Hanneke Gilchrist had said time of death out loud four hundred and some times, and every one of them had been a small lie.
The heart does not announce itself. It slows, it stutters, it quits, and sometime afterward a person in a uniform decides the quitting is permanent and says a number so that a form can be filled in. The number is the minute somebody said it. It is never quite the minute it happened. Hanneke had made her peace with that around her second year on the ambulance, and she had never once said so to a family.
This one was a kitchen on the east side of the county, a little after six in the morning. A retired machinist in his undershirt lay on the linoleum with his eyes half open, and his wife stood against the refrigerator with both hands pressed flat on her own chest as if she were holding something in.
Mallory Fogarty had been working the chest for nineteen minutes. She stopped when Hanneke touched her shoulder. Hanneke checked the monitor, checked the man, put two fingers to his neck anyway, and waited the full thirty seconds that nobody ever believes is necessary.
“Time of death,” she said, “oh-six-fifty-one.”
Mallory wrote it on the glove box lid with a marker. The wife did not move.
“Is that exactly when?” she asked. Her voice was perfectly polite. “He was very particular about time. He’d want to know.”
Hanneke had a few answers for that question. She had never decided which of them was kindest. “That’s when I said it,” she told her. “He went a little before. I’m so sorry.”
The wife nodded as though that were a reasonable correction to a bill. Then she went and turned off the stove burner under a pot nobody had looked at, and the small click of the knob was the loudest sound in the house.
By the time they had cleared the call it was past eight and the shift was over. Hanneke sat in the station lot with the engine off and her thumb on her own wrist, counting, which was a habit she had stopped noticing years ago. Sixty-four. Fine. She had three voicemails.
The first was from her mother’s assisted-living facility, a cheerful recorded reminder that the monthly statement was ready. The second was a dentist. The third was a woman with a low, unhurried voice who gave her name as Rosalind Hagen, attorney at law, calling from Lindell Ferry, Pennsylvania, regarding the estate of Selwyn Gilchrist.
Hanneke played it twice. Then she looked at the dashboard clock, which said 8:16, and at her watch, which said 8:16, and felt briefly and unreasonably grateful that they agreed.
She had not known he was dead. She had not, if she was honest, thought about him in about twenty-seven years. He was her late grandfather’s brother, an old man in a house on a hill, a name on a Christmas card that stopped coming when her father died.
She had been to the house once, when she was seven. She remembered a very long staircase, a smell of lemon oil, and a ticking in the walls that nobody could find. She remembered her mother driving home in the dark in January with every window down.
The reading was Thursday at two. Ms. Hagen said it was in Hanneke’s interest to attend in person. She said it in the voice of a woman who had said the same sentence to the heirs of a great many people and had learned that it worked better without explanation.
Lindell Ferry came up out of the hills all at once, the way river towns do, a long slant of brick and clapboard down to the water with a bridge at the bottom and a steeple halfway up. Hanneke came into it at ten to two with her back aching from four hours of driving and her good black jacket on over a sweater, because she owned exactly one jacket for occasions like this and had worn it to every one.
A clock tower stood on the town hall at the top of Water Street. It was a big old square thing with a face on each side, white dials, black hands, a copper roof gone green. She noticed it the way anyone notices a clock, to check. Ten to two. Her watch said ten to two. She noticed that she had noticed, and kept driving.
Hagen & Hagen occupied the two rooms over a hardware store. Rosalind Hagen turned out to be a tall woman with silver hair cut to the jaw, reading glasses on a chain, and the particular stillness of someone paid to wait. She shook Hanneke’s hand and said, “You have his chin.”
“I’ve been told I have my father’s.”
“Same chin,” said Ms. Hagen. “Sit anywhere.”
There were two other people in the room. One was an old woman in a navy coat and a hat that had been good in its day, sitting very straight in the chair nearest the window with her handbag on her knees. The other was a man in his mid-forties in a gray suit that fit him, with a pleasant tired face and hair going silver at the temples, who stood when Hanneke came in and held out his hand.
“Marcel Gilchrist,” he said. “We’ve never met. I’m your father’s cousin, which makes us something, I’ve never worked out what. I’m glad you came.”
“Hanneke.”
“I know. I’ve seen your name on a page I’d rather not have been reading.” He smiled, and it was a good smile, and it did not reach very far. “Uncle Selwyn was my great-uncle too, so we’re in the same boat. Sorry. I’m a lawyer. I do boat metaphors when I’m nervous.”
“You’re a lawyer,” Hanneke said, “and you’re not handling the estate.”
Marcel’s smile held. Ms. Hagen, behind her desk, made a very small sound that might have been a cough.
“Selwyn asked for an independent executor,” Marcel said. “It was sensible of him. I’d have done the same.”
