“You should not be here,” I said, to the fingers.
“I am aware of that.” Her voice came in pieces, as though she had walked a great way with it in her mouth. “I came by the river path. It is three miles and a quarter. I counted. Teel lent me his coat and did not ask a single question.”
I got off the cot and knelt at the window. She was crouched on the gravel on the other side of the bars, a grey shape in a man’s greatcoat, her cropped head bare and her breath standing up in the lamplight. I could see her hands. They were blue.
“Go back,” I said. “Please. If you are seen, they will know, whoever they are. They will know on the day they would least wish to.”
“They know now.” She said it very calmly. “Somebody rang that bell on purpose on Sunday night, Eleanor, to tell us that the cellar was no longer a secret. I have been thinking of it for five days. Whoever rings a bell wishes it to be heard. I am tired of being dead to people who have already decided I am alive.”
“It is a charge of obtaining a situation by false pretences. I wrote that character in my own name. I shall plead.”
“You shall not.” Her fingers closed on the bar. “You will not go to prison for my hand. I wrote it. I pinned the slip. I chose you in the dark and I did not ask you, and I have let you be called a forger for a week in my own house.” The thread of her voice shook and held. “I have made one decision for another person in my life, and it was Matthias’s, and look.”
“Lavinia, the poisoner will have seen you by noon.”
“Then let him see me by noon, in a Grange hall, with sixty witnesses and the Squire. Let him see that I am a woman, and not a cough in the wall.” She was crying, I think, though one could not tell by the voice. “Mrs. Boyce is a good woman, and Teel has told her. She has a cupboard under her stair. I shall sit in it until ten o’clock. Do not argue, Eleanor. I have practised the argument for nine months and it is perfect.”
I put my hand through the bars and she took it, and her fingers were like ice, and I held them until the guttering of the lamp.
The Tarrow Landing Grange is a long wooden hall with a stove at each end and a platform at the back, where on summer Saturdays they hold the dance. On Saturday the fifteenth of November it held the whole of the village, and a good part of the road. They sat on the benches in their Sunday black, whispering, with the look that comes over a people who have been given a play. I counted a hundred and four. I saw old Mr. Spurr in the third row, and Mr. Boyce with his new boots. I saw Mr. Crane in the front, large and red, with his hat on his knee. I saw Dr. Rainsford beside him, paler than usual and patting his pocket. I saw Matthias, in his dark coat, on the aisle, with Mrs. Dunning on one side of him and Rosalind on the other, her ledger on her knee.
I stood in the dock, which was a railed square of floor, with Constable Dobbs breathing on my left.
Squire Hobart Pell was a stout old farmer with a white beard and an ear trumpet, which he laid on the table before him like a sidearm. Mr. Pruett rose and said the whole of it in eleven minutes: a character forged in the name of a deceased lady, employment obtained thereby, children placed in the care of one who had lied at the door. Dr. Rainsford testified, with a handkerchief, and read his friend’s letter from Troy. Mr. Crane testified that he had always thought Miss Whitlock a pleasant girl. They were very kind.
“Prisoner,” said Squire Pell, into his trumpet. “How do you plead?”
I had a speech. I found that I did not need it.
“I copied the hand of Mrs. Harriet Lyle of Troy, sir,” I said. “I wrote a draft in her name, in October, to get a place, and it was a bad forgery and a worse lie. I plead guilty to that. But the character that was read at Blackwater Hall was not mine. I did not write it. I did not know it was there. I should like the court to hear the person who did.”
“The prisoner proposes,” said Mr. Pruett, “to call a dead woman.”
“Not a dead one,” I said. “Not exactly.”
Behind me, at the far end of the hall, the great door opened.
I did not turn. I saw it in the faces. I saw it go along the benches, one after another, as the wind goes through a field. A woman in the fourth row put her hand over her mouth. Mr. Spurr stood up slowly, with his bad ear to the door, and said, quite loud, “That is the stone,” and sat down again.
She came up the aisle in Teel’s greatcoat, with her cropped hair bare, so thin that the coat moved before she did. She walked slowly. At every third step she looked at the floor, and then up, as if she were counting. She stopped at the railing.
“Squire Pell,” said Lavinia Caldwell. “I wrote the character at Blackwater Hall. I am the mistress of that house. I read four applications and chose one. I wrote the letter in the name of the late Mrs. Lyle, whose amanuensis I was for four years and whose hand I wrote by her leave. I should like it entered that no one was deceived by it but myself.”
For a moment nobody breathed. Then the hall went up like a flock of rooks.
I saw three things. I saw Matthias on his feet, without a word, with his hands at his sides, quite white. I saw Rosalind, who did not rise, but sat as straight as a post and said, perfectly audible in the din, “Nine months and twenty-seven days.” And I saw Dr. Rainsford. He had gone the colour of candle-wax. He stood, and went out into the aisle with his arms held wide and said, in a voice that broke on the first word, “Thank God. My dear Lavinia. Thank God.”
“Edmund.” She did not step back. She lifted one blue hand, flat, as one stops a horse. “Please do not touch me. I have not been touched by a kind hand in some time, and I find I am out of the way of it.”
He stopped. His arms went down. He looked, I thought, like a man who has been handed a gift he did not order, and does not know the price of.
It took the Squire a quarter of an hour to restore order, and he did it with his trumpet, on the table. When he had done he asked Lavinia a number of questions, and she answered each in the voice of a schoolmaster’s daughter, and it was a pleasure to hear. Then he took off his spectacles.
“I am a farmer, Mr. Pruett,” he said. “I have heard a good many laws read. I never heard of one that makes it a fraud for the lady of a house to choose her own governess and write her a good character. The man has not been deceived, for his own wife did the hiring. The children have been well taught, I understand. Nobody has lost a penny.” He put the spectacles on. “Dismissed. And I hope Miss Whitlock will be paid for the days she has sat in my lockup.”
Dobbs unlocked the rail with his hat in his hand.
I stood in the open space, and it was Mrs. Dunning who rose.
She came out of the bench into the aisle with her keys at her waist, like a ring of small bells, and she wiped her hands on her apron once, slowly, in front of a hundred and four people.
“Squire. If it is to be entered, it had best be entered right.” Her voice was entirely steady. “Mrs. Caldwell was in my keeping in the ice keeper’s rooms under the Hall, from the nineteenth of January. I put her there. I fed her. I told no one, not the master nor the children nor any person, and I did it alone. She was not drowned. I let the village bury a stone.” She turned and held out both wrists to Constable Dobbs, palms up, as if for a pair of gloves. “You will want me, I think.”
Dobbs, God help him, burst into tears, and took her.

