The pencil weighs nothing, and I cannot lift it.
It lies in Tansy’s brown palm, a short yellow Ticonderoga with a flattened eraser and a ring of small even tooth marks around the ferrule. It is not the pencil I dropped. That one has a deeper dent where I bite when I’m adding in my head. This one has the dents of a girl who bit it because she was frightened, and had not yet learned to do it in the right place.
“Take it,” says Tansy. “It’s yours. She said whoever came second.”
“I didn’t come second. I came after a hundred years of Marlows.”
“I only know what I was told.” The old woman tips her palm. “It is a fair thing. She paid a toll she did not owe, and I have kept it fourteen years, and I would be glad to be rid of it. It is a heavy pencil for something so small.”
I take it.
It is warm. Nothing in this Court is a plain temperature, and I have stopped being surprised, but I am surprised by how warm it is, as if a hand had only just let go. I hold it between two fingers. The girl bit down on it at nine-fifty on a night in autumn, in a barn, in front of a jar she could not afford, and decided she’d be back when she was older.
I put it in my hair. It fits the place exactly.
“Examiner,” says Tansy. “May I say a thing that’s not a charge?”
“You’ve done it twice already.”
“Third time lucky.” She leans on the besom. “I’ll tell the Treasurer what I saw, if she asks. She has not asked. In fourteen years, nobody has. I thought that was strange.”
“Does the Treasurer know about the girl?”
“I’d not say she knows. I’d say she has not wished to.” Tansy shrugs. “It is a difference the Summer is very good at.”
---
Theo finds it at the top of the stair, under the oak trapdoor, with the notebook open on his knee and the lamp on the straw beside him. He has been silent for ten minutes. For Theo, that is a kind of fever.
“Dess.”
“What?”
“Row forty-one.” He does not look up. His pencil has stopped. “I’ve copied three hundred and four tags. I’m not skipping. I copy every one, even the ones I think I can guess. And there’s one that isn’t an employee’s.”
He turns the notebook around. In his small, careful, fair hand, it reads:
*Wynhollow, E. Drawn: by consent. 14 yrs and 2 mo. before the Reckoning. Title: “What I promised Mrs. Marlow.” Hour: planted, unsprouted. Held: for the drawer, until asked twice.*
I read it three times. It does not change.
Emrys is standing a pace behind me at the lip of the trapdoor, still holding the tallow lamp. He has not moved. I look at the lamp, and see that it is shaking, a little, so that the flame throws the shadows of the beams back and forth over the straw. He has not said a word since the closet.
“Emrys.”
“I have read it,” he says. “I read it over his shoulder.”
“You didn’t know.”
“I did not.” His voice is not steady. “I said, in the hall, in front of a hundred people, that I did not witness what happened in the kitchen. It was true. I would not have said it, in a fae’s hearing, if I could not stand behind it.
It was true as to my *memory.*” He closes his eyes. “I have lost an hour, Dess. I have lost it by my own consent. I sold it to be forgotten. I did not even know there was a hole.”
“The Roll struck your name. You couldn’t have known what you didn’t have.”
“I could have felt the shape of it.” He opens his eyes. “A man who has had a thing taken feels the shape of the pocket. I thought it was the Strongroom. I thought it was four hundred years.”
I step toward him. I do not mean to; it is only that there is nowhere else I would be. I take the lamp out of his hand, because I’m afraid he will drop it, and set it down.
“It’s yours,” I say. “You can have it back.”
“Asked twice.”
“You’ve been asking for fourteen years. You’ve had the second time coming.”
“It says *the drawer,*” says Emrys. “Not the Gleaner. The drawer. I think I put it in the drawer myself.”
---
Tansy has not stopped sweeping. She has gone round the trapdoor and is working the other side of the table, flicking chaff into a heap with the wheat besom, and she does not turn her head as we come up behind her.
“I’ll ask you the question you’ve been wanting,” she says, “and then you can ask yours. Yes, there is a drawer. No, I do not keep it. The Treasurer keeps it. She keeps a good many things. The drawer is shut, and it has been shut since a Tuesday when she was not yet Treasurer.”
“I’d like to open it,” says Emrys.
