At a quarter to nine Mrs. Dunning lit the fire in the study. She did it without being asked, and it was the first time in eleven days I had seen that grate with anything in it but laid kindling. She said it was because gentlemen of the law felt the cold. I think she wished the room to look like a place where a sane man sat.
I was sent for at nine exactly. I had been awake for thirty hours and my sleeve still smelled faintly of milk.
There were four of them. Mr. Crane filled the best armchair, red and shining, turning his hat in his big hands. Dr. Rainsford stood by the window with his watch chain across his waistcoat like a small silver fence. A thin grey man I had not seen before sat at the desk in Mr. Caldwell’s own chair, with a tin deed-box open before him, and beside him on a stool a young man with a long neck and a notebook, who did not look up at all.
“Mr. Obadiah Pruett,” said Mr. Crane, “of Troy. Your father’s man, and mine. Now, my boy, nobody here wants any unpleasantness.”
“Then we shall have very little,” said Mr. Caldwell, from the hearth. He had not slept either. He had shaved, and he had put on a dark coat and a collar, and he stood with his hands loose at his sides and his back to the fire, which I understood to be a considerable effort.
Mr. Pruett read the clause aloud. He had a voice like a ledger being shut. I will give it as near as I can, because I wrote it down that night in this book with my own hand, and I do not forget a document.
“Should the master of Blackwater Hall be unfit in body or mind to have the care of my children, the guardianship of the said children and the management of the Caldwell Ice and Cold Storage Company shall pass to my three trustees, being Barnabas Crane, Edmund Rainsford, physician, and Agnes Dunning, housekeeper, they concurring all three, and a physician unconnected with my family so certifying.”
“Agnes,” I said, before I could prevent it.
“Josiah Caldwell,” said Mr. Pruett, “trusted no one he had not fed.” He looked at me over his spectacles for the first time. “You are the governess.”
“I am.”
“Miss Whitlock will sit,” said Mr. Caldwell, and a chair was found, and I sat in it with my hands in my lap and my feet exactly together, as I had sat on the day I was dismissed from the Alderdices.
Dr. Rainsford spoke next, and he did it beautifully. He did not say Matthias was mad. He said he was unwell, and that it grieved him, and that he had known the man since they were boys of nine at the same school. He listed the sleeplessness, the tremor of the hands, the loss of appetite. He said, with real tenderness, that Matthias had not been able to feel the cold since August. He said that the master of the Hall went down to his cellar every night at midnight, alone, and stayed until three.
“And speaks,” said the doctor, gently, “to his jars.”
Nobody breathed. I looked at the fire.
“Miss Whitlock,” said Mr. Pruett. “You are the children’s governess. I shall put some questions, and you will answer them as you would before a magistrate. Has Mr. Caldwell ever struck either child?”
“No.”
“Raised his voice?”
“I have not heard him raise it. He lowers it when he is angry.”
A scratch of pen from the stool. I saw the clerk’s hand then, as I had been trained to see hands, and I noted the pen was held too upright, almost like a skewer, with the wrist stiff, forming each letter as if from a printed copy. A clerk’s hand, the kind taught in a counting-house. I remember it only because I was looking anywhere but at Matthias.
“Does he wander at night?”
“He sits outside the nursery door, in the corridor, with a rug. He counts the children’s breathing.”
Dr. Rainsford sighed, and made a small motion of his head, and Mr. Crane looked at his hat. I had, I saw, said the wrong thing in the right words.
“I believe,” I said, “that it is the most sensible thing any adult in this house does. Two children have buried a mother and two stepmothers. It is something that there is a person who sits outside their door.”
“Does he converse with persons who are not present?”
I had a great many answers to that, and I chose the least of them. “I have heard him say ‘That will do’ to a good many people who were present.”
Mr. Crane laughed. He could not help it; it burst out of him and he swallowed it, scarlet, and said, “Capital. I beg your pardon.” The clerk’s pen paused and went on. Mr. Pruett did not smile.
It is a skill, I have decided, to tell the truth in small pieces. A lie is one long thread, and you may be tripped on it. The truth is a handful of coins. You can lay them down one at a time and keep your hand shut over the rest.
“Mr. Caldwell,” said Mr. Pruett. “Have you anything to say?”
“I have a question for Edmund.” He spoke to the window. “You have listed my habits with great accuracy. I should like to know which of them you have seen.”
The doctor’s hand went to his pocket. “Why, my dear boy, I have it from Agnes, who sees you daily. And from my own observation. The tremor, you know. The hands.”
There was a sound at the door. Mrs. Dunning stood in it with a tray of tea she did not seem to have noticed she was holding. She was white to the lips.
“I have not signed anything, Mr. Pruett.”
“Agnes, my dear woman.” Mr. Crane lowered his voice to the pitch he used for horses and widows. “Nobody asks you to sign today. Only to see how matters stand.”
“I see how they stand. I shall sign nothing until I have heard the Troy man.”
“Dr. Hollis,” said Mr. Pruett, and turned a page. “A physician of long experience with nervous disorders, in no way connected with this family or this valley. I have written. He will examine Mr. Caldwell on Sunday next, at noon, in this house. If he certifies, and if the three trustees concur, the matter is settled. If he does not, it is not.” He shut the deed-box with a small, final noise. “Until then, nothing in the household changes. No servant is to be dismissed. No child is to be moved.”
“Six days,” said Mr. Crane, heartily. “Why, that’s hardly a week. We shall all be easy.”
“Miss Whitlock,” said Mr. Caldwell. He turned from the fire and looked at the four of them, one after another, and at last he looked at me, and I saw that his voice, when it came, was not meant for the room. “Miss Whitlock is my children’s governess and my witness. She will remain in this house. That will do, gentlemen.”
They went out in their order. Mr. Crane clapped him on the shoulder, hard, and said, “Capital, my boy, capital,” as if something had been settled. The clerk went last, with his long neck bent over the notebook, blotting a line.
When the door closed Matthias sat down, in his own study, in front of his own fire, for the first time in my experience of him. He put his shaking hands on his knees and looked at them.
“Six days,” I said.
“Six days and three hours.” He did not look up. “Eleanor.”
“Yes.”
“Edmund said jars.”
I had to think a moment. “I heard him.”
“I have been going down to that vault for nine months. In all that time I have said the word jars to no living soul. I have not said it to Agnes. I did not say it to Barnabas. I have not said it,” and here he did look up, and his eyes were quite dry and frightening, “to Lavinia, until last night.”
The fire cracked. In the corridor a floorboard gave, as it does under a person who is trying not to be heard.
“Then somebody in this house told him,” I said.
“Or somebody has been standing in my cellar passage for a very long time.” He rose. “Come. I should like to know who has been standing at which door.”

