The roofers worked only at night, and in eight nights nobody in Carrick had seen one of them eat.
I had noticed it on Wednesday. I had put it in the same place I put every small wrongness I had learned to notice that winter, a back pocket of the mind where it could wait for a second thing. The second thing came on Monday, when Priya, going through the crew’s paperwork for the grant file, found that the firm’s name, Harmon and Sons, Roofing and Restoration, Teasel, Ohio, appeared on no contractor register, had no license number and no insurance certificate, and had been paid, according to the check register, in advance, by the Public Department, for the entire job, in a lump sum of exactly one hundred nineteen nights.
“Nights,” she said, on the phone. “It’s in the unit column. Rowan, I’m looking at the invoice. They’re billing in nights.”
On Tuesday I went up to see them.
The courthouse roof was four stories over Carrick Square, a steep old hip of slate and copper with a cupola at the peak and a catwalk along the ridge. The scaffold had gone up in a day and a half, pipe and plank, wrapped in blue sheeting that snapped in the wind. At dusk a line of lamps came on along the planks, not work lights but kerosene lanterns, old brass ones on hooks, and the whole structure glowed under the sheeting like a paper lantern at a fair.
Felix and I went up the ladder at six, in our coats, with a thermos, and Hester Lind came behind us in the old gray cardigan she wore over everything, with her knitting in a cloth bag. She had insisted. “I know that stoop,” she had said in the square, looking up at the planks, with her hand on the ladder. “I’ve known it since nineteen seventeen. I can do the stoop in my sleep.”
They were on the north slope, six of them, in canvas coats and flat caps, on their knees along the pitch with hammers in their hands. They were laying slate. They laid it exactly, with the dull slow tap of men who have done a thing so many times that thought has gone out of it, and they did not look around. A seventh stood on the plank above them with his back to us and a tape in one hand, a tall lean man in a gray cap, and he did not turn.
“Evening,” I said.
The hammers did not stop. It was not rudeness. It was the way a field does not look up at a car on the road.
“I’m Rowan Pell. County Auditor. I’ve got coffee.”
I unscrewed the thermos and poured a cup. I set it on a plank beside the first man’s knee, a thick white mug with a chip, and the steam went up straight in the lantern light. He did not turn his head. The hammer rose and fell. The cup sat on the plank and cooled, and nothing about it changed, and I stood in the dark and understood that I could set down a hundred cups and not one of them would be touched.
“They’re not tired,” said Hester, softly, at my shoulder. “It’s not tired, dear. It’s thin.” She had her hand at her throat. “Look at the shoulders. That’s how you get to stand after a hundred years. You don’t use anything up. You only go on.”
“Is that how you were?”
“That is exactly how we were,” said Hester Lind. “We had a hoe, and a bad hip, and we never once wanted for anything, and we had no name.” She laid her hand on my sleeve. “Say something, Rowan. They can’t answer. But they can be told.”
I had Odell Wheeler’s list in my coat. It had come in the mail that morning in a plain envelope, two sheets typed on a manual machine, single-spaced. The names of Marrow Fork Township as they had stood on the school roll in the fall of 1971. Two hundred and eleven. At the foot he had written, in a big hand like a farmer’s, I have said these every morning for fifty-five years at the gate, and nobody has heard them. Maybe you can.
I unfolded the sheets. I held them under the lantern.
I will not tell you I knew what I was doing. I had read a name at a Dutch door at dawn with a cold hand and a crowd of forty. I had read three hundred at once. I had never read to a man with his back to me, on a roof, in a wind. I said it in the weather-report voice. I said it as Mrs. Pilcher says it. A plain statement, a name, a number, a full stop.
“Abbott, Edwin. Seventy-one.”
A hammer stopped.
“Abbott, Ruth. Sixty-eight. Abbott, Dale. Forty. Abbott, Janice, thirty-seven, and Abbott, Daniel, twelve.”
Another. A third. They did not look round. But along the pitch, a tap at a time, the little ticking tune of the slate began to come apart, as a clock does when a spring runs down, until a single hammer was left going on the north slope, slow and sure. The foreman on the plank did not move.
“Gaskill,” I read. “Gaskill, Everett. Thirty-eight.”
The tape slipped from his hand. It was a steel tape, and it ran out down the slope and rang on a scaffold pipe and hung there swinging in the lantern light, and the tall lean man turned.
I had expected a ruin. I had expected the face of a body that had been dead. It was nothing of the kind. It was a plain, pleasant, weathered face of thirty-eight, a long jaw, a small crooked mouth, a good deal of gray at the temples, and a pair of tired and very clear blue eyes. They looked at me. Then they looked at the paper in my hand, and at the lantern, and at Hester, in her cardigan, with her knitting, and at Felix, who had taken off his cap.
“That’s me,” said Everett Gaskill. His voice was rough, as a hinge is rough that has not been used. “That’s my name. That’s Gaskill.”
“Yes.”
“I wasn’t sure.” He passed a big hand across his mouth. “They don’t say it. We’ve got Harmon, the firm. It’s the name for the whole crew. I have been Harmon for a long time.” He swallowed. “She doesn’t say it either. The lady. She’s very good to us. She says thank you.”
“What for?” said Felix, very gently.
“She doesn’t say.”
“Mr. Gaskill, I’m Rowan Pell.” I stepped across the plank. My legs were not steady. “I’m the County Auditor. I’d like to ask you a few questions, and I’d like to give you some coffee. You don’t have to answer.”
“I’m not supposed to talk about the work,” said Gaskill. He said it in a flat, apologetic way, as one cites a speed limit. “It’s part of the arrangement. We stand a night, and we’re credited, and we’re not to say what for. They’re very particular about what for.” He looked down the slope at the five others, bent over the slate, tapping. “I’ve got a crew. I’m the foreman. I can’t tell them to stop.”
“Then don’t.”
“I’m not allowed to leave the roof.”
“I know. Nobody’s asking you to leave. I only want to ask you one thing.” I held out the list in my left hand. “Do you know Odell Wheeler?”
The face changed.
It was very small, the change, and I saw it as one sees a crack in ice. It was the face of a man who has been working a long time in the dark at a task so heavy he has forgotten it was ever a task, and has just been handed, quite without ceremony, a letter from home.
“Odell,” said Everett Gaskill. “Little Odell. The lamp-oil boy.” He put the back of his hand to his eyes. “He was on the bus. He was on the bus when we, when it happened. I saw it go by. Oh, God, I saw it go by on the road below the school, and I thought, there goes the Wheeler boy, he’s too late, he’ll be home for supper.”
“He’s sixty-six,” said Felix.
“Sixty-six.” The foreman’s mouth went crooked. “He had a licorice whip.”
“He keeps the gate,” I said. “At the overlook. He says your names every morning.”
“Every morning.” Gaskill stood very still. Along the slope the last hammer had stopped, and five men in canvas coats had straightened, one at a time, and turned their faces toward the lanterns with the slow bewilderment of sleepers wakened. “Every morning,” said Everett Gaskill. He turned, and looked at me with a terrible plain hope, and asked it in a voice like a boy of eleven.
“Ma’am. Did Odell get out?”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!