I am not allowed to carry the ballots, so I do the only other thing the book permits. I sit in the van with the engine off and watch a twelve-year-old do my job.
“You can come in,” says Wren.
“I can’t. Article Nine. I’m a party.”
“You can come in as far as the door.” She has the manila envelope against her chest and her composition book under it, and a pencil behind each ear, a habit she caught from Walt and cannot lose. “You can stand at the door and look interested. That isn’t carrying.”
“Is that a rule?”
“It’s a distinction.” She says it with great dignity. “Mr. Strake says it’s the whole of the law.”
It is Wednesday, a quarter past nine, and Brookside Manor squats in the rain at the end of its drive, a long low brick building with a flagpole, a ramp and a sign that says WELCOME, FRIENDS AND FAMILY, which has always seemed to me a rather hopeful list. Wren climbs down. She goes up the ramp alone, small, straight-backed, in Ruth’s second-best raincoat with the sleeves rolled, and I stay at the door, interested.
---
Orrin Stiffler is ninety-four years old and has, on the table beside his bed, a pocket radio, a plate of toast, a set of false teeth in a cup and a photograph of a fire engine in a silver frame.
“The bearer,” he says. “That’s you.”
“I’m Wren Elm.”
“Elm.” He looks at her. His eyes are very pale, nearly colorless, like water in a glass. “That’s the Tamarack side. You’d be the one who writes it down.”
“Yes, sir.”
“Sit.” She sits. “I seconded that motion. Did they tell you? That spring. I was twenty-six. Gil’s father was in the chair. I said *seconded* before he’d finished the question, because I was in a hurry to go to a dance.” His mouth works. “I’ve thought about that dance more than the stone.”
“They found the mark,” says Wren. “Under the plaque. A lantern.”
“A lantern.” He closes his eyes. “I’ll tell you something. In the summer, after, I used to stand at the door in my uniform on a hot day, and I’d put my hand on it, and I swear, it was *wet.* Like a stone in a spring. I told Hollis. He said it was condensation.” The pale eyes open. “It wasn’t.”
“Will you sign?”
“What for?”
“For the stone to go back. To where it came from.”
“Give me the pen,” says Orrin Stiffler. He signs, in a hand that has not shaken in ninety-four years, *O. T. Stiffler, Life,* and on the bearer line, with a flourish, *Wren Elm, my girl.* He watches her blot it. “Is there another?”
“Mr. Bashore. In the next room.”
“Leroy.” The old man’s face changes. “Go easy.”
---
She goes easy. I watch her go through the door, from the hall, with the envelope held in both hands, and I do not hear what happens, and I would give a great deal to.
When she comes out she is walking more slowly. She stops in front of me in the corridor and holds out the second ballot. It is blank. She has not even taken it from the sleeve.
“He asked if I was his granddaughter,” says Wren.
“Wren—”
“He said he’d sign anything. He said he liked a girl with a paper.” She says it flatly. “I think he’d have said yes to a cake. I think he’d have signed *Roosevelt.* And then it would have been thirty-two and not true.”
“You could have taken it.”
“The Secretary said a member’s ballot.” Her chin comes up. “That’s a member. That isn’t him. Somebody’s got to not do it, Mags, or the rule’s a stamp.” She sniffs. “I had a long conversation with him about his late wife. I think that’s the thing he can give.”
I put my arm around her. She allows it, for about the length of a breath, and then she steps back and checks her pencil.
“Seven to go,” she says.
---
The rest of Wednesday is a telephone.
It sits on the diner counter, the beige one with the cord, which Ruth has lent to the cause and from which she has removed the coffee, and in the long gray afternoon, from two to six, every member of the Company who owes a Tolliver a courtesy hears a voice on the line asking whether he would be so kind as to name a bearer.
The first Florida man is Lenny Chulik, who is in Sarasota and says he’s never wanted to be anywhere less. “Put the Tolliver girl on,” he says, and I do, and he says, “Whatever you need, honey, I’m in,” and names Raymond, who is in the kitchen and surprised.
The second is Bud Alder, who needs it explained twice. The third is Marv Hollis, the Captain’s grandson, who is in Naples and lets me say all of it, and then says, with a decent, awful politeness, “I’m sorry. Granddad carried that stone. It’s the only thing of his I’ve ever been proud of. I can’t.” I thank him. I write *no.*
Ed Orlowski, with the hip, is Pat’s husband. He votes yes from his recliner, in front of the wife who is not allowed to witness it, and she stands at the door and looks at the ceiling.
Kyle Dunmire is in the Navy and is, so far as anyone can tell, on the far side of an ocean. Jonah finds him by email at four. By five there is a scanned form with a signature that looks as if it was made on a bunk, and under it, *bearer: my mother,* and Mrs.
