Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 13

The Examiner

Warren Ostrander shook my left hand because he had noticed that I had not offered the right.

“Cold?” he said.

“Since Wednesday.”

“I’m sorry to hear it.” He meant it, which was the first thing that worried me. He was fifty or so, with tidy gray hair, a rain shell zipped to the chin and the manner of a man who has delivered bad news in a great many conference rooms. He clicked his pen twice, as a man might cross himself. “I read your voicemail four times. The part I keep stopping on is the unit of measure. Most irregularities come in dollars. Occasionally in acres.”

“It came in persons.”

“So you said.” He set the banker’s box on the scale house desk and looked at the Dutch door, the stove, the framed Orders with the calendar finally pushed aside. Then he looked at Mrs. Pilcher, who had come in from the kitchen drying her hands on a dish towel, and he went perfectly still.

“Good morning, Mr. Ostrander,” she said. “You will have my file. I should save you the trouble. I am Edna Pilcher. I was declared dead in 1991. I find it has not taken.”

He opened the box. He took out a folder and checked the name on the tab against her face, and then did it again, as one does with a bill that seems too large.

“Define the unit,” he said, to nobody.

I will give Warren Ostrander this: he did not call anyone. He did not say fraud, which he must have been thinking, or hoax, or ask anyone to sit down. He took out a legal pad and asked Mrs. Pilcher whether she would be willing to answer some questions about 1989. She said she would be delighted. It was the first time in thirty-seven years anyone had asked.

By noon he had the whole afternoon planned like a deposition, and I let him, because it was something I understood. The box held the 1989 file, the petition, a number of forms, and a folder labeled A.C.-1915 in a clerk’s hand that predated the State’s typewriters.

“What’s a Receiver?” I asked, looking at the form on top.

“Hm?”

It was a single sheet, yellowed and mimeographed, headed RECEIVER’S CERTIFICATE. A blank for my signature.

“It’s been in the file since 1916. Every Examiner hands it to the next with a rubber band around it. Nobody has ever signed one.” He tapped it. “It certifies the Alder Compact as examined. I always took it for a joke. A rite of passage, like a hazing.” His pen clicked. “It’s not a joke, is it?”

“I don’t know yet.”

“That’s the first honest answer I’ve had since Columbus.”

We went to the church hall first. Pastor Reinholt had lent it to the people who had no kin to go home to, and I had been avoiding it. Folding cots lined the wall. There were sixty or seventy of them, the ones whose families were gone or never had been, and they sat over bowls of soup under a banner that said BREAD OF LIFE SUPPER, SATURDAY.

A woman in a long gray work dress was eating with great concentration, as though somebody might come for the spoon. A boy of twelve in patched overalls watched the clock above the door and then watched the other people watching it. Ostrander knelt by the woman and asked her name.

“Hester Lind,” she said. She had a high clear voice. “Mr. Gosnell took me for the Burn. I went in at the end of October.” She looked at the ceiling. “I think I’ve been twenty-eight a good while. Is it still 1917?”

He wrote that down, in full, with the date. When he stood his knees cracked, and I noticed that his hand on the legal pad had a slight tremor, and that he had not spoken in some time.

“Define,” he said quietly, and left it there.

We reached Carrick by two. Felix had the County Book laid out on the kraft paper like a patient, and he stood beside it with his hands clasped behind him, a man who wanted it known that he had touched nothing.

I turned to the last page of the roll. “Orrin Suter,” I said. “Look at the strike. Look at the ink.”

Ostrander looked. Then, because he was Warren Ostrander, he took out his phone and called the hospice at Carrick Memorial and asked, in the voice of a man ordering a part, for the time of death of an Orrin Suter, ninety-one. He listened and thanked them. He dialed the maternity ward and asked, in the same voice, whether a child had been born to a Suter family on Thursday.

“Wren,” he said. “Six pounds eight. Twelve-oh-four.” He lowered the phone. “Mr. Suter died at eleven fifty-six. His great-granddaughter was born eight minutes later. That’s the entry.”

Beneath the new name, in the small upright hand, the roll ran on to the bottom of the page. I counted with my finger, left-handed and silent, and the total at the foot of the column said what it had said on Thursday.

“I don’t believe in coincidence as a unit,” said Ostrander.

“Neither do I.”

“Then—”

At 2:09, by the vault clock, a line on the second-to-last page drew itself through a name. Kimball, Dorothea. Returned. All three of us watched it go. Felix made a very small noise, like a man closing a drawer on his own finger.

Ostrander’s pen did not click. He took out his phone again. The nursing home on Mill Street confirmed it in forty seconds: Mrs. Kimball, ninety-four, peacefully, a few minutes ago. At 2:14 the roll’s last line filled with the name of a child born at a clinic in Weller Township. He did not call to check.

“All right,” he said. “I accept that the record is real. I don’t accept what it’s a record of.” He turned. “May I speak to you in the stairwell, Auditor? Alone.”

It was cold in the stairwell, and it smelled of floor wax.

“I read your personnel file,” he said. “You carry a payroll garnishment from Carrick Memorial. Sixty-one thousand, four hundred and two dollars. Your mother’s final illness.”

“That’s private.”

“It’s a lien. It’s in the county’s own books.” He took a folded paper from his shell. “The State has a position open. Chief Examiner, Special Audits. Columbus. It would be yours by January on the strength of your reports alone. The department has a hardship advance for new hires with qualifying liens. It would clear this bill.” He held the paper out. “I’d recommend you without it.”

I looked at the paper. I looked at the sum, which I could have recited in my sleep. For three years I had been paying it a little at a time, as though every check were a stair, and the building had no top floor.

“Thank you,” I said. “I can’t.”

“It’s not a bribe.”

“It’s a gift from the man who’s examining my examination. A gift is a debt in a nicer cover.” “I’d have to put it in the workpapers.”

“Then put it in the workpapers.” He held out the yellow form instead. “Sign the Certificate, and let Columbus take custody. You’d be on the other side of this by Friday. Whatever it is. It would become the State’s problem.”

I took the form, and as I held it, I felt a slant of old pencil come up through the paper under my thumb. I turned it over. In the margin, in a faded copperplate I knew from the Association’s pages, it said: Do not sign anything.

Ostrander took off his glasses. He had seen it arrive. He said nothing for several seconds.

“That wasn’t there,” he said.

“No.”

“I intend to move on Thursday for custody of the records and closure of that parcel. I owe the public that much.” He put the glasses back on. “I’m not your enemy, Auditor. I’m simply the first person in a hundred and eleven years to show up with a form.” He turned to go, and then stopped on the stair, with a photograph on his phone. It was the Compact’s title page.

“One more thing. The signature. Josiah Pell. Any relation?”

“Pell isn’t unusual. There are thirty-one in the phone book.”

“The tick beside the sum,” he said, “is yours. It’s also his. Look at the tick by his name, on the page after.”

I did not need to look. My mother ticked every grocery list in green, with a bar through the stem. She said it was how a Pell checked a thing. I had thought it was her habit. I had thought it was mine.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!