Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 3

What the Coroner Signed

Mrs. Eames came in by the back door with her coat still buttoned and stopped just inside it. She looked at the table. She looked at the two cups, the toast, the cold coffee, the kettle on the range. She looked at Hanneke, standing with a sheet of cream paper in her hand, and her face did not change at all.

“It’s ten past eight,” she said.

“It’s eight-oh-six. Sit down, please.”

“I’ll not.”

“Then read this.”

Mrs. Eames took the note. She held it at arm’s length, the way people do who will not admit to needing glasses, and read it once. She did not read it a second time. She folded it along the crease it already had and set it down very gently on the table, beside the toast, as if it might spill.

“Did you eat any of it?” she asked.

“The toast? No.”

“Good. Don’t.” She took off her coat at last, hung it on the hook behind the door, and tied on an apron that had been waiting on the same hook. “That’s not for you. It wasn’t made for you.”

“Mrs. Eames. Somebody wound that clock.”

“I couldn’t say.”

“Somebody wound it, and at seven this morning I lost an hour of my life. I was sitting right here. I was looking at the second hand. I want to know what you know about it.”

The old woman went to the range. She took down a small saucepan, filled it, and set it on the burner, and for a long moment she stood with her back to the room and her hand flat on the cool iron rail.

“Tonight,” she said.

“That isn’t good enough.”

“It’s all I have this morning. I’ll tell you tonight, when I’ve done my day. I’ll tell you what I can.” She turned the gas on. “You’re a nurse, Miss Gilchrist. You know there’s a time for bad news and a time for breakfast.”

“Paramedic.”

“It’s all the same to the patient,” said Mrs. Eames.

She put an egg in the water. She laid a place at the head of the table, with a white egg cup and a spoon, and sat the egg in it when it was done and set a square of toast beside it.

Then she left it there, steaming gently, in front of an empty chair, and went to see about the upstairs fires. Hanneke watched the steam thin and stop. At nine o’clock, without a word, the old woman came down and took the plate away and scraped it into the bin.

“Since the Monday,” she said, to nobody. “Every morning.”

Water Street ran down the hill in a long curve, and Hanneke walked it with her hands deep in her jacket pockets and her mind going over the facts as she would have gone over a patient’s chart. A man dead at four-twelve.

A body found at ten past eight. A voice answering at seven. A clock that had been stopped and was now running. And a woman who knew more than she would say and had chosen, for reasons of her own, to cook breakfast for the dead.

The town was awake and busy. A man in a canvas coat was hosing down the pavement outside a butcher’s. A woman with a stroller was arguing amiably with a florist. Every shop window she passed had a small white card taped in the corner of the glass, lettered in the same square black capitals. LINDELL FERRY TIME. And underneath, smaller, in some cases written in ballpoint: SET BY THE STANDARD.

At the top of the street the tower stood against the sky with its four white faces. She stopped under it, because it was the thing to do, and checked her watch against the east dial. Her watch said 9:31. The tower said 9:38.

She frowned, and checked again, and it was the same.

“Seven minutes,” said a voice behind her. “Since this morning. It was six when I came in.”

A man in a county sheriff’s uniform was standing at the foot of the town hall steps with a paper cup of coffee. He was about her age, narrow and tidy, with close-cropped hair and the look of a man who ironed his own shirts. There was blue ink on the back of his left hand, in small neat figures. She read, upside down, 9:31 / 9:38.

“You’re keeping a log,” she said.

“I’m keeping a note.” He turned his hand over and looked at it. “I don’t carry a notebook. My notebooks go missing. Wade Sutcliffe. I’m the deputy, the day deputy, and the night deputy, and on Sundays I’m also the dog warden.” He held out his hand, and then looked at the ink and hesitated, and then shook hers anyway. “You’re Selwyn’s. The paramedic.”

“Hanneke. Does everybody know that?”

“It’s a town of three thousand, and you parked in front of Hagen’s on Thursday. They knew by Thursday lunch.”

“I’d like to see whatever you have on Selwyn’s death.”

He did not ask why. That interested her. He drank some of his coffee, looked at the tower, and said, “Come downstairs.”

The sheriff’s substation was in the basement of the town hall annex, two rooms with a barred window at pavement level and a coffee machine older than either of them. A single steel cabinet held the files for the whole of Lindell Ferry. He found the folder in the third drawer without looking and slid it across the desk. “There isn’t much. It was a natural.”

There was less than she had hoped for. A one-page incident sheet. A typed supplementary report from the coroner. A short note in Sutcliffe’s own hand: attended residence 9:50, decedent seated in study, family notified, no suspicious circumstances. No photographs.