Dunmire, out in a car on Mill Road, takes the phone from a man at a stop sign and says, in a tone I have heard from only one other woman, “Tell that girl I’m on my way.”
By six there are six yes ballots in the envelope, and one blank, and a no.
---
At seven Ruth lights the lamp.
I watch her do it, as I have done every evening since the first of November. She takes the chimney off with her good thumb, trims the wick a quarter inch with the small silver scissors, sets a match to it and breathes out. The flame stands. It does not flicker. The diner takes it, as it takes a bell.
“Seven,” she says. “That’s the one.”
“It’s six.”
“The seventh is Hank Chulik. I’ve been told he’s in the barn.” She puts the chimney back. “He doesn’t answer a telephone. He’s never answered a telephone in his life. His twin does, and says he’s out.”
“The twin voted no.”
“I know what Wayne voted.” She wipes her thumb. “I’d go to the barn. If I were a person who could. A member’s door is not a thing you telephone.”
“I’ll go,” says Jonah.
He has come out of the kitchen with his apron over one arm. He is looking at the lamp. “He’s the one who gave me the siren,” he says. “In the summer, at the fire hall. He was forty. He let me turn the key. And then Dutch caught me, and Hank didn’t say a word, and took the blame, and I was kicked out and he was suspended for a week.”
He sets the apron on a stool. “I never thanked him. I thought, in the car, I could do it now.”
“It isn’t a payment.”
“No.” He nods. “It’s a visit.”
---
Hank Chulik is on a tractor.
I can tell it is Hank by the way Jonah stops in the yard, with Wren at his side in her raincoat, and stands, hat in hand, in the mud at the edge of a hay barn with the door rolled open. The tractor is a green one, older than I am.
Its engine has been taken apart in a hundred pieces on a tarp and laid out on the concrete in the order of its removal, and a stooped man in coveralls is looking at the pieces with a wrench in his hand as a man looks at a map of a country he would like to leave.
“I’ve the ballot,” says Wren. She is already at the edge of the tarp.
“I heard.”
“You’re named. By the Secretary. You can sign if you’ll tell us a bearer.”
“Who’s it for?”
“The stone,” says Jonah.
Hank Chulik straightens. He is sixty or so, with a face like a ham and very small eyes, and he looks at Jonah for a long time.
“You were the siren kid.”
“Yes.”
“I got a week for you.” He says it without rancor. “You couldn’t have been more than fourteen.” He puts the wrench down on the tarp. “I’ve not heard from you in twenty years. I’d the notion you’d gone to the bad.”
“I did, for a while.”
“And back.”
“I came back.”
“Well.” Hank wipes his hands on his coveralls. “That’s the thing about it. You can’t tell a man to come back. You have to leave the door.” He takes the pen from Wren. “Is it true about the lantern?”
“It’s true.”
“Then I’d have been in favor if you’d come with nothing.” He signs. He looks at the line for the bearer, and then, slowly, at Jonah. “Put *you.* The one who turned the key. Nobody else.”
---
At ten that night there are seven yes ballots in the envelope and a long list of the unreachable.
There were sixteen absent members. Six were at euchre at the American Legion, and the Auxiliary’s telephone chain has found them, one by one, in the middle of a hand, and five have said that the Company had always known best and they didn’t see what a stone had to do with it. The sixth has said yes.
“That’s seven,” says Wren. She has lined them up on the counter, in two rows, the way she lines up everything. “And Mr. Bashore, who didn’t, and Marv Hollis, who said no, and Wayne Chulik, who said no, and five who didn’t care.” She looks at the sixteenth place. It is a blank line. “And that one.”
The sixteenth name on the roll, in Pat Orlowski’s tidy hand, is *Tolliver, Francis X., Captain.*
“Twenty-four in the room,” says Nair. She has come, as she comes, without warning, at ten in the evening in her state coat, with a slice of pie that she has not asked for and is eating at the counter. “Plus seven. Thirty-one. One short.”
“It isn’t a joke,” says Ruth.
“I did not say it was.” Nair sets down the fork. “I said it was thirty-one.”
“He can vote,” I say. I hear my own voice, and it sounds thin. “He told me. At noon on Monday. *A vote’s not a request.* And his dues are paid. But he can’t—” I stop. “I don’t know if the rule will let me hand him a thing in the minute. A ballot isn’t a gift.”
“No,” says Ruth. “It’s a vote.”
“It might not take.”
“Then it won’t,” says my mother. She turns the lamp down a quarter turn with the tip of her finger. “And thirty-one’s what we have.”
