Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 44

The Best Hour

Cleveland, on a Thursday in November, is thirty-eight degrees and smells of wet leaves and bus exhaust, and Sorrel Vane stands in the annex lot with her mouth open and her arms wrapped around her ugly sweater like a woman who has been slapped by an entire season.

“Oh,” she says. “Oh, it has *edges.*”

“It’s weather.”

“It is *rude.*” She tips her face up into the gray. A single raindrop lands on her nose, and she goes cross-eyed to look at it. She has left the basket. She has left the coat. She has left, I notice, the poppy kerchief, and without it she is only a tall young woman with a lot of dark hair and a sweater the color of a pond.

It is hand-knit. It has one sleeve a good three inches longer than the other, and a collar that appears to have been invented under duress. “Is this what it is like every day?”

“Mostly.”

“How do you *bear* it?”

“Coffee,” I say. “And a bad car.”

The car is the Corolla, silver, 2013, in the exact space I left it forty-nine days ago. There is a ticket under the wiper. There are, in fact, four tickets under the wiper, fanned out like a hand of cards and curling in the damp. I peel them off and fold them into my blazer without looking at the total. I have decided that today I am not a woman with an arrears schedule. I am a woman with a jar.

It is in a brown paper lunch bag, the kind Mara used to pack, folded over twice at the top. Frane’s leave slip is in my other pocket, and it says, in the Receiver’s tidy gray hand: *Carry nothing in or out, save one jar, being the property of the person to whom it is delivered. Return by the dawn bell. It is Thursday. I have a niece.* Under that, in a different ink, very small: *Please eat something.*

I have not yet. I will.

Sorrel gets in the passenger seat and puts on the seatbelt with the care of a person defusing a small bomb.

“Dess.”

“Yes?”

“Is it all right if I say one thing, before we go in, and then say nothing at all?”

“Is it a charge?”

“It is a *request.*” She folds her hands in her lap. “I should like to be thanked for nothing today. Not at the door, not afterward. If it goes well, and I have done nothing but stand there, I would like you to say *noted,* and for it to be the truth.”

“Noted,” I say.

“Thank you.” She catches herself, and a small shocked laugh comes out of her. “I did that on purpose.”

---

Maple Court has a lobby that smells of floor polish and soup. The clock above the front desk is eleven minutes fast. It says ten past ten, and my watch says ten to ten, and the Summer Treasurer reads it with an expression of deep suspicion and says, “Is that a lie?”

“It’s a Delia,” says Joaquin, from behind the desk, in his burgundy scrubs. He is twenty-four and he has seen the retirement of three hundred and eleven puzzles. “She won’t reset it. She says it keeps people on their toes.” He glances at Sorrel’s sweater, and his whole face rearranges itself. “That’s a *great* sweater.”

“It is not.”

“It is. I mean it. Somebody loved making that.” He slides the visitors’ book across the counter. “Sign in. Name, time, relationship.”

Sorrel takes the pen. She hovers. It is a plain blue ballpoint, chained to the desk by a little beaded cord. I watch her read the page: Dess Marlow, over and over, every Thursday. Further up, in a neat upright hand I’ve seen in a hundred inventories, *W. Voss, 10:05 a.m., Friend.* Her eyes stop on that, and then she writes.

*Sorrel Vane. Ten-ten, Cleveland standard. Witness.*

Joaquin turns the book around to read it. He does not say anything. He looks, for a moment, as if he would like to ask what a witness is. Then he looks at me, and I look at him, and I say, in the voice of a woman declining a gift, “It’s a long story.”

“I’ve got till seven.”

“Thursday,” I say. “Come ask me next Thursday.”

“Noted,” says Joaquin, and slides me a coffee.

I have not asked for it. I take it. I say, “Thank you,” and it costs me something, a small coin of something, the way it always has, and I find I am paying it without a flinch. It is a human coffee. It is lawful. I think I am getting better at this.

---

The sunroom has the lighthouse puzzle on the long table, nine-tenths done, with the sky still missing. Beyond the windows the November rain has begun, in small gray needles, running down the glass.

Walt is in the chair by the east window, in the green sweater. He is turning a puzzle piece in his fingers. He doesn’t look up when we come in. Beside him, in the second chair, a lean man in a tan raincoat has a crossword folded on his knee and a pencil behind his ear, and he gets to his feet with a jerk when he sees the woman in the pond-colored sweater.