“No pictures?”

“Dr. Ottway doesn’t allow cameras at a natural. He says it’s a death, not an exhibit. I’ve been here six years and he’s been coroner for twenty-eight.” Sutcliffe leaned back. “He’s usually right.”

“Were you in the room?”

“For about four minutes.”

“Tell me what you saw.”

He considered it. She liked how long he took. “He was in the leather chair, with his hands on his knees and his head a little forward. Like he’d dozed. Reading glasses folded in his shirt pocket. Dr. Ottway had his bag open. There was a tray on the desk with a pot and two cups.”

“Two.”

“Two. Good china. Both full.” He rubbed the ink on his hand with his thumb. “I took the lid off the pot. I don’t know why. It was just the kind of thing you do when a room’s too quiet. The pot was warm. Not hot. Warm, like it had been standing half an hour.”

Hanneke said nothing for a moment. “At nine-fifty.”

“Nine-fifty-two. I wrote it on my hand.” He turned the hand over. The numbers had been washed away weeks ago, but she could see where they had been, a pale smudge on the skin. “It bothered me. It bothered me that the pot was warm, and it bothered me that the old man was cold.

I put the back of my fingers on his cheek. I’m not a doctor, but I’ve had to do it before. He was cold right through. He was stiff in the chair. Dr. Ottway’s very good about not saying things at a scene, but I saw his face.”

“What did he say?”

“He said, ‘Nine-forty. Write nine-forty.’ And I did.” Sutcliffe looked at her steadily. “I’ve been wondering for eighteen days if that was an order.”

Hanneke took a pen out of her jacket and asked if she could write on the back of the incident sheet. She wrote the sequence out in a column, as she would have written a call. Rigor, full, at nine-forty, in a room at average temperature. That is hours. Three at the least, usually more, six at the outside.

Pot warm at nine-fifty-two. Pot made when? The warmth of a pot of tea in a stone house in November fell off fast. Half an hour, he had said. Perhaps an hour. Poured about nine. By a man who had been dead, by any measure she knew, since the small hours.

“What are you writing?” said Sutcliffe.

“A list of things that can’t be true.”

“Is it a long list?”

“It’s one thing. It just keeps being the same thing.” She capped the pen. “Have you been in the house since?”

“Once. Last week, to check the locks. Mrs. Eames wouldn’t have me past the kitchen. She gave me a cup of tea and I stood in the doorway and she told me the time four times.”

That made Hanneke smile, to her surprise. “She does that.”

“She’s done it to me since I was twelve.” He studied her. “The tower. You noticed the tower.”

“It’s seven minutes fast.”

“It’s been creeping a little for a month. Since the day he died it’s gained about a minute every few days. This week, more.” He said it quietly, in the voice of a man who had said it to himself several times in an empty room. “I’ve told the board. They tell me to mind the traffic. The Standard hadn’t been out by a second in a hundred and sixty years, not until this fall. Mr. Selwyn went up every Saturday with an oil can. Now nobody does.”

“Who does it belong to?”

“The family,” said Sutcliffe. “I assumed that meant you.”

Her phone rang as she came out into the daylight. It was a local number. She answered it standing on the town hall steps with a hand shading her eyes.

“Hanneke, it’s Marcel. Marcel Gilchrist.” His voice was warm and a little rueful. “I hope I’m not catching you at a bad moment. I heard you’d been at the sheriff’s.”

She looked up and down the street. Nobody on it was looking at her. Nobody was not looking at her either.

“It’s been fifteen minutes,” she said.

“It’s a small town. I’d have heard if you’d stopped for a sandwich.” He laughed. “Look, I only want to say that if you have any questions about Uncle Selwyn, anything at all, I’d much rather you asked me. It’s a family matter. People in the town are very fond of him, and they’ve been, well, a little protective. There’s a lot of feeling. I’d hate for you to hear things secondhand that aren’t quite the way they were.”

“Such as?”

“Such as nothing in particular. I mean generally. I mean that old men die, and we’re a town that likes to make something of it.” A pause. “How was your first night?”

She thought of the ticking. She thought of the clock with its red second hand and the cream paper lying on the kitchen table. “Quiet,” she said.

“Good. That’s good. It’s a quiet house.” His voice relaxed, just slightly, and she heard it and filed it. “Let me take you to supper tomorrow. Not business. I’d like to know my cousin.”

“I’ll let you know.”

“Of course. Take your time.”

