I will not pretend that the supper was my idea. It was Frame’s, in the sense that he sat down, and Voight’s, in the sense that he pulled out the chair, and Teague’s, in the sense that Teague, after standing a full minute with the pen raised, put the notebook on the table and said, “I will enter that the Bailee, being in the room, was asked to supper by the Keeper, and that to refuse would be discourteous.” But it was mine, in the end, because I was the one who sent for the others.
I sent Felix up the stair with a note, and Dub after him with the coffee urn, and by two o’clock the room had begun to fill. I had not known it could. The table, which had looked so long, took everyone without a murmur, as a good table does, and the chairs, which had stood empty for two hundred years, seemed to shift on the brick, a quarter inch at a time, to make room.
Mrs. Pilcher came first. She came down the shaft on Dub’s arm and Junie’s, in her cardigan and her white gloves, with a covered basket, and she stopped at the door and looked at the table, and did not say a word. I watched her read the cards. I watched her read the one that said THE CLERK, beside a plate with a yellow pencil, and I saw her right hand, the black one, the one that wrote what the book wanted, lift from her side and open, slowly, palm up, as if it had been handed something.
“Mind the margin,” she whispered. It did not sound like her tic. It sounded like a woman asking whether she might.
“It is your place, Mrs. Pilcher.”
“I have written in a book at a desk for forty years,” said Edna Pilcher, “and nobody ever said I had a chair.” She sat. She took off the white glove from her left hand and laid it by her plate, and then, with a hesitation like a diver, she took off the right.
It was ink-black to the wrist, and it was still. She laid it in her lap, and she did not look at it.
Junie came next, and Cyrus and Felix, who had been sitting in the corridor like boys outside a principal’s office. They took the plain chairs, without cards, and Dub Hanratty, after a long, formal, mutinous silence, lowered himself into the last and said, “I have not sat at a table since my wife passed,” which was all that he said for an hour. Frame sat at Voight’s right, his napkin in his lap, with his hands folded, in the posture of a boy at his first dinner party. Voight sat at the Keeper’s place. I think it took him the better part of a minute to put his weight on the chair. When he did, the candle in its stick leaned toward him, a hair, and steadied.
Teague took the seat at the Recorder’s side, though the card was not Teague’s, and said only, “One exception. I do not eat.”
“You do,” I said.
“I have not,” said Teague, “for some time.”
“You ate in Vane, the night of the lanterns. A pickle.”
“It was a very small pickle.”
“Colleague,” I said, and Teague looked at me, over the candle, with an expression I will not describe, except to say that it was the look of a person hearing their title said aloud in a place where it had not been used. Teague picked up the spoon.
At half past five, Junie went up the stair again, and came back leading Mabel by the hand.
She was in the yellow gingham, in a white collar, with her hair in two braids, and her face was scrubbed and solemn, and she stopped in the doorway and looked at the room as a small child looks at a church. She had not been told. I had said only that there would be supper, in Carrick, and that she was invited, and that she should wear her dress. She walked to the table slowly. She read her card. She read the line beneath it, and put her hand to her mouth.
“That is my writing,” said Mabel.
“Yes.”
“I do not remember doing it.”
“No.”
“Did I do something wrong?” Her voice shook. “Am I in trouble?”
“No, honey,” I said, which was Dessa’s word, and not mine, and I did not know where it had come from. “You were setting your own place. That is not wrong. That is what a person does who has been waiting to be asked.”
She looked at the chair for a while. Then she pulled it out and climbed into it, and sat with her hands in her lap, and her feet not quite touching the brick. The candle leaned toward her, too.
And I took the chair on the other side of the table, the eighth, with the card that said THE GUEST, and the pencil addition in my mother’s hand, M. Pell, in absence. I did not sit in the ninth. I want that set down. I looked at the spoon, bent, with its crust of clay, and I did not touch it. I put my hands on the back of my mother’s chair, and said, to the room, to nobody, “I am here in her place. I am a guest. I would like to eat first.”
“It is a good rule,” said Voight, softly.
“It is my mother’s rule.”
“It is the table’s,” said Voight. “It is older than any of us. She only remembered it.”
It was Mrs. Pilcher who lifted the cloth from the loaf, and Frame who, after a long hesitation, lifted the lid from the covered dish, and the steam that came up smelled of onions and butter and thyme. There was a hot dish of chicken and dumplings, in a blue crock, and a bowl of green beans, and a dish of applesauce with cinnamon, and a plate of pickles, and cold milk. It was the supper my mother had made on a Tuesday in October when I was seven and had a fever. It was exactly that. I do not know how.
“It is not the Lender’s,” said Teague, very low, tasting. “It is not charged. I would say that it is not entered at all.”
“It is only supper,” said Mrs. Pilcher.
I ate. I will say that I have eaten, since I came to Alder, with attention and with fear, and I have eaten with a sense that every bite was a loan. I did not eat that supper with either. I ate it as one eats at one’s own mother’s table: with a dumpling on a fork and a vague sense of being forgiven. My arm lay on the cloth, in the candlelight, with the old green lines upon it. Nothing ticked. Across from me, Frame cried quietly into his napkin and went on eating, and Voight, at his left, put out one square, clean hand and laid it very briefly on the gray man’s sleeve.
No one counted anything. For an hour and a half no one in that room said a number. Dub told a story about the winter of 1978, when the courthouse boiler had frozen and Ferd Lutz had chipped it out with a ladle. Felix asked a question and was permitted to finish it. Junie, who does not like to be looked at, laughed out loud at the pickle. Cyrus said that he thought the loaf was sourdough and that the sourdough was older than the table, and Mrs. Pilcher said it was, and that she had the starter, and that she had always wondered where it came from.
At the end, when the dishes were pushed back and the candle had burned exactly no lower, Mabel put down her spoon. She looked round the table, at the faces in the gold light, the clerk, the keeper, the guest, the stationer, the man with the boiler. She folded her hands on the cloth and said, in her clear, hoarse, patient voice, to nobody:
“Thank you for having me.”
Mrs. Pilcher said, “Heard.”
And, at the head of the table, in the Lender’s place, with a sound like a long breath let go, the cover of the book lifted, of its own weight, and fell open.

