On Sunday afternoon the seven officers of Alder County sat down together for the first time in the county’s history, in a conference room on the second floor of the courthouse with a broken blind and a plate of grocery-store cookies, and for twenty minutes nobody could think how to begin.
It was Felix who had called it. He had sent a one-line notice on county letterhead, signed F. Bascomb, Acting, which said only: Terms. Sunday. 2 p.m. Please come. Every one of them had come. I sat by the window, as a private person, with the status of a guest who has been told to take notes and not to talk.
They were all there. Judge Dolores Kimmel at the head, in her cardigan, with the mug. Dale Whitcomb, the Prosecutor, forty-eight and soft, with the look of a man who has said no position so often it has begun to feel like a position. Sheriff Dub Ratliff, sixty-one, in uniform, a very large calm person with a mustache who sat sideways in his chair so as to keep an eye on the door. Lorraine Kopp, the Treasurer, in a red blazer, with a calculator she had not put down since Wednesday. Walt Hensley, the Recorder, seventy-three, thin, in a sweater vest, with the long face of a man who has spent his life looking at deeds and has learned from them the infinite patience of land. Morris Teague, the Engineer, sixty-six, who surveys the bridges. And Felix, at the foot, with the leather glove on his right hand laid on the table like a paperweight.
“I’ll start,” said Judge Kimmel, “because I have the least to lose and the most to say. Each of us has been read a term. By Office. It closes on the Long Night. I do not need to tell you what I think that means. I want to hear what you each think it means.”
“I think it means I’m going to die,” said Sheriff Ratliff, “in about a week, and nobody asked.”
“Dub.”
“I’m saying it plain, Judge. Somebody ought to.”
“It doesn’t say die,” said Lorraine Kopp. She had her reading glasses on her forehead and her calculator in both hands. “I’ve read it. I’ve read it nine times. It says Returnable. Returnable, the Long Night. I’ve been the Treasurer for twenty-two years. I know what returnable means. It means a thing lent and called in.” She laid the calculator down, very carefully. “I am not going to cry in front of the Sheriff.”
“I’d think less of you if you did,” said Ratliff, quite gently.
“I’ve got a will,” said Walt Hensley, to nobody. “I wrote it in 1994. It’s a good will. It leaves everything to a cat that’s been dead for eleven years.”
Dale Whitcomb said nothing. He was looking at the cookies. After a moment he put down the one he had been holding and said, in a voice that was not his usual one, “My father signed the 1991 petition.”
The room turned.
“Case ninety-one-PR-oh-one-fourteen. Edna Pilcher, presumed dead.” He cleared his throat. “He was the prosecutor. He signed for the county. I found it in March, in his files, with a note, in his hand: Do not look into this. I looked. I didn’t do anything. I told myself it was a clerical matter. When you came in, Auditor, in October, and asked for a county attorney’s opinion on an association’s charter, I said I had no position.” He looked at me. “I had one. I thought the position was that I’d rather not know.”
“Dale,” I said.
“I am not asking to be forgiven. I am saying that since last week I have a term, and I would like to spend it better.” He turned to Felix. “What do you need?”
It was, I think, the first honest thing I have heard a prosecutor say in a room. It went through the others like heat. Felix, who had been holding himself as straight as a nail, let out a breath. I watched his gloved hand open on the table.
“Quick question,” he said. “Does anybody in this room know how to carry a plank?”
It was not the answer anyone expected. Teague laughed, and then everybody did, and the laugh went round the table with a kind of clatter, and Sheriff Ratliff unbuttoned his collar, and Lorraine Kopp took the cookie plate and passed it round without a word.
We worked for three hours. I will not give every minute. I will say what I think the room decided, since I was not a party to it. They decided to be seen. Nobody had asked them to; it came up, as such things do, in the course of an argument about a bridge. Teague had walked the plank bridge on Saturday with a tape and a level and said it would take a crowd of two hundred, comfortably, and four hundred if they were fools, and a thousand only if they crossed in order and slowly. He had drawn a plan of a handrail. He had priced the rope. He had the face of a man who finds in the middle of a catastrophe, with enormous relief, that there is a part of it he can build.
“We cross first,” said Judge Kimmel. “Tomorrow. All seven. In order. In front of the county. With our hands out of our pockets.”
“Why first?” said Whitcomb.
“Because people watch the ones who go first,” said the Judge. “It is the only power we ever really have.”
It was Walt Hensley who spoke at the end. He had said very little. He had been sitting with his long hands folded and his eyes on the water-stained ceiling, and when the others were putting on coats he said, “I have something in the vault.”
“What vault?”
“Mine. The Recorder’s. It is in the basement, under the Common Pleas.” He took off his glasses and cleaned them on his sweater vest. “I’ve been going over the deeds since the Reckoning, and I haven’t slept. I wasn’t going to say. I wasn’t sure it was my place. But the way you said it, Dale. About the position.” He looked at Felix. “I would like the Auditor to see it. And the Examiner.”
The Recorder’s vault was behind a green steel door, like the vault under the elevator, with a combination lock Walt Hensley had set himself in 1979. It smelled of paper and radiator and old paste. There were forty-one rows of leather deed books on steel shelves, each a hundred years of Alder County’s land, numbered, indexed, in the ranked and faded hands of a century of clerks. He went to the fourth row and drew out a volume with a broken spine, and set it on the reading stand, and opened it to a page he had marked with a strip of newspaper.
“This is the deed,” said Hensley, “to the Reserve.”
It was dated October 9, 1915, the same day as the Article. It ran four pages, in a black-brown iron-gall ink gone the color of tea. I read it with my left hand flat on the glass. I have read ten thousand deeds, and I know the shape of a conveyance as I know a recipe. There was a legal description. There were the old metes and bounds: from a white oak, N. 14 degrees E. to a stone, and so on, round the twelfth parcel, a rectangle of one hundred and eighteen acres, across Sorrel Creek from Long Bottom. There was a consideration of One Dollar. And there was a grantee.
“Alder,” I read. “A person.”
“The Land,” said Hensley. “It is conveyed to itself. It is the owner of record. It has been since 1915. I looked at the tax duplicate: no taxes have ever been assessed. A person who owns himself cannot be taxed, in Ohio, by a rule of 1851. It’s still good.” He cleared his throat. “That is why the county has not been able to close it. The county does not own it. The Association does not own it. Nobody does. It is its own.”
“Who signed?” said Felix.
“E. Gosnell, trustee, for the grantor,” read Hensley. “The grantor is blank. It has been struck through. And—” He turned the book toward the light and put his finger at the foot. “A witness.”
It was in a faded, careful, upright round hand, the hand of a child taught to make each letter separately and to leave no space between the loops. It was green. The ink had gone so pale it was nearly the color of the page. I knew the hand. I had stood in a clearing, in the cold, and watched it come up out of a leaf.
Beneath the name, in the same hand, the witness had added her age, as a child will, to be exact. M. Gosnell. Aged nine.
I do not know how long we stood there. Somewhere above us, on the second floor, a radiator knocked. Mrs. Pilcher, who had come in behind us without a sound, had taken off her glove, and with her pale right hand she touched the margin of the page, and then took it away quickly, as if the ink had been warm.
“M,” said Felix. “Quick question. M for what?”
“Mabel,” said Mrs. Pilcher. She did not look at him. “Mabel Gosnell. The first Clerk’s daughter.” Her voice was very small. “She is not in any of the registers. She is not in the school roll. I have looked for her for thirty-seven years. I thought I had made her up.”