She rang off.

She stood on the steps and let the call settle. Marcel had known where she was within minutes, and he had known the word sheriff, and he had not once asked what she had learned. A man who wanted to know would have asked. A man who already knew the shape of the answer asked how she had slept. The tower said 9:52 and her watch said 9:45. It occurred to her that she had never in her life been so conscious of being in the wrong time.

Dr. Abel Ottway lived at the top of Church Street in a brown shingled house with a gray cat in the front window and a brass plate by the door that still said PHYSICIAN, polished so often that the letters had worn shallow. He answered the bell himself. He was seventy-one, tall, bent at the shoulders like a heron, with white hair brushed straight back and a cardigan that had been mended at both elbows by someone who knew how.

“Ah,” he said. “I’d wondered which morning.”

“Dr. Ottway, I’m Hanneke Gilchrist.”

“I know. Come in out of the street. They’ll be at the windows.”

His study was a small crowded room smelling of pipe smoke and old paper. A chessboard stood on a table by the window with a game in progress. She noticed, without meaning to, that both sides were still in play, and that the black king had been tipped over on his side, and that the dust on his felt base was a good deal thicker than on any other piece.

“You play?” said Ottway.

“No.”

“Neither did he, really. He played like a man looking for the exit.” The doctor lowered himself into a chair. “Sit. You’ll want to ask me about nine-forty.”

She had prepared an opening. She put it aside. “Yes.”

“It is wrong.”

“I know.”

“I wrote it, and it is wrong, and I would rather you heard me say so before you worked it out for yourself.” He folded his big spotted hands. “I’ve signed some four thousand certificates, Miss Gilchrist. I have never before put down a figure I knew to be false.

Rigor was fully established at nine-forty. The lividity was fixed. He had been dead, at a fair estimate, five or six hours. I should have put four-fifteen, or thereabouts, and I put nine-forty instead, because Marcel asked me to.”

“Marcel asked.”

“He telephoned me before he went to the house. He said, if it’s Selwyn, then please, Abel, for the family, make it the time you pronounce.” Ottway looked at his hands. “It seemed a small thing. There’s a custom in that family about times. I’ve respected it for thirty years. I told myself it would be an hour or two.”

“But it wasn’t an hour or two. It was five hours, and you knew what that meant.”

“I knew that he was dead at four in the morning, and that a pot of tea was warm at ten.” He did not say anything further for a moment. “I knew that, and I am a physician, and I made a note in my own book and said nothing. I should like to think I will be given an opportunity to explain it.”

“Explain what? I’m not asking you to explain a clock.” She leaned forward. “Dr. Ottway. Who made that tea?”

“I have never said that anyone made tea.”

“You said the pot was warm.”

“A pot may be warm of its own accord.” His mouth moved, a tiny, bitter smile. “You see how it is. In this town one can be a great deal of use by saying nothing at all in the right order.”

“I’m not trying to catch you out.”

“No. You are trying to find where it hurts. That is a physician’s instinct.” He looked at her, for the first time directly. His eyes were pale and clear and very tired. “It runs in families. It would run in yours, I think.

I was your great-uncle’s friend for fifty years, and I will tell you the one thing I am able to say, which is that the house is not what you suppose it is, and that you are not to be frightened of Aveline, and that.”

He stopped.

“And that?”

“That the rest of it is not mine to say.”

It was the pause of a man whose sentence had run into a wall. She had seen the same thing on the faces of the elderly when a question touched something they had been forbidden to speak of: not secrecy, exactly, but a kind of physical stop, as if the words were there and the road beyond them had been cut.

Ottway rose, with some difficulty, and went to the window. He stood looking out at the street with his back to her. A long time went by. The gray cat, which had been asleep on the sill, opened one eye and shut it.

“You haven’t eaten,” he said.

“I had breakfast.”

“No. You had a cup of tea you did not make.” He did not turn around. “Take your pulse.”

Hanneke sat very still.

It had not occurred to her that she was holding her wrist. It was in her lap, in the fingers of her other hand, where her thumb had been resting on the artery for some time without her noticing. She looked down at it. She counted. She did it carefully, with the second hand of the old school clock in her mind, ticking.

“Fifty-two,” she said.

“Fifty-two.” The doctor nodded to the glass. “It would be fifty-two, the morning after. It was Selwyn’s, every morning after his hour, for forty-one years. I took it myself, now and then, over the chessboard, when he would let me.” He turned around at last, and his face was gray, and quite gentle. “Miss Gilchrist. Before you go. Did she leave you a note?”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!