Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 85

Petition for Review

The Prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas keeps his office on the second floor of the courthouse behind a counter of varnished oak, and at five past nine on Monday morning he stamps a petition for the first time in his life with a face like a man closing a coffin.

“Filed,” says Mr. Voss.

He is a small neat bald man with a mustache and a green eyeshade, and he has held the post for thirty-three years. He lays the stamp down. Behind him, on a shelf, there are nineteen thousand case files in manila, and not one of them, I think, has ever been brought to his window by a man in a three-piece suit with a pocket watch that does not run.

“Thank you,” says Ambrose Sproule.

“Docket number is on the cover.”

“I am obliged.” He bows, slightly, and turns, and finds that the whole of the corridor behind him is full of us. He does not seem surprised. “Miss Tolliver. Miss Nair. Mr. Brandt, how good to see you outside the Annex. And Mr. Strake, of course.” The pink face crinkles. “I did not think you would come so soon.”

“We came to read it,” I say.

“It’s a public file.”

“We know.”

“You’ll find it quite short.” He lifts his hat. “I tried to make it clear. It is a pleasure to be understood.”

He goes out. He goes down the stairs, and I hear his polished shoes on every step, an even tread, unhurried, to the bottom, and the revolving door of the lobby turn, and then I find that I am holding on to the rail.

---

It is eleven pages, and Strake reads it standing.

He does it in the corridor, under the window, with the file on his forearm and his reading glasses on the end of his nose, while Nair stands at his shoulder and Brandt at the other, holding the empty walnut frame, and Wren sits on the floor against the wall with her book open. Tully, in his slicker, has come up from the lobby with the rule, and stands in the stairwell, listening.

*In the Court of Common Pleas of Tamarack County. In re: Declaration of Taking, One Hundred and Nine Parcels. Petition of the Asset Review of the Western Division for Review of the Order of the Board of View and for Declaratory Relief.*

“Three counts,” says Strake. He has taken off his glasses to read the first, and he puts them on to read the second. “I shall try to give it you plain. It is a very good piece of work, and I should like to say so, and have it struck.”

“Say it.”

“Count One. The conveyance of the Tolliver hand, of the hundred and nine parcels, recorded at Tamarack in the year of the Review’s first sitting, names no grantee. A conveyance with no grantee conveys nothing. It is a nullity. The land never left the grantor.” He turns the page. “That is not new. It is the thing Mr. Brandt told us in the Bureau, with his own mouth, in front of Miss Nair. The Review has the same copy.”

“And?”

“Count Two follows. If the fee never left the grantor, it is in the grantor’s successor. The grantor was *the Tolliver hand.* The Tolliver hand, at present—” He stops. He looks at me over the glasses. “At present is you.”

---

“I own it,” I say.

“The Review says you do.” Strake’s voice has dropped. “The Review says that you are, by operation of law, the owner of record of the hundred and nine parcels, in fee, subject to such liens and charges as may attach. And that, *as owner,* you are the person against whom the Board’s valuation runs.”

“Against.”

“The Board’s valuation is of what the ground is *owed.* If the ground has an owner, it’s the owner who owes it.” He lets the page fall. “Every name on the Roll, Miss Tolliver. Emil Pruett’s stone. The girl at the low end. The hour at the fence. The church ditch. The Commonwealth’s ledger *and* the water’s. Count Two says, in language I’m rather ashamed to admire, that the debts of the ground are the debts of its owner, and that the owner has, by the Board’s own process, been identified as you.”

“Her body included,” says Brandt.

He has said it so quietly I almost do not hear. He is looking at the frame. “It’s in the Manual. Section Twenty-two. *An owner in possession is answerable for the encumbrances upon the land to the extent of his or her interest, and in default thereof the person.* It’s an old clause. It was meant for the tenant-farmers. It was never used.”

“It was waiting,” says Wren, from the floor.

“And Count Three?” says Nair.

Strake turns it. He does not read it. He looks at it a moment, and then he folds the page back, very precisely, with his thumbnail.

“Count Three is the other jaw,” he says. “In the alternative. If Miss Tolliver *disclaims.* If she says, with perfect truth, that she is not the owner, and will not be; if she wishes to keep her hands clean; if she says the ground belongs to nobody.” He looks up. “Then it is ownerless. And ownerless land, in this Commonwealth, escheats.”

“To the Commonwealth.”

“To the Commonwealth, and the Commonwealth sells.” He lays the file on the sill. “It is the most elegant trap I have seen in twenty-six years of practice. You are the owner, and you owe the ground’s debts, and it will take your body. Or you are not, and the ground is the Commonwealth’s, and is auctioned on the courthouse steps.”

He takes off the glasses. “Both ways, Miss Tolliver, somebody ends by owning it. The Review does not care who. It only cares that the answer is a *name.*”

---

We stand in the corridor for a time. A woman comes out of the Register of Wills and looks at us and goes back in.

“Point nine,” says Strake, finally, to the air. “Reading a petition. Point one, being impressed.” He pauses. “Struck.”