“You’d like to *ask* for it.” Tansy sets the besom against the table. For a moment she is looking at him, at the salt-white hair and the pink cloth wound round the left hand, and her black bird’s eyes go gentle. “I’ll tell you what my grandmother told me. A thing that was given freely may be taken back freely. A thing that was sold must be bought. Which was yours?”
“I do not know.”
“Then you must say which.”
“It was given.” He says it at once. “I remember nothing. But I know myself. I would not have sold it. I would not have taken a price for what I owed to a woman who was risking her daughter.”
“Then it is given. And a given hour is the giver’s to resume, on the second asking.” She holds out her hand. “I have not a drawer, but I have a floor. Whatever falls is mine. It is a rule, and I keep it. Do you have something that will fall?”
He has no pencil. He has no pocket worth the name. He has a gray coat and a gray shirt, both lent, and a boarding-house key that is not his, and, wound round his left hand from the palm to the wrist, a long strip of pink cloth, stained a little at the edge with an old dark brown.
I have not seen him without it since the day I met him.
“It was Pim’s,” says Emrys, to nobody. “A tea towel. He tore it and bound my hand when it was split open, and he said *I’m not a charity, it’s a loan,* and he has not asked for it back.” He looks at it. “I will make him a fair repayment.”
“Emrys, no. You don’t have to—”
“It was a fair offer.” He has begun to unwind it. His fingers are quick and exact, a treasurer’s fingers, used to counting a coin through a glove. “Hold the end.”
I hold the end. The cloth comes away in a long, soft ribbon. Under it, his hand is whole. I had thought it would be frozen, a lattice of blue-black beads of ice. I had thought, I realize, that he was being brave.
It is a hand. It has a long pale scar across the palm, thick, like the track of a rope, and nothing else. It has healed so well that I would not have known it had been hurt, except that he holds it very slightly curled, as one holds an object one has been told is fragile.
“It was healed on the day I was released,” says Emrys. “The cloth was to remind me that I had been held. I think I have carried it long enough.” He gives the end of the ribbon to Tansy. “That is the toll.”
“It is a good one,” says Tansy, softly. “A cloth that was tied on by a friend. It will not be a heavy thing in my pouch.” She folds it, not roughly, and puts it with the pencil, and the others. “Then I’ll tell you where.”
---
The seed is the size of a lentil. It is at the very back of the cellar, in a small black tray by itself, behind a beam. A tag on a pin: *Wynhollow, E.* A pale, smooth, faintly shining thing, unsprouted, lying in damp earth like a bead on velvet.
Emrys kneels. He does not touch it. He looks at it for a long moment, with his hands on his knees.
“What does one do?” he says.
“You eat it,” says Tansy, who has followed us down the stair. “It is not so bad. It tastes of rain.”
“Raw.”
“It is your own hour. It has had no time to learn another name.” She settles herself on a low crate with a creak. “I will not watch.”
She does not, she turns her face to the wall and shuts her eyes. I am not sure why that is the moment I find hardest. It is a barn cellar, in a Court I do not belong to, at one in the morning, and an old woman is giving a man privacy to be given back a piece of his own life. It seems to me quite simply the kindest thing that has been done in this place.
Emrys picks it up. It rolls, very slightly, in his palm. He puts it in his mouth.
I count. It is an old habit, and I let it go on. At twenty, his shoulders come up. At thirty-one, his eyes open and he is not looking at anything in the cellar. At forty his hand reaches blindly for mine, and I take it, the healed one, the scarred one, and it is cold, and then it is not.
Somewhere past a minute, he says, in the voice of someone reading very fast from a page he has been told will burn: “Oh, Mara.”
---
He tells it in the anteroom, at the stone table, with the lamp lit and the kettle on and the clock at its stopped hour.
It is nearly three. Ysmere is not here; she has gone to bed, or whatever she does that resembles it, and the chair is empty with a cup beside it and a brass dish of minutes. Hale has gone to sleep in his chalk circle.
Nettle is on the step with her chin on the cigar box and her eyes shut. Theo has made tea. Nobody drinks it. Emrys sits with his bare scarred hand around a cup and tells us, in a voice that has gone flat and quick and very nearly fae, what he lost.