The old woman in the navy coat did not say anything. When Hanneke looked at her, she looked back with a pair of pale, steady eyes and then, deliberately, down at her watch.
“Mrs. Eames kept house for him for thirty years,” Ms. Hagen said. “She’s named.”
“Aveline,” the old woman said. “Nobody calls me Mrs.”
So the reading began.
It did not take long. Selwyn Gilchrist’s will was a single page of plain sentences that made Hanneke think of a man who had spent his life repairing things that other people had overcomplicated.
There was a bequest to Mrs. Eames, which made her close her eyes for a moment and open them again. There was a bequest to the town for the upkeep of the tower clock. The residue of the cash estate, which Ms. Hagen mentioned without inflection, went to a family trust of which Marcel Gilchrist was trustee. And the house, with all its contents and the land around it, went to Hanneke.
“Subject to a condition,” said Ms. Hagen, and took off her glasses.
Hanneke had been waiting for it. Nobody gets given a house.
“The beneficiary must reside in the house for thirty nights, not necessarily consecutive, within one year of this date. During that time she shall keep the clocks as she finds them. She shall not wind them, adjust them, repair them, or permit them to be touched by any person except Aveline Eames for the purposes of dusting. If these conditions are met the property is hers outright. If they are not met, it passes to the trust.”
Nobody in the room said anything.
“It’s not unusual,” Marcel said. “Old houses, old collections. He was proud of them.”
“Thirty nights,” Hanneke said. “And I can’t touch a clock.”
“Not in a way that changes it, no.”
“How many clocks are there?”
It was Mrs. Eames who answered, in a voice like a drawer closing. “Thirty-four.”
Hanneke looked at the number of dollars that Ms. Hagen had written on a small card and turned face up on the desk. It was the appraised value of the house and land, and it was the first thing anyone had said all afternoon that she understood immediately.
She did the other arithmetic without wanting to. Her mother’s facility was six thousand one hundred a month. Her mother had two replaced hips and a pension that covered a third of that. For nineteen months Hanneke had been making up the rest with overtime and a credit card she did not discuss.
“If I sell it afterward?”
“Then it’s yours to sell,” Ms. Hagen said.
“I would buy it,” said Marcel quietly. “At the full figure. I’m only saying so you know you wouldn’t be stuck. I’d rather it stayed with the family. But I’d rather you weren’t stuck more.”
It was a generous thing to say and he said it kindly, and Hanneke trusted it exactly as far as she trusted anything said to her on a day when somebody was handing her a house. She thanked him. She signed where Ms. Hagen put a flag. Mrs. Eames got up, buttoned her navy coat to the throat, and said, “I’ve the kettle on at the house, Miss Gilchrist. When you’re ready.”
“Hanneke.”
“When you’re ready,” Mrs. Eames said again, and went out.
Gilchrist House stood on the bluff above Water Street at the end of a gravel drive that curled up through bare maples. It was a tall house, three storeys of weathered gray clapboard and old fieldstone, with a pitched slate roof and a square stair tower at one corner, the tower window lit amber although it was daylight.
She parked behind a small green sedan she took for Mrs. Eames’s. For a moment she sat with her hands on the wheel, looking up at the lit window, and thought the thing she always thought arriving at a scene: what is the problem, and who has it.
Then she went in, and the house began.
The front hall was wide and dim, floored in dark boards worn pale along the middle. There was a smell of lemon oil and old wool and, underneath, cold stone. A grandfather clock stood against the wall opposite the door. It was eight feet of dark walnut with a brass face, a moon dial in the arch, and a pendulum hanging behind the glass like a held note. The hands said ten to twelve.
It was not ten to twelve. She looked at her watch to be sure.
“It stopped when Mr. Abram’s granddaughter went,” said Mrs. Eames, coming out of the passage that ran back toward the kitchen. She had taken off the hat. Her gray hair was pinned in a coil. She was perhaps five foot two and walked as if the floor belonged to her. “Before my time. You’ll want your bag brought in.”
“I can get it.”
“Then I’ll show you round.”
It was a tour no one should have wanted to give.
In the library a tall case clock with a painted ship rocking on its dial stood stopped at twenty past three. On the stair landing a bracket clock stood stopped at nine minutes to nine. There was a carriage clock on a bedroom dresser stopped at a quarter to two, a school clock over a door, a cuckoo in a sitting room with its tiny shutters closed, an iron-faced thing in the pantry.
Each one stood dead still. Not a single pendulum swung. Not one of them showed the right time, and not one of them, Hanneke noticed, had so much as a film of dust on its glass.
“You dust them,” she said.
“I am allowed to.”
“All thirty-four.”
