come get me."
The video ended at 11:59 and 48 seconds.
Priya and I sat frozen at the kitchen table. Neither of us breathed. The refrigerator hummed. Somewhere in the house, a clock ticked.
Then Moose scrambled to his feet.
His ears went up. His whole body went rigid, staring at the table. At my phone, lying face-down beside the laptop.
A second later, it lit up and began to ring.
I turned it over.
The caller ID read: THEO LINDGREN.
Priya grabbed my arm. "Don't," she whispered.
I answered it.
At first, there was only sound. A deep, slow, churning rush, like standing inside a waterfall. Like the inside of a seashell, magnified a thousand times. Like being very, very deep underwater.
And then, faint and cracked and unmistakable, a voice I'd just watched disappear.
"Sadie? Can you hear me? I'm still here."

