He read it in the back pew on the left, where his brother had sat, with the door shut and nobody in the church.
Dovie had taken one look at his face and said, "We'll be on the steps." Pearline had put her dust rag in her cardigan pocket and gone out with a sniff and a hand on Everett's elbow, and the door had closed on its old iron hinge, and the long bars of light had stood across the aisle with the dust turning in them.
Silas unfolded the paper. His hands were not steady. It was a single sheet of notebook paper, written on both sides in a quick, tall, upward-leaning hand, with a doodle of a dog in the margin.
He read the first line aloud to nobody, in a whisper, because it said to.
Si,
I'm in a church. You'd laugh. I've been in a pew for four Wednesdays running with a notebook on my knee, taking dictation from a woman who is seventy-five years old and has a voice like a clean knife, and I have never in my life been so happy to be told I'm flat.
I'm writing this because I know you. You'll go to the Mail Route first, and you'll find the other letter in the box, and you'll say Fine and walk off. You'll leave this one for later. So I've put it where you'll look when you're ready. Dovie knows the place. I told her once and I think she nearly told you. She's a better keeper than she knows.
The bad news first. I'm not going to say sorry for going. I'd go again. I've been trying for two months to write that sentence a kinder way and I can't. So I'll say it the way it is.
You said, Go on, then. See who calls you up.
I know you think that's what I carried down the road. It isn't. I carried your face when you said it. You were sixteen years old, six foot nothing and about as wide as a ladder, and you looked like a kid who'd been told his dog was going to live at somebody else's house. I thought, I did that. I put that look there. And I went anyway, and I'm sorry about the look. I'm not sorry about the going.
I asked you because I knew you'd say no.
Don't read that wrong. I didn't want a no. I wanted you to say a thing. Any thing. You'd been quiet since Dad left, Si, you went quiet like a house with the power out, and I thought, if I ask him for the one thing he can't give me, he'll have to say something. And you did. It was the wrong thing, and it was something. I've kept it in my pocket for a year like a stone.
Okay. Enough of that.
He put his hand over his mouth. After a while he took it away and read on.
Here's what I've learned, in order, in case you're a fool and take it in the wrong order.
One. The ballad. It's in five parts. Dovie gave me the first. Ferrell gave me the second and I learned it by the shape of his mouth. Odell gave me the third, with a letter I wrote to Dad in four words, which I won't tell you. Rena gave me the fourth, and I cried in a creek, and I'd do it again. The fifth is the Hollow's. It has no words. You'll see.
Two. I think there's more than five. I think the ballad goes on past the Hollow, and there are staves under the stair that the people down there hold, because every person held at a stand ends up knowing the verse of the stand they're on. It's how the Hollow remembers. I could be wrong. I'm often wrong. But I don't think a song makes it all the way up the stair without somebody carrying it down first. So somebody has to go and pick them up.
Three. This church. Pearline's mother's church lined out a hymn once that I think is the ninth. It's not on a trail. It's not on a mountain. It's in a book in a piano bench, and it needs a whole house to sing it. I think it's the way back. I think you can't call a person up out of the dark with one voice. I think you need everyone who ever knew you to answer at once, and say what they'd have said if they'd had the nerve.
That's all I've got on the theory. The rest is walking. Odell says walking's just thinking with your feet, and she's right, but I'd add that it's also what you do when you're scared and don't want to say so. I'd know. I've got one of those in my own family, and he's very tall, and he's reading this in a pew.
Now the part I'm scared of.
Silas looked up. A bar of light had slid across the pew in front of him. He could hear, very faintly, Dovie's cane tapping the step outside, once, twice, a long way off.
The second night I stood at the Lip, a voice sang something to me. My own voice. Same crack on the G, same laugh. It told me something true about myself that I had never said out loud to anyone. I was standing there in the frost with my hands in my pockets and a stranger's voice, my voice, said the true thing I'd been holding. Si, I almost went down it. It didn't lie. That's what I'm saying. It didn't lie. It was so exactly right that I could have kissed it.
I think that's what the thing at the bottom is. I don't think it's a liar. I think it's very good at telling the truth. It tells you the truth you haven't had the guts to say, and you hear it, and you think, at last, somebody who understands. And you start to go toward it. I don't know what it costs. I don't know what it takes. But I've listened to it for a week now, and I know this: it sounds like me, and it sounds better than me, and I think that's why it's dangerous.
So do not hate it. I mean that. Don't do what I did and stand there with your hands in your pockets hating it. That's what it feeds on, hate. It was never hate. I think it's lonely.
I'd like you to hold the light.
I know you won't want to. I know you're going to be angry at me for six months at the very least, and probably for six years, and you'll be right. But if you ever get this, if you ever stand where I'm standing: don't go down alone. Don't be me. Bring somebody who loves you and is a little bit afraid. That's what I'd do if I could do it over, and I can't, and that's all right.
Give Mama my love. Tell her I'll be back for supper.
Love, your brother, Wyatt
P.S. If it ever sounds better than me, it's because it's had a lot of practice at being me. Ask it what it costs. It'll never say.

