The band room at Calloway High smelled of valve oil and old carpet, and on Friday at four o'clock, with the buses gone and the janitor's radio playing down the hall, it held a bass drum, forty folding chairs, a boy with a fiddle, a woman with a laptop, and two brothers who were not supposed to be there.
"This is the only room in the building with a door that locks," said Toby Wray. "And it's got no windows on the hall. Nobody sees in." He set a metal music stand at the exact center of the circle of chairs and put a dented gray laptop on it. "Also Mr. Haddad lets me have the key. He thinks I'm practicing."
"Are you?" said Marian Voss.
"Mostly." Toby adjusted the small flesh-colored hearing aid behind his left ear. He was fifteen, with an owl's solemn face and a cowlick, and he had taken, since Sunday, to wearing a lanyard with a tiny silver tuning fork on it, a gift from Pearline Ayers. "I mean, I will be. In a minute."
Silas sat down in the nearest chair and tried to take up as little room as possible. Wyatt was in the next one, wrapped in a gray blanket Dr. Reyes would have disapproved of, with a paper cup of June's cocoa and his boots off, because he had said he wasn't ready to stand in them for the length of a school day. His eyes had half closed. He looked, in the low yellow light, like a man listening to rain.
On the wall behind him, as thin as a pencil line against the cinder block, the pale second shadow lay quiet. Dennis had asked to come. He had said it was a great many rooms since Sunday and he liked a school, with its smell of chalk and sharp pencils.
"I would like to say one thing before we begin," said Dennis. "Please do not press the large triangle. It is the play button. The thing that I am, is fed by being heard. I would prefer, if the recording must be played, that it be played on this one small speaker, and once, and not shared."
"Nobody's sharing it," said Toby quickly. "I swore."
"I know you did. It is a true oath. I am only saying that I can hear it from here, and it is not a comfortable feeling."
Toby swallowed. He put a pair of studio headphones on the laptop and left one cup off his ear. "Okay," he said. "So. This is the four hundred hours."
What was on the laptop was a window full of thin colored lines: blue, then green, then yellow, each one a day, stacked as neatly as shelf paper. Toby had recorded everything. Rankin Gap at night, Rankin Gap in rain. He had set his phone, he said, in a coffee can on the cairn, and a second at the fence, and a third at the spring box.
"I've been listening for the flat third," said Toby. "Not the real one, the one the Hollow does. I mean the one under it." He tapped the screen. "Pearline says every great ballad has a drone, like a bagpipe, a note that stays the whole time. I think the Hollow does. It's under everything. A really low sound, down around a bass E, and nobody hears it because it's lower than the room tone." He looked at Marian. "You've got the map."
"I do." Marian touched the trackpad. Since the Lip she had not stammered once on a true word, and she was not sure what to make of it. "The Open Lantern red dots. Seven. Plus the two nobody marked."
A map bloomed on the second screen: the county, a green thumbprint among hills, with nine red-and-gray pins. Rankin Gap sat in the middle of it, in a small hollow of contour lines. The rest lay scattered round it in a rough ring, none nearer than twenty miles.
"Okay," said Toby. "So. Hold your ears."
He did something with his fiddle. He put it to his jaw, closed his eyes, and bowed one open string, very slowly, until the note came out of it long and true and low as a hum. Then he bent, and with the tip of a finger on the string, found a place a hair's breadth sharp of it, and played that. The two notes beat against each other, slow and wavering.
"That's the Rankin drone," said Toby, "and that's the third. The flat third's not a note, it's the gap between two. A sort of wobble. Hear that?"
"I hear it," said Marian.
"I hear it," said Silas.
"So the whole mountain is humming a chord that's, that's wrong on purpose. And if you put a lot of hours together, you can, hang on." He pulled the headphones on, both cups, ears covered, with the aid pressed flat against his skull. His fingers danced on the keys. The spectrogram on the screen rolled and gave up a shape, a faint bright smear, like a thumbprint on glass, low in the frequencies.
"That's Rankin," said Toby. "That's every night. Same pitch, same spot. Now." He scrolled. "This is Tuesday, three-oh-four in the morning. Nobody's there. I wasn't there, the can was alone. Look."
A second smear, a little higher and a little thinner than the first, wavered up out of the noise. It ran for eleven seconds, and was gone.
"It's not Rankin," said Marian.
"It's not Rankin. It's a different note. It's a half step up, almost exactly. And it's not coming in the air." Toby's voice had gone quick. "It's coming in the ground. You can see it, it hits the can through the cairn first and then the air, there's a, it's a delay. It's coming through the rock from the west."
"Pinch Gap is west," said Silas.
"Pinch Gap's twenty-two miles west." Toby took his headphones off. "Which is too far for a normal sound. Except I think it's not a normal sound. I think the Lips are, I think they're connected. Underneath. And each one hums its own note, and mine's the only mic that was ever left alone on one long enough to catch the next one over."
Nobody spoke. Silas looked at the thumbprint of light on the screen.
"May I," said Dennis.
It was nearly inaudible. Everyone turned. The pale shape on the wall had come away from the cinder block a little, as though leaning in.
"That is what I heard on Tuesday," said Dennis. "I did not have the word for it. The note is held by a great many people who do not know they are holding it." A pause. "It is held, I think, in a house. Or a church. It has walls. I could not hear what was in them."
"Toby," said Silas. "Can you play it?"
Toby nodded. He tucked the fiddle under his chin. He listened to the room with his good ear for a moment, one hand lifting like a swimmer's, and then he drew a long low note out of the string, and held it, and let it bend a little at the end, where the real sound bent. It was a plain note. It was no more than a half step above the first.
For the first time, in the dim yellow room, the cinder-block wall seemed to listen.
It was Wyatt who spoke. He had not moved. He had not opened his eyes. He sat with the cup in both hands and his head against the wall, and his face had gone smooth and unguarded, the face of a man being sung to sleep.
"I know that hum," he said.
Everyone looked at him.
"I heard it on a porch," said Wyatt, in a drowsy, clear voice. "The year I walked the circuit. I went to a place, it was past a sawmill, there was a church at the end of the road, and a woman on a porch. She was old, then. She was humming that, over and over, with a lantern in a coffee can at her feet. I asked her about the stair." His eyelids lifted a very little. "She stood up and told me I was not welcome on her porch, and she went in and locked the door. And the humming didn't stop. It went on through the wall, all night. I stood out in the yard and listened to it until I couldn't."
"Wyatt," said Silas. His mouth had gone dry. "What was her name?"
His brother's eyes were open now, and they were wide, and very dark, and fixed on something that wasn't in the room.
"Tolliver," said Wyatt. "I didn't know it was anybody's. She said one grave in the family was enough."