“It was a Thursday,” he says. “Eleven days before the night in the kitchen. It was your mother’s second descent of the Strongroom stair. She had filed her request for the Schedule and been told she would be admitted, as an auditor of the Bureau, to a single room on Level Nine, for one hour. She chose the room where I was kept.”
“Why?”
“Because she had read my entry in the Schedule, and it said, in the margin, that I was the only officer of the Winter who could not be bought.” The line of his mouth moves. “She meant it as a compliment. I was not able to take it as one.”
“What did she want?”
“A witness.” He looks at the cup. “She did not tell me for whom. She said that she had a thing she meant to do, and that she would need, afterward, one person who knew what was said and what was not. A person who would not be in the room. She said that if she was in the glass, she would not be able to say. She said that you would need to be told.”
“She didn’t say it was me.”
“She did not say a name. She said *the one who reads the footnotes.*” He glances at me, and it is almost a smile. “I thought it was a joke. I had never met you. I did not know I would.”
I put down the pencil I am holding. I did not know I had taken it out of my hair.
“I said that I could not witness what I did not see,” says Emrys. “I was seized. I had no standing, and no pen, and no way to be in a Cleveland kitchen. Your mother said that a witness need not be present. A witness need only be willing, and bound, and have a thing to say when asked. *In absentia,* she said. It is a Winter custom, older than the Accord. She had studied it. She had a form.”
“The Instrument of Witness.”
“She did not have a form. She had a *clause.* She wrote it on the back of her hand, with a ballpoint, in blue.” His mouth twists. “I read it off her wrist, through a slot in a door.”
“It said that I, Emrys Wynhollow, Treasurer, would witness the consent of a minor, being a girl of seventeen, to a pledge that she could not be told in full; and that when she asked me twice, I would say exactly what she had and had not been told, and by whom.”
“And that was the agreement.”
“That was half.”
He lifts the cup, and sets it down without drinking.
“The other half was a price. I asked for none. I am a Treasurer, I cannot give a thing for nothing; but I was ashamed to ask her for anything. She said that it must be fair.” He looks up. “I said that I had not been in a room that was not a cell for a long time. I said I would like her, if she could, to put a thing of mine in a safe place.”
“A thing.”
“My name.” His voice does not break. It simply stops, like a clock, and starts. “On the Roll, I am Item 4419. In the old Court I had a name that was written on a slip of paper in a drawer in the Registrar’s room, and the Registrar was dead.
It could be lost. I thought, if she took it, and kept it, in something that was not a Court’s, and was not a ledger, and was not a place a Bureau could read, then it would exist.”
“Where did she put it?”
“I did not ask. I think that was the point. A thing you are not told the place of, you cannot be made to say.” He glances, once, at the stone doorway, and the empty chair. “I think I know now. I think you know it, too.”
I do know.
I knew it in the barn. I knew it at the lock, with my hand on the brass, humming a tune that has been in my head longer than I have been able to read. It was a number, and a number is a place. It was a song that said *this is where it is,* in a notation only the Winter could read, to a man who would hear it at last and not know that it was for him.
“The eight bars,” I say. “It isn’t only the routing number.”
“It is a routing number. It is also an address.” Emrys nods. “A tally of the old Winter, you see, has two readings. A number, and a name. The last four digits, the one-one-four, are a note. But the *first* four, read the other way, down, are the letters of a name. I have been looking at them for three days, and I could not see them, because I did not have the hour.”
“Say them.”
“E. M. R.” He swallows. “Y. S.”
Nobody moves. The kettle ticks.
“She wrote my name into a song,” says Emrys, “and gave it to your father to keep, because she trusted him to hum it. And he has been humming it for twenty-two years. And every Thursday, in a sunroom in Cleveland, a man with a lighthouse puzzle has been telling a stranger where I was.”
I put my face in my hands. It is a short time. I take them away.
“He couldn’t have known,” says Theo. “Walt. It’s a song. He just—”
“He did not know,” says Emrys. “I think he *kept the place.* It is what he said. He kept it. A thing can be kept without being understood.” He turns the cup in his scarred hand. “There was a last thing, in the hour. Your mother said it, at the slot, just before the Hoar Watch came down the stair. She said it low, because they were near.”
