The Coroner of the county was a thin, wheezing man named Tobias Quill, who had held inquests in kitchens and barns and, once, he told us, a hearse, but never in a dining room with a blue-rimmed teacup laid at the head of the table. He asked Mrs. Dunning’s girl to take it away. Birdie carried it out in both hands, as if it might wake.
Six men of the Landing sat on hard chairs for a jury. Sheriff Colby leaned in the doorway. Mr. Pruett sat at the far end with his papers squared, and his clerk’s stool beside him was empty. Matthias, who had been poisoned eleven hours before and had not told a soul but three, sat very straight with his hands behind him. Dr. Hollis stood at his shoulder, pretending to look at the wallpaper.
Mr. Barnabas Crane, who had been ordered to the Sheriff’s office at nine with the company’s books, had not come. Nobody had yet said so aloud.
“Mrs. Caldwell,” said Mr. Quill, and wheezed. “You will be sworn. I am bound to say that I have never in thirty years been asked to bury a verdict.”
“Then it is time you had the practice,” said Lavinia.
She stood at the foot of the table in a grey wool dress of Mrs. Dunning’s, taken in at the waist with pins, with her cropped hair brushed flat and her hands folded, and she did not look at her husband once. I thought she had never been so plain, and never so formidable. She took the oath. Then she told them.
She told them she had been ill from the October before, and afraid, and had not known of whom. She told them she had walked to the open cut in the river ice on the night of the nineteenth of January in a shawl and one boot, and left the shawl and the boot where they would be found, and walked back along the shore in the dark with the other boot on, and been let in by a cellar door. She said she had not done it as a wise woman would. She said she had done it as a frightened one, and she did not ask the jury to call it anything else.
“Who helped you?” said Mr. Quill.
“Mrs. Dunning. Because I asked. She has never in her life been able to refuse a person who is hungry or afraid, and I knew it, and I used it.” She paused. “I would like that entered.”
“It will be entered,” said the Coroner, kindly, and did, in a hand like a bent pin.
The six men looked at each other and at the floor, and the foreman, a red-necked blacksmith in his Sunday coat, got up and said he did not know the form of words but the lady was plainly not drowned.
“There is no death, therefore no inquest,” said Mr. Quill. “The stone in the churchyard will be corrected at the parish’s expense. Mrs. Caldwell is living. Gentlemen, I am obliged.”
I let my breath out. It was Mr. Pruett who spoiled it, as I had known somebody would, and he did it as he did everything, like a ledger shutting.
“If the Coroner will permit. There is a matter touching the late Josiah Caldwell’s will which I had no occasion to read to this household last Monday, there being then no occasion.” He unfolded a sheet. “Item the sixth. Should the master of the Hall die, or be adjudged unfit, and a lawful wife of his survive him, such wife shall be guardian of his children and mistress of the Hall, and the trustees shall serve as her advisers and not as her masters.”
Nobody spoke. Lavinia’s chin lifted a very little.
“The third Mrs. Caldwell was thought dead,” said Mr. Pruett, “and so the item lay dormant. It is no longer dormant. I put it to the Sheriff that a woman who has lived ten months in this house, in secret, with the freedom of the cellar passage, who has by her own admission written another person’s name for four years, and who has now come back from the dead at a moment when her husband is dying of arsenic, is a person with an interest.”
“Mr. Pruett,” said Matthias.
“I am not accusing the lady, Mr. Caldwell. I am describing her.”
I got to my feet before I knew it. I had the brown wrapper in my reticule and I put it on the table in front of the Coroner with the twine still on it.
“That came with a tin of cocoa on Friday,” I said. “It is arsenic. The address is in the swan-necked hand that Mrs. Caldwell wrote in Mrs. Lyle’s name for four years, and it is not her hand. It is mine. I copied it from her letters and made two mistakes, which are on the wrapper, which anybody may see who has looked at my draft. I surrendered my draft to Mr. Pruett in front of this household on Thursday.”
“You are a confessed forger, Miss Whitlock,” said Mr. Pruett, not unkindly. “Which does not help us. Two forgers in one house, Mr. Coroner, one of whom admits it with a certain pride, and each of whom is now the other’s alibi.”
“I was in the lockup on Friday.”
“So you were.” He folded his hands. “It is an admirable alibi. I have often noticed that the people who are best able to account for themselves are the ones who had somebody else to hold the pen.”
It was a good stroke. Sheriff Colby said mildly, from his doorway, “The draft, Mr. Pruett. Where did it go?”
For the first time that morning Mr. Pruett did not answer at once. He took out his handkerchief and touched his upper lip.
“I gave it into the keeping of my clerk, Mr. Wren, on Thursday afternoon, for the court file.”
“Then I would like a word with Mr. Wren.”
“So should I, Sheriff.” Mr. Pruett put the handkerchief away. “He has not been seen since Saturday night. His bed at the inn has not been slept in. I had meant to mention it after the Coroner had done.”
I think there was one beat when every person in that room looked at the empty stool.
“Squire Pell will hear my petition on Friday at ten,” said Mr. Pruett, rising, “for the lady to be held on suspicion until the matter of the poisoning is cleared. I have no wish to be hard, madam. I wish it understood that the law is not.” And he bowed to Lavinia as a man bows to a dead woman who has been inconsiderate enough to get up.
They let Agnes out at four.
Matthias had put up a bond of a thousand dollars, and Sheriff Colby had said it was irregular, and taken it, and Constable Dobbs brought her to the front door in the gig himself, weeping into his red moustache. She stood on the step in her black bombazine with a bundle in her hand and her keys gone from her waist. She had never looked so small. I did not know until that moment that I had been afraid she would not come back.
“You are four days late,” said Rosalind, from the stair. “You said supper on Saturday. That is inaccurate.”
“Well now,” said Mrs. Dunning, and wiped her hands on her apron, which was not there. She wiped them on her skirt instead. “So I did.”
“Is it a rule or a suggestion,” said Fitch, “that you come home?”
“It is a rule, my lamb.”
She was in the kitchen inside the quarter hour, taking down a pan. I took it away from her and told her about the Three-Hand Rule, and she looked at me, and at Birdie, and then she sat down in her own kitchen chair and put her apron over her face and laughed until it turned into the other thing. Nobody told her to stop. Birdie put the kettle on and watched it.
That night I sat up in my little room off the nursery with the door open the width of a hand, and the candle, and my father’s watch. At a quarter to one a sound came from the corridor side of the nursery. Not a footstep. A small dry scratch, like a mouse’s, and then nothing.
When I got there, with the candle, a folded paper lay half under the front door. Thin blue paper, the colour of skimmed milk. I opened it standing up. The hand was round, and uphill, and unmistakable, because I had read it nine times in one night and could have said it in my sleep.
Ask Barnabas who held the lantern. Look in his stove. H.
I counted the windows, which is what I do. There are seven. Then I counted the words, which is what I do when I am truly afraid, and there were ten, and a letter, and every one of them was an errand.

