Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 85

The Examination

Justice Orne of Greenfell had a voice like a hinge and a rule that nobody should speak in his court who could be made to write it down instead, and on Monday morning he sat under the county seal with a quill behind his ear and looked at Matthias Caldwell as though he were a document with a smudge.

It was not a trial. I want that clear, because Rosalind asked me on the train, very seriously, whether Mr. Crane would be hanged, and I had to explain the difference. It was an examination, held in the open courtroom on the first floor of the Greenfell Grange, a long, cold, panelled room that smelt of wet umbrellas and cigar. The District Attorney, Mr. Welland, a tidy young man with a cough, was to ask the Justice whether there was cause to hold Barnabas Crane and Judith Caldwell for the Anatomy Act and for what the clerk’s paper called “a conspiracy to conceal a death.” The gallery was full. I sat at the back, between Constance and Mr. Boyce, who had come in his muffler on the principle that a witness is not obliged to be in the box to be correct.

The first witness was Dr. Hollis, and he gave it plainly. A twist of blue sugar-paper, containing about a drachm of white granular matter, had been handed to him on the fifteenth. He had tested it by Reinsch’s method, in the presence of a magistrate’s officer, with a bright copper strip and spirits of salt. The copper had taken, in nine minutes, a film of grey-violet. He held up a slip of copper in a glass tube to prove it.

“It is arsenic,” said Justice Orne.

“It is a white arsenic, sir, in a quantity sufficient to kill four adults.” Dr. Hollis cleared his throat. “I should add that the test was devised, conducted, and in the first instance read by a young lady whose father was an apothecary in the city of New York. I merely signed my name.”

“She is not in the witness-box.”

“No, sir,” said Dr. Hollis. “She is in the gallery, being modest.”

A hundred heads turned. I looked at my hands. Constance, beside me, pinched my arm so hard that I had a mark till Wednesday.

Mr. Crane was next. I had not seen him since December, and I was shocked. He had lost two stones, and the ruddy colour had gone from his cheeks and left them in loose folds, and he held his hat before him in both hands like a man at a graveside. The great loud generous voice had shrunk to the voice of an old man. He took the oath. He said that he had been a general manager of the Caldwell Ice and Cold Storage for twenty-six years, and that he had shipped, at Josiah Caldwell’s order and afterward, some forty boxes a year of unclaimed dead from the Albany and Troy dispensaries, on the ice, to the anatomy schools, and had never thought of it as anything but a trade in the way of the world.

“And on the seventh of March, 1881?”

“I did as I was told,” said Mr. Crane. “By a note. In the master’s hand, as I thought.”

“Whose hand?”

“Mr. Matthias’s.” He flinched. “I know now it was Miss Judith’s. I did not read it twice. I never did, sir. A man gets used to being given a paper and putting his hat on.”

“You were present at the Hall on the evening of the sixth.”

“I was, sir, at the dinner. I sat on Mr. Matthias’s left.”

“Who else was at the table?”

“Mr. Matthias. Mrs. Adelaide. Miss Judith. Dr. Rainsford.” Mr. Crane stopped, and a long silence went through the court. “And a gentleman I did not know. Introduced as Mr. Stannard. He came in with the doctor, and I thought, a lawyer, at a Sunday dinner, it is not usual, and I held my tongue.”

“Describe him.”

“A big man.” He passed a hand over his forehead. “Beard. Spectacles. He did not say much. He ate nothing. And he knocked on the table.”

“I beg your pardon?”

“Twice, sir. With his knuckle, on the cloth.” Mr. Crane demonstrated, hesitantly, on the rail of the witness-box. Two small, quiet, deliberate taps. “When the mistress said grace. When she had done, he rapped, twice, as the old Dutch families do for luck. My own grandmother did it at Poughkeepsie. I said to myself, there’s a man who was raised in a Dutch kitchen. I had not seen it done in twenty years.”

I wrote it down. I could feel Constance writing beside me with a pencil stub on her glove.

“Mr. Crane,” said Justice Orne. “You are a very foolish man.”

“I know it, sir.”

“The jury will decide whether you are a wicked one. Stand down.”

It went on until the lamps were lit. Miss Judith Caldwell, in black, deathly pale, with her State Street parlour gone out of her voice, said that she had forged her brother’s initials on household papers for ten years because he never read anything and she was tired of being asked to look for his hat, and that she had ridden down the river on a box of ice in good faith, believing she was taking a dead woman’s wish to the College, and that she would not forgive herself. Justice Orne wrote it down. The District Attorney asked if she knew anything about the gentleman in spectacles. She said she had thought him a lawyer. She said, rather faintly, that he had been very civil, and that he had helped her on with her cloak.

And at four o’clock, the court having been told that the Hall had a document that bore on the sixth of March, Matthias Caldwell was called.

I do not think anyone in that room had ever heard him speak in public. He walked to the box in his black coat, with his bad right hand held against his chest, and took the Testament in the left, and said his name. And the Justice, who is not a man given to kindness, looked at him over his spectacles for a long moment.

“Mr. Caldwell. The District Attorney has a note, said to be in the late Mrs. Caldwell’s hand, to Mr. Abel Stannard. It has been identified by his widow. Will you read it to the court?”

“I will,” said Matthias.

He took the paper in his left hand. I saw him find the first line with his thumb, as he does, and I held my breath so hard that Constance turned her head.

“‘Dear Mr. Stannard,’” read Matthias.

His voice was clear and not loud. It carried to the back of the gallery. He read it slowly, as a man crosses a plank, every word set down square, and when he came to the sentence, “I think there is something in what I am given, and I am not sure what, and I do not wish to find out in front of my children,” a woman in the third row put her handkerchief to her face. He did not look up. He read, “‘He is a good man who does not read.’” He read it in the same voice, to the end, and gave the paper to the clerk. And then he stood in the box with both hands at his sides and did not say that will do.

Nobody in Greenfell Grange made a sound.

The Justice held Mr. Crane for the grand jury and discharged Miss Caldwell for want of intent, and said so with such a crack of his quill that three jurymen jumped. But it was the District Attorney who stopped us on the steps, in the early dark, with the snow coming down in big slow flakes under the lamp.

“Mr. Caldwell.” He was coughing. “A word. You will have noticed that I did not once, in that examination, ask who gained.”

“I noticed.”

“There is a reason.” Mr. Welland put up his collar. “A woman is poisoned in March of ’81, and her children are left a share of a very large fund, held by trustees, which has, as I have lately learned, been drawn on to the extent of thirty thousand dollars by a dead man’s name. I do not think it is a matter for the Anatomy Act. I think it is the Van Cuyler Fund.” He looked at Matthias. “Its lawyer, Mr. Oliphant of Albany, has refused me an interview three times. I believe he would see you.”

“Why me?” said Matthias.

“Because, sir,” said Mr. Welland, with a most unlawyerly grin, “you are the guardian of the persons who will inherit it. And you have just shown a county that you can read.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!