There is a county in southern Ohio that you can reach by state route, and a township in it that you can reach only by looking down.
We left Carrick at six on Saturday, the three of us in the county van, with Felix driving, Priya in the middle seat with a thermos and a road atlas she distrusted, and me in the back with a canvas bag of bread on my knees. It was nine degrees. The farms went by, white and silent under a night’s frost, and then there were hills, and the road began to turn on itself like a thing looking for its tail. By eleven we had stopped passing houses.
“Teasel County Reservoir,” said Priya, reading a brown sign. “State park. Boat ramp, picnic area, overlook. It says no swimming.” She turned in her seat. “Was the valley called Marrow Fork?”
“The township was.”
“Two hundred and eleven people,” said Priya, to nobody.
The overlook was a gravel lot on a bluff, with a split-rail fence, a trash can chained to a post, and a small log cabin with a green door, and a plume of white smoke going straight up from its stovepipe. Below the fence the land fell away to a long gray lake, frozen at the edges, black in the middle, between two ridges of leafless oaks. A mile out, a small round stone thing stood in the water.
“What’s that?” said Felix.
“A church,” said a man’s voice. “Or the top of one.”
He had come out of the cabin without a sound. He was sixty-six and looked it, a big heavy man with a gray beard, a canvas coat, a green park-service cap and the huge calm hands of someone who has spent a long time opening and closing a gate. His eyes were pale. They went over the three of us, the van, the bag in my arms, and stopped on my right glove.
“You’re the auditor,” said Odell Wheeler. “She sent a card.”
“Who?”
“It’s not signed.” He held it up between two fingers, a plain cream card. In the corner, in blue pencil, someone had written Examined. “Come in. It’s cold. I’ve got a stove.”
The cabin was one room. There was an iron stove, a cot, a table with a green checked cloth, three mismatched chairs and a fourth, tipped against the wall, as though someone had just left. On the wall hung a framed plat of a township, hand-drawn, yellow with age, with road names in a slanting hand. I looked at it. Marrow Fork Road. Wheeler. Lamp Oil Lane.
I set the bread on the checked cloth and unwrapped it. I said, as I had been taught, “Auditor Pell, with supper. To examine. One loaf, zucchini, one night, with thanks.” Then I stopped, appalled. “I didn’t mean thanks. Corley said not to say it. I’m sorry. One loaf.”
“You said it to the table.” Odell Wheeler smiled with half his mouth. “That’s the right place. Sit down. I’ll eat first.” He cut the bread with a pocket knife, and ate a slice standing up, slowly, with his eyes shut. “It’s good,” he said. “It’s been a while since anyone brought me a thing without a ribbon.”
I will tell it as he told it. It took an hour. He did not stop, and nobody interrupted.
He was eleven. It was the thirtieth of November, 1971, a Tuesday, a gray cold afternoon like this one, and his mother had sent him to town, nine miles, on the school bus’s last run, to buy a quart of lamp oil because the valley had no electricity yet and the Aladdin was dry. It was the first time he had been to town alone. He bought the oil, and a licorice whip with a nickel he had found. At the township line the bus driver stopped, and looked out the windshield, and said, Son, I think you better get off here.
“There was a road,” said Wheeler. “I’d been on it all my life. It stopped at the line. Beyond the line there was a hill, and woods, and the sky. No road. No smoke. I could smell supper.” He looked at the stove. “The horn was blowing. They had a horn at the mill. It blew and blew, and nobody was coming in.”
“How many?” said Priya, very quietly.
“Two hundred and eleven. I stood at the line and counted the chimneys, and there weren’t any.” He turned his head. “It was the Renewal Grant, ma’am. That was what they said afterward, the few that said anything. In the October the lady came. A Mrs. Lathrop. She had a red coat and a cake.”
“A cake,” said Felix.
“Yellow. Boiled icing.” Wheeler shut his eyes. “Everybody liked her. She knew the names. She had come to give the township a school roof and a mill wheel and a new bridge over the fork, forty-one thousand dollars, no strings, a thank you was all she wanted. Everybody said it. My mother did. I did. She gave me a licorice whip.” His mouth worked. “And then in November a man came from Columbus, an auditor, with a green pen. He asked so many questions that the trustees got frightened. He told them to wait until he’d read the file. They didn’t wait. There was a clause that said you could give it back. They thought it was a way out.”
I felt Priya go still beside me.
“They did it on the thirtieth, at four in the afternoon, in the schoolhouse. The three trustees stood up in front of the whole township, and said, We decline. Thank you, but we don’t accept.” He opened his eyes. “The horn went at four fifty-one. It was early. Everyone knew the horn went at five. It was a day before the note was due. It was a whole day early. It took the whole thing at the minute they said it. It took the township and all it carried, my mother, the Aladdin, the dog.”
“Because they declined,” I said.
“Because it was a refusal,” said Odell Wheeler, “in person, to the Grantor, of a gift. It’s called a return. And a thing that’s returned is a thing that’s due.” He put both hands on the checked cloth. “It isn’t a free look, ma’am. It’s a trigger. They put it in so you’d pull it.”
There was no sound in the cabin. The stove ticked. The lake was the color of a spoon.
My plan had been three lines in green on a legal pad. Decline in person. Return the unspent funds. Close the file. I had put a small neat tick beside it.
“It’s the free look,” I said. My voice sounded strange to me. “It’s the free look. I was going to use it. I was going to walk in on the fifth and hand it back.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“I would have been so careful. I’d have said the object and the date and the unit.” I stopped. “Mr. Wheeler, I’d have ended the county’s term at the minute I said it.”
“It’s why she came,” said Wheeler. “She’s not here to give it away. She’s here to see who refuses.”
“It’s not a footnote,” said Priya. She had both hands over her mouth. She took them down. “Rowan, it’s the whole instrument. We went through the arithmetic. We never read it for what it was for.”
Felix had not spoken. He had gone gray at the mouth, and he was looking at the empty fourth chair against the wall. “Mr. Wheeler,” he said. “Whose is that?”
“It’s for Corley, if he comes back.” Wheeler took the cap from his head and held it on his knee. “He ate at my mother’s table the night of the twenty-ninth, in the old house, and told her to wait. I’ve kept a chair for him fifty-five years.” He looked at me, and his pale eyes were quite steady. “He’s not in the lake. I looked for him for years. He wasn’t counted.” He paused. “I think he went the other way.”
“What other way?”
“I don’t know. He said, I’m going to see the lady.”
It was past two. I rose, and my knees cracked, and the old man rose with me, and he took my left hand in both of his, and held it a moment. “It’s a hell of a thing,” he said, “to be brought a loaf.” At the door he stopped, with his big hand on the latch. “I’ll tell you one more. I didn’t say it to the others.” He looked out, over the black lake and the round stone thing in the water. “I wasn’t in the schoolhouse. I was on the bus. But I saw her the next morning, at the township line, in a red coat, with a yellow cake in her hands, looking at the place where the road stopped. I was eleven. I remember her face. It was kind. It was so kind I couldn’t look at it.”
He opened the door.
“Same coat,” said Odell Wheeler. “Same cake. She hasn’t changed by a day.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!