The confirmation letters went out Tuesday night by first-class mail, and by Wednesday noon the Alder County post office had run out of the green forms.
It is a standard procedure. When you cannot trust a number, you write to the person it concerns and ask them to say, in their own hand, whether it is right. Teague had drafted seven letters, one for each of the seven names, and she had typed the same sentence in each: The Examiner reports that on October 12, 2026, you were counted among seven hands owed. Please confirm or state exceptions.
“They’re going to be insulted,” said Felix, stuffing envelopes at the scale house oak table. “Quick question. Is it a form? Is it a form if it’s about being taken?”
“It’s the only form we have,” said Mrs. Pilcher, from behind the Dutch door, with a plate in her hand. “Mind the margin, Mr. Bascomb. You have stamped Dr. Valdez upside down.”
Teague had come out to Yoakum Crossing in a gray Ford sedan the color of a filing cabinet. She wore her flannel suit and rubber boots, which she had bought at the farm store in Carrick that morning and wore with enormous pride. She ate two slices of zucchini bread at the door before she would touch the Book. Mrs. Pilcher watched her do it with an expression I have only seen on women judging jam.
“Very good,” said Teague. “No exceptions.”
“Madam,” said Mrs. Pilcher, “I am obliged.” And she smiled, a thing she had begun to do with her whole face since January, and slid the saucer an inch toward our visitor.
I will say there is nothing in this world like watching a Factor of the Public Department take a second helping of a dead woman’s recipe.
The replies came in over three days. The first was Cyrus Eberly’s, on the back of a seed-company calendar, in his drafting hand. Confirmed as to the count of seven, he wrote. Exceptions as follows. One, the unit is not stated; seven of what? Two, the date. Three, the enclosed. He had enclosed a protractor.
“It’s a very good protractor,” said Teague, holding it up to the light. She seemed genuinely moved. “I shall return it.”
Nate Dillard’s came in a diesel-stained envelope. Confirmed, with exceptions. The exceptions ran to a page and a half, and the first one read, in block capitals, DO NOT SEND ME A FORM ABOUT THE WORST WEEK OF MY LIFE, and the last one read, in smaller letters, but I would have, if I’d been you. He had signed it twice.
Beth Ann Tackett wrote on lined paper in the careful print of a woman who has to fill in forms for two small people daily. Confirmed. Exception: please state whether the twins count. They are four. They were not taken, but they were counted by me at the time, and I would like it on record that I counted them. I wrote them down. She had drawn two small stick figures beside the line, and a round sun between them.
“That is a legitimate exception,” said Teague. She was crying a little, with great composure, into a paper napkin. “I shall have to find out whether it is Minor.”
Pastor Reinholt confirmed without exception and prayed for the reviewer. Dr. Valdez confirmed in Spanish and English and added a note about the reviewer’s blood pressure that Teague, to my surprise, said was probably correct. Wilma Haskett enclosed a program for the Easter cantata. Confirmed, she wrote. I do hope the examiner will come to the cantata. She will have to sit in the alto section, for the acoustics.
It would have been an easy week, and rather lovely, if it had been all that. It was not, because Teague was a reviewer, and she had written her finding before she had read a word of the mail.
On Thursday morning she laid it on the oak table in the scale house with Felix on one side of her and Cyrus, who had come to supervise his protractor, on the other.
“Finding S-1,” she said. “Significant. Do you want to hear it all?”
“I would like to hear it as you wrote it,” I said.
She read it in her clear voice. It took four minutes. On October twelfth, the Examiner stated “Seven” at the fence, with no unit. The Association’s Book carried a figure of seven under Hands Owed. The Row of likenesses numbered seven. Seven persons were later identified. The Examiner ticked the figure. Three different units, said Finding S-1, had been collapsed into a single count by a single tick: seven scarecrows, seven hands, seven persons. The three were not the same. The tick had not distinguished them. The tick had therefore made them one.
“I did not collapse them,” I said. “The Book did.”
“You ticked.” She said it with enormous gentleness. “You ticked beside a number that had no unit. I think that you did it because you were afraid, and I think that it was the best that anyone could have done at the fence. I think it was also the first act of the whole matter, and I think it matters that it was unsupported.”
“Is it Material?”
“It is Significant.” She smoothed the page. “It is one.”
Cyrus had picked up his protractor and laid it across the finding as if to measure the angle of the sentence. “It is a precise accusation,” he said. “I find that I cannot dispute the geometry.”
“It was one of three.” I looked at her. “You said they aggregate.”
“Three Significant, one Material. Yes.” She did not look up. “I have not found the others yet. I would not say I am looking for them.”
I think she meant it. I think that was the awful part.
The last reply came on Friday, in the afternoon mail, a long white envelope with Junie’s name on the return corner and the stamp placed crooked. I had not asked her to confirm, because she had not been counted in October; she had been counted in a pencil that I had never seen. I took it into the yard to read it by the elevator, in the cold, with my hand tucked into my sleeve.
Dear Auditor, it began. Respectfully, I do not confirm.
I read it standing up. I read it a second time sitting on the step.
I was not taken in October. I was taken on August 14th, at 11:40 at night, when Mrs. Pilcher’s hand wrote my name in pencil and I felt it. I felt it like a draft on my neck. I knew from the day my father went, on a page I could not see, that I would be the seventh. I told nobody. I have been counted since August. You did not count me. You only said it.
I looked up. Across the lane, Mrs. Pilcher stood at the Dutch door with her white gloves folded, and she was looking at me with an expression I had seen once before, on the first morning, over a saucer.
I went in. I put the letter on the table, in front of Teague, without a word.
She read it. She read it twice, with her lips moving. Then she took her blue pen and, very slowly, in the margin of Finding S-1, wrote a line. I read it upside down.
Exception noted. The seven were counted before the examiner counted them. Query: then what did the tick do?


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!