The knife started again at nine-forty.
It was slow at first, one dry tick and a long wait, as though a man were trying a stiff hand. Then the rhythm came back, four and a gap, four and a gap. Ephraim said only, from under the stair, "I have taken it up, miss. Tell her not to be afraid. I will carry it till somebody can relieve me." And Ruth's voice, from the lip, said nothing more. Dovie had sat a long time at the stump in the dark with her back to them, and when she came in she said, "Nobody say anything to me tonight," and nobody did.
So it was a tired Silas who stood in the gravel at ten the next morning when the gray Subaru pulled up and Ines Calder rolled down the window and said, "Get in. I'm driving to Asheville. I want a witness."
"For what?"
"I don't know yet. That's why I want one."
She drove fast and well, with both hands on the wheel, and said nothing for forty minutes. The road came down out of the mountains into a long gray valley, and the exits got closer together. At last she said, to the windshield, "My mother is seventy-one. She was a church secretary for thirty-four years. First Presbyterian, Hendersonville. She kept the attendance. She kept the minutes, the flower calendar, the keys. She has Alzheimer's. It came on slowly and then it didn't. I visit her Sundays because that was the day she worked."
"I'm sorry."
"Don't be. I'm telling you because Lon asked if I counted myself, and I said I'd tell you before Friday. I haven't got there yet. I thought you should see the evidence."
Laurel Court was a low brick building with a fenced garden and a keypad on the door. It smelled of lunch and floor cleaner. A woman at the desk said, "Morning, Ines," and Calder signed a book, and they walked down a long hall hung with watercolors of birds, to a sunroom at the end with a view of a bird feeder and a parking lot.
Jean Calder was sitting at a card table by the window. She was small and straight, with short white hair and a cardigan the color of oatmeal, and she had a spiral notebook open in front of her and a pencil in her hand. She looked up as they came in, and her face went through three or four expressions before it settled on pleasure.
"Ines," she said. "You're late. Service starts at eleven."
"I know, Mama. I brought a friend."
"Well, sit, sit. I'll need a count." She pulled out a chair for Silas and looked him over with a church secretary's quick appraising eye. "Young man, you're welcome. Are you a visitor or a member?"
"A visitor," said Silas. "Silas Ketterman, ma'am."
"We'll put you down as a visitor, then, with an address. I always say, a visitor who isn't written down is a visitor who doesn't come back." She turned the notebook toward him. "Here, you may as well see."
It was a page of tidy columns. Names, he saw, in a small clear hand, and beside them check marks. Some were plainly invented. *Mrs. Gladys Orr, alto.* *Mr. Pitts, usher.* *The Hallorans, four.* Down the page they went, and at the bottom, in a box, a tally.
"Forty-one," read Jean Calder, with satisfaction. "Forty-one in the sanctuary. Eleven in the choir. Six ushers and the children in the nursery. I count everybody."
"Do you, Mama?" said Calder softly.
"I do. It's the secretary's whole job. If you don't count, nobody does. I have counted every pew in that church every Sunday since 1983." She tapped the notebook with the pencil. "Look. Eleven in the choir. Well, that's the way it comes out, eleven. Though I always feel it should be twelve."
"Why twelve?" said Silas.
"Because there's twelve of us. But I'm sitting in the alto section, and I forget. I count the others and I forget the one I'm in." She laughed, a small dry laugh with a note of apology in it, as if confessing a charming vice. "Forty years! I count everyone in the church and I never once counted myself. The preacher says it's the sign of a good servant. I say it's a sign I need glasses."
Silas did not move. Across the card table, Ines Calder was looking at her own hands.
"Mrs. Calder," said Silas carefully. "What would you do if you did count yourself?"
"Well, I'd have to be somebody, wouldn't I?" She said it simply, as though it were the answer to arithmetic. "I'd have to stand up and be one of the people, and not only the one who keeps the book. And that's heavier. Counting is light, young man. Being counted is heavy."
The pencil in her fingers had stopped. She looked at the bird feeder a while. Her face had begun to go vague, the expression sliding out of it like water out of a basin, and she said, without turning, "Ines, are we late?"
"No, Mama. We're early."
"Good. That's the way. I like to be the first, so I can count the others in." She patted the notebook. "I'll want to sit near the front."
They stayed another hour. Jean Calder asked three more times whether Silas was a visitor or a member, and each time he said visitor, and each time she wrote him down with great care, in the same neat hand. When they left she kissed her daughter on the cheek, and said, "Mind the road, dear," and went back to her notebook before the door had closed.
In the parking lot, Calder stood with her keys in her hand for a long minute, looking at the brick.
"She always said that," she said. "Every Sunday of my childhood. Eleven. I mean twelve. I forgot myself. I thought it was a joke. It was the only joke she had. And I grew up and became a person who keeps the book for everybody else. I count what I'm owed, and I count what I owe, and I do not once put myself in the column."
"Lon saw that," said Silas.
"Lon saw it in a quarter hour on a cot." She unlocked the car, and did not get in. "Mr. Ketterman, I have a thing I'd like to say aloud, which I haven't said to anyone, and I'd like you to hear it. This place costs eleven thousand dollars a month. I pay it out of my partnership share. Mr. Voss's firm is my largest client, and the one that makes me a partner next year. If I recommend that the landing parcel be held in trust for the Rudds, or for the booth, or for whatever you decide it is, the firm will drop me by Monday. And my mother loses that sunroom."
"I didn't know."
"No. Nobody does. I made certain." She looked at him, with her lawyer's face and a woman's eyes. "So here is what I want to know. You told me eleven, in the cellar, when it cost you something. Why?"
"Because if I said ten and was wrong, he'd have been counted out again."
"Who?"
"The one under the floor. He's been told for ninety-five years there isn't an eleventh step." Silas shrugged, helplessly. "I couldn't say it too."
She nodded slowly. Then she did a thing he did not expect. She opened the folder on the Subaru's roof, took out the spiral notebook her mother had filled the Sunday before, and handed it to him. "Look at the last page."
He opened it. The final entry was dated Sunday last, in a hand slightly less sure than the rest. *Choir, eleven.* And under it, in a different pencil, small, cramped, and emphatic, as though written in a rush of clarity: *Twelve. Me.*