“What?”
“She said: *if she asks you who asked me, tell her. Tell her it was a woman. Tell her it was not Ysmere, and not the King, and not the Bureau, and not me.*” He lifts his eyes. “*And tell her I said I would have done it myself, if it had been allowed.*”
I do not know what it is that I feel. It is not grief. It is not quite relief. It is the feeling of having been handed a coat that does not fit, which is nevertheless warm, and which someone has been carrying for fourteen years.
“You know,” I say. “Who asked her.”
“I know the name. It was said, in the hour. At the end. At the slot, as the Watch came, she said it, and I had it on my tongue, and then—” He stops. “I ate the hour. I heard it. I cannot hear it now.”
“Why?”
“Because it is held in a Roll.” The words come out dry as paper. “As my own is. As Agnes Pell’s was. A name on the Summer Roll cannot be heard by anyone it has not been entered to. I heard it in the hour, as a man hears in a dream. I woke, and the sound was gone.”
“The woman who asked my mother to pledge me is on the Roll.”
“The woman who asked is *held,*” says Emrys. “By the Summer Court. In some entry, under some number, at the Treasurer’s hand.”
---
I want, very badly, to ask him. I want to say the name’s first letter, and see if he flinches, and I am going to. I open my mouth.
“Who asked my mother to pledge me?”
He looks at me, and I watch him decide. It is the face of a man who has been through four centuries of questions and has just learned that this one will be put to him by a girl with a pencil in her hair.
“That is the first time,” says Emrys quietly. “You have asked once. I may not answer until the second.”
“The clause.”
“It is her clause, and it is yours. She wanted you to have a day between.” His voice is very gentle. “I think she knew you. I think she knew you would ask it, and ask it again before the sun was up, and she wished you to choose it on purpose.”
“I choose it.”
“Not tonight.”
“Why not?”
“Because I am telling you what the clause does not.” He puts down his cup. “I am telling you what it costs. When I answer, the hour is spent. The setter of the seal will know it was spent. They know what we know, when a name is said that they have been waiting to hear. It will be the first thing since the Strongroom that is not a debt, and it will be *heard.*”
I look at the stone table. At the cup, and the pencil, and the brass key that says EXAMINER, and the cent beside it, which is warm.
“They’ve been waiting for me to ask.”
“For fourteen years. I think so.”
“And if I don’t?”
“Then you do not know.” Emrys spreads his scarred hand. “It is a fair choice. I would not make it for you. It is the only thing, I think, that she asked me never to do.”
I sit for a long time. I think about a green-sweatered man in a sunroom, who hums four bars and stops. I think of him on Thursday, in his chair by the lighthouse puzzle, with a jar of pale warm light in my lap that I am going to put in his hand.
I think about asking the second time on a day I haven’t given him his hour.
“Thursday,” I say.
“Thursday?”
“I’ll ask you on Thursday. The day after I’ve given my father his hour. Not before.” I pick up the pencil. It is the girl’s, and it fits my fingers exactly, and I write it on a card in a hand that is only a little unsteady. *Ask E. twice. Thursday, after Maple Court.* “I don’t want the setter to hear it until my father has eaten what’s his. I want him to have his one clean hour first.”
“That is a Marlow decision,” says Emrys.
“It’s a clause.”
“It is a clause.” He almost smiles. It is the first time I have seen it reach his eyes. “You may ask me on Thursday. I will answer figure first.”
“Thank you,” I say.
I have said it. I did not decide to. It is out of my mouth before I know it is coming, and I hear it land on the stone table, between the kettle and the clock, and I wait for the cost.
Nothing happens. It does not cost anything. Not from him.
“It is received,” says Emrys, “and not tallied. I find that I did not need it to be.” He looks, for a moment, almost young. “You may take it back, if you like. I will not hold you to it.”
“No,” I say. “I’ll keep it.”
On the step, without opening her eyes, Nettle says, in her small flat sleepy voice, “That’s two.”
“What’s two?”
“Two *thank-yous* that didn’t cost.” She opens one eye, and shuts it. “I’m counting. I’m not telling you what the number is for.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!