---
Thursday comes in raw and bright, and at ten to twelve Hal arrives.
He comes in without his hat, which is worse than with it. He stands for a moment in the doorway with the cold coming in around him, a huge old shambling man in a coat the color of cinders, and looks at the lamp, and then at the frame, and takes his place at it as he has taken it on Thursdays since the middle of March. He sets his left hand flat to the wood.
It is the hand that is made of the thing that burns. It is the color of old pewter. Where it touches the frame there is a small thin curl of smoke, like a breath on a cold window, and Raymond, who is watching it with a dish towel, nods once, and goes back to the sink.
“Mags,” says Hal.
“Hal.”
“Halvard,” he says. “Of the ridge. Himself.” He says it every time, now, with a flat, dry pride, like a man reading his own name off a lease. “It’s a stone I know. The ones in the firehouse. I had to go and look.” He looks at the floor. “I was a mile off, at the time of the blast. I felt it come down. I thought it was thunder. I thought, *that’s a great deal of rock for a dry day.*”
“You didn’t take it.”
“I hadn’t the chance.” He sounds almost regretful. “I’d have kept it, you know. I’d have put it under the hay. It’s the best thing I’ve ever seen made by men.”
The clock goes quiet.
---
He is in the door when the light comes.
He has the shirt on. He has the half-smile of a man who has been waiting a long time to say something and has settled on a very small thing to say instead. “Halvard,” says Frank.
“Frank.”
“You’re holding the frame.”
“I am.”
“Good.” He nods. “Keep your thumb off the top rail, it’s got paint.” He looks at Ruth, who has come up beside the lamp with her hands folded and is not looking at him in the way that she does, as if he were a thing she could only look at slantwise, like the sun. “I’ve a ballot to sign.”
“Yes,” says Ruth.
She has it. It is in her apron pocket. She takes it out and lays it on the counter, at the end, beside the coffee, with the pencil from the order pad, and her hand does not shake, and Frank bends over it.
He is a big man. He has to turn the paper a quarter to fit the line. He holds the pencil in his whole fist, as he always did, as a man holds a hammer, and I think that nothing in the whole of this long cold winter has been so near to what I once lost.
He writes *F. X. Tolliver.* He draws a short line under it, a tick, a habit. And on the line under that, the one for the bearer, he looks at his wife, who is looking at the wall, and writes *Ruthie.*
The pencil does not go through the paper. It does not burn. It is just a ballot, in a man’s hand, on the counter of a diner at noon.
“There,” he says.
“Is it—”
“It’s in.” He sets the pencil down. “I voted yes. For the Company, and the stone, and for what the thing was, which isn’t mine.” He smiles, crookedly, at Hal. “Dutch held a hose on that barn nine hours, Halvard. You’ll want to speak to him.”
Hal’s hand tightens on the frame. A thread of smoke goes up from the wood.
“I know,” he says.
“I don’t mean today.”
“I know when you mean,” says Hal. “I know. I’ve heard it said. I’ll go and be looked at.” He swallows. “As it were.”
“It’ll keep,” says my father.
The light goes. Ruth takes the ballot up from the counter with both hands, like a woman taking a bird from a window. It is warm. She holds it against her coat. “I’ll take it myself,” she says. “Right now. I can make the Secretary by twelve-twenty.”
---
The Secretary opens the box in the apparatus bay at twelve twenty-two.
I stand at the door and look interested. The members who came to witness crowd the apron: the Chief, with his hat in his hand; Pat Orlowski with her reading glasses; the Auxiliary in rows; Brandt, still holding the frame. Dutch Eckert is in a folding chair by the engine, with his cane across his knees. He has not been asked to come. He has come.
Pat unfolds each ballot, and reads out the name, and the vote. She lays them on the card table in two piles. She does it slowly. At the thirty-first she looks at Ruth, who has come in from the van and is standing at the back with her hands folded on her purse, and she says, in a voice I have never heard from her, “Thirty-one in favor, and one.”
She turns it over.
“*Tolliver, Francis X., by Ruthie. Yes,*” she reads. “Thirty-two.”
It is not a loud room. There is a sound, though, like a breath going out of a barn.
“Twenty-four in the room and eight by written ballot,” says Pat. “Thirty-two of forty-seven.” She puts down the paper. “Mr. Chairman. The motion is carried.”
“Carried,” says the Chief.
---
The stone is not given away. It is *carried,* and the difference takes four hours.
I understand it as they do it. I stand at the edge of the apron in the thin sun and watch the Company of men who have paid dues to a roof for fifty years take their own bay door apart. They do it by hand.
