Cora Pyle told it at the yellow table over a pie nobody ate, with her coat still buttoned to the throat.
Her mother had gone into the hills in the fall of 1958. Hester Garrett was thirty-six, a tall woman with a laugh you could hear across a field, and that summer her youngest boy, Amos, had drowned in the millrace at nine years old. The sheriff said she had walked off in grief. The church said she had gone to her sister’s. Cora, who was fifteen, said nothing at all, and for sixty-eight years nobody had asked her to.
“I only know one thing about where,” she said. “Mama wrote on the kitchen wall, in pencil, three days before. MRS. H. GARRETT. I thought it was a joke. Later I found out there was a mailbox on the old mule road that carried the name.”
Silas set down his fork. “On the Mail Route.”
“Odell Tate’s route. I’ve left a letter in that box every Christmas since I was fifteen.” The old woman’s mouth worked. “Fifty-one letters. I tell her about the hens.”
Nobody spoke. June reached over and laid her hand on the claw of Cora’s hand, and Cora let her.
By afternoon Dovie had heard it through, at her own kitchen table, with her feet in a dishpan of hot water and her coat across her knees. When it was done she sat a long while with her eyes closed.
“Hester Garrett,” she said. “That’s a name I never had.”
“She went in alone,” said Silas.
“Then she went in on the other thing.” Dovie opened her eyes. They had lost their dryness since Saturday, and were a very bright, wet gray. “My mother had a word for it. The Borrower. Said it was the one thing in that Hollow that’s never lent a crumb and never once paid. It wears whatever voice it’s heard. It sat on my seventh night and called me Dove in Ruth’s mouth, and I have lived my life as though that was my sister.” She stopped. “Ruth said she never asked me down. I’ve turned that over all day, hon. And I can’t make it lie flat.”
“It sings in my voice,” said Silas.
“It’s learned you.” She lifted her chin. “It’ll offer you the fifth, all finished, clean as a whistle. A walker’s stave is the one he makes. Anything that hands you one is selling.”
They went up at dusk, five of them in a line on the old cart road, with Cade a little ahead carrying the porch lantern, and the frost already whitening the bracken. Cora walked between June and Dovie. She had insisted on coming and nobody had found a way to refuse her. She wore her church coat and carried her purse, and she looked at the oaks and the road and the wall of rhododendron at the Lip like a woman walking into a hospital.
“I don’t see anything,” she said.
“You won’t.” Silas knelt on the lip grass and put his palm to the first stone. It was cold as a plate. “Not till it hears me.”
He hummed the first five notes. The flat third.
The laurel breathed out.
Cold air rolled up the steps and the frost ring on the grass spread to a yard. The stair opened at the Lip, a pale cut through the dark, with mist lying on the seventh step like a hand. Behind him he heard Cora’s purse hit the ground.
“Oh,” said the old woman. “Oh, Mama.”
“Easy,” said Cade, to nobody, and lit the lantern off the cairn.
Silas stood. He had four staves in him and a closing verse, and he knew that was not enough. Four laid the rope down to the third stand. The fourth stand was where a woman in a cotton dress might be sitting, sixty-eight years in the dark. He needed a fifth.
The Hollow gave it to him at once.
“The stair goes down, and the stair goes down,” sang his own voice, from below. Clean and warm. “A name for every stone. I leave my light on the topmost step, and go in the dark alone.”
He felt it settle into him easy as a coat. The whole stave, four lines, with a hole at the end the exact shape of anything he wanted to say. It would have fit. It would have carried the whole Calling on its back.
It did not take a breath.
“No,” said Silas.
He said it low, to the dark, and felt Dovie go still beside him.
“That’s not mine.” He had to stop and swallow. “That’s not mine, and you know it. It’s got no breath in it and it doesn’t crack. You’re not the Hollow.”
The mist on the seventh step stirred. For a second the voice in his own throat said, patiently, kindly, in his own warm cracked G, the thing he most wanted: Si. Come down.
He shut his eyes. The lantern ticked.
He took a breath, a real one, long, low, with a catch in the middle of it like a rusty hinge. And he sang.
“The stair goes down, and I go down no farther than I’ve paid.”
It came out cracked and plain. It sounded like a boy at the back of a church. Behind him he heard June draw a breath of her own, in the gap, the way she had taught him.
“I hold the light for those below, and the bargain that I made.”
The blank came up in front of him like the edge of a cliff.
He had a hundred true things. He had a three-year tally of miles. He had a porch step. He reached for the smallest one, and it was the heaviest.
“I’m not leaving,” he said. “Not this time. I’m not going anywhere till he’s up.”
The Hollow rang.
It was a small bell this time, one clean tone, and it came up through his boots into the bones of his legs. The stair lit pale gold as far as the fourth stand, and the Borrower’s voice was gone in mid-word, as if somebody had pinched out a candle.
“Oh,” said Dovie, very quietly. “Oh, that’s the one.”
On the fourth stand, in the gold, someone had stood up.
She was tall. She wore a printed cotton dress and a man’s cardigan with the elbows out, and her hair was tied back in a rag. She held a coal-oil lamp, unlit. She looked up the stair at the little crowd on the lip, and Silas heard the old woman beside him make a sound like a door opening.
“Cora Jean?” said the woman on the stand. “Is that my girl?”
“Mama,” said Cora Pyle. “Mama, yes. It’s me.”
Silas turned his head. “Aunt Cora. Put your hand on my shoulder.”
“Mama,” Cora said again, and then, more softly, “Which shoulder?”
“Either.”
The old hand landed on him, light as a leaf. He felt the rope go taut between her and the woman below, thin and bright and old as anything in the world.
“Hold the light,” he sang, and June took the line and sang it back, level and slow, and under her Cade held the lantern high with both hands. “I’m a long way down tonight.”
They lined it out from the top, down the staves, backward, like rope hand over hand: the Sink, the Mail Route, the Ladder, Laurel Run. At every blank a voice from the fourth stand filled in, weathered and young and half a beat behind. Hester sang about the millrace. She sang about the boy. She sang it in a plain, hard, terrible voice, and her daughter wept on his shoulder, and Silas kept his eyes on the lamp and his breath in the gaps.
At the end of the first stave the Hollow gave a gentle shudder, like a ship taking a wave.
“Easy,” whispered Cade.
Then Dovie said, in a flat voice he had never heard from her: “There’s someone at the cairn.”
At the north end of the Lip, in the shadow of the split rails, stood a woman in a field jacket, small and gray-haired and bareheaded. In her hand a little recorder gave out a faint green light. She could not possibly see the stair. It was behind a wall of rhododendron. She was looking straight down it.
One foot was on the seventh step.
She was answering something. Silas heard it come up the stair: a man’s voice, kindly, tired, a little hoarse, with no breath in it.
“I’m coming, Daddy,” said the stranger, in an ordinary, grown-up voice. “I’m coming.”
And stepped down into the mist.

