Sheriff Colby was a long, mild man who looked like a deacon and read like a clerk. He stood in the doorway of the workroom with his hat in his hand and read the docket book for eleven minutes without speaking, and then he looked at the casks and said, “Mr. Caldwell, you are going to tell me you did not sign this.”
“I am going to write my name, Sheriff, and you may lay it beside the book.”
He did. Matthias wrote on the sheriff’s own notebook, with the sheriff’s pencil, in the square, careful hand I had seen on a hundred labels in the vault. Beside it the signature in the ledger leaned forward and flourished, like a man who had never been refused.
“A man may alter his hand, Sheriff,” said Mr. Pruett, from the back. He had a folded paper in his glove, which he held out. “I received this under my door at the inn at midnight. It was unsigned. I thought it my duty.”
Look in the third ice house. The hand was upright and built, every stroke lifted. Lavinia and I looked at one another and did not say it, and I saw Mr. Wren was not with them.
“Somebody wrote to you in the dark,” said the sheriff, gently, “and you came, Mr. Pruett, with the law, to the owner’s own stores, at dawn. And somebody else wrote a name in a book.” He closed it. “I shall take the casks and this under seal. I shall want the cellar jars Dr. Rainsford spoke of. After the doctor from Troy.”
“After,” said Matthias, “by all means.”
Dr. Ambrose Hollis was small and bald and brisk, with a snuff-brown waistcoat and eyes like a bird’s, and he did not shake hands, because he had decided at the station that nobody in the valley could be trusted with a hand. He examined Matthias in the study at noon, with the three trustees’ chairs in a row and Mrs. Dunning’s empty one among them, and the Sheriff by the door. He took an hour.
He put a pin to the soles of Matthias’s feet and the tips of his fingers. He struck a tuning-fork and laid it on his knuckle. He had him shut his eyes and touch his nose, and walk a line of chalk, and grip a spring balance, and say the months backward. He asked a great many questions in a voice of dry delight, and at the end he put the pencil behind his ear.
“Glove and stocking,” he said. “Loss of feeling to the wrist and ankle on both sides, tremor, weakened grip, white lines across the nails. Mr. Caldwell, who is your physician?”
“I am,” said Dr. Rainsford, from his chair.
“What have you given him?”
“Fowler’s solution. Ten drops, nightly, in milk. It is the safest tonic in the pharmacopoeia.”
“It is also arsenic.” Dr. Hollis said it as another man might say Tuesday. “May I see the draught?”
I had it ready. I laid two small brown bottles on the desk, one Monday’s, one Tuesday’s, with its upright label, and a clean copper strip from my pocket, and a cup of spirits of salt from the scullery. “That one is cold tea,” I said. “That one is not.”
Dr. Hollis dipped his strips, and held them over the lamp, and talked about the weather in Troy, and in twelve minutes the one strip was bright and the other the colour of a dove’s breast with a violet edge.
“That is not Fowler’s solution in any strength a physician would own,” he said. “Dr. Rainsford. Did you write this label?”
Dr. Rainsford had gone grey. He took the bottle, and turned it over, and read it. I watched his lips move.
“That is not my hand,” he said.
“Write me a line.”
He wrote one, on the sheriff’s notebook, with a hand that leaned and looped like a man bowing, and underneath it the other lay, stiff and upright as a fence. Nobody needed to compare them.
“I never wrote it,” said Dr. Rainsford, and his voice cracked on the second word. “Matthias. As God hears me. I give ten drops. I have given ten drops for twenty years.” He put his hand to his breast, where the pencil was, and patted it and patted it, and I could not tell whether it was the gesture of a liar or of a vain man who has discovered that he has been made a fool of in front of the county. I think, I still think, that it might have been both.
“Then somebody has been using your name,” said Dr. Hollis, “which is a matter for the Sheriff, and not the Faculty.” He turned to the three chairs. “Gentlemen, and Mrs. Dunning’s empty chair, I certify nothing of the kind. This is a man being poisoned, and not one being mad. The tremor is arsenical neuritis, as surely as I am Hollis, and a condition I have seen before, among the eaters of arsenic in the Styrian hills. I should add that he is a good deal better than he ought to be, and that somebody, I take it, has been feeding him rust.”
“Iron hydrate and magnesia,” I said. “With milk.”
“Your doing?”
“My father’s.”
“Your father,” said Dr. Hollis, “is a man I should have liked.”
Mr. Pruett rose. He was not a stupid man. “The cellar, Doctor. Sheriff Colby has searched the cellar this morning. Jars labelled with the initials of three dead women, a ledger of notes, a bench of powders. I submit those are not the property of a man who is merely poisoned.”
“Show me,” said Dr. Hollis.
They brought the ledger up in a pillowcase. He read it standing, in the window light, and he read it all, and I saw him come to the line about pennies and stop. He took off his spectacles.
“I have examined a good many madmen’s notebooks, Mr. Pruett. They are generally very sure of themselves. This is the book of a man apologising to the dead.” He shut it. “I should be glad to certify Mr. Caldwell sane. I find I am not sure I can say as much for the rest of us.”
Mr. Crane stood up then. He was purple, not red, which I had not known was possible, and he opened his mouth, and for the first time in my acquaintance with him nothing came out. “My boy,” he said. “My boy. I never—”
“Mr. Crane,” said Sheriff Colby, mildly. “If you would be so good as to call at my office tomorrow at nine, with the company’s books. And the fourth key.”
They went in their order. Dr. Rainsford went last, weeping, without his hat.
That night Rosalind sat on the end of my bed with her ledger, and wrote, in red ink, with a flourish: Miss Whitlock, 18 days and the first to be arrested. Record. “It is not a thing I intended to enter,” she said. “But it is accurate.” She put a gold star beside it, which I have not earned and mean to keep.
At midnight Dr. Hollis sent for me to the scullery.
He had borrowed the apparatus from the vault, the flask and the bent tube and the spirit lamp, and he had set it up on the scrubbed table with the care of a man performing a rite. A sample of Matthias’s water, taken at nine that morning, was cooking in the flask with zinc and acid. The gas went through the tube, over the flame. On a cold white saucer held against the jet there formed, as I watched, a dark and perfect mirror.
“Arsenic,” said Dr. Hollis. “Metallic. It is a good bright one. That means fresh. Not Tuesday’s and not Monday’s, Miss Whitlock. This man has swallowed it within the last twenty-four hours.”
“That is not possible. We stopped the draught on Monday.”
“Then tell me what he has swallowed since yesterday.”
I told him. The rust-and-magnesia, three times, from my hands. Milk from the jug in the kitchen. Tea, which I poured myself. Bread. At the Hall, nothing from a stranger. Birdie’s pie. Birdie’s suppers. A tin of cocoa that had come by the Troy post on Friday, without a card, and been put in the pantry.
“Without a card,” said Dr. Hollis.
“Honora wrote,” I said, and I heard my own voice go quite thin. “Do not take what is given you.”
He looked at the black mirror a very long time. Then he looked at me, and not unkindly, and said what I had been afraid to say to myself.
“Either someone in this house is feeding him, Miss Whitlock, or you are.”
I stood in the scullery, with my hands on the cold table, and thought of every single cup I had carried up the stairs to him, and every one had been made by me.