A crowbar. A cold chisel. The long steel sill of the door they lift out in two sections and lay on the gravel, and under it they find the rest of the stone, eight inches of dressed end, with the lantern on it, clean as the day it was cut.
They do not touch it with machines. They rig a sling, with a set of ladder straps and two canvas hose-carriers, and six men a side, and on Pat Orlowski’s count they lift.
It is seven hundred pounds. It comes up out of the apron with a long low sound, as of a tooth leaving a jaw.
I do not help. It is not allowed. Jonah stands at my elbow, with his hands knotted in his coat, and I feel him strain, and I hold his sleeve.
“The Company owes it,” I say. “It’s the Company’s hands.”
“I know.”
“It has to be theirs.”
“I *know,*” says Jonah, and he laughs, shakily, because Dutch Eckert, at the foot of the sling, eighty years old and ashen, has taken a place in the line and nobody has the heart to tell him not to.
---
They put it on the brush truck.
I do not think it was planned. It stands at the end of the apron, a squat old green Ford with a flatbed and a water tank, and it is the one the Company’s parade committee wished to borrow for Independence Day. Dutch has a hand on its fender. He says, to nobody, “It’s not wearing bunting,” and the Chief, beside him, puts a hand on his shoulder, and says, “No, Dutch.”
They lay the stone on a blanket. They tie it down, with seven straps. Dutch asks to drive.
It is the strangest procession I have ever seen. It goes down Ketterly Road at five miles an hour, behind a rusty green truck with an eighty-year-old man at the wheel, and behind it, on foot, in a long double line, the Company walks: the Chief and the Secretary, the men from the home, the Auxiliary in coats, a boy of fourteen in a Junior shirt.
There is no siren. There are no lights. The porches along the road come awake as they pass, one by one, a woman at a screen door, a man in an undershirt on a step, a girl on a bike with her hand over her mouth, and no one calls out, and no one asks what it is. They stand. A flag on a porch hangs at half.
We follow in the van. Ruth sits beside me and does not speak. At the cut they have set the keystone on a pallet at the foot of the shale, beside the guardrail, in its box. Dutch brings the truck up at a creep, to within ten feet of it, and sets the brake, and gets down.
He stands a moment. Then he takes off his cap.
“Down,” he says. “On three. And not a man of you drops it.”
---
They set it beside the keystone, on the gravel, at the foot of the cut.
It is the larger of the two, the broad wedge with the lantern on its end, and when it touches the ground the whole of the road goes still. Thirty men and women stand in a ring on the shoulder in the late sun. Nair has her Roll sheet. Ms. Szabo’s machine is going. And Wren, between them, with the composition book open, has put down her pencil, and is not writing at all.
The rule rings.
It is Tully’s, and he has it in both hands, and it does not ring as it rang for Emil. It is lower. It is a deep slow note, like a bell in a cellar. The two stones seem to hum with it. The lantern on each face, hers and his, kindles together, a thread, a coal, and on the face of the cut over our heads, high up, where the notch is, the pale socket brightens like a window.
There is a dry sound of water.
It begins at the foot of the shale and runs, under the gravel, along the line of the old bed, with a sound like a hand drawn over silk. It goes under the guardrail. It crosses the road. It does not wet the pavement. At the far shoulder, on the top of the guardrail, a cork float is bobbing.
I do not see it come. It has the brown paper strip wound round it, and the long thin tea-colored hand.
*The second thing. Thank you.*
And below it, smaller:
*One more. In the Commonwealth’s wall.*
---
Dutch Eckert is the last to leave.
I find him at the guardrail in the dusk with his cap in his hand. The Company has gone back up the road, with the brush truck, in the same slow line, and the porch lights have come on one by one along the valley. He is standing alone, with his cane, and he is looking at the two stones.
“I hold a grudge for forty years,” he says, without turning his head. “I’ll say that for myself. It’s the one thing I’ve kept up.”
“Mr. Eckert.”
“It had let him go. I said that. I told myself the stone had let him go.” He looks at the lantern. “And it was just a stone. It was never the thing that was supposed to hold him.”
“No.”
“It was us,” says Dutch. “It was *us.*” And he puts his hand, flat, on the stone, palm down, the way he must have a thousand times, and stays there in the failing light, with his back bent, an old man in a blue jacket.
I leave him. It is not mine to see. I walk back to the van, where Ruth is waiting with the engine off, and as I reach it the siren on the firehouse hill, two miles off, begins to rise.
It is a call. They will go. And I think of the apron, and the long raw hole where the sill was, and a Chief with a hand that has nothing now to touch, who will step down from the cab in a minute, as he has done for twenty-nine years, because nobody told him to stop.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!