“Is it true?”

“Is what?”

“That the blank is a nullity.”

“The law of the matter,” says Strake, “is that a deed with no grantee is void.” He scrapes a thumbnail along the file. “The *law* is simple. The *ground,* if the ground has a view, has not been consulted.”

“The ground has a view,” says Tully.

He has come up the last of the stairs. He holds out the rule in both hands, with the green stain on his fingers, and he looks, with his pale freckled face and his wet slicker, about eleven years old. “I can ask it. If you like. I can ask the rule if you’re the owner. It’ll tell you.”

“It won’t be a good answer.”

“No.”

“Ask anyway,” I say.

---

We do it in the lobby, at the counter, under the dead clock.

I put my hand on the brass edge. Wren stands at my elbow, with the book. Brandt, holding the frame, and Nair, with the Roll, and Strake, with his pad, and Ms. Szabo, who has come down from the courtroom with her machine under her arm and set it up in the gray light of the revolving door without being asked. Tully holds the rule at the level of his chest.

“I’ll say a thing,” I say. “And you tell me.”

“I’m to say that I’ll hear no question the Board hasn’t had,” says Tully. “I think the Board has had this one.”

“*The ground is mine.*”

The rule is silent.

It is not hollow. It does not ring flat. There is no note at all, like a bell with a hand on it, and Tully’s face changes. “*None,*” he says. “It’s false. Mags, it’s—it’s *false.*”

“*The ground is nobody’s.*”

Silence again. The same. A dead place in the air, like a cold spot in a room.

“False,” says Tully, very quietly.

“So they’re both false.” I try to say it as a clerk would, as a fact. “I’m not the owner. And it isn’t nobody’s. That’s two.”

“You need a third,” says Nair.

“I haven’t got one.”

“Try.”

I try. I stand at the counter with my hand on the brass and say, “*The ground is held,*” and the rule gives a small soft note, hollow, true but not whole, like a cup with a crack. I say, “*The ground is mine to keep,*” and it is flat. “*The ground is in my care,*” and it is hollow again. I say, “*I am the one who answers for it,*” and the note is very faint, like a bell in another county, almost true.

“Almost,” says Tully.

“What’s missing?”

“I don’t know.” He looks at the rule as if it had spoken to him in a foreign tongue. “It’s as if there were a word. A word that goes in the middle. And it isn’t *owner,* and it isn’t *nobody.* It’s the thing the Grandmother said. *To keep. Not to own.*” He wets his lips. “It isn’t a word we have.”

“We’ll have to find it,” I say.

“By the twentieth,” says Nair.

It is the first I have heard of a date. She has the petition in her hand. She is looking at the last page, at a line in the typed prayer for relief. “The Court has fixed the hearing on the Petition for Tuesday the twenty-first, at ten in the morning. The respondent’s answer is due by four on Monday the twentieth. A day before.”

“A week.”

“Seven days.” She closes the file. “To say what you are.”

---

Kerr comes at six.

He comes in the back, through the kitchen, which he has never done, and stands at the end of the pass-through in a gray raincoat with his hat in his hand, a thin tired young man with a very straight back. He has not shaved. He has the look of a person who has been dismissed from the only trade he knew, and has been walking.

“Mr. Kerr,” says Ruth. She puts a plate on the pass-through. “Sit.”

“I can’t. I’ve been told not to.” He looks at the plate. “I’m not their man, Mrs. Tolliver. I’ve not been since March. But there’s a paper that I was asked to carry, and I’ve kept it, and I think it’s better that you have it from a person who is sorry.”

He lays an envelope on the counter. It is cream, thick, sealed with a blue wafer, and it has, on the front, in a very clerkly hand, *Halvard. Of the ridge.*

“It’s his,” says Kerr. “The Reservation. The Secretary’s application. It was drafted in February and was to have been served after the Roll. They’ve moved it up. It’s noticed for a hearing on Wednesday the twenty-ninth, ten a.m., Courtroom Two.” He turns the hat in his hands.

“It’s the application to reserve him. As a creature of the Commonwealth’s soil. It says that a thing which burns a barn, and eats a field, and has lived upon the Commonwealth’s ground for four hundred years without a license, is, in the Review’s view, a thing *held.* Not a person. And may be taken into custody.”

Ruth does not move.

“Where is he?” says Kerr.

“At the ridge.”

“Will you tell him?”

“I’ll tell him myself,” says my mother. She takes the envelope. She turns it over, once, in her flour-whitened hands, and sets it on the shelf under the register, between the health certificate and the fire company picnic. “He’ll want to know it came from a person who was sorry.”

“Mrs. Tolliver—”

“Eat something, Mr. Kerr,” says Ruth. “You’re not a bad boy. You’re only one that doesn’t know where to stand.”

He eats standing, at the pass-through, as a man eats in a train station. He does not look up. Raymond, at the sink with his dish towel, slides a coffee along the steel without a word.