“Dess.”

“Voss.”

“It’s, uh.” He looks at Sorrel. He looks at me. “It’s Thursday.”

“It’s Thursday.”

“I didn’t know that this was—” His eyes go over Sorrel’s shoulder, up, and out, to a middle distance that seems to cost him something. “I’m sorry. I’ve been signing in at ten-oh-five for fourteen years. I could stand somewhere else.”

“Stay,” I say. “It’s your hour too.”

I mean it. I find that I mean it. He sits down. He puts the crossword on the arm of the chair. He has the look of a man who has been told, at the end of a long audit, that there will be a second part.

I cross the room. Walt looks up.

“Dessie,” he says.

It is the right name. It is the *right name.* I stop on the carpet with the lunch bag in both hands and cannot move.

“There you are,” says Walt. His voice is slow and warm, like a kettle. “I thought you’d be Mara. You’ve got her way of standing. Like you owe somebody an apology.”

“Hi, Dad.”

“Who’s the tall one?”

“A friend.”

“Is she a good friend?”

“I don’t know yet,” I say. “She’s wearing a sweater.”

“Oh,” says Walt. He looks at Sorrel, and she, God help her, gives him a small wave, a shy hand lifted from the wrist, and he gives it back with perfect gravity. “That’s a good one. It’s a good one. Somebody loved making that.”

---

I kneel by his chair, on the sunroom carpet, with the jar in my lap.

I had planned a speech. I have a speech. It is three paragraphs, in the second person, with a footnote. I open the paper bag, and I take out the jar, and it is just a jar: squat, thick-walled, the size of a jam jar, stoppered with a cork, with a brown paper tag tied round the neck with kitchen string.

Inside it the light is the color of weak tea held up to a window. It moves slowly, the way honey does when you tip the glass.

*The tick on her jaw.* The tag says it in Walt’s own hand.

“It’s yours,” I say. “It’s not mine. I’m only bringing it back. You drew it out of yourself on the fourteenth of August, two thousand four, and some people put it in a barn. I found it on Monday. I don’t know what it will do.”

“It’s an hour,” says Walt.

“Yes.”

“Is it a good one?”

“I think it’s the best one you’ve got.”

He puts down the puzzle piece. He lays his hand, which is big and spotted and gentle, over mine on the jar, and I feel the glass warm, and the cork, which is not really a cork, begins to turn by itself, a slow quarter turn, as if it were being unscrewed by somebody patient.

“Dessie,” says Walt, “you don’t have to say a speech.”

“I know.”

“You’re going to say a speech.”

“It’s three paragraphs.”

“I’ll hear it after.” He smiles, and I see the man in the photograph on my mother’s desk, the man at the wheel of a rented boat. “I’ve got a feeling about this one. I think I’m going to be busy.”

The cork lifts, and the room fills with August.

---

I cannot describe it. I am an auditor; I have tried. I have written it three times in the notebook with the hooked tick and struck it three times, and what remains is a column of figures that don’t add.

There is light. It comes up out of the jar like steam from a cup, gold and slow, and it does not go to the ceiling. It goes to Walt. It folds around his face and his hands and the green sweater, and for one breath he looks like a man at the bottom of a clear pool, with the sun on his back. And then he breathes in, long and deep, and the light goes in with the air.

His shoulders drop. His hands, on the arms of the chair, stop being the hands of a man who has been asked a question he can’t answer.

“Oh,” says Walt. “*Oh,* that’s good.”

“Dad?”

“That’s the picnic.” He laughs. It is a rolling, delighted laugh, and I haven’t heard it in fourteen years, and it hits me in the sternum like the strike of a bell. “That’s the *Bureau picnic.* It’s August. It’s Wade Park. Somebody brought a *Jell-O mold* in the shape of the Cuyahoga.” He looks around the sunroom, bewildered, delighted, taking in the lighthouse and the rain, and his eyes come back to me, and they are clear. They are forty-six years old. “Dessie. You’re *nine.*”

“I’m not.”

“You’ve got a hot dog on your shirt. Come here, kid.”

He has been in the sunroom for fourteen years. He is also, I understand, in Wade Park, in August, with a paper plate in his lap, and the two places are laid over each other like two sheets of tracing paper, and I am nine years old and grown at once, and I put my head on my father’s knee and let him put his hand on my hair.