“Thirty-three,” said Mrs. Eames. “There was thirty-three, till last month. Then Mr. Gilchrist.”
She said the name with no change of voice at all, and went on up the stairs.
By the third floor Hanneke had stopped trying to find a pattern in the clocks and had started, without deciding to, to do what she did at a scene. Count the exits. Note the temperature. Watch the one person in the room who knows what happened and is deciding how much of it to say. The house was cool, not cold. The air was still. The floors did not creak where she expected them to creak.
And there was no sound at all, which she realized only on the second floor landing, because she had been braced for ticking.
She had been braced for ticking since she was seven.
“We’ve had them stopped a long time,” she said.
“Some of them a hundred and fifty years.”
“Why?”
Mrs. Eames paused with one hand on the newel post. “It’s ten of three,” she said. “We’ll have our tea.”
Hanneke let it go. She would learn that this was how Aveline Eames answered any question she was not ready for: she told you the time. At the moment, it was only an odd little habit in an old woman, and Hanneke filed it with the rest.
The last room on the tour was the study.
It was on the ground floor at the back of the house, a square room lined with shelves, with a desk, a high-backed leather chair, a reading lamp and a window that gave onto the sloping back garden and the dark line of the hill beyond.
A longcase clock stood against the wall to the left of the desk. It was a plain, handsome piece in mahogany gone nearly black, taller than a man, with a silvered dial and a pendulum bob the size of a saucer.
The hands said twelve minutes past four.
“Here,” said Mrs. Eames. She did not come in. She stood in the doorway with her hands folded in front of her. “That’s his. He was in the chair when I found him.”
Hanneke stepped in. She did not touch anything. She looked at the chair, and the carpet in front of it, and the angle of the lamp. She looked at the clock face. Then, because Ms. Hagen had put an envelope into her hand at the end of the reading and she had been carrying it all afternoon like something hot, she took it from her jacket and slid out the certified copy of the death certificate.
She read it standing up. It was the sort of document she had read a thousand times from the other side. Name, age, date, place. Cause of death: cardiac arrest due to atherosclerotic heart disease. Manner: natural. Pronounced by Abel Ottway, M.D., county coroner. And under it the line that mattered to her: Date and time of death, approximate. 9:40 a.m.
“Mrs. Eames. When did you find him?”
“Ten past eight.”
“And you called?”
“I called Mr. Marcel. He rang Dr. Ottway.”
“Before an ambulance.”
“He was gone,” said Mrs. Eames. “Any fool could see.”
“Any fool could,” Hanneke agreed. “But that’s not the order you do it in, as a rule.” She said it gently. “The certificate says nine-forty. The clock says four-twelve. If you found him at ten past eight, and Dr. Ottway got here an hour and a half later, then nine-forty is when the doctor was in the room. It’s when he wrote it down. That isn’t when Mr. Gilchrist died.”
“No,” said Mrs. Eames.
“And the clock is right?”
The old woman did not answer. That was an answer.
Hanneke turned back to the chair. She was not being clever. She was being what she was, which was a person who had spent eleven years learning to look at a body and say what time it had stopped. She asked what was in the file because it was the question a stranger would not ask, and she asked it because she wanted something concrete to hold. Not a ghost story. A discrepancy. A discrepancy was a problem, and problems had causes.
“When did you last see him alive?”
“Sunday night, nine o’clock. I do his tray and go home. I live on Mill Street.”
“And you got here Monday at.”
“Half past six. I always am.”
“Then you were in the house from six-thirty on.”
“I was upstairs,” Mrs. Eames said. “Mr. Gilchrist liked the kitchen to himself at seven.”
“Every day.”
“Every day for forty-one years.”
“Why?”
The old woman looked at the clock. It was a long look, and for the first time since Hanneke had met her there was something in her face that she was not managing.
“It was his hour,” she said.
Hanneke waited. It was another of the things she had learned; people will fill a silence if you let it get long enough to be rude.
“At seven I was in the linen room,” said Mrs. Eames. “Over the kitchen. I heard the kettle go on. I heard his slippers on the stone, and the back door, and the bottles. And I called down, the way I do. I said, Good morning, Mr. Gilchrist.”
“Did he answer?”
“Somebody did.”
The house was entirely quiet. Out in the garden a single dead leaf let go of a maple and came down on the grass without any sound at all.
“Dr. Ottway’s certificate puts him at nine-forty,” Hanneke said carefully. “The clock puts him at four-twelve. You say he was making tea at seven. All three can’t be true.”
“No,” said Mrs. Eames. “They can’t.”
“Then who answered you?”
“Not him.” The old woman’s hands came apart and folded again, tighter. “It wasn’t his voice at all.” She looked at the dead clock on the wall, and her own face was as steady as the dial. “It was a woman’s.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!