---

At seven Ruth lights the lamp, and at six minutes past, Strake knocks on the glass.

He is on the sidewalk in the dusk, with the pad under his arm, and he has not come in. He says, through the pane, that he has something he would like to put on the record, and that it is not a bill, and that he will be at the counter in a moment.

He is. He takes the stool nearest the pie case. He sets down the pad. “It occurs to me,” he says, to the pie case, “that I have been in this room for five months, and have billed you, by my own reckoning, for something like sixty hours, and that of those I have struck about forty, and that the figures do not agree with the ones in my head.”

“What are the ones in your head?”

“Zero.” He says it with a kind of bleak astonishment. “I have been—I think I have been counsel for the ground since the second week of November, Miss Tolliver, and I did not notice. I had the sense of being at a very long dinner at which the check had been mislaid.”

He rubs his eyes. “Count Two is a lawyer’s trap and I should like to have been the lawyer who set it. I have thought about it since nine this morning, on the road, in the car. There is an answer to it. I cannot find it. It will not be a lawyer’s.”

“A third.”

“A third thing.” He nods. “Not owner and not nobody. I have been through the Restatement and the Code and the Manual and my father’s dictionary, and there is no category for what you are.” He looks at me. “I think that is the thing the Review is afraid of. They cannot attach a person who is not a category.”

“Mr. Strake—”

“I shall be at the hearing,” he says. “In whatever capacity the Court will allow. I mention it so that you may not suppose I have been ordered. Point five, advice. Not struck.”

---

At noon on Tuesday, Sproule himself is at the sill.

He does not come in. He stands in the street, on the bright wet sidewalk, with the umbrella furled, in the full light, at the edge of the diner’s step, and he waits with the patience of a man who has been told what time a train will come. Raymond, at the frame, has his hand flat to the wood. Hal, at the end of the counter with a cup he has not drunk, is looking at his own shoes.

The clock goes quiet. The light comes.

“Ambrose,” says my father.

I have not heard him say the name. I do not know if he has ever known it. He says it in the voice he used for the boys on the Company, a friendly, flat, easy voice, the voice of a man who has been asked for directions.

“Captain Tolliver,” says Sproule. He takes off his hat. “I had not expected—”

“It’s the hour. It comes at noon.” Frank leans on the jamb. “You’ll want to say your piece, then, and have it done. Ruthie’s got the pie in.”

“I have no piece. I came to deliver a courtesy copy.” He takes the envelope from his case, a cream one, a duplicate of the thing he put on Monday in the court’s own file, and holds it out across the sill, as one might hold out a hand to a dog. “It is in the matter of your daughter.”

“I know what it’s in.”

“I did not wish the occupant of the lamp to be surprised.”

“I’ve been surprised before,” says Frank. “It doesn’t take.” He does not reach for the paper. Ruth does, from behind the counter, a long arm and an unsmiling hand. “I’ll tell you what I think, Ambrose. For nothing. I’m not a lawyer.”

“I should be glad.”

“You’re right about the blank.”

It is very still. I see Sproule’s face change, very slightly, in the way a lake changes at the first breath of wind.

“A name on that line,” says my father, “and somebody would have owned it. Somebody does. That’s the trouble with a name.” He rubs his jaw. “And the only people who’ll leave a line open, Ambrose, are people who’ve been burned by what happens when they don’t.”

He smiles, a tired, kindly smile, and for a moment I do not see a man who has been gone since a fire. I see a captain, in a hall. “Somebody’s got to hold it. You’ve the right of that. You’re only wrong on who.”

“And who is that?”

“Not me to say,” says Frank. “I haven’t the standing.”

The watch in Sproule’s waistcoat, I can hear it from the counter, ticks once, a small clear mechanical tick, and stops.

---

At midnight, in the dark, on the second-floor landing, I take out the green book.

I write the date. I write the two false sentences, *the ground is mine* and *the ground is nobody’s,* and under them, in a column, the half-true ones, the hollow, the almost: *held. In my care. The one who answers for it.* I draw a line.

Under the line I write *the word that goes in the middle,* and I put a question mark, and then I cross out the question mark, because a clerk does not put question marks in a ledger. I leave it blank.

Jonah has gone to sleep on the other side of the bed, with his arm flung over his head and a little pale line of the landing light along his jaw. I do not wake him. It is a quarter to one. The Hedge hour has begun. I feel the cold come up through the floor, from the Room Below, as it comes every night at midnight, a clean slow ache like water over a stone.

There is a tap at the window.

It is a very small sound. It is a sound as of a bird, or a bit of gravel, or the knuckle of a hand that has not been used to knocking. I go to the sill. I lift the sash. And there, on the outside ledge, in the thin moonless dark of the second week of April, is a cork float with a strip of brown paper wound round it, wet and shining, in the long thin tea-colored hand.

It has two lines.

*She kept it. Look where she kept it.*

And beneath them, small, as though added after a long hesitation, by someone who was not used to being the one who advised:

*Not the Commonwealth’s. Hers.*

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!