Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 183

The Tally House

Teddy Harlow was standing on a dock when they found her, with a clipboard in one hand and a plumb line in the other, looking at the river as if it owed her money.

Harlow Landing was a place Silas had passed on the road a dozen times and never once seen. The county had a sign for it, brown with white letters, and a gravel pull-off with a trash barrel, and below that a grass slope running down to the river's edge where the ferry had once docked. There was no ferry now. There was a concrete ramp gone green, and a cluster of cottonwoods, and at the far end of the gravel a small gray building the size of a toolshed, with a padlock on its door and a rusted pipe stuck through its roof.

Teddy turned when she heard the car doors. She was in her slicker and rubber boots, her gray hair pulled under a cap, and her face did something complicated when she saw who it was.

"Lon asked," said Silas, before she could speak.

"I thought he might have." She set down the plumb line. "Where did he ask?"

"In his other ledger. In the margin. He wanted to know where the Harlow bell went."

Teddy took off her cap and ran a hand over her hair. For a moment the river made the only sound.

"Well," she said. "That's a question my daddy asked, and his daddy. We always figured we'd never know." She looked past them at the gray building. "But I know where the book is. Come on. I'll want a witness. I haven't opened that shed since my father died, and I'd as soon not be the only person who's seen what's in it."

She was not alone, as it turned out. A man in a green rain jacket was crouching on the ramp with a metal rod and a notebook, taking some sort of measurement, and he stood up at their approach with a grunt of knee trouble. He was sixty-eight, Silas guessed, large and slow, with a white mustache stained at the corners and the faintly annoyed, deeply patient look of someone who has spent his life waiting on a river to do something.

"This is Gideon Marsh," said Teddy. "He's the county's gauge man. He reads the river for the weather service. Has done for forty years. Gideon, this is the Ketterman boys. Wyatt, who you've heard of, and Silas."

"I've heard of the both of you." Gideon shook hands the way a man shakes hands with a large fish. "You're the folks from Rankin Gap. You're the ones with the, um." He gestured vaguely at his own ear. "The singing."

"We're the ones with the singing," said Wyatt gravely.

"Well. I don't ask. Teddy says you're all right, that's good enough for me. She says you need into the tally house?"

"If the key still turns," said Teddy.

It turned, with a shriek. The door opened inward on dark and dust and the smell of a place that had been shut up for years with nothing living in it but spiders. Gideon found a switch inside the door and clicked it, to no effect. He sighed, and produced from his jacket a flashlight as long as his forearm.

"There," he said. "Mind the floor. It was a good floor when Eisenhower was president."

The tally house was one room. Along three walls ran shelves, floor to rafters, and on the shelves lay sticks.

Silas had expected papers. There were papers, a few bundles of them tied with string, but the sticks were what the eye went to. They were hazel, or something like it, each about two feet long, peeled and dried to the color of old bone, and every one of them was covered with notches. Some were cut in neat groups of five, four strokes and a fifth across. Some were cut deeper, with a longer slash for ten. A few had been split lengthwise, the way a tally was split in the old days, so that two halves would match.

"Oh," said Marian, behind them. She had followed in the second car, with Hollis, and they stood now in the doorway. "Oh, look at them."

"What are they?" said Wyatt.

"Ferry tallies." Teddy stepped carefully in among the shelves. "The Harlow Ferry crossed here from 1889 until the bridge went in at the Gap in 1931. Every passenger who set foot on the boat got a notch. By law, I think, or by habit. Each day a stick, and each stick tied with a tag. When the boat closed the sticks stayed in this shed, because nobody could bring themselves to burn them." She ran her hand along a shelf. "My great-grandfather Ephraim kept them. He was the tallyman. He sat on a stool by the landing rope with his knife and he cut one notch for each person who crossed. Nobody paid him to. It was just what he did."

"For forty-two years," said Gideon. He had come in behind, with the flashlight. "I did the figures once for a historical society. Over three hundred thousand notches."

"Three hundred thousand people," said Silas.

"Heads," said Gideon. "He counted heads. People, mules, a cow once. The cow got a notch with a little hook on it."

"Four short and a long gap," said Silas, slowly. He was looking at the stick under Teddy's hand. "Four strokes, a gap, and a fifth across. Wyatt."

Wyatt had gone very still. In the thin beam of the flashlight his face was pale.

"It's the same," he said. "It's the same as Toby's recording."

Teddy looked from one of them to the other. "I don't follow."

So Silas told her. He told her about the ticks under the nine voices, running since October, a notched row at the bottom of the screen. He told her about the voice under the stair last night, dry and slow, that had said eleven and count me. He told her about Lon's margin note, and the knife he had heard in the gap between four and five. He kept it plain. He had learned that, anyway, in a year of this. If you told it plain, nobody could say you were hiding anything.

When he finished, Teddy was sitting on an upturned bucket.

"My great-grandfather," she said.

"We don't know."

"No. We don't." She sat looking at the sticks. "But I'll tell you something I never told Lon. When I was little, my dad took me down to this shed on the anniversary. It was in October. He said that on the last night the ferry ran, the tallyman went out into the weather and did not come back. They never found him. The family story was that he drowned. But my father didn't believe it. He said the boat was found tied up fine, and the stick for that day was lying on the stool, and it wasn't finished."

"Unfinished," said Hollis.

"Eight notches. Then nothing." Teddy rose. She went to a shelf at the end, the last in the row, and reached up to the bottom board where a single stick lay apart from the rest, wrapped in a strip of oilcloth. She unwrapped it with great care and held it out in the beam.

It was a hazel stick like the others. It had a tag tied to it with string, and on the tag, in a faded brown hand, someone had written *Oct 31, 1931.* Under the date there were five notches in a bundle, with a stroke across. Then three more.

And then, at the end, the stick was bare for the length of a man's hand. Not cut off. Not broken. The wood simply went on, clean and pale, with no notch in it, as though the knife had stopped in mid-air.

"That's the last thing he did," said Teddy. "He cut eight and he stopped. And look." She turned the stick. On the underside, small and deep, there was a single cut that was not part of any bundle, set a little apart from the rest, like a mark made by someone who had meant to come back and finish the thought.

"What's that one?" said Wyatt.

"That," said Gideon, and his voice was low, "is how you would count yourself, if you were a tallyman and somebody finally asked you to."

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!