“There she is,” he says. “That’s my girl. That’s my good girl. You’re all pencil. Look at you. Did your mother do that? Did she give you the *tick?*”

“She taught me how. You drew the first one.”

“I did it with a pen.” Walt’s chest shakes. “It was a bet. I bet her five bucks that if she marked the kid’s face with a check she’d be able to find her in a crowd, and she said that’s the dumbest thing she ever heard, and I said, *Mara, it’s an audit.* And I got a pen out of Jim Voss’s pocket and I did it myself.

That’s the whole thing, Dessie. It’s not a Marlow secret. It’s a dumb bet. It’s the dumbest bet in the history of the Bureau.”

“Wait,” says Voss.

He has stood up. He is not aware that he has. He has a hand at his breastbone, and his face is a unusual color, and his eyes are on Walt and not on any of the rest of us.

“I laughed,” says Voss. “I know I laughed. I’ve got a photograph. I’ve got a picture of me on a lawn with a paper plate, laughing at a man I couldn’t identify. Walt. What was the *joke?*”

Walt looks at him. He blinks, once, slowly.

“Jim,” he says. “You’re looking old.”

“I’m sixty-three.”

“That’s old.” He grins. “The joke was the Jell-O. I said, *it’s the Cuyahoga: you can see the bottom but nobody wants to.*”

There is a silence. It lasts about two seconds.

Then Voss, standing in the middle of a sunroom in Cleveland with a crossword on the arm of a chair, begins to laugh. It is not a good laugh. It starts as a cough and breaks into pieces. It is a laugh that has been waiting twenty-two years to be let out, and it is the laugh in the photograph, and he cannot stop it.

He puts both hands over his face and bends over, and Sorrel, who has not said a word, sets her hand very lightly on his back.

“There,” says Walt. “That’s the one.”

Voss straightens. His face is wet. “I got it back,” he says. “I’m sorry. I got a—it’s not the hour, it’s, that’s not—” He wipes his nose on his raincoat sleeve. “Thank you. Dess. Thank you. It’s the best thing anyone’s ever done for me.”

“I didn’t do it for you.”

“I know.”

“It’s a *receipt.*”

“I *know,*” says Voss, and begins to laugh again.

---

For fifty-two minutes Walt Marlow is a man in his forties with all his words.

He tells us about the picnic. He tells us about a three-legged race that Mara won and a softball game that Jim lost, and he asks me whether I still pick the onions out of everything, and I say I do, and he says *course you do.*

He tells Voss that he used to bring the numbers to him on Thursdays and that it was the best part of the week. He tells me that my mother has a particular laugh, a kind of single bark, and that he has never heard it without wanting to say something worse.

He asks me what month it is, and I say November, and he looks out at the rain and says, “Huh. It’s *been* a while,” and for a second I think the whole thing is going to crack.

It doesn’t. He pats my hand.

“I know where I am, kid,” he says. “I’ve known for a while. It’s just that most days I can’t get the words to go to the right place.” He looks at his own hands. “This is a nice hour. I’m going to enjoy it.”

At minute fifty-one he turns to Sorrel.

She has been standing at the window with her back to the glass, her arms folded round her own ugly sweater. She has not moved in an hour. I have watched her watch, with an expression I have never seen on her, a face with no charm in it at all, only wanting. She looks like somebody who has been shown a door and told it isn’t hers.

“You,” says Walt.

“Me,” says Sorrel.

“You’re wearing her sweater.”

Nothing in her moves. Not her hands, not her mouth. I watch her go quite white under the sun-brown.

“I’ve never seen it,” says Walt. “But I’ve seen the stitch. She used a left-hand cable. She did it on a bus. It was a deal, she said, for a year of her afternoons.” He studies Sorrel’s face in the gray window light, and something in his own face softens, as if a note he’d been holding for a long time had finally been allowed to fall. “You’ve got her chin. You’re Ilex’s girl.”

“You *knew* her,” Sorrel says. It is hardly more than a breath.

“Once.” Walt nods. “Two thousand four. A Saturday, at the picnic, round about three. She was sitting on a blanket at the edge of the park with a bowl of peas, and I thought: that is a strange woman. She had a basket. I went over to say hello.” He smiles. “She said a thing to me. I’ve been carrying it around for twenty-two years, and I think I know why.”

