On the third Thursday of December, Weller Township Community Church held its Christmas concert at three in the afternoon, and for a little under two hours nobody in Alder County counted anything.
It was Pastor Reinholt’s idea. He had put a note in the bulletin and a sign on the scale house door, and it said only: Come as you are. Bring a casserole if you must. No numbers. The pews had filled by half past two. The folding chairs came out of the basement. The children’s choir, which had eleven members and a piano teacher, stood in two uneven rows in front of the altar in red sweatshirts, and the Reinholt baby, six days old, slept in a basket on the front pew, in a knitted cap, with the grave unconcern of someone who has just heard her own term read and thinks it a reasonable length.
I sat in the fifth row with Felix and Junie. I had left my cold arm in the sleeve of the raincoat, and it hung there, quietly and almost companionably, like a bag of ice. The glove lay in my lap. Ray Truitt, thin, very tall, in a borrowed suit, sat at the end of the pew with his father. Abel had put on a tie. It was the first time in two weeks I had seen him laugh, and it was at something Ray said, and it was a surprised and ruined sound, like a gate that has not been opened since the spring.
The pageant came first. I will say only that the angel, a nine-year-old with a coat-hanger halo, forgot her line, and Mae Tackett, in a duck costume, said it for her in a clear carrying voice, to the delight of the whole church, and that Ollie, who had been cast as a sheep, ate the straw. Beth Ann, in the aisle, put her head in her hands. Nate Dillard sat beside her with his daughter on his lap, and I saw him look at the child’s upturned face, and look away, and wipe his eyes on the back of his wrist.
At four, the lights went down a little. Pastor Reinholt came to the front, with his collar and his reading glasses and a sheet of paper in one hand, and said that Mrs. Haskett had a piece to play.
She had a cane. She had never needed one in her life. She walked to the organ bench with it, on Valdez’s arm, very straight, in a green velvet dress with the enamel brooch, and she sat, and put away the cane, and adjusted her glasses with the unhurried care of a woman who has done this four thousand times. “It is a short piece,” she said, to the church. “Brahms. The second of the Intermezzi, from the opus one-eighteen. I am playing it on the organ, which Mr. Brahms did not intend. I am sure he would forgive me. I am a very old woman and it is a very old organ.”
There was a ripple of laughter. She smiled, and turned, and touched the keys.
I have no musical education. I will say what I heard. It began very quietly in a minor key, a gentle, falling, unhurried phrase, like a person walking home in the evening and thinking of something she has lost and is not sorry to remember. It was not sad. It was a sort of accounting. Each phrase set down a thing and moved on, and the next one picked it up, and added a little, and went on, and I began to understand, at about the third page, that it was a piece about a long debt, honestly kept, with all the entries neat. There was a middle part that rose, and brightened, and nearly broke into something like joy, and she played it with her bad hand trembling on the keys and her good one steady. Then the first phrase returned. It was the same. It was not the same. It had been paid for.
I was not the only one. Beside me Junie had put her face against Ray’s sleeve. Abel Truitt was looking at the ceiling beams with the expression of a man doing a sum he did not like. Down the pew, Felix had taken out his handkerchief and was not using it.
I looked round. I did not mean to. It is a habit of mine, in a room, to count the exits, and I found, in the very back pew by the door, in a charcoal overcoat with the collar up, a man alone, sitting with his gloves folded in his lap.
Ansel Kroeger was weeping.
He did not know it. I want to be exact. He sat perfectly upright, with his glasses on and his eyes on the organ, and the tears ran down his face and fell on his gloves, and he did not move, did not wipe them, did not sniff. It was the weeping of a man who is listening so hard he has forgotten there is a body attached. When the last phrase died, and Wilma lifted her hands, and the church held its breath, I saw him take off his glasses and look at them in bewilderment, as if he had found them wet.
Then everyone was clapping, and he was clapping, too, a little late and quite correctly.
I found him on the church steps at five to five. The light was going over the stubble, a long thin copper bar under the clouds, and the cars were starting up in the lot with their lights on. He was standing at the foot of the steps with his collar up. I stood two steps above him, which made us nearly level.
“That was a very fine thing,” he said, before I could speak. He had recovered himself entirely. “I did not expect it. I came to observe. I find I attended.”
“You’re welcome to stay for supper.”
“Thank you. No.” He gave a small bow. “I should not wish to complicate the table.”
“Mr. Kroeger,” I said. “I need to ask you something, and you’re under instruction to answer it.”
“Ask.”
“We found the Note. Last night. Box twelve.” I watched his face, and it did not change. “The definition of the standard has been cut out with a razor. The Lender signed with a Pell tick. And under it, in blue pencil, someone has written Examined. Who examines the Lender?”
He did not pretend not to know what I meant. I give him that. He looked up at the sky, which was going gray, and then down at his gloves, and then at me, with the calm, tired, unflinching look of a man who has been waiting some time for a particular question.
“The Lender is examined every January,” said Kroeger. “A report comes to my office. It is a single sheet. It is always in blue pencil. It says, in a hand I have never been able to place, one word, and a date.”
“Examined.”
“Yes.”
“By whom?”
“I do not know.” A pause. “I have wondered, for twenty-two years, whether it is a person. I have sometimes thought that if it is, I should like to meet her.” He took off his glasses and polished them on his sleeve, and I understood that he had meant the pronoun and did not know he had said it. “You would have made an excellent Factor, Miss Pell. I mention it as a compliment. I hope it is not a warning.”
“It might be both.”
“It usually is.”
He bowed again, and went down the gravel to the black car. I watched it go, and I stood on the step in the dusk with the horn due in thirteen minutes and the principal at ten thousand, seven hundred and ninety-eight, and the Land’s Note unpaid, and a man’s blue pencil on the back of a document, and I thought: it is very odd to be fond of a person you are afraid of.
Hester Lind was waiting at the corner of the church, in Mrs. Yoder’s late husband’s coat, with her hands folded. She had been standing in the cold, apparently, for some time. She had the patient, unsurprised air of a woman who has stood in a row since 1917, and she did not smile.
“Auditor,” she said. “Quick word.”
“Of course.”
“Tomorrow at the horn, the Land will answer the claim. Everybody says so. They say it will be allowed.” She turned her head, and the last of the light caught her face, a young woman’s face, thin and fine and tired. “I want to tell you something I know. I have stood in that field for a hundred and nine years, and I have heard it speak. It does not lie. It is not clever. It will tell you the truth. And the truth is that it owes us.” She took my sleeve, with a gloved hand. “But don’t let them tell you it can pay.”

