The Reading Room had eleven desks and a smell of pencil shavings. Tull put me at the one by the window, where there was a porthole of grey daylight, and left the other three on their feet behind me like relatives outside an operating theatre.
“A carbon,” he said, “is a Reader’s Copy. It is what the subject of a file is entitled to see. It is not the file. The file is the original, and it has things in it that the subject is not entitled to, and which the Reserve has not seen either, because Retention Review keeps them.” He placed a folder on the blotter. It was a plain buff one, quite thin. “I should say that I have read the carbon. I read all of them. I find that if I do not, I am not a good clerk.”
“Is it bad?”