I feel the voice’s slip in my pocket. I have the paper in my fingers before I know I have reached for it. *Please do not take Sorrel Vane to Maple Court. Her mother told your father something in 2004. She has been looking for it since.* I have the whole sentence like a stone in my hand.

“Dad,” I say. “Dad, maybe—”

“She said it to me, Dessie.” He doesn’t take his eyes off Sorrel. “She said, ‘Mr. Marlow, you look like a man who keeps things in the right place.’ And I said I try. And she said, ‘Then you’ll keep this one for me. I can’t. They’ll know.’ And I said, ‘What is it?’”

“What was it?” says Sorrel.

“It was a chair.”

The rain is loud on the glass. Nobody moves.

“She said, *the third chair at your kitchen table.* I said we haven’t got a third. We’ve got Mara’s chair and mine, and the kid’s stool, and a spare. And she said—” He frowns. The light has begun to fade from him; I see it go, a little, round the corners of his eyes, like a tide pulling back from a rock. “She said, *you will. Put it under the seat.*

I thought she meant—a *paper.* I put a paper under the spare chair. I wrote it down so I wouldn’t forget. *Under the third chair.* I’ve been saying it for twenty-two years.”

“The third chair,” I say. My voice is not mine. “The one in the kitchen. The one that’s been empty for fourteen years.”

“That’s the one.”

“What was the thing, Dad?”

“I don’t know.” He is smiling, and it is the saddest smile I have ever seen. “I didn’t look. She said that if I looked, I’d have to be able to say. And I never was, much, with the tune.”

At fifty-six minutes the gold has gone from his hands.

I know it before he does. I watch it, the quiet unpicking of a man from himself, a stitch at a time. He looks down at the puzzle piece in his lap. He looks up, and for a moment his eyes are still on mine, steady and kind, and then they slide away, politely, toward the window.

“Is it going to rain?” says Walt.

“It’s raining, Dad.”

“Huh.” He turns the piece over. It is a piece of sky. “Are you the new aide?”

I do not say it. I hold his hand, which is warm and spotted and does not know me, and I sit on the carpet with my coffee going cold and the jar empty in my lap. It is the best hour of the year, and it has cost exactly what it was always going to: him, afterward. I know the price. I paid it with my eyes open. It is the only way I know how to pay.

“Thank you, Dad,” I say.

“It doesn’t cost anything,” says Walt, vaguely, at the rain. “You can just say it.”

---

Sorrel is outside before I am. She is standing under the awning of Maple Court with her arms wrapped around her ugly sweater and her eyes on the road, and she has the stillness of a deer in headlights. Rain drips off the edge of the roof in a bright thin line. When I come up beside her she does not turn her head.

“You asked me not to be thanked,” I say.

“I did.”

“I’m not going to. I’m going to say *Noted,* and I’m going to say it truthfully. You were there. You did nothing. It was the right thing to do.” I wait. “That’s the hour. It’s paid. The Summer Treasury is satisfied, in full, under section three. I’ll put it in the Receiver’s book.”

“And my mother’s book?”

“That comes after.”

“It comes *now,*” says Sorrel. Her voice is hard. It is the first time she has sounded like a Treasurer. “Examiner, it’s Thursday. It’s twelve minutes past noon. In four hours and thirty-nine minutes, when the sun sets, the Summer reads its books aloud. I’m a witness to a thing said on a Thursday in the hearing of a Summer officer. I have to enter it. It goes into the reading. It goes to the whole Court. It goes to everyone who is listening.”

“Everyone.”

“Including the one who set the seal.”

I stand under the awning in the rain, with a lunch bag and four parking tickets, and look at her. *Thursday is when the Summer reads its books aloud, and what’s said on a Thursday is heard.* I have the page in my pocket in a seventeen-year-old’s blue ballpoint. I did not need to be told.

“You can’t not enter it?”

“No.” Her eyes finally come to mine. They are wet and hazel and wide open. “I’m so sorry. I did not know. I asked for the hour because I wanted to *see.* I would have asked for another if I had known it would be heard.”

“I believe you.”

“What do we do?”

I look at the car. At the gray sky above it, which will be dark by a quarter to five. At the four tickets, and the key in my pocket, and the very long, very ordinary drive across the east side of Cleveland to a house I have not entered since the night the clock jumped.

“We have four hours and thirty-eight minutes,” I say. “And I have a kitchen to find a chair in.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!